1. Breeze's Difficulty (3,18 stars, 363 notes)
2. Easy (1,36 stars, 97 notes)
3. Hard (4,47 stars, 609 notes)
4. lepidon! - Taiko Oni (4,53 stars, 763 notes)
5. Normal (3,89 stars, 348 notes)

Shulin wrote:

Hai!

General:

~ Set BG colour to black. Done
~ I don't think this needs an Easy (because I know someone will ask for one eventually XD) Agreed
~ Remove (Nobuo Uematsu) from the source and throw him into tags. Done
~ AI Mod is bitching about the map length but it's so lovely, so ignore it. :3
~ All your inheriting sections are late, the nazi modders will probably mention this, up to you whether you change (it's about -25 on everything if you decide to). I guess I am not gonna change unless someone says how exactly and how much does it affect gameplay :p
~ You have 2 .obs's make sure to delete "Nobuo Uematsu - Suteki Da Ne".osb and do a full submit, you may as well delete the other .osb too since you don't have a SB. Oh :D


Normal:

~ Add a silent slider slide? What? How?

01:44:160 (2) - I love this overlap, maybe a bit too tricky for the easiest difficulty but w/e. Yeah might be confusing. Changed it so that it doesnt overlap anything.
01:54:660 (4) - I think you should use a silent slider slide for this and the other normal sliders (if you need one let me know), it will silence that grinding noise from the normal hit slide.
02:37:088 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Grid snap these triplets and align them so they look even. Fixed. Might not be how you meant it to be but its now how I wanted it to be.
04:35:160 (1) - Move forward to white tick, end same point. Done
04:35:160 (1) - Soft at the end of this spinner sounds better imo. True that.

The vocals do seem to stray from the beat sometimes like 05:01:517 (3) - seems to be on a blue tick, I didn't get chance to test your offset thoroughly so its either Rikki being stupid or a wrong offset. I made the offset according to the beat, not the singing. So yeah, Rikki might be stupid :D In 25% speed it sounds like it shud be on blue tick but in 100% I think it sounds too late. I'll let it remain on the white tick.

Hard:

~ Silent slider slide? Nani?
~ Add a preview point. Done

00:45:445 (2,3) - Grid snap this stack. You has an accurate eye :o
00:50:802 (1) - Make it neater lol. Done
01:13:088 (1) - A bit too far off grid. Done
01:13:945 (2,3,4,5) - Didn't like this bit, beat seems a little random. Done, since its 100% of the modders so far didn't like it :P
01:25:517 (2,3,4) - Uneven stack (grid snap is your friend) I have no idea why they weren't grid snapped
01:56:802 (5) - Make this land the same place as 01:55:945 (1) - Done
02:02:374 (5) - Was this supposed to be a heart? lol. I have no idea what else it could be. Also, is it too round or something?
02:23:802 (6,7,8,9) - Random double notes imo.Yup. 100% hate :P changed
03:28:945 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ But now accompanying a slider. Yeah well there's 3 1/4 beats now becouse of the slider so they shouldn't sound as random.
03:58:945 (9) - Make this the same place as 7 (grid snap again lol) ;_;
04:33:231 (4) - Not sure I like this shape XD Yeah you should really tell me whats up with that.
04:35:374 (1) - Soft? If not make Normal sound the same. Done
04:59:803 (5) - This is easier than normal, maybe use this in normal? Oh and add a new combo. Done changes to normal too.

I liked the triplet stacks those were nice, I'm not so sure about the triplet streams though it gave off the overmapped feeling, also some of the stacks look uneven because of grid snap make sure to look out for those. I'll try to fix some of the streams soon :s

Anyways here's a star for a wonderful map :D

Shulin wrote:

~ I don't think this needs an Easy (because I know someone will ask for one eventually XD)

Armin wrote:

Optimize the offset: 41795, then resnap all notes in all the difficulties.
Also, delete the file .osb in the folder.

[Normal]

Overall: Nice map, just some points of concern: 1) Some sliders are asymmetric, like 00:42:231 (2); 2) Some hitsounds seems a little random, try to add a hitsounds-patterning (download the file at the end of the post for this);No, since I don't know what you changed. There is no "right" way to hitsound things. 3) Decrease the slider tick rate. Yes sir!

