those wrote:

Extra is really good with the cool whistles, but Insane abuses sliderslide hitsounds, so I wouldn't be so sure this will stay in qualified much longer.

Andrea wrote:

This Extra difficulty is actually really fun to play. You will think that it's weird to hear that from me, but that's not everything.

To be honest, this difficulty seems to be mapped with a completely different song in mind, like a val0108's high BPM map.

It doesn't follow this song at all, but I still enjoyed it. Congrats on rank!

Reasons for disqualification:

Additional Suggestions:

Sylith wrote:

finally!

Sylith wrote:

finally!

Sylith wrote:

finally!

Sylith wrote:

finally!

Fast wrote:

wow congratz

p3n wrote:

Reasons for disqualification:

[General]
drum-sliderslide53.wav has 25ms of silence in the beginning and this is not rankable as it delays the hitsound. This is relevant in this case as the drum sound is used as a hitsound with impact that simulates something like a slider tick clap without the actual tick in the slider in [K i A i's Insane].

The use of hitsounds in this way is NOT RECOMMENDED. This specific hitsound will play more than once while playing the map on HT and will further mess up the player feedback.

Fixed sliderslide file, removed silence in the beginning and added silence at the end to avoid repeats (thanks Garven): http://puu.sh/dMLtU/08cddaff0b.wav


[K i A i's Insane]
00:52:239 (1,2) - 1/16 snapped slider ends should be on 1/2 instead as has been done in all the other similar repeating parts in this map.

Additional Suggestions:

[K i A i's Insane]
01:26:269 (1) - should end 1/1 later to match all the other diffs.


[Extra]
In general this difficulty is extremely overmapped. It feels like a constant 1/4 spam that doesn't really follow any characteristics of the song.

00:22:071 (2) - slider starting on 1/8; while it kind of fits the harp(?) in the melody, it plays really weird and you should avoid starting sliders or streams on 1/8 ticks for gameplay reasons. You can try to end the previous slider on that 1/8 tick and just use a longer kickslider afterwards.
01:19:384 (2) - ^same

While the Extra is something I would never rank myself, it seems like a good amount of players actually enjoy it. If you can fix the 1/8 slider heads it should hold even though there will be people still complaining how stuff like this got ranked in the first place.

Sylith wrote:

finally!

Sylith wrote:

finally!

1. 00:55:373 (7,8,1) - The flow here is kind of awkward. 00:55:261 (6,7,8) - This flows downwards quite significantly and the jump upwards to 00:55:821 (1) - is a bit harsh when you take into account the speed of the play. Its a pretty pattern though!
2. 01:12:612 (4,5) - This raises some concerns for readability, I found that the start of 4 obscures 5's sliderpath due to the fast nature of the play which made it overall kind of confusing.

1. 00:21:791 (1) - Poorly placed spinner imo, the spinner ends on a very strong sound in the music so I feel it would be better to accent it with a circle. Also with 00:23:134 (1) - coming right after it can be confusing to figure out which rhythm is which since it happens so fast. Alternatively you can do what jieusieu did in the extra with a fast repeating slider.

1. 00:33:209 (6,8,9,10) - The stack leniency boinks up the pattern unfortunately. 6's spacing between 00:32:985 (5) - is shortened to due the stack. I suggest you find somewhere else to place 00:33:657 (8,9,10) - so that it looks neater and can avoid any confusion.
2. 00:52:239 (1,2,3,4,5) - I enjoyed this pattern, nice job here!
3. 01:01:866 (3,5) - Stack is slightly off, not that big of a deal but it bothers me to look at hehe
   01:07:239 (2,1) - This is unrankable unfortunately. 2's hitburst doesn't disappear until 1 is about to be played. This doesn't give enough time IMO for the average hard player to recognize.

1. 00:48:657 (1,2,3) - I think a stack of three is a bit confusing and hard to look at especially when you are a normal player. Unstacking these would be more appropriate, especially since you did not do this much throughout the diff. You have stacks of two later on, so the player might be used to clicking three times and mess up as well

Lust wrote:

[Norman's Normal]
Cool diff name :3 lol, thanks

1. 00:48:657 (1,2,3) - I think a stack of three is a bit confusing and hard to look at especially when you are a normal player. Unstacking these would be more appropriate, especially since you did not do this much throughout the diff. You have stacks of two later on, so the player might be used to clicking three times and mess up as well Delete 00:48:881 (2)

Lust wrote:

Additional Modding

[Extra]
Marvelous diff, I had tons of fun playing this and the whistles sound great. o rly?

1. 00:55:373 (7,8,1) - The flow here is kind of awkward. 00:55:261 (6,7,8) - This flows downwards quite significantly and the jump upwards to 00:55:821 (1) - is a bit harsh when you take into account the speed of the play. Its a pretty pattern though! I have no idea how to fix this. sorry
2. 01:12:612 (4,5) - This raises some concerns for readability, I found that the start of 4 obscures 5's sliderpath due to the fast nature of the play which made it overall kind of confusing. fixed

[Gloria's Hard]

1. 00:33:209 (6,8,9,10) - The stack leniency boinks up the pattern unfortunately. 6's spacing between 00:32:985 (5) - is shortened to due the stack. I suggest you find somewhere else to place 00:33:657 (8,9,10) - so that it looks neater and can avoid any confusion. fixed
2. 00:52:239 (1,2,3,4,5) - I enjoyed this pattern, nice job here!
3. 01:01:866 (3,5) - Stack is slightly off, not that big of a deal but it bothers me to look at hehe fixed
   01:07:239 (2,1) - This is unrankable unfortunately. 2's hitburst doesn't disappear until 1 is about to be played. This doesn't give enough time IMO for the average hard player to recognize. fixed

Beautiful song and mapset! Why haven't I seen any of your mapping before? I guess I am a fan now haha o7
Call me back after you finish making these changes.

those wrote:

There's no overmapping in this map.

bbj0920 wrote:

those wrote:

There's no overmapping in this map.

as long as it fits the song <3

Rakuen wrote:

As requested!

Legend

Default = Normal mods
Blue = Strongly recommended
Red = Unrankable issue
Pink = Will be discussed if not changed

Gloria's Hard

1. 00:18:209 (1) - Unnecessary big jump (don't aim to let players retry)
2. 01:07:239 (2) - ^ Possibly decrease this too (1.6?), whole diff isn't really mapped for jumps

Call me back!

Rakuen wrote:

Requalified

Sylith wrote:

next disqualify when??????

Frobe wrote:

님이 무슨 랭크임 사기치지 마셈 ㅡㅡ

scanter wrote:

만우절 농담 미리보는 재미