Regou wrote:

placeholder

1. Should have applied claps/snares for first drop's hitsounds, when you guys are actually following the bass drum i don't see a point to not to add them for better emphasis fixed
2. 00:43:345 (1) - this should be 1/6 instead of 1/4?
3. 00:44:035 (1,1) - using two 1/2 sliders when the rhythm intensifies feels pretty underwhelming to me. How about replacing them with 1/4 and 1/8 reverse sliders correspondingly?
4. 01:03:517 (4,5) - since the background music is pretty quiet here using high spacing jump that pops out from nowhere is pretty awkward tbh, could reduce the spacing here instead (e.g. overlapping (5) on the tail of (2)) fixed
5. 02:04:380 (2,3) - could increase spacing here so that i feels more balanced when compared to 02:05:931 (1,2,3,1,2) - fixed
6. 02:54:380 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - could use much lower spacing which is similar to 00:19:897 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - for better consistency
7. Second drop makes me nut 100 times

sahuang wrote:

Metadata pls

00:32:311 (1,2) - swap NC to keep consistency with previous 2 patterns fixed
01:01:104 (7) - don't see the reason of suddenly using 1/1 to pass the long white tick, could stick to previous rhythm imo listen again, there's a 'water drop' sound in the background that i want an emphasis on
01:30:845 (2,2) - BLANKET
01:39:207 (1,2) - i think 1/8 is more than enough, the sounds tbh is more suitable for 1/4s like 01:40:587 (1,2,3,4) -
02:09:897 (1,2,3,4) - straight line?
02:42:828 (1) - maybe should ctrl+g this, or move 02:42:655 (5) - to the slider end of 02:42:828 (1) - because in other places you have that kind of design (e.g. 02:45:414 (5,1) - 00:08:172 (5,1) - )
02:48:173 (5,1) - 02:53:690 (5,1) - same
02:54:380 (1,2,3,4) - agree with Regou
03:24:035 (3,2) - stack?
03:43:518 (1) - The downbeat here is really loud and noticeable, it is kinda sad to behave similar to 03:43:690 (2,3) - with 1/2 slider tbh
04:14:552 (1) - didn't see a reason that you used NC here
04:16:966 (2) - I would recommend you separate this with kick slider end since the music is quite intense. Maybe make something like 04:18:000 (1,2) - or 04:19:379 (2,3) - lol
04:27:138 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - music here has no difference with 04:25:414 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - , what is the intention of stream jumps?

Should be all

Regou wrote:

1. 00:43:345 (1) - this should be 1/6 instead of 1/4? i don't know? i can clearly hear the 1/4 sounds but i'm having a diffiult time hearing any clear 1/6 sounds
2. 00:44:035 (1,1) - using two 1/2 sliders when the rhythm intensifies feels pretty underwhelming to me. How about replacing them with 1/4 and 1/8 reverse sliders correspondingly? nah, i just like it that way more and i don't think rhythmical impact is more important than intensity in this case
3. 02:54:380 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - could use much lower spacing which is similar to 00:19:897 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - for better consistency yea i tried
4. Second drop makes me nut 100 times

sahuang wrote:

01:30:845 (2,2) - BLANKET fixed
01:39:207 (1,2) - i think 1/8 is more than enough, the sounds tbh is more suitable for 1/4s like 01:40:587 (1,2,3,4) - Did you mean 1/16? Aren't those 1/16? Why are those 1/16? When did i map those 1/16? I don't remember, but i'm turning the second one into a 1/8 and i'm letting it stay because the voice distortion can be heard there, and because the sound i was basing the group of sliders 01:38:518 (1,1,1,1) - on stops at 01:39:552 - , right where the second 1/8 begins.
02:42:828 (1) - maybe should ctrl+g this, or move 02:42:655 (5) - to the slider end of 02:42:828 (1) - because in other places you have that kind of design (e.g. 02:45:414 (5,1) - 00:08:172 (5,1) - ) you know i was gonna say it follows the principle at the start with the alternating head stack - tail stack thing, but i just realized now that the beginning isn't exactly like that and now i'm just really confused if i'm tripping balls or skystar just changed something. So it doesn't matter now, i'm redoing everything so that only the weakest sound has the head stack, maybe with the only exception of 04:49:552 (5,1) - , because of no particular reason, i just feel like it.
02:48:173 (5,1) - 02:53:690 (5,1) - same all that stuff above
02:54:380 (1,2,3,4) - agree with Regou yea
03:24:035 (3,2) - stack? fixed
03:43:518 (1) - The downbeat here is really loud and noticeable, it is kinda sad to behave similar to 03:43:690 (2,3) - with 1/2 slider tbh i don't see where when or how a 1/2 exists in this context (i assume you mean 1/4. They are 1/4 in mapping terms right?) but maybe i am cranking 03:43:518 (1) - up a bit
04:14:552 (1) - didn't see a reason that you used NC here i don't know? Consistency with skystar's 03:58:173 (1) - ? You'd have to ask what i was thinking 3 years ago
04:16:966 (2) - I would recommend you separate this with kick slider end since the music is quite intense. Maybe make something like 04:18:000 (1,2) - or 04:19:379 (2,3) - lol yeah my intention is the exact opposite of this, 04:16:793 (1,2) - should be this tiny window of slowdown and tension before 04:17:138 (1) - picks up the pace again. Other than that, i don't think the sound at 04:16:966 (2) - is in any way similiar to 04:18:173 (2) - or 04:19:552 (3) -
04:27:138 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - music here has no difference with 04:25:414 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - , what is the intention of stream jumps? there's the voice thingy getting sightly stronger and the 1/4 tick sounds getting gradually weaker but regaining some volume at every white tick until the end of the section

Garden wrote:

03:30:587 - should say that i like the patterns but there can be a better introduction to them (like increasing spacing gradually but i doubt if it works since patterns are strictly structured), suddenly coming across the stream jump here after 3 whole minutes can be really annoying, also i guess players won't even be prepared cuz it's in the relatively calm section. I was thinking of using just 1/4 repeat sliders but i don't know if that would end up beign too easy