1. Easy (1.92 stars, 248 notes)
2. Hard (4.86 stars, 582 notes)
3. Normal (4.04 stars, 362 notes)
4. Taiko Oni (4.82 stars, 910 notes)

samiljul wrote:

Taiko Oni Modding

Red : You must fix this
Blue: You should fix this
Green : Suggestion


00:45:589 (1,2,1,2,1,1,2,3) - avoid to overlap x1 notes and x0.5 notes Fixed. I manually set the speed of the notes in notepad
02:14:204 (1,1,1,2,1,1,1,2) - ^ Fixed, same as above


And nothing wrong. Do you want pattern modding? Yes~ Thanks in advance


+ star Thanks

samiljul wrote:

Pattern mod

00:32:089 - kddk OK~
00:33:012 - ^ OK~
00:33:935 - ^ I want to make 31:743~33:589 simillar to 2:00:358~2:02:205, while 33:935~35:435 similar to 2:02:551~2:04:051, so i didn't change this.
00:45:589 - dkddkdk OK~
01:07:512 - kkdkd I think kdddk is fine, so i didn't change.
01:12:820 - ddkkd OK~ I also changed 2:41:435~2:41:897 to ddkkk so they look simillar.
01:21:128 - ddk OK~
01:28:281 - ddk OK~ I also changed 2:56:897~2:57:358 to kkd k so they look simillar.
02:00:705 - dkkd OK~
02:01:628 - ^ OK~
02:02:551 - ddkd I want to make 31:743~33:589 simillar to 2:00:358~2:02:205, while 33:935~35:435 similar to 2:02:551~2:04:051, so i didn't change this.
02:03:358 - ddk OK~
02:53:204 - kkd k OK~
03:16:743 - dkkkd OK~

Thanks!

Roganis wrote:

Hi !

Taiko

00:45:589 : I think you shouldn't do timing changes, most of taiko players don't like that OK~ Now the speed of the notes are the same. ( No change in speed )
02:15:128 : ^ OK~ same as above.
01:40:051 : Please don't do break times in taiko mode OK~ Add some notes in breaks to delete them.

Good map, Star~ Thanks !

wmfchris wrote:

[taiko diff]
pattern 14/20
content 24/30
=========
38/50 level 4+ (please ignore this if you don't understand) Is this a rating??

suggestion: SV1.6 I don't know why every authentists wants 1.4 and that's holy boring OK~

grid refers to level 3.

[normal]
0:32:435 (3,4,5,6) (3,6) down 1 grid, (4,5) down 2 grid OK~
0:36:128 (3,4,5,6) ^ OK~
0:46:512 (1) weird shape OK~ I made a new one. Hope that will be ok~
3:29:205 (x) break OK~
3:32:897 (x) ^ OK~

star~ Thanks!

MittenMasterzz wrote:

Mod Request~

[Taiko Oni]

SV: 1.4 Changed to 1.4 for now~ But wmfchris said that 1.4 is boring. I will ask more people's opinions before having a final decision.

00:24:128 - Change to Don It is already a don, isn't it?
00:24:358 - Change to Katsu It is already a kat, isn't it?
00:30:705 - Change pattern to dkkd OK~
00:35:781 - Change pattern to kddk k Like you did at 00:32:089 OK~
00:36:705 - ^ OK~
00:39:128 - Maybe make this a finisher? OK~
00:45:128 - Change to ddk OK~
00:54:128 - Change this note to Katsu OK~
00:55:051 - ^ OK~
01:05:435 - Change to Don OK~
01:13:974 - Unsnapped slider, make it end at: 01:14:897 Fixed~
01:25:974 - Maybe change to don? OK~
01:50:205 - Change to don. I didn't change this because i want to have some differences between this and 01:51:128, just like what i did in 01:46:281 and 01:47:205~
02:24:128 - Change to katsu. OK~
02:42:589 - Unsnapped slider, make it end at: 02:43:512 Fixed~
02:46:281 -- 02:51:589: This whole section sounds ugly to me Q_Q OK~ I change the pattern of the section from 02:43:974 to 02:51:589~ Hope that this will be better~
03:41:666 - Unsnapped slider, make it end at: 03:42:589 Fixed~

I like the map, it's fun. And the background is Moe moe~~ Thanks!

Roganis wrote:

01:40:051 : Please don't do break times in taiko mode

samiljul wrote:

Roganis wrote:

01:40:051 : Please don't do break times in taiko mode

Hmm..? I think can use break times in taiko mode.
It's fine~ The new notes in break times will not affect the gameplay. So i just keep no changes~

I_Tatsuo_I wrote:

Hai here comes my mod~

[Overall]
I'm not a big fan of how your difficulties are totally different in their ending points. Can you give me some suggestions about good ending points? Thanks~
I can understand beginner but not easy. Can you tell me why you can understand beginner but not easy? Thanks~
Try and map to the same length... Although 4 minutes is already getting too long. I will consider mapping the whole song in diffs beginner and easy~ (2010/6/30)Done now~
Is there anyway you can cut the mp3 and end it earlier? I want to map a full ver of this song, so i am not planning to shorten it, sorry!
Remove this non-inherited timing section. Completely unnecessary. Fixed~
Also, please don't separate your Kiai time with a second in between them. It's annoying. Fixed~ but i didn't fix it in Taiko Oni since i'm sure that this is acceptable in Taiko diff.

