forum

Greatest Idea Mafia - Game Over (Mafia Win)

posted
Total Posts
349
show more
Irreversible
gg i lost :c
Blue Yoshi_old
Hammer
/in
DakeDekaane
It seems I'm late for this one awa

/in as replacement (if needed)
Topic Starter
Sakura
Randomizing roles

Role Cards sent out waiting for each players' picks
pieguyn
aw crap ;w;
in to replace
Topic Starter
Sakura
Waiting on 1 person to send their role choices.

All choices are in and it's a setup that we can run, so role PMs will go out shortly.

All Role PMs are out, game will begin when 5/7 confirm.
Sephibro
confirm
Amianki
Confirm
Zexion
Confirm
GuyInFreezer
'firm
Blue Yoshi_old
conform
Irreversible
cofnirmed
Topic Starter
Sakura
6/7 Confirmed so let's begin

Day 1 ends on 18th October 2013: 12:39 GMT-5 <-- Click for countdown.

Not voting (7): Sephibro, Irreversible, GuyInFreezer, Lincolm, Zexion_Vi, CalignoBot, Blue Yoshi

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch

Sephibro discarded: Survivor Mason
Irreversible discarded: Werewolf Mason
GuyInFreezer discarded: Werewolf Roleblocker
Lincolm discarded: Cop
Zexion_Vi discarded: Ninja Werewolf
CalignoBot discarded: Alien Sympathizer
Blue Yoshi discarded: Hirosute Townie

Anyone not confirmed yet has 24 hours since day start to confirm or get replaced.
GuyInFreezer
Vote: Lincolm
Irreversible
Vote: Blue Yoshi
Blue Yoshi_old
Why would I even use Hirosute townie, I don't want to be detrimental to town.
Blue Yoshi_old
Vote: Sephibro
Lincolm
Lol I discarded Cop. I like you, Sakura.

Vote : GIF
Lincolm
Hey, Blue Yoshi, what card did you use for your alignment?
Zexion
Vote: GuyInFreezer
Topic Starter
Sakura
Page grab
Topic Starter
Sakura
Lincolm (1): GuyInFreezer
Blue Yoshi (1): Irreversible
Sephibro (1): Blue Yoshi
[L-2]>GuyInFreezer (2): Lincolm, Zexion_Vi

Not voting (2): Sephibro, CalignoBot

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch
Blue Yoshi_old
Used VT for alignment.
I could've used Hirosute townie for alignment, but I would've rather used that as my public choice.
GuyInFreezer
RQS time

1) which faction do you prefer? Town, mafia/ww, or SK?
2) do you prefer funny role or serious role?
3) do you think massclaiming the alignment card is a good idea?
GuyInFreezer
1) town in serious games, SK in joke games (ilike chat mafia)
2) serious roles
3) yes.
Irreversible
1) can I ask what SK is? I'll answer then o.o
2) uhm, well i don't really see which role is funny and which not.
3) Can't really tell, don't have any experience with it (just being honest, lol)
GuyInFreezer
SK is a serial killer, aka third party.
Funny roles like psychomagnetizer (I think that's what it's called), WPWT, etc. Norm roles are the general roles that you should know.
Sephibro

GuyInFreezer wrote:

RQS time

1) which faction do you prefer? Town, mafia/ww, or SK?
2) do you prefer funny role or serious role?
3) do you think massclaiming the alignment card is a good idea?
1) Town
2) Funny role i guess
3) I still have to think of a good strategy for this game, i would say no for the moment

Vote: Lincolm for the moment
Sephibro
Oh and there are at least Survivors and Aliens too among the factions
Irreversible
1) k then, town
2) Never played any of those, but I'm sure it'd be fun
GuyInFreezer
Lincolm vote is a good vote. Just see what he discarded.

Also I think claiming alignment card will be good because sometimes the two claimed alignment cards can counterclaim each other because scum would have to lie about his alignment card. It's not like we're revealing our roles or anything. Just an alignment.
Zexion
1) Maybe town because ignorance is bliss sometimes.
2) Funny roles. The funnier the better.
3) No idea. First time playing this setup, but at least it allows some hints... but not too good hints either.
Irreversible
GIF, why are you so agressively trying to lead the conversation?
Sephibro
this is the fact: in usual games one should always claim the "good" faction, i.e. the one which has the majority. The only safe claim in this game is Town, since we're sure that townies don't know each other

Then no, alignment mass-claim is NOT a good idea
Blue Yoshi_old
1. 3rd party of any variety (survivor, sk, hurr durr)
2. For this setup specifically I like funny roles, because that's the reason this setup was made.
3. No input on this, unless you mean the actual role.
Topic Starter
Sakura
Bump of Faith
Topic Starter
Sakura
[L-2]>Lincolm (2): GuyInFreezer, Sephibro
Blue Yoshi (1): Irreversible
Sephibro (1): Blue Yoshi
[L-2]>GuyInFreezer (2): Lincolm, Zexion_Vi

Not voting (1): CalignoBot

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch
Irreversible
Wait, Lincolm votes for hisself?

