aabc271 wrote:

As requested by mingmichael in pm, I'm coming to have a look on the futsuu diff
Let's go :3

Blue~ Critical issues. You must fix this
Purple~ It's better to fix this
Pink~ Suggestions only. Change only if you want to
Grey~ Explanations of my suggestions

-----------------------

[ Futsuu]

Diff looks clean. Pattern mod below ~

Suggested patterns ~

Here are the minor suggestions of patterns / hitsounds. It's your own choice whether to follow these suggestions.

00:38:889 ( 76~81 ) o o o o o o ? ( Consider 73~75's k d k, imo it could be nice to extend the idea of k d k rhythm at 76~81. This depends on you because this suggestion is totally optional ) sorry nope ;w; because i used k's at 00:38:889 (76,77,79,80) - to follow the guitar sounds there, and i used d at 00:39:812 (78) - because the guitar sound becomes lower than the notes before it
00:53:658 ( 106~111 ) - ^ ( Same reason ) ^

00:48:582 ( 95 ) - Add finish ? ( In terms of song structure, this is very similar to 00:33:812 (66) and so I think a finish fits well here ) aahh sorry nope for using finish ;w; i don't want use too many finishes at futsuu diff (except for the kiai starts and ends) but.. okay, i wil think about this again
01:14:428 ( 145 ) - ^ ( Same reason. Similar structure with 116 )

01:24:582 ( 165 ) - Blue note ? ( It has a higher pitch than 164 in vocal and instrument, so I think d -> k is a better solution ) ohh okay >w< changed~

You once said in pm a bat said this one was quite boring
I'd say this is actually ok and it's repeats have it's own valid points
Therefore imo this is ready to rank :3

Star and good luck ~

toara_fict wrote:

hi~ >u< Taiko modding from osu chat><

Futsuu

[Futsuu]

00:03:812 (9) - k ? (　Cymbal sounds　) sorry, but i focused with the guitar sound which becomes lower at that part ;w; so nope sorry...

00:37:043 (74) - d
00:37:505 (75) - k (vocal pitch)
^ changed them~ >w< good hearing!

00:43:043 (86) - move to 00:42:812 (86) - or i used this one :3
00:41:889 (84) - move to 00:42:120 (84) - or
00:41:889 (84) - Del (Timming) it's been deleted o.o

01:19:966 (158) - Del ...? nope, because it follows the guitar sound ;w;


Mature was very high
That I thought I wonder if this much?
Good luck ming >u< Fight Ranked!!!>u<

OnosakiHito wrote:

Having one or two more mods wouldn't hurt in my opinion.

OnosakiHito wrote:

Requested Taiko Mod by HeatKai

[ Kantan]

General

Since the rule for OD/HP dosen't exist anymore, you may use OD/HP level 3. okay, changed to be 3 now

Notes

{ 00:04:274~00:19:043 - Suggesting having here less kats because in this way you can emphasize the upcoming sections at 00:19:043 ohh okay
00:06:582 (11) - don changed~
00:13:505 (20,21) - k d ^
}
00:20:889 (31,32,33) - Since this is a Kantan, I recommend to make the patterns less dense by deleting 00:21:351 (32) - and make 00:21:812 (33) - to kat. okay~
00:24:582 (37,38,39) - ^ ^
00:28:274 (43,44,45) - ^ ^
- If you did this, the part 00:33:812 should be now more emphasized.
00:33:812~00:57:812 - Recommending to delete the k d k k d patterns by deleting the third kat, because else the kiai isn't emphasized enough. deleted

[ Futsuu]

00:23:428 (47) - Probably better to have a kat here? Fits to vocal. oh yah, it's fit with vocal @_@ sorry i didn't hear it carefully D: changed
00:29:197 (60,61,62,63,64,65) - Maybe having k d k d k d here might be better? okay quite better than the first one, changed
00:41:197 (82) - D since you used it previously as well? nope, i don't want use D's except at the 00:33:812 (67) - 00:57:812 (115) - 00:59:658 (117) - 01:23:658 (165) -
00:54:120 (108) - have a don here. Fits better when considering your previous parts where you followed a certain beat. okay C: i changed 00:55:505 (111) - to be don too
01:19:966 (158) - ^
- Well, the kiai is the same as previous section. You could delete some notes from 00:33:812 to 00:57:812 to emphasize the kiai more. Same as in Kantan.