[Beginner]
01:03:128 (4) - New combo OK~
01:06:820 (4) - ^ OK~

[Easy]
You're getting too high in combos for an easy difficulty. Try and keep it below 6. Fixed, but i still have some of them with combo of 7. Can you give me some suggestions about those combos?

[Normal]
You got some pretty small hit objects for this difficulty. I suggest you raise the circle size by one tick.
01:36:128 through 01:38:205 - Make this all one combo. OK~
03:28:281 through 03:28:974 - ^ OK~
03:32:666 (1) - Remove this, just make this section one break time, instead of a hit circle surrounded by break times. OK~

Forum PM me when your beatmap is done and you made some fixes. I want to mod all difficulties when they are here. Then you will get your star.
Thanks for your modding!

I am sorry that i asked so many questions that may annoy you.

banvi wrote:

K-ON <3

General
Open song folder file & delete osb. file. OK~
I don't recommend using grid lv1 even easy because many spacing become wrong. OK~ Next time i will use Lv.3 for all diffs

So I take nazi(spacing) mod using grid lv3.
Bigineer
01:23:435 (1) 2 grid right OK~
01:27:589 (1,2,3,4) spacing is too close. OK~
02:46:974 (4,5) ^ I think the spacing is correct, so i didn't change this~
03:22:974 (2) 2 grid left OK~
03:24:820 (2) 2 grid right OK~
Easy
Because of grid lv2 , many spacing is wrong. Fixed many others you didn't mentioned~ Next time i will use Lv.3 for all diffs
Example : spacing is a bit close in this pattern like 00:17:666 (2,3,4,5) . try using distance snap. OK~
Other pattern: 01:02:205 (3,4,5) spacing is a bit close OK~
00:04:051 (1) remove new combo OK~
00:07:743 (1) ^ OK~
00:11:435 (1) ^ OK~
01:03:128 (1) ^ OK~
01:06:820 (1) ^ OK~
01:10:512 (1) ^ OK~
01:17:897 (1) ^ OK~
01:21:589 (1) ^ OK~
01:25:281 (1) ^ OK~
Please remove new combo like this pattern. Indeed, I can't write all All done~ Next time i won't use this pattern~
Normal
00:45:590 (4) new combo? OK~
00:48:128 (6) ^ OK~
00:48:358 (1) remove new combo OK~
01:03:358 (1) ^ OK~
01:38:205(1,2,3,4,5) I don't recommend this jump because this is normal. XD OK~ I shorten the distance between notes~
01:38:205 (5) new combo? OK~
03:11:897 (2,3) spacing is too close OK~
Hard
00:08:435 (4,5,6) 1 grid left OK~
00:43:743 (7,8,9) ^ OK~
01:09:128 (2) 1 grid up OK~
01:18:358 (5,6,7) ^ OK~
01:30:128 (4,5,6) add jump? OK~ This is the 1st jump, so the distance is not very far away
01:38:205 (5) new combo? OK~
02:04:973 (4,5,6,7,8) 1 grid left OK~
02:13:050 (6) 1 grid right OK~
02:16:973 (2) ^ OK~
02:47:205 (6) ^ OK~
02:56:897 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) 1 grid down OK~
02:58:743 (4,5,6) add jump? OK~ This is the 2nd jump, so the distance is a bit further than the 1st's
03:57:820 (4,5,6) ^ OK~ This is the 3rd jump, so the distance is a bit further than the 2nd's

In all diffs, I also fixed some spacing issues and problems that you didn't mentioned~

This is your 1st map? 0.0 Very nice~ Yes~ Thanks!
star & gl Thanks for your star and detailed modding!

I_Tatsuo_I wrote:

Hai, here's a recheck~~

[Overall]
What I meant about understanding Beginner but not Easy was that Beginner had an earlier ending point that Easy. Anyway~~
Delete the .osb from your songs folder and full submit please. OK~
So long in length x.x

[Beginner]
Good~

[Easy]
Good~

[Normal]
Good~

[Hard]
Great~~ Thanks!

Wow nothing I could complain on.
You can have a star~ Thanks for rechecking and star!
*star*

Mystearica wrote:

Not really much to say, it's ok overall but it just feels.....kind of plain. Can you give me some suggestions how to make the map become less plain? I am new to making osu maps and i don't really know much about styling. Thanks!

Suggest you increase overall difficulty for Hard, it's a bit too slow even for me... OK~ I increased the overall difficulty by 1~

Thanks for modding and star!

lepidopodus wrote:

These are just suggestions, so don't need to take seriously. Just fix which is worth to fix.

