That's because that map isn't even ranked (and it's graved) so nobody even notices maps like thoseTidek wrote:
I dont know why BGs in some maps are not deleted yet, people complain about anime gurl in bikini, but no1 is complaining about that kind of maps https://osu.ppy.sh/s/185753 (and there is more stuff with that kind of BGs).
Anyone is checking it to keep it save from things like in above example?
yeah. it doesn't matter for play. man who dislike the bg, players can just dim and do thatKibbleru wrote:
this.
well osu! is a game that was intended for like 13+ i think? and u know... the government and parents and sht doesn't want sexually suggestive things. even if peppy doesn't really care about this himself, it's gotta be done.
on the other hand i really don't think there's anything wrong with the current.
it's just like pantsu = no and bikini = acceptable right?
well who the fuck puts gore in a bg likeWOOB22 wrote:
Why is all talking about boobs and things .-. Remeber to that gore is NSFW too
Well that's an entirely different discussion altogether because that's considered artistic nudity. It's not really portrayed in a sexual sense, it's just a portrayal of the human body. It also does not show any genitalia (As artistic nudity showing genitalia would probably be shot down regardless of its meaning).Kuro wrote:
lol gore
*ehem*
Anyway....
If watercolour got ranked with 2 nude people in the bg, then I don't see why anything else can't.... J/S bro >:
/me runs
CptBlackBird wrote:
we need anime boobs,boobs are love,boobs are life
+∞OzzyOzrock wrote:
we can't ban boobs that's why people download the map!
That's a really stupid way to think about it, as what would be questionable to one person may not be questionable to another as it depends largely on where you're raised and who by. What could be considered tasteful in one country may be widely considered "sick filth" in another more conservative country.Lust wrote:
After speaking to some others and gathering a few opinions, the general consensus seemed to be if you had to ask if it was NSFW, then it probably already is. So if you have any doubts over its "rankability" then its best to suggest a different background. Although my opinion remains the same (the one I posted earlier)
Pantsu is yes????piruchan wrote:
I suggest we use fapability as a guidance. If you can fap to it, then it's not rankable. (But some of you might fap to girls in bikini)
Why don't we have a list of what is acceptable or not? Use this as an exampleV = acceptable, X = not acceptable
Bikinis and male swimsuit V
Skimpy bikinis (ones that barely/only covers private parts) and skimpy male underwear X
See through underwear beneath V
See through no underwear beneath X
Pantsu V
Boxers V
Lingerie X
Hand bra X
Cleavage V
Cameltoe and male equivalent X
Things that seem to be nipples, but the character is still clothed X
Side boob V
Under boob V
Too much boob X
Too much ass X
Ahegao X
Girls/guys blushing and panting X
Nipples and genitalia X
etc
Now someone tell if best BG in 2014 is NSFW or notKinda stupid and off topic, but I think it would workMaybe we need someone who is capable of deciding if BGs are NSFW or not. He/she must have a reasonable approach to this matter. This person doesn't check backgrounds on his/her own will, mappers and BATs come to him/her if they have a questionable BG on their hands. He/she must be able to give clear reasons to each judgment and maybe set a criteria of what is acceptable and not.
I'm more impressed that you managed to come up with such a big list of things...piruchan wrote:
V = acceptable, X = not acceptable
Bikinis and male swimsuit V
Skimpy bikinis (ones that barely/only covers private parts) and skimpy male underwear X
See through underwear beneath V
See through no underwear beneath X
Pantsu V
Boxers V
Lingerie X
Hand bra X
Cleavage V
Cameltoe and male equivalent X
Things that seem to be nipples, but the character is still clothed X
Side boob V
Under boob V
Too much boob X
Too much ass X
Ahegao X
Girls/guys blushing and panting X
Nipples and genitalia X
etc
Wut bro... gtfo, i thought you were cool.. :<piruchan wrote:
Things that seem to be nipples, but the character is still clothed X
mfw when I watch the video up close and see a penis.Wafu wrote:
To be honest, nothing's gonna ever change from what I have seen so far.
Let's talk about this map https://osu.ppy.sh/s/15430
If you open the video (recommended in video player, not osu!, because that will mess up a timing a bit) on 1:42, you can clearly see the girl is holding a penis in her hand and holds it near the mouth (also to mention, she's most probably a loli, what's considered as a child porn in some states, so basically, who downloaded this could have downloaded stuff he can be arrested for without a warning, yay!). That map was never unranked. Because it is "too old" or because it cannot be told what she holds (obviously it's not when you zoom it to your monitor's resolution while the resolution is many times smaller)? If we consider age of the map, we should not remove other NSFW things so it can be fair to all people, both to this map and people who would get their maps removed (for example my map because of having pu**y in song tile) I do not think any justice was used here. If you make a murder, you are not forgiven after few years, you still did a murder. So we shall probably start removing maps and judge what's NSFW after we apply justice to maps which are really NSFW, not questionable. Obviously, not even the fact the QAT system didn't exist back in that time, it shouldn't be an apologize for this map being still available.
About the rules, common sense could be applied I think. Anything what does not emphasize the genitals or breasts is just safe. Showing panties is okay unless a cameltoe is visible, showing breasts partially is okay unless nipples or their shape is visible. What is NSFW about panties, bras, swimsuit and other underwear? You haven't ever seen someone in swimsuit on beach or so? I guess most of us did and I don't think there was anyone who told them to take clothes, obviously. Unless it is sexually suggestive (or eventually showing brutal stuff like interrupted parts of body), it is not NSFW.
sounds legitpiruchan wrote:
Too much ass
Well.. she does have big boobs, but still, that's not sexually suggestive, or if it is, it is same sexually suggestive as flat chest.[ kenon ] wrote:
question
this is NSFW or not ?
this BG for my maps
NSFW shouldn't be depending on boobs, this is kind of unfair to people who has small boobs. It could be NSFW even the person has small boobsWafu wrote:
Well.. she does have big boobs, but still, that's not sexually suggestive, or if it is, it is same sexually suggestive as flat chest.[ kenon ] wrote:
question
this is NSFW or not ?
this BG for my maps
this is kinda funny xD[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
this is kind of unfair to people who has small boobs.
I wonder if people even read the thread stop stealing myStarry- wrote:
this is kinda funny xD[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
this is kind of unfair to people who has small boobs.
i see[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
NSFW shouldn't be depending on boobs, this is kind of unfair to people who has small boobs. It could be NSFW even the person has small boobs
i cri evrytiem ;_;[ kenon ] wrote:
i see[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
NSFW shouldn't be depending on boobs, this is kind of unfair to people who has small boobs. It could be NSFW even the person has small boobs
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/190754
This is not an apologize for anything. You could submit a song that explicitly offends a certain country or race - Which would be obviously deleted, because I do not think we are allowed to propagate racism here, but you could say: "You can mute the game or only music in-game." That's totally insensible. If something is avoidable by some way, that should not be the thing which can make the exceptions. This game is PG-13, so the content provided by it is supposed to be PG-13. No matter the warnings, it does not have to do anything there unless the game's required age is increased. What is so important about putting suggestive backgrounds to the map. Take something mild or neutral and you do not have a problem. If your background does have to show breasts, underwear and so on, so be it, 13 years old people see people in underwear quite regularly (beaches, pools, films that are PG-13 or less), but that obviously happens only in a limited range - For example, there won't be a girl that will put her breasts or ass exactly in front of your face on pool, because it's quite harsh and sexually suggestive - You cannot tell the reason of her acting like that, thus she is probably making a sexual suggestion, it quite easy to judge, if there is a normal picture with someone with underwear who does not do anything related to sex, it is okay (standing in certain angles to emphasize some parts of body might already start to be sexually suggestive, that's like the minimal point I think).CptBlackBird wrote:
almost everyone plays with 100% bg dim,then who cares if you see the boobs for 5 sec when you start the map?
