1. Easy (0.91 stars, 180 notes)
2. Hard (4.91 stars, 561 notes)
3. Normal (3.56 stars, 342 notes)

Zelos wrote:

Easy:

01:18:710 (1,2,3) - these aren't equidistant. (considering the same timing placement among the notes) Done

Normal:

02:19:927 (2,3,4) - these are a bit unequal too. Done

03:41:008 (2,3,4) - ^^ ^^

Hard:

00:35:925 (3,1,2) - this isn't exactly pretty looking. Not exactly sure why you say that, but I rearranged it a bit anyway.

Thunderstorm wrote:

Greetings

Some suggestions

[Overall]

Maybe, decrease volume of hitsounds a bit?

[Easy]

00:18:710 (3) - Mid point 1 grid right, end point 1 grid up fiiiine
01:34:927 - maybe, end it here 01:37:359 ? I agree that it does sound better, but I ended it earlier so the player has more time to recover after the spinner.

[Normal]

00:20:129 (1, 2, 3, 4) - spacing (ok, new combo, but [Normal]) I don't see anything wrong with the spacing?
01:11:818 (4) - align with 3? oh why not
02:56:413 (3) - spacing Just because it's Normal doesn't mean I can't have a little jump or two

[Hard]

Seems fine

That's all. Good luck =)

1. All diffs must have the same offset, check hard diff.
2. Use the same kiai time in all diffs

1. kiai time ?

1. 00:57:832 (1) Remove new combo ?
2. 01:38:981 (1) ^
3. 01:52:967 (1) ^
4. 02:47:089 (1) ^
5. 03:14:048 (1) ^
6. 03:23:575 (4) This slider is too low don't you think?
7. 03:39:589 (1) Remove new combo
8. 03:57:629 (1) ^

1. 00:21:143 (4) Fix this slider ?
2. 00:22:562 (1) Remove new combo

1. This diff have a different offset
2. Kiai time ?

1. 00:19:303 (7) Fix this slider ?
2. 02:46:466 (1) Remove new combo
3. 03:10:587 (6) New combo ?

eldnl wrote:

[General]

1. All diffs must have the same offset, check hard diff. Ah good catch, fixed.
2. Use the same kiai time in all diffsdurr fixed

[Easy]

1. kiai time ?

1. 00:57:832 (1) Remove new combo ? I like all the new combos where they are.
2. 01:38:981 (1) ^
3. 01:52:967 (1) ^
4. 02:47:089 (1) ^
5. 03:14:048 (1) ^
6. 03:23:575 (4) This slider is too low don't you think? It looks fine in-game.
7. 03:39:589 (1) Remove new combo
8. 03:57:629 (1) ^

[Normal]

1. 00:21:143 (4) Fix this slider ? Sure, neatened it up a bit.
2. 00:22:562 (1) Remove new combo

[Hard]

1. This diff have a different offset
2. Kiai time ?

1. 00:19:303 (7) Fix this slider ? Neatened.
2. 02:46:466 (1) Remove new combo
3. 03:10:587 (6) New combo ?

Great. Star

TheVileOne wrote:

Easy

01:18:710 (1,2,3) - I would prefer this to be spaced in 0.8. But you wont do that I know. Actually yeah, that would help with the somewhat difficult rhythm.
01:04:116 (3,1,2) - ^

01:56:008 (3) - I think this should be moved down a little to make a more defined curve.

http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/94639

Do the same to this 01:57:630 (1,2,3) - if you do as its intended to look the same right?

01:59:252 (3,1,2) - 0.8
03:21:954 (1,2,3) - ^ I'm mentioning these, because they don't play right to me. Feel free to ignore these unless you really like them.

Normal

01:07:359 (2,3,4,5) - This curve is strange and it seems I have to pause when transitioning between 2 and 3. Maybe increase spacing? sure

03:06:548 (3,4,5) - This doesn't match the styling of the rest of the diff. yeah I can see that, changed

03:17:900 (5,1,2,3) - weird curve IMO... adjusted it a little

03:20:737 (4,5,6) - curve somewhat? It's weird. I think I'll keep it like this for now.

Hard

00:21:736 (7,1) - I don't like this at all. Moved it a liitttle to the right to lighten the jump, but I do kinda like this

Keep these segments if you want. But it plays better with regular snap. All of the segments...

A lot of IRCing. Yes there was.


Very well mapped.

Nharox wrote:

You might want to add kiai time on the last part on [Easy] and [Hard] as well because there is only one on [Normal]. Doh, the last guy pointed that out and I forgot to upload the change till now >_>

Lanttu wrote:

I think I'll mostly quote Shiirn about this one. And I really like the hitsounds, too<3 Thoooough...

00:56:813 (1) - Finishes in all these similar parts sound so loud to me when the background is that silent. Maybe lower the volume on that finish to 50% or something? Sure I'll do that. Lowered the rest of the hitsounds as well as I was meaning to do that for a while but kept forgetting >_>

..A-and that seems to be all, there's nothing to point out. Everything flows really nicely. Have my star<3

DarkDunskin wrote:

General:
- add "Up!" to the Source ( The albums name) Albums don't belong in the source, actually.
- Tag suggestions: country sure
- No SB = no .osb -> delete it It'll just keep coming back anyway =/ peppy said just to leave them alone so yeah

Normal:
- 00:51:138 (4) - the slider is a bit at the bottom of the screen, consider moving it more up? It's low in the editor but it actually looks fine in-game.

It's not fun modding maps that are really good to beging with ^^"
Your hard diff became really beautyfull :O
I kinda disagreed with your hitsounds at the first time playing your map, but after a while I started to like them too ^^

Useless mod, good map -> star

NotShinta wrote:

General:
I think it would be cool if you colourhax'd (changing the colour of it via the little menu besides new combo, that is) all the 'nah!' hitcircles the same colour to create familiararity with each other. Preferably blue because I like blue. Ehhh I'll think about it, I'm kind of old fashioned so I'm not quite comfortable with all this combohax shenanigans yet

Hard:
02:36:138 (2,3,4) - This looks ugly and uneven, I'd move 3 like up 1 grid. Just flat out changed the combo
03:18:300 (8) - I suppose this could be confusing or awkward, considering this type of thing doesn't show up again. But then again, nah! Possibly, but I'll wait and see if anyone else thinks the same way

Normal:
Tick rate 2 please. Considering this is 1/2 and Hard uses it. sure
00:25:192 (5) - I'd like a clap at the start of this. k
01:22:759 (6) - And a finish at the end of this. I prefer the silence in this part as opposed to the echo of the finish
01:50:326 (5) - I would flip this vertically, and keep it in the same place obviously, so it fits with the pattern more. fiiine
03:52:353 (5) - New combo this? But you don't have to~ Ah yes, good catch
03:55:596 (5) - ^ ^

Easy:
Tick rate 2 may be a bit excessive, but maybe, this time! Yeah considering the sliderspeed I think 1 is sufficient
The overlaps may sometimes be confusing for the lil' Easy players but oh well Well the number of overlaps starts out light then gradually curves up as the map progresses, so I think the newbies will be able to handle the progression.

Maybe I should continue pretending to have masculinity. Nah! Masculinity? In osu!? pshhhh

konan-yoshi999 wrote:

konan-yoshi999's mod:

[Easy]
General: The rythyms are a little confusing for east but they work.

[Normal]
00:27:219 (2) - Make linear with the 1,2 stack? Nah, that was intentional.

[Hard]
General: Increase HP Drain to 7 so it's different than normal? Oh wow, how did I forget to change the HP drain >_> fixed
00:54:584 (3) - Not exactly symmetrical with the (2) Good catch, fixed
01:45:259 (2) - Make linear with (1)? Decided to change the pattern a different way.
02:59:651 (1) - Make symmetrical? Yeahhh that was a lazy one, done.