Overall
Check the timing sections and deleted some un-needed ones. OK~ Now only needed ones are left~
(grid = tiny, level 3)

Beginner

SPOILER

00:09:589 (1,2) - make these parallel to each other, or make these curved? and how about remove whistle from the body of the slider? OK~ I made these parallel to each other and removed whistle from the body of the slider~
00:18:820 (2) - make this align to 00:16:974 (1)? OK~
00:20:666 (1,2) - spacing is kinda short I didn't change this because if so, it will cause all the notes after this point become unplacable because they are out of grid~ I don't want to make big changes to the diff~
00:22:512 (2,1) - spacing is kinda long...? (but there's plenty of time to ready for that... I'm not sure about this.) I think it is OK, so i didn't change this~
00:33:589 (3) - one grid up OK~
00:53:897 (1) - how about moving third middle point of the slider two grid right? OK~ Now the slider looks much better
01:01:281 (1) - add finish? OK~
01:08:666 (1) - try somewhat better and smooth shape OK~ I remade this slider~
01:12:358 (1) - ^ OK~ I remade this slider
02:06:820 (3,1) - spacing? OK~
02:26:205 (1) - add finish? OK~
02:29:897 (1) - ^ OK~
02:44:666 (1) - ^ OK~
02:45:589 (3,4) - spacing? OK~
03:25:281 (1) - add whistle? OK~
03:36:358 (1) - add finish? OK~
03:40:974 (3) - remove whistle? OK~
03:43:743 (1) - add finish? OK~
03:54:820 (5) - how about semicirclular shape? OK~ I also moved the notes after this point~

Easy
Try to make long sliders better shape OK~ Now i have remade all long sliders to make them look better~

SPOILER

00:03:128 (3) - put clap in the end of the slider? OK~
00:06:820 (3) - ^ OK~
00:10:512 (3) - ^ OK~
00:20:666 (1) - move one grid down, and one grid left? OK~
00:23:897 (7) - add whistle? OK~
00:27:589 (3) - ^ OK~
00:38:666 (7) - ^ OK~
00:42:358 (3) - ^ OK~
00:57:589 (1) - add finish? OK~
01:01:281 (1) - ^ OK~
01:13:281 (3) - remove whistle? OK~
01:24:358 (3) - add clap in the end of the slider? OK~
02:10:512 (6,7) - add whistle? OK~
02:26:205 (1) - add finish? OK~
02:29:897 (1) - ^ OK~
02:38:205 (3) - add clap in the end of the slider? OK~
02:44:666 (1) - add finish? OK~
02:52:512 (2) - add clap? OK~
02:53:435 (4) - ^ OK~
02:53:897 (5) - add clap in second & third return of the slider? OK~
03:35:435 (1) - add finish in the end of the slider? OK~
03:43:743 (1) - add finish? OK~

Normal

SPOILER

00:17:436 (2) - add clap? OK~
00:18:359 (5) - ^ OK~
00:19:282 (1) - ^ OK~
00:20:205 (4) - add clap in the start of the slider? OK~
00:21:128 (2) - add clap? OK~
00:22:051 (5) - ^ OK~
00:22:974 (8) - add clap in the start of the slider? OK~
00:23:897 (1) - add clap in the start & first return of the slider? OK~
00:32:205 (2) - add clap? OK~
00:33:128 (5) - ^ OK~
00:34:051 (1) - add clap in the start of the slider? OK~
00:34:974 (2) - add clap? OK~
00:35:897 (2) - ^ OK~
00:36:820 (5) - ^ OK~
00:37:743 (1) - add clap in the start of the slider? OK~
00:38:666 (2) - add clap? OK~
00:57:590 (1) - add finish? OK~
01:01:051 (2) - add finish in the end of the slider? OK~
01:27:589 (2) - add whistle in the start of the slider? OK~
01:28:512 (4) - add whistle in the start & first return of the slider? OK~
01:45:589~02:59:435 - some what similar with the privious part, so put some more hitsound based on the above. OK~ I understand the methods to put claps now. Thanks!
02:44:666 (4) - move the end of the slider one grid up OK~
02:48:358 (6) - move the end of the slider one grid down OK~
03:13:512 (5) - move one grid left OK~
03:23:435 (5) - try to make better shape... OK~ I remade this slider. Now it has reverse arrows~
03:28:974 (4) - add finish? OK~
03:35:435 (1) - add finish in the end of the slider OK~
03:52:051 (3) - move one grid down OK~

Hard
Ok, hitsound is better than previous ones... But maybe it's kinda overmapped. Should I delete some circles or sliders? I didn't change anything for now~

