Lizbeth wrote:

Why slider velocity in Love is lower than Normal? Not good.
this is because circle size in Normal is 3 and Love is 5
if i decrease sv in Normal, the slider become shorter and i think they're ugly
if i increase sv in Love, the difficulty increase and i think current difficulty satisfy me

Love
03:10:930 (2) - still don't agree with this, I don't find a good reason of keeping this, would you mind to explain?
i like to bring various spacing by snapping the distance from slider start(normal slider) or slider end(repeat slider)
sliders below are all using this concept (there are more, i just list 3):
01:12:397 (5,1) -
01:49:245 (2,3) -
02:31:637 (4,5) -
i agree this one might be the hardest to sightread, and have nothing to do with the music, but that's my mapping style.

i already found more than 100 testplayers for this map, most of them FC it with 1 playcount, and as far as i remembered less than 10 players break combo here, only 2 or 3 players complain about this, so i think it's okey (and also it looks better, since i use such a small DS multiplier)

Yuki's Hard
01:33:919 (4,5,6,7,8) - I just feel this part off: try this: http://puu.sh/2G7c

Normal
03:21:528 - what is the reason of increasing spacing after this point? to add difficulty to the last part? If so, maybe not a good idea for normal, but since is not a big difference I guess is ok. However I suggest to wait till last kiai time. Makes more sense.
yes and remapped

ps. Please check in Timing Setup Panel if you have useless timing sections and delete them.
only find 1 in [Love] and it's deleted

Lizbeth wrote:

Yuki's Hard
01:33:919 (4,5,6,7,8) - I just feel this part off: try this: http://puu.sh/2G7c Change

loveFantasy wrote:

Lizbeth wrote:

Love
03:10:930 (2) - still don't agree with this, I don't find a good reason of keeping this, would you mind to explain?
i like to bring various spacing by snapping the distance from slider start(normal slider) or slider end(repeat slider)
sliders below are all using this concept (there are more, i just list 3):
01:12:397 (5,1) -
01:49:245 (2,3) -
02:31:637 (4,5) -
i agree this one might be the hardest to sightread, and have nothing to do with the music, but that's my mapping style.

i already found more than 100 testplayers for this map, most of them FC it with 1 playcount, and as far as i remembered less than 10 players break combo here, only 2 or 3 players complain about this, so i think it's okey (and also it looks better, since i use such a small DS multiplier)

Lizbeth wrote:

Normal
04:15:658 (1) - too close to prev circle fixed
I'm not sure about the x1.30 sections, I wouldn't make change on speed like that in a normal.
also you have x1.00, x0.75 and x1.30. And you change from x0.75 to x1.30, I don't think thats a good idea, because the change is a bit drastic.
they played out well as a Normal ( i found 4~5 Normal-skilled players after the remap )
actually there're only 1/2 and 3/4 sliders and they're all curvy ones, if you click at the right place you don't even need to move the cursor for 1/2 sliders to get 300s, you need to move a little for 3/4 sliders, though

as you can see, since i lower the SV and the song itself is at a very low BPM, 0.75 to 1.00 is not enough to bring the contrast effect i want for last chorus, and this is a Normal diff not an Easy~

Love
01:01:637 - add note here? nope
02:18:267 (3) - should be closer to 2 rearrange position of (1,2,3) a bit

I understand the concept, and I agree with it. But I have to say this three you mentioned:01:12:397 (5,1) - 01:49:245 (2,3) - 02:31:637 (4,5) - are 1/2 jumps.
But the one I mentioned: 03:10:930 - 03:13:539 (3) - is 1/4 jump. That's why I don't agree with it. But let see what other modder say.
remapped into something else

Hard
03:49:246 (1,2) - Looking at this whole diff, this jump was a bit drastic. Is the only jump this big in the map and is kinda out of place due to this. Just my opinion, you decide what to do :3

Good luck~~

Lizbeth wrote:

Hard
03:49:246 (1,2) - Looking at this whole diff, this jump was a bit drastic. Is the only jump this big in the map and is kinda out of place due to this. Just my opinion, you decide what to do :3
OK, maybe I shouldn't make the jump because the other similar parts have no jumps

Sakura Hana wrote:

[Storyboard]
All storyboarded images that have higher dimmensions than 640x480 must be resized, the playfiled is 640x480 so there's not really any need for the images to be larger than that unless they are scrolling images, and i dont see the lyrics scrolling anywhere.
all image with >640 width is fixed.
it was my first map so i knew little about mapping limitation that time

[General]
You probably should add another break in the 2nd half like on [Yuki's Hard] (although that one doesnt fit imo)
well..at that part, all my diff were mapped so i don't need break

[Normal]
Why not end the 1st kiai at the same spot as the other diffs? (01:51:202)
instead remapped [Love] at that part so the kiai is consistent with [Normal], i think this is better
[Yuki's Hard] is guest diff and don't need the kiai to be the same, and it's good as it was imo
03:31:310 (2,1) - Please dont use kick sliders on the easiest diff D:
i think this is fine, also i asked enough testplayers for this diff to make sure it fits as easiest difficulty in my mapset

also adjust some tiny finish pattern in this diff

Nice mapset, contact me again when you've done fixes for a recheck (and maybe a bubble)

Sakura Hana wrote:

[General]
You probably should add another break in the 2nd half like on [Yuki's Hard] (although that one doesnt fit imo) :p"

Alace wrote:

Final nazi

<Normal>
00:28:702 (1) - add new combo (silly bug)

<Yuki>
03:42:397 (1) - new combo