You saw nothing!

-Sakura
Irreversible
^ should be in bold
GuyInFreezer

Sephibro wrote:

this is the fact: in usual games one should always claim the "good" faction, i.e. the one which has the majority. The only safe claim in this game is Town, since we're sure that townies don't know each other
That's the point.
We all know that mafia won't claim mafia, wolf won't claim wolf, etc.
So they'll gonna lie. When they lie, there's a chance that the alignment card might cross, creating a counterclaim. (E.G. There's only one "Town Vigilant". If two people claim that they used Town Vig as their alignment card, we have scum in those two.)
GuyInFreezer

Irreversible wrote:

GIF, why are you so agressively trying to lead the conversation?
Because I can 8-)
Irreversible
oh really :x
Blue Yoshi_old

GuyInFreezer wrote:

So they'll gonna lie. When they lie, there's a chance that the alignment card might cross, creating a counterclaim. (E.G. There's only one "Town Vigilant". If two people claim that they used Town Vig as their alignment card, we have scum in those two.)
Nowhere does it say that the pool of roles is taken out as each person gets their 3 choices.
Irreversible
What if Blue Yoshi dropped his town card (which isn't good for us), while taking a scum factionned role? So he can act like he's done something good for us, but in real you just want to trick us, while he's really being scum?

Or am I totally wrong with this thought?
GuyInFreezer

Blue Yoshi wrote:

GuyInFreezer wrote:

So they'll gonna lie. When they lie, there's a chance that the alignment card might cross, creating a counterclaim. (E.G. There's only one "Town Vigilant". If two people claim that they used Town Vig as their alignment card, we have scum in those two.)
Nowhere does it say that the pool of roles is taken out as each person gets their 3 choices.
But I know how this setup works.
Unless Sakura messed up, you are not allowed to get duplicate cards. She linked the role list in OP, I believe.
Irreversible
uhm, there's a 'you' in my sentence which should obviously be a 'he'
Irreversible
btw, i'm now offline, sleeping time, cya guys
GuyInFreezer
"you" as in general.
Lincolm
RQS is wasting time.

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Lincolm vote is a good vote. Just see what he discarded.
Lol your discarded card is very good as scum team. Especially werewolf, you can kill or roleblock people and discard it? No no no, your card is a distraction for become more townie. Your RQS prove me right any way.

Cop only can detect mafia and I don't know how many mafias will be, maybe even 0. In 7P, it is almost likely worthless role. I randomize my discarded card anyway. They were FBI Agent or Cop. ;)

What is your alignment card then?
Topic Starter
Sakura
I should've added it to the setup description but the way roles are distributed I put the entire list on random.org and then start giving 3 roles in order to each player in the playerlist in order.
[L-2]>Lincolm (2): GuyInFreezer, Lincolm
Blue Yoshi (1): Irreversible
Sephibro (1): Blue Yoshi
[L-2]>GuyInFreezer (2): Lincolm, Zexion_Vi

Not voting (1): CalignoBot

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch
GuyInFreezer
Town lover, because screw lovers.
GuyInFreezer

Lincolm wrote:

Lol your discarded card is very good as scum team. Especially werewolf, you can kill or roleblock people and discard it? No no no, your card is a distraction for become more townie. Your RQS prove me right any way.
I'm trying to understand what you're trying to say here, but sadly, I can't.
Zexion

Sakura wrote:

I should've added it to the setup description but the way roles are distributed I put the entire list on random.org and then start giving 3 roles in order to each player in the playerlist in order.
[L-2]>Lincolm (2): GuyInFreezer, Lincolm
Blue Yoshi (1): Irreversible
Sephibro (1): Blue Yoshi
[L-2]>GuyInFreezer (2): Lincolm, Zexion_Vi

Not voting (1): CalignoBot

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch
Then that would mean that two people could have gotten the same role card? From what I understand, that would be a yes.
Lincolm
Well. sorry about that. Werewolf can kill someone. Roleblock can block power role or scum kill . I mean, you can have your own alignment with kill or roleblock someone.

You prefer other power rather than roleblock, which mean this one is more powerful. I don't want to know this power, but isn't werewolf with power is very powerful? Hey, if you get werewolf + power, you can kill someone + use your power at the same time in night, rather than town + power.

I think you discarded that card because you're trying to appear more townie, as you get 2 scums cards, it doesn't matter what alignment, it is still scum team.
Lincolm

Zexion_Vi wrote:

Then that would mean that two people could have gotten the same role card? From what I understand, that would be a yes.
Yes.

Maybe you can look in here.
GuyInFreezer

Zexion_Vi wrote:

Sakura wrote:

I should've added it to the setup description but the way roles are distributed I put the entire list on random.org and then start giving 3 roles in order to each player in the playerlist in order.
[L-2]>Lincolm (2): GuyInFreezer, Lincolm
Blue Yoshi (1): Irreversible
Sephibro (1): Blue Yoshi
[L-2]>GuyInFreezer (2): Lincolm, Zexion_Vi

Not voting (1): CalignoBot

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch
Then that would mean that two people could have gotten the same role card? From what I understand, that would be a yes.
random.org lists use unrepeated sequence, so it would be "no."
However, some roles have multiple cards (for example, VT have 6 or 7 cards, I believe.)

Lincolm wrote:

Well. sorry about that. Werewolf can kill someone. Roleblock can block power role or scum kill . I mean, you can have your own alignment with kill or roleblock someone.

You prefer other power rather than roleblock, which mean this one is more powerful. I don't want to know this power, but isn't werewolf with power is very powerful? Hey, if you get werewolf + power, you can kill someone + use your power at the same time in night, rather than town + power.

I think you discarded that card because you're trying to appear more townie, as you get 2 scums cards, it doesn't matter what alignment, it is still scum team.
Even if I got 2 scum cards (I didn't.), I could discard one and use the other scum role for the role therefore making myself as town, if that's what you're talking about.
GuyInFreezer
Also roleblocker is not my style.
GuyInFreezer
I don't like how this doesn't give me a preview or anything.
So, yes, roles can be duplicate, but only for certain roles.

Also there are 12, not 6. (I'm still thinking of an old Great idea deck -.-)
Lincolm

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Even if I got 2 scum cards (I didn't.), I could discard one and use the other scum role for the role therefore making myself as town, if that's what you're talking about.
That's the point, except that role is so strong you won't use it for your alignment.

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Also roleblocker is not my style.
Why? I think it is pretty fun cause I ever get roleblocker power once. (And I roleblocked the other roleblocker when she hit the scumteam :lol: )
GuyInFreezer
I have a very bad memory with the roleblocker role.
I don't wanna talk about it.
Lincolm
Seems a bad memory lol
Sephibro
sorry for my low activity, I will post later..it's friday night
Lincolm

Lincolm wrote:

Cop only can detect mafia and I don't know how many mafias will be, maybe even 0. In 7P, it is almost likely worthless role. I randomize my discarded card anyway. They were FBI Agent or Cop. ;)
Just a reminder for you, Sephibro. I want your respond.
Amianki
I'm not going to partake in RQS.

I only briefly skimmed the game so far. Are the cards truly unique or are they reusable? This entire alignment-claiming business depends on the answer and I have yet to see a definitive one as of yet.

More thoughts later. I want to think when my feet aren't killing me.
GuyInFreezer
But but but
my questions actually will help finding scumz later :<
(so answer them please)

cards aren't reusable. They can have few duplicates, but they aren't reusable.
Amianki
It's been a very long time since I last thought RQS was anything but a terrible version of RVS, so I'm not going to support its use.

Sorry.
GuyInFreezer
you scared? :P
Sephibro
ok, here we go

GuyInFreezer wrote:

That's the point.
We all know that mafia won't claim mafia, wolf won't claim wolf, etc.
So they'll gonna lie. When they lie, there's a chance that the alignment card might cross, creating a counterclaim. (E.G. There's only one "Town Vigilant". If two people claim that they used Town Vig as their alignment card, we have scum in those two.)
I thought about this too, in fact I was about to ask if each card was unique, but there are so many duplicates of safe alignment claims that it's not even worth it.


