1. Easy (0,6 stars, 58 notes)
2. Hard (4,25 stars, 155 notes)
3. Normal (2,75 stars, 98 notes)

1. kill the .osb file and full submit when you update this map next time.

1. 00:00:000 (1) - make it end at 00:00:480

1. 00:11:522 (1,2,3,4,5) - how about ctrl+h them? they are just the same as 00:07:681 (1,2,3,4,5).

Colin Hou wrote:

Hi, I hear your call in #modrequest :3

[General]:

1. kill the .osb file and full submit when you update this map next time.Goddamn osb :< Fixed

[Normal]:

1. 00:00:000 (1) - make it end at 00:00:480Fixed <.<

[Hard]:

1. 00:11:522 (1,2,3,4,5) - how about ctrl+h them? they are just the same as 00:07:681 (1,2,3,4,5).Done

that's all and star~

Nivalis wrote:

Wow, I am downloading this as soon as I hear that someone is mapping Moonsong
1.4 MB...I think I'm getting good at making small maps

[General]
Perhaps... Use a quieter spinnerbonus.wav? No
Add "Daisuke Amaya" to the tags? (because Daisuke Amaya is Pixel's real name)Done, forgot that one
Oh, and perhaps also add "Studio", because in some cases this game is known as a game from Studio Pixel.As Pixel and Studio won't link together if I just add Studio there is no point in adding it

[Easy]
00:39:369 (2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - One grid up for all maybe?Changed
00:53:772 (1,2) - One grid left?Mmm chained
01:12:017 (2) - I'd move this to 01:12:257.I think my current are much better

[Normal]
Fine.

[Hard]
00:14:883 (x) - Maybe add a note here with finish hitsound? And if this is implemented, change 00:14:403 (5) into clap?I was considering this but I actually though it was nicer this way

As I've said, Moonsong is the best song ever in the entire game - Star

Garven wrote:

Meh, can't find anything wrong. Just an opinion, really.

[Easy]
The claps feel a little loud when there are so few notes. They feel okay on the other difficulties though.I found them not that bad :/ Maybe I should recheck them later

[Normal]
01:08:176 (7) - Remove whistle from sliderslide.No

Great stuff!

Oh, if you want, I have all of the sound effects from the game lying around somewhere if you would like to use some as hitsounds (not sure if many would work for a song like this though, hehe)Hmm yeah, I don't think hitsounds like that would fit the song well. Maybe you could give me the song that plays after you defeat a boss for applause.

312,128,33608,2,0,B|394:165|378:237,1,140,2|10

310,130,33608,2,0,B|398:172|373:247,1,140,2|10

NoHItter wrote:

Just some nazis

Normal
00:33:608 (2) - In the .osu file, change

312,128,33608,2,0,B|394:165|378:237,1,140,2|10

with

310,130,33608,2,0,B|398:172|373:247,1,140,2|10

00:37:448 (2) - One grid right

Soaprman wrote:

Saw this in #modreqs.

The map layouts don't really need modded any. However, the offset feels a little late to me. (yes, the zero offset) Maybe try changing it to -12? A negative offset isn't unrankable somehow, is it?

I dunno, give it a try, see if it sounds better to you.

Great stuff here!

arken1015 wrote:

[SB]
At the end of final spin... http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/12882 ???Yes I know this problem but I don't know to make a smooth translation to the BG :/ It's not noticeable in regular osu! though

[Easy]
00:35:684 (2) - [Suggestion] How about align with previous end point? [Umm... you need to off Grid Snap to do this ;_;]No, I prefer the look on it right now
00:39:525 (2) - ^

[Normal]
00:22:721 (2) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid up?Yeah, done.
00:32:804 (5) - How about move 1 grid down?Also done.
01:09:292 (3,5) - How about move 1 grid up?Well there is no point not doing it so done.

[Hard]
00:12:881 (4) - UnsnappedThanks, I missed that
00:16:722 (4) - ^
01:03:292 (4,5,6,7,8) - [Suggestion] How about move 1 grid up?I see no point doing this.