when you realize that osu! is a PG-13 community :')eldnl wrote:
when did sex became that bad to us :'(
This.[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
Mappers shouldn't even put something that could be possibly seems at NSFW
Just put something that is 100% safe or change the BGs
Having NSFW BGs with a warning is stupid
Why putting something that could be NSFW when the whole thing is on the charts instead of the god damn BG
Put something safe so I don't even need to worry about iconing something
The map won't be looked down when you have a safe BG isntead of a sexy BG
There is nothing more to add. This is exactly what I meant with "if you already have to ask people if the picture might be nsfw, then you should already not use it". People should stop trying wandering on the borders of allowance. Just put something neutral, don't put underaged super tits, don't put sexualized things, hence why do you need to put swimsuit bgs if the song doesn't resolve around either swimsuits, summer, swimming, beach, etc.?[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
Mappers shouldn't even put something that could be possibly seems at NSFW
Just put something that is 100% safe or change the BGs
Having NSFW BGs with a warning is stupid
Why putting something that could be NSFW when the whole thing is on the charts instead of the god damn BG
Put something safe so I don't even need to worry about iconing something
The map won't be looked down when you have a safe BG isntead of a sexy BG
Or having different opinions what's sexual and what's not.xxdeathx wrote:
Y'know people got their priorities straight when there's 5 pages of posts discussing the rankability of anime titties
Or maybe the brain matter to treat osu! seriously as a game that's accessible to anyone and everyone and is marketed as such. Since all of its content comes from independent users, they need to be made aware of what would fly in a real-world application, instead of the typical teenager fantasy titty utopia. One wouldn't be able to make a PG-13 game that has little girls smearing their tits and arse in the player's face, so as a community, we should be able to apply the same consideration to the game that we all want to thrive and progress.Aurani wrote:
I sadly have to agree with Captain Democracy up there. Are you seriously THAT bored or just simply lack any brain matter to conclude yourself that it should stay as is?
All hail D33d.D33d wrote:
Or maybe the brain matter to treat osu! seriously as a game that's accessible to anyone and everyone and is marketed as such. Since all of its content comes from independent users, they need to be made aware of what would fly in a real-world application, instead of the typical teenager fantasy titty utopia. One wouldn't be able to make a PG-13 game that has little girls smearing their tits and arse in the player's face, so as a community, we should be able to apply the same consideration to the game that we all want to thrive and progress.Aurani wrote:
I sadly have to agree with Captain Democracy up there. Are you seriously THAT bored or just simply lack any brain matter to conclude yourself that it should stay as is?
Also, seriously guys--stop using dumb and borderline-NSFW backgrounds in a bid for attention. It's asinine and downright tasteless. Have some class and grow the fuck up.
well maybe you're not affected with it, maybe only one in a million that was really affected by something like heavily suggestive image. but, extremely retarded people exist in this world. for example a 12 y.o kid that rape his friend because of the porn vid (real case in my country)eldnl wrote:
I don't remember that something sexually suggestive was that bad to me at 11 - 13 years old, do not underestimate kids, and don't misunderstand me either,
wow that's bad but don't blame the porn :'(Yuzuru wrote:
well maybe you're not affected with it, maybe only one in a million that was really affected by something like heavily suggestive image. but, extremely retarded people exist in this world. for example a 12 y.o kid that rape his friend because of the porn vid (real case in my country)eldnl wrote:
I don't remember that something sexually suggestive was that bad to me at 11 - 13 years old, do not underestimate kids, and don't misunderstand me either,
basically, maybe it's nothing for you but for the others, it may rang their tower.
TL;DR= Lewd BGs makes the game more appealing.Philantropist wrote:
I've been reading this thread for a while, and the solution really does seem very simple.