SPOILER

00:06:358 (3) - one grid right? OK~
00:07:051 (4) - maybe one grid one and one grid right? OK~
00:16:974 (1) - maybe add finish? OK~
00:55:282 (2) - add whistle? OK~
00:57:590 (1) - add finish? OK~
01:01:051 (2) - add finish in the end of the slider? OK~
01:51:127 (7) - try to make this smoother shape OK~ I remade this slider~
02:18:820 (2,3,4,5,6) - consider it's hard, this jump would be too big. OK~ I reduced the distance between the notes~
02:26:204 (1) - add finish? OK~
02:29:666 (2) - add finish in the end of the slider? OK~
03:16:512 (2) - move one gird left and one grid up OK~
03:16:974 (3,4) - move one gird up OK~
03:36:358 (9) - add finish? OK~

Taiko Oni
02:14:781 (2) - remove finish. Too confusing. OK~ I'm too careless

...anyway, I'll star. Thanks for your star and detailed modding! I have learnt more about hitsounds now~ Thanks very much!

SadKangaroo wrote:

Hi.
Not bad,I want more hitsounds and here is list of things you need to fix:

[Beginner]
00:22:512 (2) - Fix distance. OK~
00:32:666 (2,3) - Use distance snap. OK~
00:42:820 (1) - Well,same concept.Just check your difficulties(Beginner and Easy especially)and try to use Distance Snap more properly.Then I won't suggest about each one here. OK~ I also fixed some in other difficulties~ However, i'm not sure if i have fixed all~
01:01:281 (1) - Use whistle after each 1 white tick? I don't really understand your suggestion. Do you mean this? http://puu.sh/1Jv (Yellow means adding a whistle)
01:30:820 (1) - Silence the spinner maybe? Or at least add a whistle. I am new to making maps and i am not sure how to silence the spinner. Do you mean this? http://puu.sh/1Jl (Red arrow)
02:29:897 (1) - Use whistle after each 1 white tick? I don't really understand your suggestion. Do you mean this? http://puu.sh/1Jv (Yellow means adding a whistle)

[Normal]
03:17:897 (1) - 1 grid up? OK~

[Hard]
00:22:743 (6) - Allign better. OK~
03:35:435 (1) - Ah,it's messed.Fix it. I am not sure if the mess is caused by X0.5 & X1 BPM issue in 03:32~03:36. Since i just deleted some useless timing sections today (Suggestions by lepidopodus), I later realised that in the 03:32~03:36 part, the BPM becomes X0.5(I didn't change it to X1 at that time because i was careless) This caused some length errors of sliders in Normal and easy in 03:32~03:36, which were fixed by me later by changing to X1 BPM and remaking the sliders. I'm not sure if this issue affects Hard, but i have changed 03:32~03:36 into X1 BPM in all diffs. I hope that this will solve your problem. Please tell me if this isn't the point you are talking about~

Others are fine.

Good luck,star~ Thanks for your star and modding!

SadKangaroo wrote:

01:01:281 (1) - Use whistle after each 1 white tick? I don't really understand your suggestion. Do you mean this? http://puu.sh/1Jv (Yellow means adding a whistle) I meant 02:29:897 (1),02:30:820 (3),02:31:743 (1) and etc,but your updated version seems fine.Well,up to you. OK~ I used your pattern in 2:2x~2:3x, and i used my pattern in 1:0x

01:30:820 (1) - Silence the spinner maybe? Or at least add a whistle. I am new to making maps and i am not sure how to silence the spinner. Do you mean this? http://puu.sh/1Jl (Red arrow) Yes,you did well. OK~ I silenced that spinner in all diffs except Taiko Oni~

Thanks for answering my questions!

roflninja wrote:

Hi,

[beginner]

02:04:974 (1,2,3) - a little high, this always bugs me, but its fine, up to you OK~ I moved them 1 gid down (Lv.3)~

[easy]

02:02:897 (1) - new combo? imo The pattern is same in 02:06:589, i think both of them are OK, so i didn't change this~

[hard]

01:28:974 (10) - you have both whistle and finish on this OK~ Removed whistle here~
03:13:281 (3) - this sounds better imo if you remove 2 repeats and extend 1 tick OK~

nice map Thanks for your modding and star!

Sallad4ever wrote:

First thing I want to say is good job on mapping 5 diff for full 3:58 minutes Thanks!
You must be like K-On! Very much Yeah~ I like the anime very much~

[General]
- Remove the following from tags, cause these item is already present on other subject (Artist, Source, and Genre )OK~

SPOILER

• - Anime
  - K-On
  - Toyosaki Aki
  - Yoko Hikasa

- Decrease the stack option by 2 ticks OK~
- Also disable the countdown in song option, you won't need it OK~

[All Diff]
01:30:820 (1) - I'm not sure with how you absolutely silent this spinner, no sound make me feels like I'm spinning for nothing. At least increase the volume by 3 or 2 ticks OK~ I increased it for 3 ticks~
03:32:666 (1) - I'm guessing you try to add kiai to the stress on the lyric here, but it's strange to see a kiai fountain with no note to hit XD I strongly suggest you to remove the kiai. OK~
03:58:512 (1) - change the volume on this timing section to 40% or 50% OK~ I changed it to 40%~

[Beginner]
I suggest you to change the whistle in the chorus into clap just like in the easy diff I am not good at musical terms, so i don't know the meaning of chorus. Could you give me the time period where i should change the whistles into claps? Thanks!
01:16:051 (1) - Finish him, like what you did too 02:44:666 (1) OK~
Timing section
01:45:589 - move this timing section backward to 01:45:128 OK~

[Easy]
This play more like normal than easy with the sort sliders and the small CS
Decrease circle size by 1 I'm not sure if this is good because if i decrease the circle size (Do you mean to make the circles become smaller?), the circles in Normal will be bigger than Easy. So i didn't change this for now~
00:45:589 (2,3,1) - this is not a good pattern for easy diff OK~ Now it becomes easier~
Timing section
01:45:589 - move this timing section backward to 01:45:128 OK~

[Normal]
01:36:128 (1,2,3,4) - let's see what will the next modder say about this jump on normal :3 OK~ I keep no changes for now~
Timing section
01:36:128 - move the timing section in this place backward to 01:35:897 OK~

[Hard]
Increase HP by 2 and Overall Diff by 1 or 2 OK~ I increased the Overall diff by 1~
02:18:820 (2,3,4,5,6) - could you spread this jump ? Do you mean to increase the distance between the circles? I don't really understand so i keep no changes for now~
02:58:512 (3,4,5,6) - ^ ^
03:57:820 (4,5,6) - ^ ^
Timing section
01:36:128 - move the timing section in this place backward to 01:35:897 OK~

The diff spread is kinda iffy, seeing how easy diff is not that easy and almost similar with Normal diff. Should i make the easy diff become even easier?
ugh...not a very good mod from me I think your modding is quite good actually because you gave me a lot of suggestions in "song setup". Other modders didn't mention them.
Anyway Good Luck Thanks for your modding and star!

DJ KRZY wrote:

Wow...that was the longest beginner/easy difficulty I've ever seen.

[Beginner]
Well done! Thanks!

[Easy]
All right, here goes a ton of NC mods~ All NC mods are done~

SPOILER

00:04:051 (4) - Add NC
00:07:743 (4) - ^
00:11:435 (4) - ^
00:19:743 (6) - ^
00:23:435 (6) - ^
00:34:512 (6) - ^
00:38:205 (6) - ^
01:03:128 (6) - ^
01:06:820 (6) - ^
01:10:512 (3) - ^
01:14:205 (5) - ^
01:17:897 (4) - ^
01:21:589 (4) - ^
01:25:281 (4) - ^
01:48:358 (4) - ^
01:52:051 (4) - ^
01:55:743 (6) - ^
01:59:666 (6) - Actually, how about putting two separate notes instead of a slider here? Add NC either way. OK~
02:10:512 (6) - Add NC
02:31:743 (4) - ^
02:35:435 (4) - ^
02:39:128 (4) - ^
02:46:512 (4) - ^
02:50:205 (4) - ^
02:56:205 (2,3,4) - Not appropriate for [Easy] imo, just put separate notes instead of sliders here maybe? OK~
03:55:281 (2,3,4) - ^ ^
03:12:358 (4) - Add NC
03:16:051 (4) - ^
03:22:512 (4) - ^
03:23:435 (7) - ^
03:45:589 (6) - ^
03:49:281 (6) - ^

OR, you could rename this diff [Easy+] and ignore all these moddings except the red one. XD Since i fixed all the modding, i didn't change it to Easy+ ~

[Normal]
01:26:205 (X) - Add a note here maybe? OK~
02:50:435 (2) - Move 1 grid up, and the rest of the notes before the spinner too if you have to. OK~

[Hard]
00:22:743 (6,1) - Move 1 grid right OK~
01:06:358 (1) - ^ OK~
02:18:589 (1) - Move 1 grid down OK~
02:18:820 (2,3,4,5,6) - Move 2 grids down OK~


Great job with [Hard]! Thanks!

Star! Thanks for modding and star!

Sallad4ever wrote:

Some updates after in-game chat~ Thanks very much!
[Hard]
Increase HP by 2 and Overall Diff by 1 or 2 OK~ I increased the Overall diff by 1~
02:18:820 (2,3,4,5,6) - could you spread this jump ? Do you mean to increase the distance between the circles? I don't really understand so i keep no changes for now~ (2010/07/06)I want to keep this simillar with 00:50:205 (1,2,3,4,5), so i didn't changed this~
02:58:512 (3,4,5,6) - ^ (2010/07/06) OK~ I changed the pattern~
03:57:820 (4,5,6) - ^ (2010/07/06) ^

aabc271 wrote:

Some updates after in-game chat~ Thanks very much!