01:05:802 (9) Make this slider better rofl, done
02:14:802 (3) Use the spacing no
01:17:802 (3) Stack this perfectly with (2)'s end (01:17:374) Done
01:34:088 (7) You shouldn't add jumps like this in a Normal like this, If you want, stack this hitcircle with the previous (5) Okay, changed.. Even though don't know why.

Overall Rating: 8,5/10

[Hard]

Overall: Increase the overall and if you want download the .osu at the end of the post for the hitsounds modding. No, since I don't know what you changed. There is no "right" way to hitsound things.

01:55:517 (8) Spacing. Make a perfect triangle Done
02:02:374 (5) Hard slider to fit. Make the start and the end visible. no
04:33:231 (4) As above no
02:06:660 (x) Place a hitcircle here Sounds awkward :o
04:04:088 (1,2,3) They have different spacing (I don't mean the jump in (3)) but in the timeline they are all placed in white ticks. Move the (1) in the middle of (2) and (3) Fixed
04:58:945 (3) Stack this perfectly with (2)'s start Fixed

Overall Rating: 8,5/10

Xgor wrote:

~Disagree~
I hate when a song is calm and relaxing yet and dosn't have a relaxing Easy >:( Normal isn't relaxing? I am not making an easy becouse it is a long song and the normal is easy enough. Even beginners will find it a good, easyish practice since the bpm isn't high and life drain is very low.

(That's what i think)

[All diffs]
Maybe lower the Overall difficulty so it becomes more relaxing Lowered it in normal

[Normal]
04:30:231 (1,2,3,4) - I dislike stacks like that.... they are stupid in my opinion You just cant hit them >;P

[Hard]
00:54:231 (1,2,3,4,5) - Yet again i dislike stacks like that. Silence, they rock
01:01:088 (1,2,3) - Why a Anti-Jump here? Becouse
01:04:088 (3,4,5) - ^
01:07:945 (1,2,3) - ^ (I prefer stacks than this)
01:21:660 (1) - Could you make this slider more like 01:05:802 (9) on normal, It's soo... boxy right now. AgrEEeeed
01:46:517 (1,2,3,4) - Stupid Stack o_o /me refuses to fix
02:02:374 (5) - It's impossible to see what direction the slider goes, Add a SB arrow or change it a bit That whatever-it-is-called-yellow-sliderball-radius-circle is so damn big. Its not possible to screw that up.
02:36:660 (1,2,3,4,5) - I think slider overlaps like that (Or with any slider overlaps at all) is allowed. I think so too.
03:17:374 (8,9,10,11) - Stup.... Meh i stop saying it. (After all, it's just my opinion) :D
04:33:231 (4) - Same thing with the slider direction again (These slider are against the guidelines) If they wont make an exception becouse of the cursor radius thing, they're retarded.

As i said before, I prefer Easy diffs for relaxing sing like that but you have said already that you won't make one so...meh
Great map.
*star*

Shulin wrote:

I was going to attach a silent slider slide but .wav extension isn't allowed :(

Instead, download the silence from here.

Then rename the file "normal-sliderslide" and put it in your song folder. Every time you switch to normal on a slider use "Custom Override 1", and the slider should now be silent. If you decide to use it make sure to full submit, I hope that made sense :P

1. osb.file didn't used, please delete and full submit
2. [Hard] didn't set preview time, please set same one as [Normal]
3. I think (Nobuo Uematsu) should be a tag not source
4. I'm afraid this song is a little long :\

1. I prefer to 01:58:080 (4) and 01:59:795 (4) no clap, or add clap at 02:01:509 (2), 02:03:223 (5) and 02:04:937 (5), that would sounds better
2. 02:55:509 (1) - end at with normal hitsound sounds better, maybe then add a note at 02:58:937 with finish sound
3. about green lines, you can add a normoral hitsound as custom soft-hitclap, no need to use so many green lines :/
4. 04:28:937 (2), 04:30:652 (3), 04:32:366 (1), 04:34:080 (2) - add clap

1. 00:41:795 (1,2,3) - end of them didn't stack well, fix it by turning off grid snap
2. 02:02:366 (5) - hidden slider...Players can't tell which side to go :/
3. 04:33:223 (4) - ^

Breeze wrote:

[General]

1. osb.file didn't used, please delete and full submit
2. [Hard] didn't set preview time, please set same one as [Normal]
3. I think (Nobuo Uematsu) should be a tag not source Yeah I thought I fixed that.
4. I'm afraid this song is a little long :\

People complained how it ended abruptly when it was shorter, so I made it longer.

