TicClick wrote:

[Insane]
Insane with an icon of Extra... well, it's not hard enough for Extra anyway.

1. 01:22:664 (4) - you can hear 1/4 right after the end of this slider, how about you map it?
   done
2. 01:27:831 (1) - slider tick hitsounded as a loud drum sounds not only weird, but also bad. Loud and clear hitsounds should be used only on the actual hit objects, and slider tick doesn't require player to hit it at all. It's worse than all the previous occurences of it, because you use that drum sound there more often than before. If you still want to use it, you probably want to place there a hit object or (at very least) slider's end.
   
   This hitsound makes easy to understand rhythm. I don't think it's bad...

[momimann's Insane]

1. 00:08:665 (1) - missing clap
   done
2. 00:13:164 (5) - would be nice to hear finish here
   done
3. 00:12:998 (4) - missing clap
   done
4. 00:57:331 (1,2,4) - would be nice to hear finish on their heads
   disagree little noisy.
5. 01:07:998 (2) - should have new combo instead of 01:07:831 (1)
   None. This fits vocal.

[Hard]

1. 00:35:998 (1) - shouldn't it have finish?
   done
2. 00:41:331 (4) - please add new combo
   done
3. 00:43:998 (4) - ^
   done
4. 01:15:998 (1,2) - the jump is too big, reduce it
   This jump is playable and not so big,
5. 01:27:498 (1,2,3,4) - Hard should be easier than Insane, but Insane doesn't have these notes and has only a repeating slider. Could you please change it to something else?
   Just a The difference of mapper IMO.

[Normal]

1. 00:25:331 (1) - shouldn't it have finish?
   done
2. 00:35:998 (1) - ^
   done

Please make this difficulty harder (example: more 1/2 notes on kiai) for a better balance with Hard.
I don't want Normal with more 1/2. It's too hard than Easy.

[Easy]

1. 00:25:331 (1) - needs finish
2. 00:58:164 (2) - missing something something on the tail (I'd place finish, but I see you used whistle just a slider earlier)

can't believe I've just modded a TV Size map, but oh well, I promised to recheck it

Andrea wrote:

Insane should be renamed to Extra anyway, just saying.

first this: 00:14:164 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - this stuff only should be on extra diff, it looks plays harder then it should be, you could replace it with notes, if you want to keep it as "Insane"

2nd: the whole kiai has crazy jumps that's are so big and fits for extra diff, and I only play insane diff and i couldn't even pass this...

[ Daniel ] wrote:

There is a problem loading the audio for the insane level

Urushi38 wrote:

ok I never use Extra for this mapset

Rakuen wrote:

( =`･ω･´) Rakuen's Modding Queue (NM/M4M)

Legend

Default = Normal mods
Blue = Strongly recommended
Red = Unrankable issue
Pink = Will be discussed if not changed

Hitsounds

• There are 2 hitsounds with delays here, use the modified version below:

1. 7 ms delay - http://puu.sh/dLQBu/3340fc1f69.wav , applies for:
   soft-hitwhistle2
   soft-slidertick39
   
2. 2 ms delay - http://puu.sh/dLQFS/e152137b98.wav , applies for:
   drum-hitwhistle

Normal

1. 00:21:831 (5) - Slider is off rhythm, try moving to 00:21:664 - . Nothing sounds at 00:21:831 - and 00:22:164 -
   No. There are certainly Cello sounds. I follow them.
2. 01:17:664 (3) - Whistle
3. 01:18:664 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5) - Hitsounds here a bit wrong, make the whistles at upbeats please, like 01:18:998 - , 01:19:664 - , 01:20:331 - etc.

Hard

1. 00:12:831 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Use 1.2x DS for all of them, looks neater
2. 00:58:998 (2) - Clap
3. Nice diff

momimann's Insane

1. Please use AR8.6
2. 00:10:998 (5) - Use same DS?
3. 00:23:831 (1) - NC not needed imo
   No change. ofc we can play wothout NC, but this NC makes playing better.
4. 00:40:998 - Clap
5. 01:22:998 - , 01:23:164 - , 01:23:331 (1) - Claps will sound better imo

Infected

1. 00:13:664 - Whistle
2. 00:49:331 (1) - Try to make the middle part more visible. Something like 01:11:998 (6) - or :
   
   Image

   
3. 01:02:164 (1) - Don't have to NC this I guess, it's readable (extra diff)

Call me back when you're ready!

Rakuen wrote:

Railgun's Easy

1. Please use AR3 flat I think the current ar fits the map better
2. 01:23:998 (1) - Inconsistent DS I do this intentionally to follow the instrumental. It's +0.05x i hope that's not an issue

1. 00:05:332 (1,2) - The 1/4 gap between these two sliders plus the angle of flow makes this very awkward at the beginning of the map. I usually got a 100 on the first slider. ctrl+g 00:05:998 (2) - works well and since there is a spinner afterwards you are not changing much
2. 00:12:914 (4,5,6) - This stream seems a little forced in my opinion. I think converting this to a 1/2 pattern works very nicely. Try something like this or something similar, follows the music well and plays to fit the music
   
   example

   
3. 00:39:831 (1,2,3,4) - I was seriously impressed by this pattern, it plays and flows really well! Nice job here
4. 00:53:998 (3,4,5,6) - The pattern can flow better imo. Try ctrl+g 4/5 and see how it plays
5. 01:11:331 (3) - I suggest you accent this slider with a new combo since it is obscured by 01:10:664 (1) - for the most part. Players with skins that do not have transparency in their slider tracks will have a hard time noticing this and the new combo will add more of a visual cue
6. 01:15:998 (1,2,3,1) - Really, the highlight of the map for me. I never get tired of playing this pattern and imo it fits the the vocal and music really well. Its not everyday you see something like this!

1. 01:15:164 (7,8,9) - The rhythm here is kinda awkward with the stronger vocals. Revise it to follow it more closer. Try something like this
   

1. 00:34:831 (8) - The slider ticks during this slider are very strong sounding, which may confuse the average hard player. I think removing them would be best or maybe try a different rhythm out

Lust wrote:

Lets get this back to where it should be.

[Infected]

1. 00:05:332 (1,2) - The 1/4 gap between these two sliders plus the angle of flow makes this very awkward at the beginning of the map. I usually got a 100 on the first slider. ctrl+g 00:05:998 (2) - works well and since there is a spinner afterwards you are not changing much
2. 00:12:914 (4,5,6) - This stream seems a little forced in my opinion. I think converting this to a 1/2 pattern works very nicely. Try something like this or something similar, follows the music well and plays to fit the music
   
   example

   
3. 00:39:831 (1,2,3,4) - I was seriously impressed by this pattern, it plays and flows really well! Nice job here
4. 00:53:998 (3,4,5,6) - The pattern can flow better imo. Try ctrl+g 4/5 and see how it plays
5. 01:11:331 (3) - I suggest you accent this slider with a new combo since it is obscured by 01:10:664 (1) - for the most part. Players with skins that do not have transparency in their slider tracks will have a hard time noticing this and the new combo will add more of a visual cue
6. 01:15:998 (1,2,3,1) - Really, the highlight of the map for me. I never get tired of playing this pattern and imo it fits the the vocal and music really well. Its not everyday you see something like this!

[momimann's Insane]
The volume of the hitsounds are rather quiet, especially for the parts after the beginning. I highly suggest you raise the volume on the green lines.

1. 01:15:164 (7,8,9) - The rhythm here is kinda awkward with the stronger vocals. Revise it to follow it more closer. Try something like this
   

[Hard]

1. 00:34:831 (8) - The slider ticks during this slider are very strong sounding, which may confuse the average hard player. I think removing them would be best or maybe try a different rhythm out

Find me in game