forum

Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone

posted
Total Posts
103
show more
[eifersucht]
SPAAAACE. :|
Kiyomitsu
Star :D
NoHitter
Hiyorin
Do you want a video for this? I tried to map this but gave up :S
Here it is on the off chance that you would want it http://puu.sh/1WCh
Emdyion
Want You Gone is ranked now D:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/29161
Derekku
I already spoke to Sapphire, but I'd like to mention that I plan on finishing my part within the next few days.

Then, I'll get started on the storyboard! :b

S:
Hamuko
Charles445
Oh hey this is finished
MODDING TIME

General
The ranked map has an offset of 2460, you should probably use that (60 is okay too)

Easy
AR +1 or +2
00:05:160 - I don't think having the first note on the red tick is a good idea, especially on an Easy.
Cute :3

Emdyion's Normal
01:29:160 - You should remove this slider.
02:11:910 - This spinner should start on the next white tick.
Seems tough for a normal, but it's a good difficulty.

Hard
00:40:860 - Break should start here
00:48:660 - Glados is 1/4 earlier than this. Either way, I wouldn't recommend mapping to her voice on this part.
01:21:660 - Break should start here
01:33:360 - This isn't really mapped to anything. Glados' voice is offbeat here.
02:11:460 - Remove new combo
A good difficulty, though it's strange that it has the same slider velocity as the collab.

Collab Potato

NoHItter
00:05:760 - This is better off ending on the blue tick
00:08:860 - This is pretty much unreadable and an unexpected 1/3.

Teta
Nice one!

animask
You're trying to map to the lyrics far too much - it's causing most of your part to be offbeat. You should never need to use 1/3.
It would take a while to point out the mistakes, go through it and listen closely.

-kevincela-
01:14:385 - I like this 1/8 stream and all but it is overmapped. Remove this hitcircle.
01:22:110 - This isn't mapped to anything, her voice doesn't hit here.

Lilac
01:28:410 - I don't like how you mapped to her voice going 't', this isn't intuitive to the player.
01:31:710 - This isn't mapped to anything.
01:37:110 (5,6) - Bad spacing
01:38:460 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - This whole combo is pretty much bad spacing
01:40:860 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - This is by far the BEST part of your part. It's readable, intuitive, and epic
01:44:910 - Remove new combo

Behonkiss
01:49:710 - Putting this on the blue tick might be a bad idea. It's your call though.

Emdyion
02:11:760 - Remove new combo

A nice collab with a few major problems

Ozzy's Portaikol
The insanely hard parts seem random and out of place.
You could use more finishes :O
Hamuko

Charles445 wrote:

Teta
Nice one!
Thanks :P
OzzyOzrock

Charles445 wrote:

Ozzy's Portaikol
The insanely hard parts seem random and out of place.
You could use more finishes :O
NO THEY DON'T YOU'RE CRAZY, IT'S CALLED MAKING IT HARDER THAN MITTEN

Finishes are overrated ;_;
Emdyion
Added Charles445's mod.

And remove the new combo for me on the collab diff.

Download: Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone (SapphireGhost) [Emdyion's Normal].osu
NotShinta
General:
The collab and Ozzy's Taiko keep switching places, it's confusing and disturbing

Collab POTATO![/color]:
A few hitsound inconsistencies, but that can be expected from a collab.
00:41:140 - Not sure of the reason for this rhythmic break. Might want to move it to the next 1/1 if you want to keep it.
NoHItter:
00:12:040 (8) - I'm sorry, but this does not look nice. Not even symmetrical, huh
animask:
00:46:740 (4,5) - These shouldn't be on 1/3? And if they were, you arguable shouldn't be mapping to them to prevent confusion
00:56:840 (6) - I don't personally think this jump is a good idea.
Yeah, no, none of this should be 1/3
-kevincela-:
01:22:090 (6,7) - These are kind of out of place. I recommend just removing them, poof?~
Lilac:
01:28:390 (5) - What are you doing? I mean, erm, this doesn't appear to be set to anything.
01:44:890 (1) - Any particular reason for the new combo?

Hard:
00:09:040 (3) - I would add a finish at the end of this, sir
00:23:740 (3) - You could make this a 1/2 long slider
00:41:440 - What I said before, you do remember, don't you?
01:02:440 (1) - Finishaha?

Endymion's Normal:
00:07:540 (3) - Add a new combo for consistency?
00:48:040 (3) - One would assume you want this symmetrical. Start with the sliderpoints.
02:08:440 (3,4) - You could unstack these and make a nice + pattern.

Easy:
Use more finishes
01:37:840 (4) - Move this 1/2 back? And stack onto the previous beat of course

Shit mod, etc., don't mod Taiko, tired, episode 18 looks boring
Hamuko
I asked you in-game but you told me to post so orz
On my part of the collab,
00:37:840 (10) - move this 1 grid to the right to make it centered D:
please fix this since i noticed it.
-kevincela-
Yes,I agree for both the mods about the stream 1/8 on 01:14:385 - and the notes 6-7 on 01:22:090 -,so can you fix them for me,Sapphire?
OzzyOzrock
NoHitter
Emdyion
Kecco
Overall
Nothing to warn about.

Collab Potato
  1. 00:45:940 (1,2,3,4,5) - Unsnapped~
  2. 00:48:440 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Well, I don't understand to reason for which you made those sliders and note unsnapped in that way. Anyway, I tried to fix and seems that works pretty good if you place the 00:48:440 (1) on 00:48:490; the 00:48:840 (3) on 00:48:790; the end of this slider 00:49:240 (4) on 00:49:540; the start of this slider 00:50:240 (6) on 00:50:140 and the end 00:50:440.
  3. 00:51:840 (5,6) - Please snap these notes so that they will be placed on the blue ticks.
  4. 00:52:840 (1) - The slider lenght is erred
  5. 00:56:840 (6) - Unsnapped~
  6. 00:58:840 (2) - Erred slider lenght.
  7. 00:59:440 (3) - ^
  8. 00:59:440 (3,5) - ^
  9. 01:36:940 (4,5) - This is a bit trippy in my opinion. The distance between the hitcircle (4) and the slider (5) let the player think that the pattern is following a 1/2 rhythm, but it's not so. Fix by crossing (4) and (5) like this.
  10. 01:45:640 (?) - I think you should add a note here with finish-hitsound.
  11. 01:54:640 (3,4,5,6,7) - This pattern is weird and ugly. Please make it in a better way.
  12. 02:11:440 (1,1) - I think that the jump between these notes ruin the map since it has a really relaxing rhythm and you all mapped this song by following it. So I think you should reduce that jump.
Hard
  1. 00:56:440 (3) - Why don't you silence the end of this slider? It would be more catchy in my opinion.
  2. 01:34:840 ~ 01:36:040 - I think you should map this part.
  3. 01:37:690 (?) - Add a slider here and let it end on 01:37:990
Emdyion's Normal
  1. This difficulty has a different preview time comparing to other difficulties' ones. Please fix it.
  2. Overall Difficulty -1.
  3. Circle Size : Large?
  4. 00:18:940 (5) - Distance error ._.
  5. 00:27:340 (5) - ^
  6. 00:28:840 (1) - This is placed in a bad location in my opinion. Just move it some grids away from 00:27:340 (5).
  7. 01:08:140 (5) - Distance error.
Easy
  1. Circle Size : Large?
  2. 00:45:940 (1) - Let it finish on 00:47:440. [If you do that you should pay attention on the distance with 00:48:340 (2)]
I don't know why, but I love this song. Great job~

~
Emdyion
Added Kecco's mod.

Forgot to star this, so here you go~

Download: Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone (SapphireGhost) [Emdyion's Normal].osu
OzzyOzrock


DONE, WHITE EDGES YAY
Topic Starter
SapphireGhost
So for anyone wondering, the [Hard] I had made was kind of outdated, and I had gotten better at mapping since then. I decided I didn't want anything ranked that wasn't my best work, so I remapped it. You can find the old one here to see how much I've improved!
EDIT: [Easy] has been fully remapped too, download link for old version below.

Download: Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone (SapphireGhost) [Old Hard].osu

Download: Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone (SapphireGhost) [Old Easy].osu
Sleep Powder
HellDawn
8-)
OzzyOzrock