BTW, i will propose another kind of claim: what if we all claim both the cards we didn't discard?
There's only one problem with this: we should be able to post our roles all in the same moment, which isn't possible (unless we do it in a way i proposed in another game, but looks like it is out of rules)

we can do it thanks to this site http://tny.cz/
everyone writes the two cards he didn't discard OBVIOUSLY PROTECTING IT WITH A PASSWORD and then posts the url here. When everybody has posted the url, we all give our passwords.


@Lincolm: my vote is 99% random, i voted you only because discarding cop card there's a slightly higher chance of your alignment not being town
GuyInFreezer
That's rolefishing. What I'm asking isn't.
GuyInFreezer
[quote=Sephibro]I thought about this too, in fact I was about to ask if each card was unique, but there are so many duplicates of safe alignment claims that it's not even worth it.[/quote]
Little chance is better than no chance.
GuyInFreezer

Sephibro wrote:

I thought about this too, in fact I was about to ask if each card was unique, but there are so many duplicates of safe alignment claims that it's not even worth it.
Little chance is better than no chance.

Stupid quote tag quotation mark stuff
GuyInFreezer
Also
Unvote: Lincolm

He's most likely town.
Sephibro

Sephibro wrote:

we can do it thanks to this site http://tny.cz/
everyone writes the two cards he didn't discard OBVIOUSLY PROTECTING IT WITH A PASSWORD and then posts the url here. When everybody has posted the url, we all give our passwords.
how about this thing, is it legal? If it is, i agree on claiming alignment card only too
Amianki
That is 100% against the rules, at least on Mafiascum. I would be very surprised if it was allowed here.
Sephibro
well then claiming is worthless, since people can read previous post and avoid writing the same things
GuyInFreezer

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Little chance is better than no chance.
Topic Starter
Sakura

Sephibro wrote:

BTW, i will propose another kind of claim: what if we all claim both the cards we didn't discard?
There's only one problem with this: we should be able to post our roles all in the same moment, which isn't possible (unless we do it in a way i proposed in another game, but looks like it is out of rules)

we can do it thanks to this site http://tny.cz/
everyone writes the two cards he didn't discard OBVIOUSLY PROTECTING IT WITH A PASSWORD and then posts the url here. When everybody has posted the url, we all give our passwords.
I'm gonna have to say no to this.

Lincolm (1): Sephibro
Blue Yoshi (1): Irreversible
Sephibro (1): Blue Yoshi
[L-2]>GuyInFreezer (2): Lincolm, Zexion_Vi

Not voting (2): CalignoBot, GuyInFreezer

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch
Sephibro
I'm still thinking if it's better to claim alignment card only or both. Let's brainstorm together

Let's say one has these two cards:
1. Werewolf -random_role-
2. Town -random_role-

even if his alignment is ww, he could still use the other card as a completely safe claim
Blue Yoshi_old
Okay.
My 3 cards were:
Vanilla Townie
Mafia Goon
Hirosute Townie

Picked in that order. (so I would be a townie goon)
I hoped this would give me a mason/vig combo if anyone was in the same boat as me, but apparently I was the only unlucky one. I didn't get a vig, either.
I am literally stuck with the equivalent of a vanilla townie, which is even what I am called because "townie goon" makes no sense.

To have an idea of how much this sucks:
Imagine you were a legitimate vanilla townie in a Role Madness game. All points are defeated.
Lincolm

GuyInFreezer wrote:

my questions actually will help finding scumz later :<
Tbh, RQS are stupid. They didn't find the mindset, but personality. (Sure, I like to know someone's personality, but not in the mafia game)

Sephibro wrote:

@Lincolm: my vote is 99% random, i voted you only because discarding cop card there's a slightly higher chance of your alignment not being town
That's funny. I don't see how that's make me get higher chance become not town. Care to explain this? I claim my discarded card is randomized, what do you think about that?

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Little chance is better than no chance.
I hate when you claim lover, though I like that role.

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Unvote: Lincolm

He's most likely town.
Why?

Sephibro wrote:

well then claiming is worthless, since people can read previous post and avoid writing the same things
Whatever idea you make, it is same in the end, scums attend to read the previous post. I already claim 2 of my cards any way,

@Blue Yoshi : Why claim VT this early?
Irreversible
BlueYoshi, you seem so unneccessarily nervous, why? You just offer us all your informations, all the time.

GIF, I don't like your behaviour such as 'You scared ? :P' or 'because I can :P' Why mocking us all the time?
Sephibro
FoS: Blue Yoshi

Lincolm wrote:

That's funny. I don't see how that's make me get higher chance become not town. Care to explain this? I claim my discarded card is randomized, what do you think about that?
You aren't good at maths are you?
GuyInFreezer
Because I liked ur explanation of why you discarded cop.

Tbh the #2 of my "RQS" was directed towards you but you ended up explaining the stuff I wanted to know without answering my question.
Zexion
GIF is strangely aggresive. Why are you trying to provoke people? That RQS wasn't that hepful either.
Irreversible

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Because I can 8-)
Blue Yoshi_old
Being the first one to fully claim saves me the trouble of doing it later, since it just seemed inevitable at the pace we were going.
Lincolm

Sephibro wrote:

You aren't good at maths are you?
Care explain how maths work on the probability of pulling 3 random cards in between 129 cards and 6 other people drawing 18 other cards that you didn't even know what cards they pulled?

I don't think I even want to calculate that, seriously.

Explain like I'm learning math in here please.

And you didn't answer my second question in the same quote.

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Tbh the #2 of my "RQS" was directed towards you but you ended up explaining the stuff I wanted to know without answering my question.
Care to explain which of my post and how is that answer your question? Because I don't see any.

Blue Yoshi wrote:

Being the first one to fully claim saves me the trouble of doing it later, since it just seemed inevitable at the pace we were going.
How was that make us go to the "let's mass claim our power" ?
Topic Starter
Sakura
Lincolm (1): Sephibro
Blue Yoshi (1): Irreversible
Sephibro (1): Blue Yoshi
[L-2]>GuyInFreezer (2): Lincolm, Zexion_Vi

Not voting (2): CalignoBot, GuyInFreezer

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to lynch

Please let me know if you see any mistakes
Blue Yoshi_old
Eh, I'm not sure.
I made the post about 5 minutes before I fell asleep and didn't even consider if it wa a good idea or not.
ddddd
GuyInFreezer

Lincolm wrote:

Cop only can detect mafia and I don't know how many mafias will be, maybe even 0. In 7P, it is almost likely worthless role. I randomize my discarded card anyway.
This is all I needed to hear. I wanted to see your motive of discarding the cop role. I expected it to be role preference (funny role over norm role), but it was something I didn't expect to hear and I like that answer.

Zexion_Vi wrote:

GIF is strangely aggresive. Why are you trying to provoke people? That RQS wasn't that hepful either.
Parroting, parroting, and parroting.

Vote: Zexion_Vi
GuyInFreezer
Hey Sakura, when's the deadline again?
Lincolm

GuyInFreezer wrote:

This is all I needed to hear. I wanted to see your motive of discarding the cop role. I expected it to be role preference (funny role over norm role), but it was something I didn't expect to hear and I like that answer.
Still, I don't get how that post is town post and I didn't post it for answering your RQS...

(Tbh, I really think GIF is Pikachu right now...)
Lincolm
Actually, I can do it any way.

GIF is Pikachu.

Topic Starter
Sakura

GuyInFreezer wrote:

Hey Sakura, when's the deadline again?
http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/ge ... +1+ends+in
Zexion

Zexion_Vi wrote:

GIF is strangely aggresive. Why are you trying to provoke people? That RQS wasn't that hepful either.
Parroting, parroting, and parroting.

Vote: Zexion_Vi[/quote]

Well, to be honest I didn't read the "Deal with it" and I had nothing else to say (Its D1 anyways). Can't seem to understand how parroting points to something through.
Zexion
^ I was quoting GIF, but seems I forgot a [quote] at the beginning lol
GuyInFreezer

Lincolm wrote:

Actually, I can do it any way.

GIF is Pikachu.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

:P

Lincolm wrote:

GuyInFreezer wrote:

This is all I needed to hear. I wanted to see your motive of discarding the cop role. I expected it to be role preference (funny role over norm role), but it was something I didn't expect to hear and I like that answer.
Still, I don't get how that post is town post and I didn't post it for answering your RQS...

(Tbh, I really think GIF is Pikachu right now...)
You didn't answer my RQS question, but you basically answered what I wanted to know.
Basically, you skipped a step for me.

Also it felt town. But logically I disagree with that post because still you could get mafia if there was one.
GuyInFreezer

Zexion_Vi wrote:

Well, to be honest I didn't read the "Deal with it" and I had nothing else to say (Its D1 anyways). Can't seem to understand how parroting points to something through.
Don't you know, parroting is a huge huge scumtell!
Parroting is a great way to look town by doing basically nothing.
Irreversible
..¬¬
GuyInFreezer

Irreversible wrote:

..¬¬
ㅇㅅㅇ?

sup
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply