samexLolicore- wrote:
imo make it go for loved so that I don't have to crush the souls of ripple players by removing my other map just to rank it
forum
Jeff Williams - Die (feat. Casey Lee Williams) [Osu|OsuMania
posted
Total Posts
198
Topic Starter
Topic Starter
yeah accident! will fix tomorrow zz
edit: fixed
edit: fixed
This map is amazing so here's a mod (i'm making this last minute, so this will be just a few general things.).
If this mod sounded sophisticated, good.
It's an awesome map and deserves to be ranked after a few issues are fixed! Amazing job!
[The Off-Topic Stuff]
1) Can I make an Easy Guest Diff?
[General]
1) The sliders move WAY too fast for Emelia K.'s Hard. Slow them down to at least 1.40
2) (this is for all diffs) At 00:44:337 a kiai isn't really needed here, but at 00:54:442 is where the kiai should start and should end at 01:04:548
3) In the Another diff, have the spinner start at 01:02:179 and end at 01:03:127
4) In the Another diff, place a slider at 01:01:863
5) In the Another diff, have the spinner at 01:04:548 end at 01:07:074
[Feedback]
1) The way Extra was mapped is BEAUTIFUL! Amazing job!
2) In Loli's diffs, the ways the streams were mapped were flawless. Nice!
3) Another had very few issues and was mapped yet again awesome. Woo!
4) Ambient's Insane is rocking! Cool!
5) Indeed chose some nice sliders to replace streams and things that couldn't be mapped in Insane. Amazing!
6) If I'm being honest, Emelia K.'s Hard is sort of Unrankable. I know this but I'm not an expert with mods, so consult #modhelp about this. (Not trying to be mean, I'm sorry)
1) Can I make an Easy Guest Diff?
[General]
1) The sliders move WAY too fast for Emelia K.'s Hard. Slow them down to at least 1.40
2) (this is for all diffs) At 00:44:337 a kiai isn't really needed here, but at 00:54:442 is where the kiai should start and should end at 01:04:548
3) In the Another diff, have the spinner start at 01:02:179 and end at 01:03:127
4) In the Another diff, place a slider at 01:01:863
5) In the Another diff, have the spinner at 01:04:548 end at 01:07:074
[Feedback]
1) The way Extra was mapped is BEAUTIFUL! Amazing job!
2) In Loli's diffs, the ways the streams were mapped were flawless. Nice!
3) Another had very few issues and was mapped yet again awesome. Woo!
4) Ambient's Insane is rocking! Cool!
5) Indeed chose some nice sliders to replace streams and things that couldn't be mapped in Insane. Amazing!
6) If I'm being honest, Emelia K.'s Hard is sort of Unrankable. I know this but I'm not an expert with mods, so consult #modhelp about this. (Not trying to be mean, I'm sorry)
If this mod sounded sophisticated, good.
It's an awesome map and deserves to be ranked after a few issues are fixed! Amazing job!
Topic Starter
Sure! And thanks for the mod :3Nyantiaz wrote:
This map is amazing so here's a mod (i'm making this last minute, so this will be just a few general things.).
[notice][The Off-Topic Stuff]
1) Can I make an Easy Guest Diff?
LET STOF DO A GD TBh
Topic Starter
what difficultyxLolicore- wrote:
LET STOF DO A GD TBh
only if it's between easy and insane or above 7 stars
Topic Starter
u know what just fuck this map up fam
do any diff
do any diff
wow what a time to check back on my FAVOURITE forum post
FOR LOVED
yehaj lamo
also stoof mutual pls thank
also stoof mutual pls thank
saying this at all only helps if you actually point out why; i'm aware what i've mapped is intensive on uncommon slider patterns but i see no reason why anything different should be rejected on instinctNyantiaz wrote:
6) If I'm being honest, Emelia K.'s Hard is sort of Unrankable. I know this but I'm not an expert with mods, so consult #modhelp about this. (Not trying to be mean, I'm sorry)
my basis on defending my difficulty is dissatisfaction that gameplay has stagnated into any frame at all when mapping can produce so many potential results, all with their own ideas to be learnt, instead of what years of built-up meta has taught people specifically to play
obviously if my diff does become an obstacle in the end then go ahead and remove it; i'm only a guest mapper, but i would at least like to see a concrete case first
Topic Starter
stoof mutual please
ps:
ps:
obviously if my diff does become an obstacle in the end then go ahead and remove it; i'm only a guest mapper, but i would at least like to see a concrete case firstim not removing any difficulties
updated with a few changes from irc
Miryle and WindZel both agree SV is a little high, so at some point down the line it might need to be renamed to a Light Insane?