RANK THIS
Gonzvlo
[General]
  1. Tags: Remove 'Derekku' since he is not in the collab anymore. Free kudosu \o/
  2. Preview Time is not the same for all the diffs. (Normal & Taiko)
  3. The 2nd Combo Colour looks more like Pink than Orange, try this one: '248,184,52'
  4. Taiko: The BG doesn't show the 'Map by OzzyOzrock' part while playing, is this intended?
[Easy]
  1. 01:26:740 (1) - I would start this spinner 1/2 earlier, it fits better the music than the vocals.
  2. Quite nice, my only complaint here is that the hitsounds were a bit iffy, sometimes it sounds too empty, sometimes the claps are not fitting, sometimes the whistles are placed too close to each other, well nothing too important.
[Emdyion's Normal]
  1. 00:18:940 (5) - I find this circle too hard to hit and read for [Normal]. I strongly suggest to remove this circle and then add a repeat to this slider: 00:18:040 (4) -
  2. 01:18:940 (1) - This jumps was too unexpected imo. Use distance snap like you did with the previous pattern like this one (00:38:140 (1)) the jump is too big for [Normal].
  3. I didn't like the design of this diff much, most of the sliders could be improved a lot, same for the pattern design. Many of the sliders were overlapping each other, this could be easily avoided. Read this guide and see if you can improve some of the sliders included in your diff.
[Hard]
  1. 00:38:140 (1,2,3) - Whoa... this spacing. It wasn't too bad while playing, but it's still a bit confusing. I'm almost sure that this wasn't intentional, you just forgot to flip (2) again. Also, (2) looks cramped, try something like this.
  2. 01:26:740 (1) - Same as [Easy] I think this spinner fits more the music than the vocals, you should start it 1/2 earlier.
  3. Awesome, I don't see any major problems here.
[Collab Potato]
  1. Perhaps, re-name it to 'Potato Collab'?
  2. (Teta)--------00:33:040 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I would remove (7) from this stream, it doesn't sound good, it feels kinda off.
  3. (Animask)----00:47:440 (X) - I totally expected a circle here, it fits perfectly the vocals. I strongly suggest to add it.
  4. (Animask)----00:52:240 (X) - Same here ^
  5. (Animask)----00:57:040 (X) - Yeah, I'm still convinced that those circles would fit perfectly this part of the song.
  6. (-Kevincela-)-01:21:340 (5) - You should make this slider end 1/2 earlier to match the other diffs, it sounds better too, so consider doing it.
  7. (Lilac)---------01:34:840 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - This stream sounds a bit empty, you should add some hitsounds. Some soft whistles should be enough but alternating with the 'Normal Override' would make it sounds awesome.
  8. (Behonkiss)--01:56:440 - Why the sudden change to 'Soft Override' the music didn't change, it's the same as 01:46:840 - where you used the 'Normal Override' you should use the same 'Hitsounds Override' if the music is the same, otherwise it doesn't make sense. 02:00:040 - This could be a great place to switch to the 'Soft Override'.
  9. I was quite 'awesome and odd' at the same time to see those vocals/rhythms mapped in completely different way by every mapper in this Collab.
Call me back when everything is fixed, I expect some improvements in [Normal] o/
-kevincela-

Gonzvlo wrote:

[Collab Potato]
  1. (-Kevincela-)-01:21:340 (5) - You should make this slider end 1/2 earlier to match the other diffs, it sounds better too, so consider doing it. You're right,fixed
Download: Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone (SapphireGhost) [Collab Potato].osu
Hamuko

Gonzvlo wrote:

[Collab Potato][list]
[*](Teta)--------00:33:040 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - I would remove (7) from this stream, it doesn't sound good, it feels kinda off.
There is a beat there, remove (7) and listen at 50% speed. So yeah, not removing it~ ♪ •n•
Topic Starter
SapphireGhost
Thank you for the mod, Gonzvlo! I changed most things but [Collab Potato] will stay as a reference to this. Thanks again, now waiting on the responses of the remaining collab members.

EDIT:

animask wrote:

I wasn't mapping the vocals there or at any of those parts.

Not Changing.
Now to wait for Lilac and Behonkiss.
Emdyion
Added Gonzvlo's mod.

I understand what you mean with the sliders. I fixed some sliders in between and I remapped the ending.

Download: Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone (SapphireGhost) [Emdyion's Normal].osu
Gonzvlo
Re-checked, the volume of the last spinner was increased so it's not completely silenced, everything else seems fine.

Bubbled.
Topic Starter
SapphireGhost
Thanks Gonz, I now love you forever and I'm taking a picture of the brownie right now
theowest
oh man. too late to request a place I guess. ;C
OzzyOzrock
YOU CAN DO IT SAPPHY
-kevincela-

OzzyOzrock wrote:

YOU CAN DO IT SAPPHY
GOGOGOGOGO
Topic Starter
SapphireGhost
Bubble popped for an update from Emdyion. Expect a Jibbaha mod quite soon ~
Gonzvlo
Some slider-shapes and pattern design modifications in [Normal].

Bubble repaired.
Charles445
keepin' the party goin' woowoo
bug someone
blissfulyoshi
Easy:
01:37:240 (2) - this would probably look better if it was a curved slider that followed 1

Emdyion's Normal:
00:17:140 (3) - new combo for new line of lyrics?
00:48:040 (3) - ^?
01:03:640 (2,1) - it would look a little better if these 2 sliders did not overlap each other

Hard: fine

Collab Potato:
00:54:940 (4) - with this note being covered by almost every note before it, it looks like a mess imo
01:03:340 (1,2,3,1) - looking at the overlaps, it is not very symmetric, and I guess that is contributing to how it does not look as neat as it should (normally I find the pattern fine....)
01:27:640 (3,4) and 01:31:690 (2,3) - not exactly sure what type of thing you were trying to make with this overlap, but I don't think it turned out that well.

Ozzy's Portaikol: fine

==========================
Decent mapset. I didn't find much wrong (mostly just personal things), so call me back when you did the changes you want.
Topic Starter
SapphireGhost
Pop again, now waiting on animask, Emdyion, and Lilac ~
Emdyion
Added blissfulyoshi's mod.

Fixed some of the hitsounds as well :P

Download: Jonathan Coulton & GLaDOS - Want You Gone (SapphireGhost) [Emdyion's Normal].osu
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply