1. Futsuu (2.1 stars, 189 notes)
2. Kantan (1.61 stars, 108 notes)
3. Muzukashii (2.78 stars, 313 notes)
4. Oni (3.48 stars, 441 notes)

rew0825 wrote:

Hi

[Kantan]
00:36:118 (29,30) - k okay~
00:43:042 (37) - k for consistency..okay

[Futsuu]
00:29:855 (49) - k i think a don would fit better (and consistency)
01:04:305 (22) - k don would fit better. would be a kat if it is directly continuing the previous pattern.
01:25:590 (71) - k okay

[Muzukashii]
00:16:668 (32) - k nope for consistency
00:29:855 (82) - k ^
00:32:822 (90,91) - d kay (i guess i'll make this an execption)
00:33:151 (92) - k sorry, no
01:22:294 (247) - K it sounds good already
01:22:458 (248) - Delete okay
01:22:623 (248) - move to 01:22:788 i'm not mapping to the main melody, so no
01:23:942 (256) - Ddoesn't really fit..
01:24:107 (257) - Delete this one's okay
01:24:272 (257) - move to 01:24:436 not mapping to the melody
01:25:590 (264) - D i don't really want a big not after a cluster so no
01:25:754 (265) - Delete kay
01:25:920 (265) - move to 01:26:085 same reason as last time
01:28:887 (279) - D same reason as last time
01:29:052 (280) - Delete kay
01:29:217 (280) - move to 01:29:381 same reason as last time
01:30:535 (287) - D same reason as last time
01:30:699 (288) - Delete kay
01:30:864 (288) - move to 01:31:030 same reason as last time
01:32:184 (299) - D same reason as last time
01:32:348 (300) - Delete no since the last pattern's special (as in intentionally different than others)
01:32:513 (300) - move to 01:32:678 same reason as last time

[Oni]
00:13:371 (24) - k kay
01:03:728 (277,278) - ctrl+g i feel like it's okay as it is
01:20:563 (357,358) - ^ ^

1. 00:16:668 (20) Kat fits better with the music in my opinion

1. 00:14:525 (24) Don plays better here imo
2. 00:29:855 (82) Kat fits better with the music in my opinion
3. 01:22:294 (247) BIG DON sounds awesome here imo
4. 01:32:348 (295) Could be better if you remove this note

1. 00:08:018 (6) Kat maybe?
2. 00:11:888 (17) This object feels a bit unnecessary in my opinion. What about to remove it?
3. 00:29:525 (110,111,112,113,114) This pattern could be a better idea in my opinion:
   
4. 01:03:645 (276) Kat fits good with the instrument here and flows better
5. 01:20:480 (356) (^)
6. 01:21:964 (364,365,366,367,368) Same suggestion from 00:29:525 (110,111,112,113,114)

XinCrin wrote:

Hi , from my queue


Kantan

1. 00:16:668 (20) Kat fits better with the music in my opinion for variation i think it's okay

Muzukashii

1. 00:14:525 (24) Don plays better here imo i guess it's to emphasise the later pattern..okay
2. 00:29:855 (82) Kat fits better with the music in my opinion okay
3. 01:22:294 (247) BIG DON sounds awesome here imo okay
4. 01:32:348 (295) Could be better if you remove this note i guess it'll too hard for some players...okay

Oni

1. 00:08:018 (6) Kat maybe? okay~
2. 00:11:888 (17) This object feels a bit unnecessary in my opinion. What about to remove it? it kinda feels empty without it...i think the note stays
3. 00:29:525 (110,111,112,113,114) This pattern could be a better idea in my opinion:
   sounds nice....okay~~
4. 01:03:645 (276) Kat fits good with the instrument here and flows better i guess so...yeah
5. 01:20:480 (356) (^) okay
6. 01:21:964 (364,365,366,367,368) Same suggestion from 00:29:525 (110,111,112,113,114) okay

I'm a beginner taiko modder . So, sorry if my mod wasn't helpful
Anyways , it's a funny map!. Good luck !

Q____X wrote:

Hi this is my mod

kantan

00:15:349 - add d okay
00:16:009 (11) - k it'll clash with the next kat note so...no sorry :<

Futsuu

00:22:272 - add d ok

Muzukashii

00:05:018 - add d
00:07:590 - ^
00:52:272 - ^
00:52:602 - ^
00:54:250 - ^
00:54:415 - ^
00:54:580 - ^
00:54:580 - ^ rejected all because i'm trying to map to the drums/chimes (?) in the music

Oni

00:05:018 - add d
00:05:018 - ^ rejected all because same as above

Nice map, good luck

[I]MMoRTal[S] wrote:

Hi ~ From my queue

[Muzukashii]
00:08:018 (6) - Hmm .. this can be k and i feel k is fit better here and it's the similar sound with 00:02:875 (2) - and 00:05:447 (4) - also your Oni has note on here but it's k oh..yeah i kinda forgot about that orz. changed~

00:14:607 (27) - add d : this triplet follow the song well added a don

00:24:085 (63) - add d : consider from 00:25:734 (68,69) - and 00:29:031 (80,81) -
00:27:382 (74) - add d : ^

00:29:031 (81) - this note have a higher pitch than 00:29:195 (82) - so k should be fine ~

00:30:679 (88) - add d : ^
00:33:976 (99) - add k : ^ then change 00:34:141 (100) - to d

00:43:042 (144,145,146) - swap color kkd should fit to the song more ~ all of the above added~ Thanks!

[Oni]
00:15:184 (35,36) - Ctrl+G : i think 00:15:184 (35) - is have higher pitch than 00:15:349 (36) - okay

00:16:338 (39,40,41,42,43) - wat !? : they are not fit to the song ! i suggest you to make note like my pic ddKd (why keep 00:16:833 (42) - bcos your style are going to this way)
changed to D dk

00:21:118 (65,66,67) - pitch are going down suddenly kdd should better [color=#FF0000 ]but kdd sounds awkward if not properly placed :< nope..[/color]

00:23:014 - and 00:23:179 - should be remove since it's not follow the song at all changed a bit

01:22:046 - and 01:22:211 - remove ^
01:28:640 - and 01:28:804 - remove ^ rejected this and the one above because it won't have the same impact as a five note cluster
01:28:887 (406) - change to k to follow the song okay

Good Luck ~

Senritsu wrote:

may i predict that this is going to be another speedrank from you--

ReySHeL wrote:

hi from my queue.

[Oni]

1. 00:01:590 - ~ 00:08:875 - add some notes plz. need to some notes than Muzukashii. trying to follow the drum and bell chimes, so no
2. 00:13:536 - remove and 00:13:701 - add k. sound is more fit. ok
3. 00:49:305 - remove finish. its no strong sound. changed into k and added another k after it (to follow drum sounds)

[Muzukashii]

1. 00:10:075 - add finish. kiai start here. ok
2. 00:21:118 (53,54) - try ctrl + g. can follow the melody and drum. ok
3. 00:41:064 - k. good sound. oh hey it does sound better

[Futsuu]

1. 00:10:075 - add finish. ok

[Kantan]

1. 00:10:075 - add finish. ok

nice map!
good luck!

Charlotte wrote:

Hi from Charlotte's Taiko Modding Queue

d
k
D(big d)
K(big k)

Kantan

SV1.4→1.2 done

Futsuu

SV1.4→1.2 done

Muzukashii

01:03:481 (195,196,197,198,199,200,201) - change k d d k d k d (be better?) changed to k d d d k k d
01:20:316 (263,264,265,266,267,268,269) - ^ same as above

Oni

Very Good~

Nice maaaaap! Good luck

Genocide wrote:

hiii again~

[Oni]
00:01:590 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - apa gk terlalu simple ? added spinner at 00:08:875 (kan ngikutin percussionnya)
00:11:393 (14,15,16,17) - kddk changed to kkdk
00:12:217 (18,19,20,21) - dkdd ok
01:06:470 (280) - mini don aja kali ya? klo D juga bisa tp klo buat aku sih d aja soalnya enak dengernya memang sih drumnya gak sekencang 2di 2 not sebelumnya, tapi kalo jadi don biasa takutnya kerasa disjointed/terputus dari not sebelumnya
01:18:008 (339,340) - ctrl+ g nope. big don in every 2 downbeat

[Muzukashii]
00:11:393 (13) - K rasanya gak usah soalnya ga ada yang mengindikasikan K di musiknya :<

Sorry for short mod

bbj0920 wrote:

YEAAAHH GEKIDAN RECORD FUKIN ROCKS, from my modding queue.

General : OD -1 for every diff. Seriously. arright lel

Kantan

SPOILER

00:11:723 (7) - k kay
00:49:305 (46) - ^ - It has higher pitch compared to 00:48:976 (45) - no i'm not following the pitch in this part
01:09:437 (63) - ^ want to avoid d k d k pattern so no
01:12:074 (67,68) - d k or k k, The reason is pretty much same as above^2. It has higher pitch than earlier part. it doesn't seem like it'll fit to me :<
01:17:349 (74) - k okay since it's much higher than the previous notes

Futsuu

SPOILER

00:39:745 (74) - k kay
00:46:339 (93) - ^ kay
01:04:305 (22) - ^ - Because of the pitch. kay

Muzu

SPOILER

00:47:657 (169) - k seems reasonable
01:28:887 (305) - ^ kay

Oni

SPOILER

00:36:118 (133,134,135,136) - ddkk seems good
00:42:712 (184,185,186,187) - ^ ^

1. 00:17:987 - Maybe add a kat here for consistency with other patterns? not sure what else this could be based on lol
2. well the map's really nice but it's really simple. I worry that the diff spread from Kantan to Futsuu is a bit too much considering the Futsuu has lots of 1/1s compared to the very very large gaps of Kantan, so perhaps make Kantan just a little bit harder? c:

1. 01:26:085 (72,73,74,75,76,77,78,79,80,81,82,83) - maybe break this pattern up a bit since it's quite complex for a 182 BPM Futsuu imo, also make sure to break up any other long patterns that I haven't noticed throughout...that's all I can really say about it other than maybe cut down on the 1/2s slightly since some of them make the map a bit of an easy Muzukashii imo

1. Perhaps give the final section of the song (the part after the second Kiai) some 2/1 breaks; the pattern used is really long and maybe Muzu players should still be getting the occasional 2/1 break ;_;

1. The beginning of the song really should be given a slight difficulty boost; right now it's equivalent to the Muzukashii which is really odd to me seeing how that just makes the difficulty spike in the rest of the song absolutely huge by comparison and also why is the end like the hardest part seriously this lowers the Kiais' emphasis and it's only the finishers that give emphasis (which are even less emphasised due to less notes in the Kiai compared to the end ;w;)

Dainesl wrote:

Late mod is late

Black = Suggestion/small recommendation
Orange = Strong recommendation
Red = Unrankable issue

Kantan

1. 00:17:987 - Maybe add a kat here for consistency with other patterns? not sure what else this could be based on lol done
2. well the map's really nice but it's really simple. I worry that the diff spread from Kantan to Futsuu is a bit too much considering the Futsuu has lots of 1/1s compared to the very very large gaps of Kantan, so perhaps make Kantan just a little bit harder? c: added notes here and there~

Futsuu

1. 01:26:085 (72,73,74,75,76,77,78,79,80,81,82,83) - maybe break this pattern up a bit since it's quite complex for a 182 BPM Futsuu imo, also make sure to break up any other long patterns that I haven't noticed throughout...that's all I can really say about it other than maybe cut down on the 1/2s slightly since some of them make the map a bit of an easy Muzukashii imo done

Muzukashii

1. Perhaps give the final section of the song (the part after the second Kiai) some 2/1 breaks; the pattern used is really long and maybe Muzu players should still be getting the occasional 2/1 break ;_; ok

Oni

1. The beginning of the song really should be given a slight difficulty boost; right now it's equivalent to the Muzukashii which is really odd to me seeing how that just makes the difficulty spike in the rest of the song absolutely huge by comparison and also why is the end like the hardest part seriously this lowers the Kiais' emphasis and it's only the finishers that give emphasis (which are even less emphasised due to less notes in the Kiai compared to the end ;w;) not changing since i'm merely just following the music. the last part is intentionally harder since the music's more complex there as well

good luck for rank btw~

EDIT:Actually I noticed some other things in the mapset too let me go over those real quick (please apply in all diffs that have the appropriate note, AND I WILL BE OMITTING SIMILAR SUGGESTIONS.)

All are based on the MUZUKASHII difficulty, but like I said, these also apply to other diffs containing these specific notes, because lazy blah

00:18:316 (41) - You had this as a don but I think it fits better as a kat, due to you using 00:22:602 (60,61) - these as two kat finishers, this is kinda the same sound but just with different amount of emphasis done to k f & m
00:36:613 (113,114) - Perhaps you should invert these as the latter really has very little that it's following, thus it has less emphasis, thus it should be mapped as a don, and the former has a sharp rise in pitch (just like 00:43:206 (146,147) - ) done to m
01:12:239 (225) - It would also be a nice touch imo if you got rid of this note and the next pattern would be more distinguishable from this one, thus creating similar emphasis done to m

Yay now I feel better about giving these suggestions since it's like a whole bunch packed into three

and they're to do with consistency which is mainly what I focused on in the first "part" of the mod

therefore they should be mostly relevant!

1. i talked about song title with some Japanese BATs.
   romanised title should be : Yuukyuu Shinwaroku -Haruka naru Sanmyaku ni Nagareru Taiga no Hotori nite-
2. disable widescreen support.

1. 00:22:272 (33) - remove this one for the consistency with 00:15:679 -
2. 00:47:822 (96) - the same as above. it lacks the consistency with 00:41:228 -
3. 01:20:480 (56) - move to 01:21:140 - ? just suggestion. it will work well as one variation.
4. 01:26:414 (73) - 01:33:007 (92) - remove them. i guess that such 4 plet is more harder than 5 plet, right?

1. 00:36:118 ~ 00:47:987 - i recommend that you should reduce those 1/4 triplets. so these are actually harder than KIAI time. it plays kinda weird.

1. 00:36:118 ~ 00:47:987 - yes, the same as Muzukashii. please consider reducing some 1/4 notes. also, this part needs more break absolutely.
   e.g. 00:36:118 ~ : http://puu.sh/bPzVb/fc0e0ecbb4.jpg
2. 01:21:964 ~ 01:33:667 - basically the same. maybe its acceptable for me but please consider reducing.