[Normal]

1. I prefer to 01:58:080 (4) and 01:59:795 (4) no clap, or add clap at 02:01:509 (2), 02:03:223 (5) and 02:04:937 (5), that would sounds better Took the claps out
2. 02:55:509 (1) - end at with normal hitsound sounds better, maybe then add a note at 02:58:937 with finish sound Changed the spinner but didn't add a note.
3. about green lines, you can add a normoral hitsound as custom soft-hitclap, no need to use so many green lines :/ I am not sure how and I can't be bothered now that I've already made this map :D
4. 04:28:937 (2), 04:30:652 (3), 04:32:366 (1), 04:34:080 (2) - add clap

[Hard]

1. 00:41:795 (1,2,3) - end of them didn't stack well, fix it by turning off grid snap Fixed
2. 02:02:366 (5) - hidden slider...Players can't tell which side to go :/ The radius is so large, they cant fail
3. 04:33:223 (4) - ^

Beatiful song and neat map <3
If you don't mind, you could use my hitcircle, it's suitable for this map
And...Do you mind I add a guest diff. for this map?
I really love this song




star + kds star

James wrote:

not sure about the timing, me thinks that the offset is still off, maybe ill try checking it out after i have a good night sleep

hard:

i think hard doesnt need to have "triplets" (or 3 consecutive 1/4 beat circles)
if i were to map this, ill just map it straightfoward, following vocals and with the use of soft sounds only.

01:01:080 (1,2,3) - i got tripped off the first time i saw this, but on the second time i didnt anymore, so its fine. other people "might" complain about it though I propably won't change it even if lots of people do complain about it :D I like how it looks
01:14:794 (1,2,3) - patterns like these are good to me, they are still visible because of the curved sliders
02:02:366 (5) - heart slider is ok for me also, its not that big for it to be needed with a storyboarded arrow I love you
02:52:080 (1) - spacing (at last, i found it again) Wow. Fixed
03:40:080 ~ 04:04:937 - best section to use those kinds of hitsounds. good job. and those normal finishes really fits with the song ILU!

normal:
04:56:795 (2) - spacing Fixed
thats all~

star for now, waiting for guest diffs
and i did not touch the hitsound part

gdeath wrote:

Overall :
01:39:223 --->> 02:07:509 remove all claps and finish and try the custom hitsound i gave.its a bit soft than your hitclap2. using soft hitsound only plz.
04:10:080 --->> 04:35:366 ^
I might consider doing this.. Right now I can't see any improvement to the map with that.

[Hard]
00:54:330 (2,3) - remove them.dont fit here. No
hmm...all continuous beats are not suitable IMO Im not happy with you right now.
you know the song is too soft.try mapping it easier easier easier lolz The difficulty name says Hard, see?
well.you can use some jump to make the map harder rather than triple or stream : ) No
furnish some examples which are suitable to set jumps.
eg:00:58:080 --->> 01:01:937
01:05:794 --->> 01:08:795

03:29:473 (2,3,4,5) - Orz... srO

remove all normal-finish.sound bad. Agreed. Removed SOME
eg:03:40:080 (1,5) - Haha, not agreed.
make the normal volume lower.try 45%

[Breeze's Difficulty]
02:40:937 --->> 02:45:223 make this area volume lower
replace finish with soft-whistle.you can set the volume of soft-whistle a bit higher
04:57:650 (1) - fade out
Nice.i love this diff more.

[Normal]
the same problem with [Hard] about hitsound.

Star

gdeath wrote:

not happy?
maybe my modding lack of sentiment.
you know all MODs are only suggestion.just take what you need.
well.i have to say"sorry'' if my modding bother you.

gdeath wrote:

[Breeze's Difficulty]
02:40:937 --->> 02:45:223 make this area volume lower Why? It's chorus here °_°replace finish with soft-whistle.you can set the volume of soft-whistle a bit higher
04:57:650 (1) - fade out added
Nice.i love this diff more.

