tgnehs wrote:

Short answer, because they are making better maps.

As you know osu mania star rating system is broken. The SR formula favors simple patterns like jumptrills. PP farming osu mania players end up playing those highly inflated maps over challenging tech maps. As a result many of the "older" songs which you play are just the popular ones which take advantage of easy patterns for higher SR and PP. Believe it or not, there are older songs which are similar to the "difficult" maps you are describing, such as Eternal Drain, Kamui, Mastication Numerique, and The Empress scream off ver.

The patterns that cause maps to be underweighted are jackhammers, LN layering, streams, offbeat timings, trills, and a variety of others. What I'm assuming is that the community has become aware of how lame it is to abuse jumptrills and started using patterns which actually match the music and make for an interesting map.

But maybe someone who actually does mapping can chime in, as I have pretty much zero experience. All I know is I'm looking forward to a larger variety of maps which are fun to play

Evening wrote:

if you'd list examples, it'd be easier to explain

Evening wrote:

tl;dr maps have been evolving to be more complicated

To give context on how SR works:

1.It's mostly based on density, hence if a pattern is "rough", it'll still award the same star rating as one that's "smooth".

1.1 Tech maps pivot on intentional "rough" patterns for difficulty, however, osu cannot discern between these 2 types of patterns, hence awarding them the same star rating.

1.2 SV's are not considered into the star rating. Hence if you have a hard to read SV, the map will be underrated.

1.3 Hybrid maps are where you have LNs and notes at the same time, usually they are more confusing to players who just started out since it's basically 2 types of notes to consider.

---
Why you may be struggling on some

Not sure which marianne you're looking at

2.1 The ones you struggle with have traits that makes them lean towards a hybrid map < Fly Like You; Rubber Band >
Whereas the ones you are comfortable with are more ricey < Puppet; Kanshou >

2.2 The note rhythms of Rubber Band and Positive are much more complex than that of older maps because nowadays it's justified to dump notes (i.e. map notes that aren't explicitly there, but can still represent a sound as a pattern).

2.3 LNs are harder

2.4 Minijacks, believe it or not, older maps avoid minijacks because there's a stigma that it's a bad pattern. It's just hard, and more maps nowadays use it

2.5 SVs, old maps avoid complex SVs because stigma, nowadays it's more accepted. That's why you don't see many difficult and complex SVs for old maps

---