Compliments: Loved your use of hit sounds
Hope this get's ranked (even though I hate country ) I'm not a country fan either for the most part I'll admit a few country singers are growing on me though...

Charles445 wrote:

Easy
0.7x isn't very good distance spacing - it makes the sliders seem too fast. Try 0.9x or 1.0x The sliders/spacing is s/low enough that this really isn't much of an issue.
AR +2 Don't really see why?
The offbeat nature of this is going to give beginner players a lot of trouble
01:18:705 (1,2,3) - Why is this 0.8x? This is confusing for beginners I did this because I found that syncopated notes are a little more intuitive when they are further apart. Plus newbies do tend to rely more on the approach circles than distance so I really do think it's fine.
02:01:476 (1,2) - ^^
02:13:841 (1,2,3) - ^^
03:21:949 (1,2,3) - ^^
03:34:921 (1,2,3) - ^^

Normal
AR +1 ?
03:17:083 (4) - Move this to the right 1 (woo nazi) Not really necessary, but w/e
03:54:380 (4) - ^^ ^

Hard
Good

Crimmi wrote:

Modding, CrimmiStyle!!

I might nazi a bit here so here it goes:

[Easy]

00:18:705 (3) - Align with (1). Nah
01:04:922 (3) - Maybe add a clap to the slidertail? Sure
01:17:084 (3) - A grid to the right. Don't really see the point =/
02:12:219 (3) -A grid to the left. ^
03:10:597 (3) - Align with (1)? Nah

[Normal]

Nothing~

[Hard]

02:56:205 (3) - a grid up. I like it not being 100% even
02:56:408 (4) - ^ ^

That's all, now have a star*

1. Delete .osb file.
2. Add 'Up!' in TAGs (?)

1. 02:19:516 (5) - Add new combo, because you did it here 02:22:759 (1) also.
2. 02:19:922 (1) - Remove new combo.
3. 02:23:570 (1) - ^
4. 02:26:813 (1) - ^
5. 02:28:030 (1) - ^
6. 02:30:057 (1) - ^
7. 02:33:300 (1) - ^

Lilac wrote:

I believe the album name should be in the tags...Not sure. Just for you, Lilac. Just for you.

GladiOol wrote:

[General]

1. Delete .osb file. OK I'll delete it ONCE, but if it comes back it's staying there :U
2. Add 'Up!' in TAGs (?) yep

[Hard]

I would love you to fix these new combos~ I think it looks way better like this. It's a bit new combo spammy at the moment.
If you also compare it with this 03:40:597 part, you can see how it does look nice over there. And consistency is never a bad thing~ I was SO ready to brush this off, but yeah you're right. Did all changes except for the ones I comment on

1. 02:19:516 (5) - Add new combo, because you did it here 02:22:759 (1) also.
2. 02:19:922 (1) - Remove new combo.
3. 02:23:570 (1) - ^
4. 02:26:813 (1) - ^
5. 02:28:030 (1) - ^
6. 02:30:057 (1) - ^
7. 02:33:300 (1) - ^

03:08:165 (8) - Looks a bit sloppy. I suggest changing it to a more appealing shape.
03:10:597 (6) - Add new combo, because you did it here 01:49:111 (1) and here 00:53:976 (1) also. Yeah, but this is a different pattern than the previous two times I like the running combo


[Normal]

00:30:057 (3) - Add new combo. (You also add in a new combo up there in the [Hard] difficulty, so why not here~[/list]
00:49:516 (4) - Add new combo.


[Easy]

03:36:543 (1) - Remove new combo.
03:38:165 (5) - Add new combo.
03:39:584 (1) - Remove new combo.
03:57:624 (1) - ^ Because you don't put a new combo there in the other diffs either. Yeahhh though I think I like finishing it off with a single lone combo.


Starred~

Lilac wrote:

hate me.

Alace wrote:

Mapset is pretty good
before ranking it, would you mind snap your green lines well in all diffs (they are late for 1~5ms)