Rules:
- Please only maps you're pushing for ranked
- At least one difficulty on the set needs to be 5.25*+ (if it's 5.24*, make it harder)
- If your map is massively overweighted (like BZ) I will probably deny it
- Anime / general Rock/Metal music is prob going to be a no
- Maps will be accepted based on how I feel so if you don't get in, gl next time
Format:
NM/GD -
Artist-Title -
Difficulties (SR) -
Map Link -
Example:
NM/GD - NM
Arist-Title - DJ Myosuke & Noizenecio - Architecture
Difficulties (SR) - Advanced (2.56), Hard (3.26), Insane (4.36), Extra (5.28), Extreme (6.06), Obliteration (7.22)
Map Link - beatmapsets/1022162#mania/2919366
FIVE SLOTS
- katagiri - Kyuukou
-
-
-
-
ON HOLD:
- Camellia - Circles of Death - Whilst I think the diff needs a lot of improvement I do kinda still wanna see it through.
- Kurokotei feat. Sennzai - escape (the looking-glass, and what alice found there) - I genuinely don't know what to make of this at this point, I'll review later.
- Please only maps you're pushing for ranked
- At least one difficulty on the set needs to be 5.25*+ (if it's 5.24*, make it harder)
- If your map is massively overweighted (like BZ) I will probably deny it
- Anime / general Rock/Metal music is prob going to be a no
- Maps will be accepted based on how I feel so if you don't get in, gl next time
Format:
NM/GD -
Artist-Title -
Difficulties (SR) -
Map Link -
Example:
NM/GD - NM
Arist-Title - DJ Myosuke & Noizenecio - Architecture
Difficulties (SR) - Advanced (2.56), Hard (3.26), Insane (4.36), Extra (5.28), Extreme (6.06), Obliteration (7.22)
Map Link - beatmapsets/1022162#mania/2919366
FIVE SLOTS
- katagiri - Kyuukou
-
-
-
-
ON HOLD:
- Camellia - Circles of Death - Whilst I think the diff needs a lot of improvement I do kinda still wanna see it through.
- Kurokotei feat. Sennzai - escape (the looking-glass, and what alice found there) - I genuinely don't know what to make of this at this point, I'll review later.
Completed List
- Laur - Party People (twice)
- +ERABY+E CONNEC+10N
- Mayoi Namekuji - hayburid
- paraoka - L9
- D_AAN - Another Me
- Noah - Deadly force - Put an end
- Camellia - Dance with Silence
- Toby Fox - Rude Buster (Camellia Remix)
- Camellia - Exit This Earth's Atomosphere (Camellia's "PLANETARY//200STEP" Remix)
- BlackY vs. Yooh - HAVOX (Camellia's "XATAXLYSM" Remix)
- Kobaryo - Villain Virus [feat. Camellia]
- Camellia - Azure Vixen
- Noah - Deadly Force
- Camellia - Z:iRNiTRA
- Gomitaro - S4y G00dby3
- technoplanet - Inscape [Extended Mix]
- Culprate - Beast (Vorso Remix)
- Nstryder - A Miserable Pile Of Secrets
- LeaF - Wizdomiot
- Camellia - Z:iRNiTRA
- Blacklolita - [X]
- Silentroom vs. Frums - Aegleseeker, over the horizon
- Camellia - CICADA3302
- Jaroslav Beck - $100 Bills (Camellia's "215$-Step" Remix)
- Reizoko Cj - Svensk Super Kung-Fu
- Kurokotei - Nonbinarity (Cut Ver.)
- Camellia - POLYBIUS GB SPEEDRUN (Glitchless 100% WR in 0:03:57)
- +ERABY+E CONNEC+10N
- Mayoi Namekuji - hayburid
- paraoka - L9
- D_AAN - Another Me
- Noah - Deadly force - Put an end
- Camellia - Dance with Silence
- Toby Fox - Rude Buster (Camellia Remix)
- Camellia - Exit This Earth's Atomosphere (Camellia's "PLANETARY//200STEP" Remix)
- BlackY vs. Yooh - HAVOX (Camellia's "XATAXLYSM" Remix)
- Kobaryo - Villain Virus [feat. Camellia]
- Camellia - Azure Vixen
- Noah - Deadly Force
- Camellia - Z:iRNiTRA
- Gomitaro - S4y G00dby3
- technoplanet - Inscape [Extended Mix]
- Culprate - Beast (Vorso Remix)
- Nstryder - A Miserable Pile Of Secrets
- LeaF - Wizdomiot
- Camellia - Z:iRNiTRA
- Blacklolita - [X]
- Silentroom vs. Frums - Aegleseeker, over the horizon
- Camellia - CICADA3302
- Jaroslav Beck - $100 Bills (Camellia's "215$-Step" Remix)
- Reizoko Cj - Svensk Super Kung-Fu
- Kurokotei - Nonbinarity (Cut Ver.)