[ Muzukashii]

General

SV 1.6 shouldn't be use for Muzukashii in any case. The higher the SV the harder it becomes to consider when to hit the notes, since the map contains less notes. After all the space between notes becomes larger. Also it dosen't that well to the song. ohhh... okay, i changed SV to be 1.4 again now

Notes

00:30:120 (104) - I suggest to delete the finisher here. I see no reason right now why to use it.
Well, same thing about kiai as in Kantan and Futsuu. Just a suggestion. why i used finisher there? @_@ lol okay i removed the big notes an changed it to be normal note like kantan and futsuu

[ Inner Oni]

General

01:23:658 - keep the SV from the kiai please. okay, now i keep the SV
Consider using SV 1.40. it has >w<

Notes

00:45:351 (67,68,69,70,71) - Better use this just in the kiai, to emphasize it more.
00:49:274 (90,91,92,93) - ^
okayy >w<\

Well, I didn't said much about the difficulties. They are mapped okay, but pretty monton. Kantan to Muzukashii have at 00:33:812 and 00:59:658 rather a copy-paste which makes the kiai not emphasizes enough.
Oni lacks a bit of structure with its kats, due to beat-vocal mapping, but hey, compared to your previous map which I modded, you improved a lot! That's great.
About Inner I didn't said much either. I won't interfer too much in your patterns, but let me say that it felt a little boring since the map contain a lot of tripplet patterns which are similiar to each other. In general I would suggest to delete some of these trippelts and have more 1/2 beats. In this way you make the tripplets which are left, more noticeable.
okay, i edited some at the kiai parts from 00:33:812 (1) - to be some 1/2beats notes there

Having one or two more mods wouldn't hurt in my opinion.

yeah, now i am still searching for the another modders again to mod this >.<
thanks very much OnosakiHito and HeatKai >w<

OnosakiHito wrote:

Requested Taiko Mod by HeatKai.


[ qoot8123's Oni]

General

01:23:658 - keep the SV from the kiai please.
Consider using SV 1.40.


Notes

00:06:351 (23) - Try kat here. This might sound better to the vocal.
{
00:07:505 (27) - kat
00:08:428 (29,30,31) - k d k
00:09:351 (32,33,34) - d k d
00:10:274 (37,38) - d k
} I recommend to use this pattern. Plays and sounds better.
00:12:120 (43,44,45,46,47,48) - k d k x d k d - same as above.
00:37:505 (143) - Consider to use a finisher here which can make a coherently pattern with the previous used one.
00:41:197 (156) - ^
00:52:274 (202) - ^
00:55:966 (216) - ^



Well, I didn't said much about the difficulties. They are mapped okay, but pretty monton. Kantan to Muzukashii have at 00:33:812 and 00:59:658 rather a copy-paste which makes the kiai not emphasizes enough.
Oni lacks a bit of structure with its kats, due to beat-vocal mapping, but hey, compared to your previous map which I modded, you improved a lot! That's great.
About Inner I didn't said much either. I won't interfer too much in your patterns, but let me say that it felt a little boring since the map contain a lot of tripplet patterns which are similiar to each other. In general I would suggest to delete some of these trippelts and have more 1/2 beats. In this way you make the tripplets which are left, more noticeable.

Having one or two more mods wouldn't hurt in my opinion.

Tasha wrote:

Mod Req from mingmichael

[General]
- Offset feels off, I'd recommend getting a second timing check as your offset probably changed when you had the mp3 bitrate changed (Both people who previously did a time check did it with the 320kbps mp3, so their offset is no longer correct. i think the offset already right :/

- You have a lot of wasted timing points, you should only need the uninherited one that sets the bpm, the one that starts the kiai, and the one that ends the kiai. Nothing more. It should look like this


[Inner Oni]

Keep in mind there's some note removals in here so numbers might not be accurate, use timestamps as reference instead.

00:01:274 (4,5,6) - ddk doesn't seem to really fit here, I'd suggest dkd or ddd instead. i changed to be dkd

00:01:966 (8,9,10,11) - This would probably play and sound a bit better if you move 9 and 10 a 1/4 tick over to the right. If you applied the above mod, you could use the opposite of whichever suggestion you used. (Aka, if you used dkd the first time, use ddd this time, and vice versa) sorry no changed at this ;(

00:02:774 (13) - Remove this note if you applied both above suggestions to keep patterns consistent. ohh okay >,<\

Doing the above 3 mods gives you a solid d d k d d d k d d d k beat on the 1/2 ticks. i didn't use your second mods but the patterns are o o o o o o o o o o o on the 1/2ticks. i think that's quite a good pattern too :3

00:04:043 (21) - Remove this note, the drum ends on the previous tick. nope :C sound will be weird because that

00:07:966 (34) - This downbeat sounds better as a don imo. i can't because you can hear that, the guitar sound appears at there and i use kat at that part for all diffs (except oni)

00:10:505 (43,44) - Remove 44 to fit the vocals better. I'd also suggest making 43 a don if you do this. deleted and changed~

00:15:351 (60) - Try a don here? no ;w; same like 00:07:966 (34)

00:16:043 (62) - Don here as well imo. changed

00:17:197 (67) - Move this to 00:17:428. nice~

00:18:351 (71,72,73,74,75) - Not really sure if a 5 note pattern fits here, try splitting this into a 3 - 1 pattern. I'd personally suggest ddk k but you could do other patterns too. i am agree with you here. i changed it now

00:32:774 (148,1) - Did you try removing 148 and using a (kat) finisher where the slider starts instead? Just a suggestion but I think it plays a bit better. no ;w; same like another modders said like this too

00:37:043 (19) - Suggest making this a don. no. it follows the vocal

00:45:928 (70) - Same as above. Apply to the repeat in kiai as well.

00:51:582 (103,104) - Reverse the colours on these. Apply to the repeat in kiai as well. no :/ sounds weird..

[Comments]
I glanced over the other taiko difficulties really quick, and I don't have the time to mod them all right now. Overall the guest difficulty other than some small parts seemed okay, but the rest of the taiko diffs still need work. I'll see if I can edit my post later and mod the rest of the difficulties when I have more time.

thanks Tasha for your mods

_Gezo_ wrote:

confirming what tasha said, i found the notes a little off (i felt the claps were off from the beats) and tried 574. try to get more people to time it properly to confirm or infirm my sayings about it. don't forget that they are all suggestions and I want precise justifications as to why you've refused.





[oni]
any reason justifying 120% speed at the end ?
00:31:966 (121,122,123,124,125,126,127) - the song's suggesting a small 9-stream here, as it has 8 um... snares
only thing so far I found. no change, because i want to emphasize these three vocal sound 00:32:420 (125,126,127) -

_Gezo_ wrote:

Will review the last diffs either today or tomorrow

_Gezo_ wrote:

Sorry but due to an unexpected turn of events, I might delay this a bit more. poke me whenever I manifest myself in #taiko after August 11 at 00:00 UTC.

_Gezo_ wrote:

change artist to a huge number (7!! = (7!)! = 5040!) #math lol, that's factorial

[Muzu]
00:07:958 (26) - not a good idea to leave k, the guitar whatever this is called is only a background note, you'd better focus more on kicks and snares on that part. i changed it
00:11:650 (37) - ^ ^
00:14:650 (46,47,48,49) - felt somewhat awkward. if you think this is fine, let it be. hughh? i don't think so... :/
00:19:035 (62) - to 00:31:727 (110) - : a bit odd to constantly switch from guitar to lyric (all the time) okay, now i focused for the guitar
00:46:727 (155) - expected a don, there's nothing justifying much a kat here D: changed~
00:50:650 (169,170,171) - dkd, for consistency with the pattern right before ? ohyah, i changed this._. sorry, i didn't realize from the previous pattern
00:59:420 (200) - why is he the only one small, was he punished for being the 200th total note lol, okay i changed this
01:16:496 (258,259,260) - same as 169-171 (2 above)
01:25:266 (289) - y u no make this big
^ changed both

[Futsuu]
00:04:266 (10) - to 00:19:035 (37) - weird that you use kats for downbeat kicks. okay, now i changed 00:06:112 (13,17) - to be dons
00:22:035 - maybe add a don here ? will feel less empty :U hahaha great hearing! changed
00:28:497 (61) - ^ ^
01:15:804 (149,150,151) - you should nudge them 1/2 backwards, to match the lyrics more. okay, and i added don at 01:16:958 after i nudged it

[Kantan]
01:24:574 - Add a note here ? i don't think so. i want make it empty at kantan diff. same like 00:58:727 part. i didn't want put any note there

don't kd me. should have done this with my older mod.

Sey wrote:

Don't leave this graveyarded, where's the motivation?
I do not wanna make a CtB difficulty for nothing.

_Gezo_ wrote:

You got four TBATs, more BATs that are able to rank taiko maps, how can you let the chance of getting this ranked go, really ?

eldnl wrote:

ONO I CHOOSE YOU

eldnl wrote:

ONO I CHOOSE YOU

OnosakiHito wrote:

eldnl wrote:

ONO I CHOOSE YOU

Ono, ono!

I misunderstood the request because I forgot that I modded the map. lol

[ Inner Oni]

00:16:497 (64) - Maybe make this to kat because, you had often at such time-lines a doublet of kats. E.g. 00:10:266 (42,43) - or 00:15:112 (59,60) -
00:58:727 - changed
Suggesting to have here already the SV change, so the transition to the kiai becomes better. ohh okay~
00:45:343 (65,66,67,68,69) - I'm fine with these notes, but remember next time to make not sudden pattern changes. You didn't used such doublets in the whole map, but suddenly they appeared. Afterwards notes are fine. okay ;~;

Well, I'm okay so far with it. Talked to Tasha because of his last sentence in p/2460311, but he said it is fine when I recheck it already.

Call me back afterwards.

OnosakiHito wrote:

eldnl wrote:

ONO I CHOOSE YOU

Ono, ono!

I misunderstood the request because I forgot that I modded the map. lol

[ qoot8123's Oni]

00:58:727 - Suggesting to have here already the SV change, so the transition to the kiai becomes better. fixed



Well, I'm okay so far with it. Talked to Tasha because of his last sentence in p/2460311, but he said it is fine when I recheck it already.

Call me back afterwards.

qoot8123 wrote:

Thanks~
http://puu.sh/4i34A.zip