YGOkid8 wrote:

General
Breeze's Difficulty
Most problems I had were combos, so combo mod, go~

00:45:223 (5) - New Combo.
00:58:937 (5) - ^
01:05:795 (3) - ^ (maybe?)
01:12:652 (5) - ^
01:24:652 (5) - ^
01:33:223 (5) - ^
01:46:937 (5) - ^
01:50:366 (8) - ^
01:52:080 (12) - ^
02:13:509 (3) - ^
02:15:223 (5) - ^
02:21:652 (5) - ^
02:24:652 (8) - ^
02:50:366 (6) - ^ (maybe?)
03:16:080 (5) - ^
03:29:794 (5) - ^
03:36:652 (4) - ^
03:41:794 (4) - ^
03:43:509 (6) - ^
03:55:509 (5) - ^
04:04:080 (5) - ^
04:14:366 (3) - ^
04:16:080 (5) - ^
04:17:795 (8) - ^
04:33:223 (5) - ^
04:42:650 (2) - ^ (maybe?)
04:44:793 (5) - ^
04:55:507 (2) - ^ Sorry I would not change combo unless there are other modder suggest

01:52:295 (1) - No New Combo. After finish, another group of drum sound, so new combo here

03:40:509 (1,2) - Move down 1 grid (Lv3) Why? o.o

Breeze wrote:

03:40:509 (1,2) - Move down 1 grid (Lv3) Why? o.o

Lokamp wrote:

Breeze's Difficulty
03:50:366 (1,2,3) - move them 3 square up and 3 squares left for spacing! fixed

Normal
02:55:509 (spinner) - make it end on 02:58:937 (maybe silencing the spinner's end...) Now I am very confused.. Why was my previous spinner so short. Thanks
03:42:223 (1,2,3) - swap finish with whistles, and vice-versa I did compare but I still think the current one is better
04:04:080 (spinner) - silence this spinner's end fixed

Hard
01:18:223 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - if you don't put hit sounds here, silence this beat series fixed
01:34:080 (5) - silence this slider's end fixed

I suggest you to work on the hitsound's volume... it changes quite often in every mode, and this can annoy the calm and gentle rhythm of the song... so, try to rearrange the modes with softer hitsounds to get a well-made map!

Zodiark1020 wrote:

I really like it, both the song and the map, just some things
General:
Why don't you make a difficulty a little shorter? Normal is a little boring for 5 mins o_O
I would gladly shorten the normal a bit. I just don't know where I shud cut it.

Hard:
01:56:366 (4) - clap+CS1 doesn't fit i think, use your CS2+clap with low volume... fixed
03:40:080 (1) - from here will you decrease a little the volume to those heavy beats? fixed both diffis

Normal:
01:13:937 (4) - the end of this, whistle fixed
01:22:080 (2) - whistle fixed
02:28:080 (5) - continue the chain of whistle, so whistle it fixed

Breeze difficulty is okay

TKiller wrote:

fun, now I get same result as Lybudose

beautiful song, but long

[Easy] 01:12:223 (2) - whistle Done
And if it were me, I'd use more softwhistles.

breeze's diff is kinda harder than [Hard] at some points imo

[Normal] is nice

[Hard]
01:48:652 (1,2,3,4,5) - I'm against such spacings. They are readable, but look a bit ugly imo
I'd make SB arrows appear slightly earlier and stay on screen longer. Me too but I don't know how. Was not storyboarded by me
02:06:652 - add a beat maybe added
02:46:652 (2) - try to play around with beats and slider there, probably make them follow the violin will make it sound better I'd have to move the slider to 1/6 snap divisor. Won't do that though. Added an extra beat to and it sounds better now. (As long as you don't check it in slower playback rates :D)
03:43:937 (5,6,7,8) - sure that these ones should be double beats? Probably sliders or triples imo. I was thinking of gameplay. They will remain :p

otherwise looks great

JarJarJacob wrote:

BPM: 70.000 Theres no point, is there? And its bothersome to find the same slider lengths after the change
Offset: OH GOD WHAT THE HELL but at least change it to 652. The timing on this is really problematic... :OOO changed tho.

Get a better mp3. The map is far too long as it is, might want to cut it off from around 02:58:080. ._.

Mukku wrote:

JarJarJacob wrote:

BPM: 70.000 Theres no point, is there? And its bothersome to find the same slider lengths after the change