- Camellia - POLYBIUS GB SPEEDRUN (Glitchless 100% WR in 0:03:57)
Reject List 2022
Violations:
- TOC- Rule 2 Violation
- Excuse My Rudeness, But Could You Please RIP? - Rule 3 Violation
- Blue Zenith - Blue Zenith
- Yukiotoko - Rule 1 Violation
- Blackmagik Blazing - Rule 3 Violation (Mixed LN died in 2019)
- Oshama Scramble! (Uncut Ver.) - Rule 2 Violation
- Let's Go Crazy (From Sing 2) - Rule 2 Violation
- Neo-Aspect - Rule 2 Violation
- Hachigatsu, Bou, Tsukiakari - Rule 2 Violation
- Blue Desire - Rule 2 Violation
- artefatto vita - Rule 3 Violation
- Belly Flopper - Rule 2 Violation
- Can You Feel My Heart (lullaby) - Rule 2 Violation
- ZENITH - Rule 2 Violation
Personal Reasons:
- Exit This Earth's Atomosphere - Left a post on the thread, just really wasn't interested
- Gimme chocolate!! - how can you use vocal representation on the longjack parts and then turn it into a drum chart straight after that's offensive
- Shooting Star - ironically i would've liked this to be more pure jack map instead of mixed LNs w/ vocals, but i'll hype it because i like the concept anyway
- Last Resort - I really don't care for xi songs
- #1f1e33 (#00102g version) - what i'm hearing and what i'm seeing notes wise really just don't match up, practice a bit more in the realm of dubstep-style mapping and then come back to this
- Arcaea Songs Compilation - you need to learn to track mix; the hard cuts between songs is jarring at best and i had to stop listening 25% through. no comment on the map itself
- Electromagnetic Stealth Girl Born In Philadelphia - this doesn't need mods for me
- Under Construxion - it is clear to me that you don't understand the full fundamentals of jack patterning from this chart and they were more of a second thought here, if i were you i'd look at jack charts from other mappers (mostly unranked since most of the jack charts ranked kinda suck) and try and figure out why things are laid out the way they are
- Fastest Crash - it's not you it's the song, i'd rather be listening to radio silence
- Einherjar Joker - not my thing really, both the song and the mapping style, though you should have absolutely no issue with ranking it with other people honestly
- Divine Light of Myriad - not a fan of the song mostly, also this is not close to controversial lmao
- Melancholia (e_ku's Desolation Remix) - song is kinda one-dimensional and not something i wanna subject my ears to for a long period of time for modding
- 1nput This 2 Y0ur Spine - just gonna keep it short: not a fan of this mapping style myself
- Hoshi o Kakeru Adventure ~ we are forever friends! ~ - i'm sorry but the entire top diff would need a full rework before it even came remotely close to ranked. feel free to come back once you've had someone help you out with that though
- Agito - I just can't justify this dump patterning in my head in correlation to the song
- The 'Fun' In Dysfunction - really just isn't my genre of music sorry man
- Juvenile - something about this is just not for me, i think some sections in the top diff just go a bit too hard relevant to the sounds produced in comparison to the actual intense parts, it feels like it's cramming difficulty in where it's not needed.
- All The Way - This was more well done than it had any right to be, alas I still don't want to listen to this song over and over again.
- Anoyo-iki no Bus ni Notte Saraba - I'm just not an LN heavy guy, looks like a good practice map for LNs and jacks though.
- Cross Fire - The jumptrills only increase by .4 compared to the alternative so it's not the worst thing, but I also just dont have interest in the way this map is laid out in general.
