1. Easy (3.15 stars, 186 notes)
2. Hard (4.93 stars, 340 notes)
3. Remmy's Normal (3.81 stars, 225 notes)

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

[Hard]
00:14:87 (6) - finish sounds out of place
try decreasing hit volume in timing section 2 by a tick? its too loud atm
00:22:31 (7) - try using a different hitsound on these for variety's sake
00:31:19 (1) - try a finish on the first hit?
00:33:11 (4) - ^ if you want to pattern it
00:35:03 (4) - ?? logically this should stack directly under 1
00:40:55 (2) - whistle
00:42:71 (2) - ^ yay piano!
01:00:71 (6,7) - try finishes
01:40:79 (3,6) - ^
01:41:99 (1,2) - ^
01:42:55 (4) - try a clap
01:43:19 (6) - finish the start
01:44:15 (2) - try finish
01:45:11 (8) - ^
01:47:03 (4) - ^
01:48:35 (3,9) - remove clap, add finish
01:49:91 (3) - finish
01:50:87 (1,3) - ^
01:51:83 (2, end of 3) - ^
01:52:79 (5) - ^


whew that was fun ^_^ hopefully thatll give you some hitsounding ideas~

CDFA wrote:

Hard:
00:14:630 (4) - Remove the clap Done.
00:15:110 (7) - ^ Done.
00:16:790 (1,2,3) - Overlapping sliders 3: I don't want to change these as I -believe- they're rankable. If another BAT asks me to, I'll change them.
00:27:830 (4) - Move 1 grid up. Looks awkward if I do this, leaving as it is.
00:52:790 (2) - Add a clap on the beginning of this. Done.
01:03:110 (5) - Remove clap Done.
01:23:750 (4) - ^ Done.
01:42:590 (4) - Move to blue tick (this isn't me going "SNAPPING~, but it matches more with the vocal ~) As far as this goes, I slowed it down to the slowest possible playback to make sure it matched the vocals perfectly.
You have to end kiai time. End it where the slider ends. Done.

Cyclone wrote:

Include default skin's hitcircleoverlay.png to go with the djmax hitcircles.

Hard:

Not gonna map until the end?
01:42:230 (2,3,4) - Snap these to similar timing, but use 1/8 snap instead of 1/3.
Unnecessary timing section at the end?




Normal:

00:54:710 (4) - Spacing error.
01:11:750 (4) - The spacing to this note from the endpoint of the previous slider is inconsistant with the spacing of the map thus far.
01:14:150 (3) - Somewhat similar to above note.
02:11:030 - I don't think we're supposed to do that with kiai.
Preview point not set.

CheeseWarlock wrote:

[Easy]
00:57:915 - Too many finishes in this part.

[Remmy's Normal]
Run AIMod; the spacing issues it points out aren't confusing, just a bit messy.
00:53:750 (1,2,3,4) - I'm not going to say remove this. I'm going to say structure the map so it feels more patterned, this is expected, and this happens more than once; either that or remove it.

[Hard]
01:09:590 (1,2) - This part plays poorly and I don't know why. It doesn't really go with the music, though.
01:14:150 - Could use a note here.

Cyclone wrote:

Normal:

00:54:710 (4) - Spacing error. oops. Fix'd
01:11:750 (4) - The spacing to this note from the endpoint of the previous slider is inconsistant with the spacing of the map thus far. Fix'd ... i think...
01:14:150 (3) - Somewhat similar to above note. After above fix, looks fine to me.
02:11:030 - I don't think we're supposed to do that with kiai. FIIIINNNNEEEEE

CheeseWarlock wrote:

[Remmy's Normal]
Run AIMod; the spacing issues it points out aren't confusing, just a bit messy. Fix'd since there are no more errors
00:53:750 (1,2,3,4) - I'm not going to say remove this. I'm going to say structure the map so it feels more patterned, this is expected, and this happens more than once; either that or remove it. Looks fine to me?

Mafiamaster wrote:

Maybe force the skin to default?

Mafiamaster wrote:

C-can you add an approachcircle.png?
And maybe a section-fail? Default's fine ._.

Alace wrote:

<Remmy`s normal>
AR+3 ?? (1 is really hard to read) <--- Eh, I like +2 more. Dakey can you fix?
02:02:145 (5,6) - too hard for a normal i guess <---- Not really. If I did it throughout the entire map, then yes it might be considered to hard.
02:17:025 (3,4,5) - ^ <---- I like it. It's just that tiny hint of difficulty to make it better.

Dakeyrus wrote:

Mafiamaster wrote:

C-can you add an approachcircle.png?
And maybe a section-fail? Default's fine ._.

It automatically uses the default ones, which is what I want it to be doing :c

James2250 wrote:

lol at BAT's posts and Derekku's post
Make Derekku a BAT already plz

Dakeyrus wrote:

I made a few of the changes you called for Derreku, but not all of them. A lot of what you wanted changed was not so much "unrankable" as something you felt played better. Thing is, it's not your map. I'm not going to make changes to certain parts just because you feel it works better. The spacing in normal is fine, I lowered the drain in easy, and my spinners are more than long enough to accomodate your average player.

I read your post, and I appreciate the feedback, really, but please try to be a little more open minded. Point out the things that are downright unrankable, and if you still wish to offer suggestions on asthetic changes and/or ideas you have that might help the map play better, separate them from your main post. I appreciate the suggestions, I just don't want to filter through everything just to find the parts you found were unrankable.

There really weren't many problems that could be considered "unrankable". That's why my post is formatted as it is. When I mod, I'm as open-minded as can be by putting myself in the shoes of other players. For example, if I think that something will be too hard for a new/inexperienced player, then I point it out. I'm offended that you think I'm close-minded when modding. If you don't want to sift through my "riff-raff" for only the unrankable items, then that sounds more like you're being the close-minded one. :/

Derekku wrote:

[Easy]
When you tried to move your inherited sections to the new offset, you didn't inherit the settings. So now, all of your hitsounds are using the soft sampleset and are uninherited sections. You'll need to fix that before this gets ranked. :U

[Normal]
Did Remmy do anything to his diff? The preview point is still incorrect and the difficulty settings are still ridiculously low. :/

[Skin]
Good.

Don't kd this.