'Cave Story' :3...
I had played this game sometimes ;_;

Anyway, good luck :3

gyt wrote:

I think, clap sounds a bit loud for this song. Maybe set volume to 50%?I tried and felt like 60% (My current one is the best one)

hard
00:20:561 (4,6) - delete clap?No
00:24:402 (4,6) - delete clap?No
00:25:842 (8) - whistle?No
01:07:853 (2) - whistle?No

star)

bmin11 wrote:

[Hard]
00:18:401 (1,2) - Could replace claps with whistlesWell I did it on (2) now but I think it fits on (1)
00:22:002 (7) - WhistleNo
00:25:843 (8) - ^ No yet again.
00:36:406 (6) - Clap? or Whistle?Well.. I kinda like how it sounds like now
00:37:366 (9) - ^ ^

That's all for me. They are all suggestions

Echo wrote:

Z-order (back to front) is determined by the order the files appear in the .osu file. The first storyboard event will be behind everything else, ie. if storyboard event 'A' is above storyboard event 'B', 'B' will be on top of 'A'.

Derekku Chan wrote:

[General]
*Offset looks good!
*Z-ordering is screwed up in the storyboard.This is a storyboard bug, It seems like the order changes sometime for some reason in the editor randomly...
Try re-download it and it will work again (And ticket this bug <.< )

Echo wrote:

Z-order (back to front) is determined by the order the files appear in the .osu file. The first storyboard event will be behind everything else, ie. if storyboard event 'A' is above storyboard event 'B', 'B' will be on top of 'A'.

*Thus, all of the cloud3 lines should be together at the top of the .osb, then all of the cloud2 lines, then cloud1.
*Also, there seems to be some "tearing" at the ends of the cloud sprites. Pause while they're scrolling in the editor and you'll see vertical lines through them.Well I dunno how to fix it though :/ I even think it's a part of it's sprite
*What is empty.png for?Remove it and you see why. It's there for a reason.

[Easy]
*Looks nice!

[Normal]
01:00:650 (1) - move this closer to (4)
01:03:531 (1,2,3) - Could you space these a bit closer together?
01:16:014 (1,2,3,4) - ^
*I just felt that these were a bit too tricky for Normal; and since Hard has similar spacing... XP

[Hard]
*I wish that this was a bit harder, but since it's such a soft/slow song with not many instrumental melodies, it's a bit tough...Well I don't want to make it harder than needed. (Also Easy Series)

EDIT 12: also, can you fade out the clouds better at the end? They seem to stop scrolling and THEN fade out which looks bad. =xWell made it look better now <-<

• That little SB KICKS ASS. Awesome.
  I don't think claps actually fit the song D:

• .Opinions: (Just some thoughts, I'd personally like if you follow them)
  Slidertick rate 2? Pretty please? :<

• .Opinions: (Just some thoughts, I'd personally like if you follow them)
  :3

• .Opinions: (Just some thoughts, I'd personally like if you follow them)
  Circle Size Normal? ;_;
  HP Drain +1? You already used 2 for Normal, so why not increase a tiny bit?

0_o wrote:

General
You have a nice storyboard, but it would be great if there were combo colours to go along with it; it would really add to the feel of the map. This is just an example, but here's a colour scheme I would use:Nice idea, I used a darked colour scheme (but not too dark so it doesn't blend into the background)
Combo1 : 55,255,105
Combo2 : 251,243,106
Combo3 : 3,3,133
Combo4 : 128,128,255

Normal
00:03:037 (1,2) [and the next combo] - Could you make these a bit closer together? I know it sounds nazi but the relative distance between 1 and 2 and 2 and 3 threw me off I didn't found this a problem but there is no point in not doing this so done.

Hard
01:16:015 (1,2,3,4) - This isn't a difficult pattern, but it is quite a difficulty spike compared to the rest of the map imo.I remeber making this pattern harded after wojjan whined how easy the ending was. Well made it simpler again

*

CheeseWarlock wrote:

[Normal]
From 00:18:401 - 00:49:128, I'm not really feeling the music. It's all just on-the-beat patterns. The way it is now, it's acceptable but not exciting.Agreed, re-mapped those I though didn't capture the feel (Although I kept a bit)
01:14:094 (5) - This sounds odd given that the patterns before it don't use 1/2. Well this part is a bit different and I think 1/3 fits here.
01:16:014 (1,2,3,4) - This feels like a lazy "last sequence is harder".Remapped

[Hard]
00:46:248 (2) - This should be 1/2 earlier (respace and alter the mapping as needed).I'm not mapping the main melody to (2)
01:16:015 (1,2,3,4) - Seems to me like there's an opportunity to use a few more 1/4 beats here.
No I think it's fine (and more relaxing) this way)
[Overall]
I don't think the 4th combo colour really works. A yellow shade like in the bottom right could be nice.Well I kinda though of that but didn't do it. Done that now.

These are all pretty much suggestions.

Encrypto wrote:

Good Map, but I see a little Image Error at the Clouds down, like it´s in my map...it seems that it is a common problem.^^(the little black gap)