- Deadly Force - Honestly, my advice would be just look at the qualified version for ideas (I also modded that one).
- Vindication(Extended) - The density of the map doesn't match what i can hear in the music personally so i can't really mod this without saying that most of it needs redoing, sorry.
- End of Fairytale - In just the first 5 seconds alone I have so many concerns for density consistency that if I did mod this in the way that I do, 75% of the notes in this map would have a mod against it and I don't have that time.
- Scattered Faith - Less inspired than other versions of the same difficulty, and falls under the same vibro-rolls trope that every other version does. Seen it all before.
- Vicious Heroism - ehhhhh I think there's a lot of room for improvement here, i.e. desnity priority at 00:35:756 - , 00:49:584 - this pattern in terms of hand balance, missing melody usage at 01:00:834 - , overall over-anchor usage and some overmapping, 01:50:697 (110697|3,110756|3) - this, etc. Maybe if you get like 5 people to look at it beforehand i might take another look.
- Darekare Scramble - if this wasn't 4 minutes, then maybe... i might still come back and mod like half of it tbh idk how i feel about this map yet lmao
- Electromagnetic Stealth Girl Born In Philadelphia - I have a big concern over density in this entire chart tbh, also press Ctrl-Shift-A and make sure your notes are all snapped correctly.
- <</nttld.:beings>> ~Truth in Uncertainty~ - There was enough in the first 2 mins of things I heard contrasting against notes I saw that I'd either ask for quite a rework or not have a mod that satisfies your mapping style.
- Chain of Pain - I'm very on the fence about this one because essentially the bulk of the difficulty comes from 20% of the map aka the kiai time but its not a bad map otherwise.
- Fallen Symphony - Not really vibing with this one honestly, also might need a retime in certain areas.
- Motherless Miscarriage - Not really my type of music honestly.
- I.R.I.S - Would need a massive density and snapping overhaul before I began looking at it.
- TOC- Rule 2 Violation
- Excuse My Rudeness, But Could You Please RIP? - Rule 3 Violation
- Blue Zenith - Blue Zenith
- Yukiotoko - Rule 1 Violation
- Blackmagik Blazing - Rule 3 Violation (Mixed LN died in 2019)
- Oshama Scramble! (Uncut Ver.) - Rule 2 Violation
- Let's Go Crazy (From Sing 2) - Rule 2 Violation
- Neo-Aspect - Rule 2 Violation
- Hachigatsu, Bou, Tsukiakari - Rule 2 Violation
- Blue Desire - Rule 2 Violation
- artefatto vita - Rule 3 Violation
- Belly Flopper - Rule 2 Violation
- Can You Feel My Heart (lullaby) - Rule 2 Violation
- ZENITH - Rule 2 Violation
Personal Reasons:
- Exit This Earth's Atomosphere - Left a post on the thread, just really wasn't interested
- Gimme chocolate!! - how can you use vocal representation on the longjack parts and then turn it into a drum chart straight after that's offensive
- Shooting Star - ironically i would've liked this to be more pure jack map instead of mixed LNs w/ vocals, but i'll hype it because i like the concept anyway
- Last Resort - I really don't care for xi songs
- #1f1e33 (#00102g version) - what i'm hearing and what i'm seeing notes wise really just don't match up, practice a bit more in the realm of dubstep-style mapping and then come back to this
- Arcaea Songs Compilation - you need to learn to track mix; the hard cuts between songs is jarring at best and i had to stop listening 25% through. no comment on the map itself
- Electromagnetic Stealth Girl Born In Philadelphia - this doesn't need mods for me
- Under Construxion - it is clear to me that you don't understand the full fundamentals of jack patterning from this chart and they were more of a second thought here, if i were you i'd look at jack charts from other mappers (mostly unranked since most of the jack charts ranked kinda suck) and try and figure out why things are laid out the way they are
- Fastest Crash - it's not you it's the song, i'd rather be listening to radio silence
- Einherjar Joker - not my thing really, both the song and the mapping style, though you should have absolutely no issue with ranking it with other people honestly
- Divine Light of Myriad - not a fan of the song mostly, also this is not close to controversial lmao
- Melancholia (e_ku's Desolation Remix) - song is kinda one-dimensional and not something i wanna subject my ears to for a long period of time for modding
- 1nput This 2 Y0ur Spine - just gonna keep it short: not a fan of this mapping style myself
- Hoshi o Kakeru Adventure ~ we are forever friends! ~ - i'm sorry but the entire top diff would need a full rework before it even came remotely close to ranked. feel free to come back once you've had someone help you out with that though
- Agito - I just can't justify this dump patterning in my head in correlation to the song
- The 'Fun' In Dysfunction - really just isn't my genre of music sorry man
- Juvenile - something about this is just not for me, i think some sections in the top diff just go a bit too hard relevant to the sounds produced in comparison to the actual intense parts, it feels like it's cramming difficulty in where it's not needed.
- All The Way - This was more well done than it had any right to be, alas I still don't want to listen to this song over and over again.
- Anoyo-iki no Bus ni Notte Saraba - I'm just not an LN heavy guy, looks like a good practice map for LNs and jacks though.
- Cross Fire - The jumptrills only increase by .4 compared to the alternative so it's not the worst thing, but I also just dont have interest in the way this map is laid out in general.
- Deadly Force - Honestly, my advice would be just look at the qualified version for ideas (I also modded that one).
- Vindication(Extended) - The density of the map doesn't match what i can hear in the music personally so i can't really mod this without saying that most of it needs redoing, sorry.
- End of Fairytale - In just the first 5 seconds alone I have so many concerns for density consistency that if I did mod this in the way that I do, 75% of the notes in this map would have a mod against it and I don't have that time.
- Scattered Faith - Less inspired than other versions of the same difficulty, and falls under the same vibro-rolls trope that every other version does. Seen it all before.
- Vicious Heroism - ehhhhh I think there's a lot of room for improvement here, i.e. desnity priority at 00:35:756 - , 00:49:584 - this pattern in terms of hand balance, missing melody usage at 01:00:834 - , overall over-anchor usage and some overmapping, 01:50:697 (110697|3,110756|3) - this, etc. Maybe if you get like 5 people to look at it beforehand i might take another look.
- Darekare Scramble - if this wasn't 4 minutes, then maybe... i might still come back and mod like half of it tbh idk how i feel about this map yet lmao
- Electromagnetic Stealth Girl Born In Philadelphia - I have a big concern over density in this entire chart tbh, also press Ctrl-Shift-A and make sure your notes are all snapped correctly.
- <</nttld.:beings>> ~Truth in Uncertainty~ - There was enough in the first 2 mins of things I heard contrasting against notes I saw that I'd either ask for quite a rework or not have a mod that satisfies your mapping style.
- Chain of Pain - I'm very on the fence about this one because essentially the bulk of the difficulty comes from 20% of the map aka the kiai time but its not a bad map otherwise.
- Fallen Symphony - Not really vibing with this one honestly, also might need a retime in certain areas.
- Motherless Miscarriage - Not really my type of music honestly.
- I.R.I.S - Would need a massive density and snapping overhaul before I began looking at it.
Reject List 2023
Violations:
- Someone Else - Rule 2 & Rule 4 Violation
- EXXTRA JUDGEMENT - Rule 2 Violation
- Don't Fight The Music - Rule 2 Violation
- Angelic Party - Rule 2 Violation
- INF-BL-aste-R - Rule 2 Violation
- TEmPTaTiON - Rule 3 Violation
- We are DREAMERS!! - Rule 2 Violation
Personal Reasons:
- Xronièr ("genèXe" Long ver.) - It's not you I've just had enough of the Xronial Xero album at this point.
- Duplicity Shade - I was down for this until I got to 05:58:794 - : out of curiousity, did you have a break before mapping this part? it comes off a lot different to the map before and feels out of place and in some sections just completely wrong, like 06:05:055 - . Revisit the end and then feel free to resubmit.
- BEYOND - Just very bland ngl, you can use a bunch of short LNs across the map to represent the vocals a bit more, re-evaluate what instruments should be represented in what part (mainly the empty parts with no representation) and make sure the snapping is correct during the solo
- blasphemian - Just not something i'd enjoy modding music wise sorry
- Exercises in Futility VI (KopophobiA RMX/Cover) feat. SpaceChimp - I mean it's just barebones psystyle against pretty simple mapping what do i suggest for this?
- the EmpErroR - I only reject this on the basis that the map is pretty solid as is however the suggestions I would make to improve the map would fundamentally change its structure and are prob not things you'd want to do full map changes with
- MEGANTO METEOR - The map is fine im just kinda sick of this style of camellia at this point [song wise]
- Eternally Onward - It really needs a lot more emphasis on the melody across the map, it seems to dip in and out of it without any real context, and places where it makes sense to have more density just doesn't have it, like 00:47:430 (47430|0) - , my mods would just end up being sweeping generalisation points
- Abnormality, Dancin' Girl - It's a good concept, it just needs general work in terms of consistency and density control, there's certain parts i've noticed which have a drum beat but only a single note, that might be a good place to start looking through your map once again
- BAYONEX (“Xtrablast” Long ver.) - It didn't. sorry.
- ΗΣmolΨsis - This needs a full set before it's rankable, feel free to resubmit as a full set.
- Gargoyle (2009 Version) - It's a good stam practice map don't get me wrong but I could not do a full serious mod for this for ranked unfortunately.
- 414 PER SPEED (Game Edit) - Left a comment on the map for now.
- For UltraPlayers - Not 100% down with the jacking pattern ideas but i also don't know a good way around it that would still work with this original concept, left a small mod for now.
- gigadelic (Camellia's 'THE TERA' Remix) [' 10 ' Long ver.] - It's too mashable for my tastes, seems better as a dump/grace chart than a high HP chordjack fest
sister's noise - not willing to take on jack dumps atm
- Someone Else - Rule 2 & Rule 4 Violation
- EXXTRA JUDGEMENT - Rule 2 Violation
- Don't Fight The Music - Rule 2 Violation
- Angelic Party - Rule 2 Violation
- INF-BL-aste-R - Rule 2 Violation
- TEmPTaTiON - Rule 3 Violation
- We are DREAMERS!! - Rule 2 Violation
Personal Reasons:
- Xronièr ("genèXe" Long ver.) - It's not you I've just had enough of the Xronial Xero album at this point.
- Duplicity Shade - I was down for this until I got to 05:58:794 - : out of curiousity, did you have a break before mapping this part? it comes off a lot different to the map before and feels out of place and in some sections just completely wrong, like 06:05:055 - . Revisit the end and then feel free to resubmit.
- BEYOND - Just very bland ngl, you can use a bunch of short LNs across the map to represent the vocals a bit more, re-evaluate what instruments should be represented in what part (mainly the empty parts with no representation) and make sure the snapping is correct during the solo
- blasphemian - Just not something i'd enjoy modding music wise sorry
- Exercises in Futility VI (KopophobiA RMX/Cover) feat. SpaceChimp - I mean it's just barebones psystyle against pretty simple mapping what do i suggest for this?
- the EmpErroR - I only reject this on the basis that the map is pretty solid as is however the suggestions I would make to improve the map would fundamentally change its structure and are prob not things you'd want to do full map changes with
- MEGANTO METEOR - The map is fine im just kinda sick of this style of camellia at this point [song wise]
- Eternally Onward - It really needs a lot more emphasis on the melody across the map, it seems to dip in and out of it without any real context, and places where it makes sense to have more density just doesn't have it, like 00:47:430 (47430|0) - , my mods would just end up being sweeping generalisation points
- Abnormality, Dancin' Girl - It's a good concept, it just needs general work in terms of consistency and density control, there's certain parts i've noticed which have a drum beat but only a single note, that might be a good place to start looking through your map once again
- BAYONEX (“Xtrablast” Long ver.) - It didn't. sorry.
- ΗΣmolΨsis - This needs a full set before it's rankable, feel free to resubmit as a full set.
- Gargoyle (2009 Version) - It's a good stam practice map don't get me wrong but I could not do a full serious mod for this for ranked unfortunately.
- 414 PER SPEED (Game Edit) - Left a comment on the map for now.
- For UltraPlayers - Not 100% down with the jacking pattern ideas but i also don't know a good way around it that would still work with this original concept, left a small mod for now.
- gigadelic (Camellia's 'THE TERA' Remix) [' 10 ' Long ver.] - It's too mashable for my tastes, seems better as a dump/grace chart than a high HP chordjack fest
sister's noise - not willing to take on jack dumps atm