Miryle and WindZel both agree SV is a little high, so at some point down the line it might need to be renamed to a Light Insane?
tfw u meant to make a semi-hard map but it becomes a farm map
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/ ... hot719.jpg
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/ ... hot719.jpg
WHDKAGSKSGWHDFHDJWGDJDJSGSJFHSGWWUCHFBSHAKDJF LOLI SILICA FC
yea thnx i put lots of effort into it!!!Stoof wrote:
Nice thumbnail
Please hitsound before this gets loved <3?
helo u called
Topic Starter
hello i'll need a hitsounder to be dispatched immediately please
k brb
Isn't Collapse considered a custom diff name?
Was going to remove Retribution but I don't think people would want that so I'm just remapping lulF1r3tar wrote:
Isn't Collapse considered a custom diff name?
Or maybe I might not remap who knows lo
Topic Starter
As long as it's the highest star difficulty you can name it whatever.F1r3tar wrote:
Isn't Collapse considered a custom diff name?
#modreqs actually works wew
I feel like for the most part you two are missing the red polarity. I won't check Hard because I just think that map is... well, I won't really comment on it. The point is the rhythm should be reconsidered on both of these difficulties.
That's it.~ Good luck!
ExKyu's Normal
[Normal]
- 00:20:495 (2) - This is pretty offscreen, try this?: https://puu.sh/sQkOW/56f7bd7473.png
- 00:28:074 (3) - 00:29:179 - Skipping this note on this slider feel really weird because it's very noticeable. I'm not entirely sure how to fix this, but I'm sure you can come up with something.
One solution could be to add a circle at 00:29:179 - but that's up to you. - 00:43:074 (4) - This could look more symmetrical. https://puu.sh/sQjUe/91f64e0250.png
- 00:49:390 (1,2) - Blanket fix please.~
- 00:51:916 (1) - This spinner recovery time seems too short to be honest. I would try something like this instead: end it at 00:53:653 - and add a circle at 00:54:442?
- 01:02:021 (1,2) - Blanket looks messy.
- 01:16:074 - 01:17:337 - and 01:18:600 - are skipped and it hurts. ;-;
- 01:40:074 (1,2) - Definitely can be blanketed better. 01:46:548 (5,6) - Same.
- 01:51:285 - Polarity here should be exclusively red ticks if you're following vocals. Like so: https://puu.sh/sQlxw/c386fa11db.png
- 01:57:600 (1,1) - This can also be blanketed better. https://puu.sh/sQlAh/32fa671684.png perhaps
- 02:03:758 (1) - This slider literally misses every single note that should be mapped here. 02:03:600 - Misses guitar start and the downbeat at 02:03:916 -
- 02:11:653 (1,2) - Why is this the only instance of you stacking a circle under a slider end?
- 02:14:179 - This should definitely be clickable. Something like you did 02:15:442 (3,4) - maybe?
- 02:36:916 (1) - Start spinner at 02:36:758 - because the vocals start there. Also this is a VERY long spinner.
- 02:48:285 (3) - I feel like this rhythm would play better: https://puu.sh/sQlJk/b0b418b7a0.png
- 02:49:390 (1) - Spinner recovery also feels short here, same case as above.
- 02:56:021 - Polarity changes here to exclusively red if you're following vocals. At the moment 02:57:127 (1,2,3) - skips EVERY vocal note.
- 03:02:021 - After this you can definitely map more, it looks like you just got lazy and decided to only map the guitar. This part could be considered the most intense part of the song
and I think it should definitely be mapped.
Indeed's Insane
[Indeed an Insane]
- 00:09:127 (1,2,1,2,1,2) ? Are these necessary new combos? They seem like false emphasis, since there’s not really warranting those 1>2 jumps.
- 00:10:074 (1) ? Downbeat on slider end, I don’t really thing this is good rhythm especially when this slider is 1/1 compared to all the other sliders before and after it.
- 00:10:390 ? After here you just stop following vocals altogether even though they’re still pretty audible, any reason as to why you do this?
- 00:16:390 (2) ? What is this reverse for? It’s the only one in the beginning of the map.
- 00:19:232 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) ? I don’t see the need for the 1>2 here either, the vocal is held, and has no indication of 1>2 patterning. Nothing else in the song that I can hear suggests this either. Same with the rest of the section.
- 00:26:653 (1,2) ? ? slider for vocals?
- 00:29:179 (4) ? Remove this and move 00:29:337 (5) ? to that spot.
- 00:31:706 (1,2) ? Swap these for rhythm as well, since the vocal starts on red and feels better if held. 00:32:969 (5,6) ? Same for this. In fact in most cases where rhythm like 00:32:969 (5,6) ? is used you could swap them instead for something that plays better imo. I will stop mentioning these cases.
- 00:34:232 (9) ? NC on this red since it’s the start of the next section and the slider ends on a downbeat (which in this case is okay because the red acts as the downbeat in this song in this case)
- 00:34:942 (3,4) ? Awkward flow break if I’m honest. Causing a stop here doesn’t really fit the music.
- 00:39:127 (5) ? Why kickslider if you can use a triple?
- 00:41:337 (1,2,3,4) ? Plays awkwardly and the spacing looks untidy. I get the idea but something like this rhythm: https://puu.sh/sQj8G/e1ec3017e5.png and this placement: https://puu.sh/sQj9B/b9e780295b.png could look and play better.
- 00:44:337 ? Downbeats are usually on reds on this song, so make sure you signify that with a NC or other, because at the moment it looks like you’re ignoring the downbeat entirely, which you shouldn’t. You also seem to place slider ends on downbeats too 00:46:863 ? which plays awkwardly. I will stop mentioning these since you can go and find and fix them yourself.
- 00:51:995 (3,4) ? Awkward flow break. I would expect a jump, not a stacked triple under slider end.
- 01:01:863 (1) ? I’d start this spinner at 01:02:021 ? instead. Fits better with the vocal. Add a circle at 01:01:863 ? then if you do follow this suggestion.
- 01:03:600 (1) ? End this spinner at 01:04:390 ? and have 01:04:706 (1) ? moved to 01:04:548 ? and add a circle at 01:04:863 ? like so: https://puu.sh/sQjjQ/bc217b84a4.png
- 01:33:758 (1,2,3,4) ? Why is this different from 01:34:390 (1,2,3,4) ? and 01:35:021 (1,2,3,4) - ?
- 01:55:232 (1,2,1,2,1,2) ? Again with the seemingly arbitrary 1>2 jumps.
- 02:12:285 (7,9) ? Could be awkward to read. Up to you if you want to change it.
- 02:14:179 (1,2,3,4) ? Why stack this when you spaced out 02:14:811 (1,2,3,4) - ?
- 02:29:337 - 02:36:758 ? I feel this part can be mapped way calmer to represent the calmer section here.
- 02:36:758 (1) - End spinner here 02:39:285. Could start another at 02:39:443 -
- 02:46:627 (7,8) ? Also awkward to play for the same reason as mentioned before.
I feel like for the most part you two are missing the red polarity. I won't check Hard because I just think that map is... well, I won't really comment on it. The point is the rhythm should be reconsidered on both of these difficulties.
That's it.~ Good luck!
Topic Starter
Big thanks mr dragon
btw indeed is rip so low chances of seeing that mod
btw indeed is rip so low chances of seeing that mod
Pls I come back just for u LunarFox bbLunarFox wrote:
Big thanks mr dragon
btw indeed is rip so low chances of seeing that mod
I fix tomorrow
Topic Starter
ily <3
Edit: tfw lied to. this must how being cheated on feels
Edit: tfw lied to. this must how being cheated on feels
RELATABLE (っ˘̩╭╮˘̩)っLunarFox wrote:
ily <3
Edit: tfw lied to. this must how being cheated on feels
edit: an IRC mod happened and we figured it out, fixing soonMir wrote:
I won't check Hard because I just think that map is... well, I won't really comment on it.