ExUsagi wrote:

Quality Assurance Team wrote:

Disqualification Notice

Hello!

Unfortunately, the Quality Assurance Team has decided to disqualify this beatmap. The following is a list of reasons and examples for the disqualification. We do not outline every issue in detail, so make sure to take the idea behind each reason and apply it to the entire beatmap as issues might be found in more than the spots mentioned below. If you have any questions, please reply to this post and we will do our best to clarify any misunderstandings.

General

Mapping Quality / Inconsistencies in the lower difficulties

• 
  Throughout the mapset (mainly in the lower difficulties) there are a number of mapping inconsistencies which greatly reduce the quality of this mapset. Please take into account the following issues and address them accordingly.
  
  Shana's 4K Beginner:

1. 00:38:639 (38639|3) - No real significant noise to place a note here.
2. 00:39:239 (39239|2) - Same as the above point.
3. Whereas, 00:39:539 - There is no reason to miss this kick out.
   Overall it is inconsistent with the section at 01:50:789 - to 01:51:989 -.
   
   7K Beginner:
4. 01:24:389 - to 01:29:189 - It is highly advised not to create your own rhythm using clap hitsounds and 2 note chords.
5. 01:52:589 (112589|5) - This is inconsistent with 01:54:989 (114989|4) - , as it is a normal note instead of an LN.
   
   4K Hyper:
6. 01:15:689 (75689|0,75689|2,75764|1,75839|2,75914|3) - Again feels as if you're creating your own rhythm by including a stream in every 3rd bar. It's preferred to keep this consistent, however the usage of anchors in these streams make them unnecessarily awkward to play.
   
   4K Hyper+:
7. 00:39:089 (39089|3,39126|2,39164|1,39201|0,39239|3,39276|2,39314|1,39351|0,39389|3,39389|2) - is inconsistent with 01:51:089 (111089|2,111089|3,111389|1,111389|0) - despite being the exact same sound.
   
   Ichi's 7K Hyper:
8. 00:36:239 (36239|6,36239|0,36314|5,36314|1,36389|4,36389|2) - This contains more notes than the Black Another difficulty. As it is a 1/4 kick sound, perhaps it is best to reduce the kicks to only 1 note ( like at 00:38:489 (38489|2,38564|4,38639|2,38714|4) - ), or simply add more notes in Black Another.
   
   4K Another:
9. 00:39:689 (39689|3,39689|2,39689|0) - is inconsistent with 01:51:689 (111689|3,111726|2,111764|1,111801|0,111839|3,111876|2,111914|1,111951|0,111989|2,111989|3) - , despite being the exact same sound
   
   As you can see there is a lot of small errors across each of the easier difficulties and it is highly recommended you fix all of these issues.

If you happen to have concerns about this disqualification, you can contest the decision with this form. Before using this form, please read the instructions carefully.

The Beatmap Nominators may handle this mapset after the issues have been addressed.

Good luck!

###M

Quality Assurance Team wrote:

Ichi's 7K Hyper:
00:36:239 (36239|6,36239|0,36314|5,36314|1,36389|4,36389|2) - This contains more notes than the Black Another difficulty. As it is a 1/4 kick sound, perhaps it is best to reduce the kicks to only 1 note ( like at 00:38:489 (38489|2,38564|4,38639|2,38714|4) - ), or simply add more notes in Black Another.

Added double stream on B.Another

ExUsagi wrote:

[7K Black Another]
01:24:539 (84539|4,84839|4,85139|4,85439|3) - you sure you wont layer each 1/2 beat here with double notes? pew said my pattern is okay

[4K Hyper]
i forgot how 4K hyper looks like before dq, but
01:16:889 (76889|2,77039|3) - 01:26:489 (86489|3,86639|2) - you might want to make this 1/2 jack to layer the strong kick as well as you layer the synth done

ExPew wrote:

gogo

Harbyter wrote:

yo deca , wanna say something here on the extra

00:27:920 -

00:28:520 -

01:39:920 -

01:40:520 -

in my opinion is really strange to use LNs for those 1/8 and 1/16 burst here , and the consistence of hte notes are different too

7K was used LN for represent the burst. While 4K didn't, was asked to qat for this. Still consistent for each keymode


01:03:620 - ~ 01:12:020 - first burst oky but from here 01:13:220 - why is so easy from here when there are additional instrumental in the redline lol

It should be like that. If I add another double stream star diff can pumped into 6.5 and it leads to unrankable spread. Was asked to expew about this and it fine like it was ( I'm not sure player like jhlee can ss it again )

Kuo Kyoka wrote:

Ryu* Vs. Sota - Go Beyond!! [OsuMania]

[Generals]

1. BPM: Good
2. Offset: Good
3. Snapping Conflicts: Good
4. AiMod: Good
5. Preview Time: Good
6. Hitsound: Good
7. Folder's Problems: Fine
8. Timing: Great
9. Tags: Sound Good
10. Metadata: Fine
11. Kiai: Great
12. BG: Good

Since all things are fixed w/ lets go for rebubble, no problems appears

Rebubbled

Congratulation on the rebubble, DE-CADE, [Shana Lesus], Ichigaki and Fullerene- <3 ~ Great map with good song ~
Good luck on Requalification

ExUsagi wrote:

give me some couple minutes to review this map, i only have couple hours until i left osu again.. :C

-----------------
[General stuff]
fine, all of QATs discreet seems fixed by everything..

[ichi 7k hyper]
00:09:620 (9620|5,9845|3,10070|1,10220|3,10370|5) - probably i missed this one, you can make it 2 2 4 6 6
[4K hyper]
00:07:820 (7820|0,8120|2,8420|3,8420|1) - maybe you want to make same pattern like 4K hyper, the 1st column LN sorta too faint to be a LN |rearranged
[harder 4K diffs]
00:29:420 - i'd rather remove this LN because the reverse cymbal starts at 00:28:970 -, and i almost unable to catch what instrument you trying to layer there
[rest of diffs]
its clean, all addressed issues has been fixed (and some are left like how it is before & after dq)
-----------------

ok the mp3 seems lot better (and thanks for the timing check kk)