Sallad4ever wrote:

[Hard]
Increase HP by 2 and Overall Diff by 1 or 2 OK~ I increased the Overall diff by 1~
02:18:820 (2,3,4,5,6) - could you spread this jump ? Do you mean to increase the distance between the circles? I don't really understand so i keep no changes for now~ (2010/07/06)I want to keep this simillar with 00:50:205 (1,2,3,4,5), so i didn't changed this~
02:58:512 (3,4,5,6) - ^ (2010/07/06) OK~ I changed the pattern~
03:57:820 (4,5,6) - ^ (2010/07/06) ^

[Beginner]
I suggest you to change the whistle in the chorus into clap just like in the easy diff I am not good at musical terms, so i don't know the meaning of chorus. Could you give me the time period where i should change the whistles into claps? Thanks!(2010/07/06) Fixed now~

The diff spread is kinda iffy, seeing how easy diff is not that easy and almost similar with Normal diff. Should i make the easy diff become even easier? I keep no changes for now~

• 00:53:869(1):Whistle
  00:56:666(2):^
  01:08:666(2):^
  01:12:358(1):^
  01:28:051(2):^
  01:52:974(1):^
  01:56:666(1):^
  02:22:512(1):^
  02:25:281(2):^
  02:37:281(1):^
  02:40:974(1):^
  02:53:897(1):^
  02:56:666(2):^

• 01:16:051(1):Finish
  02:54:589(5):Remove finish here
  02:55:743(1):Finish
  03:40:051(1):Finish

• 00:40:743(4):Whistle
  00:44:436(3):^
  00:49:974(3):Add new combo
  00:50:666(1):Remove new combo
  00:52:974(6):Add new combo
  00:53:897(1):Remove new combo
  01:16:051(1):Add finish at the beginning of this slider
  02:13:050(3):Whistle
  02:21:589(6):Add new combo
  02:22:512(1):Remove new combo
  02:44:666(4): Add finish at the beginning of this slider
  03:43:512(2):Add finish at the end of this slider
  03:54:820:Finish

• 00:18:351(4,5,1):Distance
  00:28:974(5,6,7):^
  01:15:820(2): Add finish at the end of this slider
  02:14:666(6):Whistle
  02:21:590(7):Add new combo
  02:22:512(1):Remove new combo
  02:58:743(4,5,6):Distance,too far
  03:43:512(2):Add finish at the end of this slider
  03:54:358(7): Add finish at the end of this slider
  03:57:820(4,5,6):Distance,too far

impossiblexu wrote:

My suggestions:

[Beginner]

• 00:53:869(1):Whistle I think it is OK, so i didn't change this~
  00:56:666(2):^ ^
  01:08:666(2):^ ^
  01:12:358(1):^ ^
  01:28:051(2):^ OK~
  01:52:974(1):^ OK~
  01:56:666(1):^ OK~
  02:22:512(1):^ I think it is OK, so i didn't change this~
  02:25:281(2):^ ^
  02:37:281(1):^ ^
  02:40:974(1):^ ^
  02:53:897(1):^ ^
  02:56:666(2):^ OK~

[Easy]

• 01:16:051(1):Finish OK~
  02:54:589(5):Remove finish here OK~
  02:55:743(1):Finish I think it is OK, so i didn't change this~
  03:40:051(1):Finish ^

[Normal]

• 00:40:743(4):Whistle OK~
  00:44:436(3):^ OK~
  00:49:974(3):Add new combo OK~
  00:50:666(1):Remove new combo OK~
  00:52:974(6):Add new combo OK~
  00:53:897(1):Remove new combo OK~
  01:16:051(1):Add finish at the beginning of this slider OK~
  02:13:050(3):Whistle OK~
  02:21:589(6):Add new combo OK~
  02:22:512(1):Remove new combo OK~
  02:44:666(4): Add finish at the beginning of this slider OK~
  03:43:512(2):Add finish at the end of this slider OK~
  03:54:820:Finish I think it is OK, so i didn't change this~

[Hard]

• 00:18:351(4,5,1):Distance OK~
  00:28:974(5,6,7):^ OK~
  01:15:820(2): Add finish at the end of this slider OK~
  02:14:666(6):Whistle OK~
  02:21:590(7):Add new combo OK~
  02:22:512(1):Remove new combo OK~
  02:58:743(4,5,6):Distance,too far OK~ I reduced some distances~
  03:43:512(2):Add finish at the end of this slider OK~
  03:54:358(7): Add finish at the end of this slider OK~
  03:57:820(4,5,6):Distance,too far OK~ I reduced some distances~

Good map!!!
~STAR~ Thanks for your modding and star!

I am sorry that i didn't change quite a lot of your suggestions of hitsounds in Beginner and Easy~ Anyway, your mod is helpful, thanks!

Vass_Bass wrote:

Hi, this is my suggestions)
Nice map, bg <3
Not bad Thanks!

[Beginner]

It's good, i don't find problems with it
01:55:743 (1) - 1 grid down OK~
02:22:512 (1) - make it symmetrical I found that it is nearly impossible to make it completely symmetrical because the slider lengthens itself a lot when i increase the distance for 1 grid, but other times,it doesn't increase at all. So i changed the structure of the slider to solve this problem~
02:52:051 (1) - new combo It is already a new combo, isn't it?
03:43:281 new kiai mode Actually i divided each kiai times into 2 parts before, but I_Tatsuo_I said that this is not good. I keep no changes ATM, but i will ask more opinions from other modders~
03:54:820 (1) - make it symmetrical Same as the issue at 02:22:512

[Easy]

03:43:281 - new kiai mode Same as the issue in Beginner (03:43:281)
03:51:128 (1) - finish sound OK~

[Normal]

01:23:897 (2) - new combo I think starting a new combo with only 1 note in a combo is not good, so i didn't change this~
02:55:743 (1) - finish sound OK~
03:41:666 (2) - make it symmetrical Same as the issue at Beginner (02:22:512)

[Hard]

hm, i like it Thanks!
00:07:743 (1,2,3,4) - 1 grid down OK~
00:52:974 (6,7) - distance I think fixing this distance will be strange ( Not match with the jump before), so i use new combo instead. Hope this will solve the problem~
01:21:012 (1,2,3) - I think this is better
I think that a 1/4 stream which starts at a blue tick is not very good, so i didn't change this~
02:21:589 (1) - finish sound OK~
02:46:512 (2) - I think this is better
Same as 01:21:012~

star~ Thanks for your star and modding!
I am sorry that i didn't use quite a lot of suggestions from you Anyway, your mod is helpful, thanks!

02:52:051 (1) - new combo It is already a new combo, isn't it?

Leorda wrote:

NI HAO You are the first modder to use Chinese for greeting

[File]
Your bg (K-on.jpg) need to resize to 1024x768 (current 767x767) Well... The BG is already in a square size when i get it from the internet ( Length and width were originally 900x900, but when i insert the BG, the system automatically resize it into 767x767~ ) and i actually like this BG quite much, so is it possible not to resize or change the BG? Since resizing a 767x767 pic to 1024x768 may make the BG become strange ( Not in scale pic will make the charactors become "Flattened" or "Stretched") ~ If changing the BG is a must, please tell me, thanks!

[Beginner]
00:26:205 (5) - New combo, it's too long for easy diff OK~
01:55:743 (1) - Move 1 grid down? This is already mentioned by the previous modder and fixed already~ Anyway, thanks for reminding me!
02:37:281 (1) - Finish at start? OK~
02:45:589 (3) - Spacing are broken here, IMO. Turn the distance snap off and move 1 grid up. Like 02:24:820 (1,2,3) OK~

[Easy]
02:33:589 (1) - Finish? I think it is a bit strange, so i didn't change this~
02:37:743 (2) - Clap? OK~
02:39:589 (2) - ^ OK~
02:48:358 (1) - Finish? Same as 02:33:589~
02:52:051 (1) - ^ OK~
03:23:435 (1) - Finish at start? Same as 02:33:589~

[Normal]
01:06:589 (2) - Maybe, try stack with 1 at the end? I think this too difficult for beginner player, IMO Actually, the pattern is same in 01:02:435 (1,2,3,4), and i think it is OK for Normal, so i didn't change this~
01:07:512 (2) - ^ ^
01:36:128 (1,2,3,4) - No jump at normal diff please OK~ Since some modders think that jumps in Normal are OK, but most of them don't think so, i decided to cancel the jump here~

[Hard]
00:07:743 (1,2,3,4) - Move 1 grid down? This is already mentioned by the previous modder and fixed already~ Anyway, thanks for reminding me!

[Taiko Oni]
00:25:974 (1) - Big Katu doesn't seems good OK~
00:31:743 (2) - Replace with Big Don here? OK~
00:40:743 (1) - Big Katu doesn't seems good OK~
01:34:512 ~ 01:45:589 (T) - Don't use 0,5x Inherited Section, that section is for kiai time Actually i think that using 0.5X here will be great. Although i don't really want to change this, you used pink words, so i decided to fix this~
01:54:589 (1) - Big Katu doesn't seems good OK~
02:00:358 (3) - Replace with Big Don here? I want to make the 1st part of that particular place of the song become all big don, and the 2nd one with all big kat, so i didn't change this~
02:09:358 (1) - Big Katu doesn't seems good OK~
02:15:128 (4) - ^ The big kat is same in 00:46:512, i think it is OK so i didn't change this~
03:03:128 ~ 03:10:512 (T) - Don't use 0,5x Inherited Section, that section is for kiai time Same as 01:34:512~
03:28:974 (T) - Don't use kiai for flash only Similar to 01:34:512, In my opinion, this is a Taiko diff but not osu diff, so the rules for maps to be ranked should not be so strict, and i think it is more epic to use kiai for flash here. However, you used pink words, so i decided to change it even i don't really want to~
03:32:666 (T) - ^ [/color] ^

Good song
STAR Thanks for your star and modding!

Vass_Bass wrote:

02:52:051 (1) - new combo It is already a new combo, isn't it?

sorry see (2) I think it is not good to leave a combo with only 1 note. Moreover, the pattern in 01:23:435 is simillar. I think both are OK so i didn't change this~

I'm sorry that there are no any changes in this post. Anyway, thanks for your kind rechecking!

kokoroanime wrote:

*Star*

Thanks for your star!

Garven wrote:

As per your request:

Why still WIP? OK~ Moved to pending~ I didn't move it to pending before because i am not sure if my maps are good enough and i want more modding before moving it. But it is fine now.

[Beginner]
Ugh, 4 minutes at such a low star rating? Maybe try upping the difficulty a little bit to make it more interesting. Or try going with the lyrics a bit more instead of the main beat? I dunno, that'd be a lot of work to keep the style consistent... ah well. What you have now is fine, though. The Slider Velocity in this diff is rather low, when i put a 1/2 beat in it, it is nearly stacked and looked bad. So i think it is not really good to increase the diff. Also, i think it is good to make a diff which is playable for even beginners

[Easy]
Well, I guess you did all that for this one. Up the hp drain by one or two, though. OK~ I increased the HP drain by 1~
02:56:666 (4) - Maybe reduce repeat by one? This pattern is same in 01:27:589 (2) and i think this pattern is OK, so i didn't change this~

[Normal]
Fine.

[Hard]
I've been trying to avoid hitsound modding lately, but please add a softened finish on the spinner at 00:13:281 (1). It's begging for it! OK~
This is really heavy on the straight lines and 90 degree turns - especially with the overmapping. Kind of removes some of the fun-factor for me, but eh. Should i simplify this diff a bit? Since some mappers think that this diff is good, i didn't change anything ATM~
The back and forth jumps are kind of eh. Maybe try to do some patterns with them instead of just going to the same spots over and over?
I'm not a osu player and i don't know many patterns or styles (I'm a Taiko player), can you give me some suggestions about jump patterns? Thanks!

[Taiko]
Sounds fine to me. I can almost play it, too. Nice to see a mild Taiko Oni. Thanks!

I was kind of disappointed in the hard difficulty, but it's technically fine.
Thanks for your modding and star!

aabc271 wrote:

This is really heavy on the straight lines and 90 degree turns - especially with the overmapping. Kind of removes some of the fun-factor for me, but eh. Should i simplify this diff a bit? Since some mappers think that this diff is good, i didn't change anything ATM~

Nah, it's just opinion there. It's not a difficulty thing - more of a thought that goes through my mind. "Why so many beats when there's nothing like that in the original song?" It's fine - it's your style. I just don't like it that much. ;)

The back and forth jumps are kind of eh. Maybe try to do some patterns with them instead of just going to the same spots over and over?
I'm not a osu player and i don't know many patterns or styles (I'm a Taiko player), can you give me some suggestions about jump patterns? Thanks!

Sure. And the taiko player perspective make the rhythms you use make a lot more sense, haha.

I guess just a general technique that I like to do is to set the distance snap to a certain point higher than what you were using before (I like to do snap + .5(snap)) and arrange the beats in some sort of pattern such as a W, a star shape, pentagon - just something pleasing to the eye and reads fine. You don't have to do it that way though - just another personal preference of mine so that I know that my jump spacing is consistent instead of seeing people just do the same 4 beats in each corner of the play field and such.

Garven wrote:

aabc271 wrote:

This is really heavy on the straight lines and 90 degree turns - especially with the overmapping. Kind of removes some of the fun-factor for me, but eh. Should i simplify this diff a bit? Since some mappers think that this diff is good, i didn't change anything ATM~

Nah, it's just opinion there. It's not a difficulty thing - more of a thought that goes through my mind. "Why so many beats when there's nothing like that in the original song?" It's fine - it's your style. I just don't like it that much.
OK~ I will just keep no changes to keep my style~

The back and forth jumps are kind of eh. Maybe try to do some patterns with them instead of just going to the same spots over and over?
I'm not a osu player and i don't know many patterns or styles (I'm a Taiko player), can you give me some suggestions about jump patterns? Thanks!

Sure. And the taiko player perspective make the rhythms you use make a lot more sense, haha.

I guess just a general technique that I like to do is to set the distance snap to a certain point higher than what you were using before (I like to do snap + .5(snap)) and arrange the beats in some sort of pattern such as a W, a star shape, pentagon - just something pleasing to the eye and reads fine. You don't have to do it that way though - just another personal preference of mine so that I know that my jump spacing is consistent instead of seeing people just do the same 4 beats in each corner of the play field and such.

OK~ I've change one of the jumps into a W shape, and the other one into a star shape~

Thanks for giving me so many useful advices! Now my jumps have more different patterns~