NSFW is defined as "containing material such as nudity, pornography or profanity, which the viewer may not want to be seen accessing in a public or formal setting such as in a workplace". I personally don't think if an image is NSFW is the right question to ask.
Putting it bluntly, majority of the community are male. I'm not generalising, but it's true and you know it. If I'm going to say that, I may as well make another observation; majority of the community have some interest in "anime". Can you see what I'm getting at? Yeah. It should also be taken into account that you need internet to even play osu!, which brings me to my second point.
Anyone with half a brain knows how to use google. Essentially, "internet! NSFW content is just a click away"."
I understand the main question here is what is NSFW/SFW. But what should really be asked is:
Does the background image/storyboard/video add to the experience of playing the map? Is it even relevant to the song? Is it tasteful? If you go through this thought process when picking a bg, there should be no issues.
(also, is osu! really pg13? I haven't seen that anywhere in the game)
tl;dr osu! is a rhythm game, this shouldn't even be getting as much attention as it currently
It's not a question of whether or not it is immoral to put such pictures/animations in a game that is essentially designed for clicking circles, not looking at pictures/animations. That is entirely beyond the point, and is (in all regards) subjective. I am, therefore, not going to give you my personal opinion about it, more so because it'd be entirely rude and insulting to most people here, than anything else.Philantropist wrote:
I've been reading this thread for a while, and the solution really does seem very simple.
NSFW is defined as "containing material such as nudity, pornography or profanity, which the viewer may not want to be seen accessing in a public or formal setting such as in a workplace". I personally don't think if an image is NSFW is the right question to ask.
Putting it bluntly, majority of the community are male. I'm not generalising, but it's true and you know it. If I'm going to say that, I may as well make another observation; majority of the community have some interest in "anime". Can you see what I'm getting at? Yeah. It should also be taken into account that you need internet to even play osu!, which brings me to my second point.
Anyone with half a brain knows how to use google. Essentially, "internet! NSFW content is just a click away"."
I understand the main question here is what is NSFW/SFW. But what should really be asked is:
Does the background image/storyboard/video add to the experience of playing the map? Is it even relevant to the song? Is it tasteful? If you go through this thought process when picking a bg, there should be no issues.
(also, is osu! really pg13? I haven't seen that anywhere in the game)
tl;dr osu! is a rhythm game, this shouldn't even be getting as much attention as it currently
Everything has been said. Stop using stupid backgrounds.Loctav wrote:
There is nothing more to add. This is exactly what I meant with "if you already have to ask people if the picture might be nsfw, then you should already not use it". People should stop trying wandering on the borders of allowance. Just put something neutral, don't put underaged super tits, don't put sexualized things, hence why do you need to put swimsuit bgs if the song doesn't resolve around either swimsuits, summer, swimming, beach, etc.?[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
Mappers shouldn't even put something that could be possibly seems at NSFW
Just put something that is 100% safe or change the BGs
Having NSFW BGs with a warning is stupid
Why putting something that could be NSFW when the whole thing is on the charts instead of the god damn BG
Put something safe so I don't even need to worry about iconing something
The map won't be looked down when you have a safe BG isntead of a sexy BG
Most people do it because sex sells and they think that they have to put their fapping material everywhere (like many do with their skins).
Get some sexual satisfaction elsewhere. I never understood why this is a question after all. Everything you would not your little daughter/son/sister/brother/cousin of an age of 13 to get in contact with or if you would wish to hide it in front of them and/or couldn't show the picture to your conservative grandparents or parents, is basically not good to go.
Yes, that includes super tits that disobey the rules of physics and anatomy. Because that's already sexualized.
p/3693313[ S a k u r a ] wrote:
Mappers shouldn't even put something that could be possibly seems at NSFW
Just put something that is 100% safe or change the BGs
Having NSFW BGs with a warning is stupid
Why putting something that could be NSFW when the whole thing is on the charts instead of the god damn BG
Put something safe so I don't even need to worry about iconing something
The map won't be looked down when you have a safe BG isntead of a sexy BG
