This game is a closed set-up.
No information on the roles and set-up will be given.
No information on the roles and set-up will be given.
forum
An osu! Mafia - TOWN WIN
posted
Total Posts
381
Topic Starter
If anything judging from the PM I received at night I'm going to...
Vote: pieguy1372
Vote: pieguy1372
don't worry NoHitter, I'm aware that roles won't be revealed so I'm putting the community to this question..
Sorry, what's a reverser role? :S
DxS's post is interesting but a little too vague to really say much about.
DxS's post is interesting but a little too vague to really say much about.
a role that when you target, your power will be applied to you instead.. something like that
I first assume it was a reverser role that was targeted by the serial killer based on the result, and with the sentence of "shot with his own gun" ..
although another possibility is the mafia gets the kill sequence first before the serial killer..
but another counter possibility is the Mafia didn't issue a kill order to avoid tracking roles, but serial killer decided to kill someone that is a reverser role or this one
I first assume it was a reverser role that was targeted by the serial killer based on the result, and with the sentence of "shot with his own gun" ..
although another possibility is the mafia gets the kill sequence first before the serial killer..
but another counter possibility is the Mafia didn't issue a kill order to avoid tracking roles, but serial killer decided to kill someone that is a reverser role or this one
If the mafia are the (amount of) people I think they are, they won't waste nights not killing.
so hey good morning guys. Killer down means only one kill each night. Means we get a lot more time to figure stuff out. Copclaims, stay put for a while.
rust flipped town, but then again town who didn't give a shit, so good riddance I guess.
I assume all of you got the weird crazy PM last night in which everyone was BCC except pieguy. Probably just a modly mistake, Dxs, don't vote off of that.
If anyone has any more iinfo to give us, let it be known. If you got a PM about anything over night best bet is the mafia dunnit.
so hey good morning guys. Killer down means only one kill each night. Means we get a lot more time to figure stuff out. Copclaims, stay put for a while.
rust flipped town, but then again town who didn't give a shit, so good riddance I guess.
I assume all of you got the weird crazy PM last night in which everyone was BCC except pieguy. Probably just a modly mistake, Dxs, don't vote off of that.
If anyone has any more iinfo to give us, let it be known. If you got a PM about anything over night best bet is the mafia dunnit.
Oh, that's what he meant. Yeah pieguy is first on the list so that's probably how it happened.
Serial Killer
I'm still a little confused with the Serial Killer getting shot with his own gun thing, but meh.
Also, I think that BCC Error with pieguy is nothing to worry about... I guess.
I'm still a little confused with the Serial Killer getting shot with his own gun thing, but meh.
Also, I think that BCC Error with pieguy is nothing to worry about... I guess.
Stop worrying about the whole 'shot with his own gun' thing... It's probably just one of nohitter's stories, like the guy falling off a tree.
Yeah, if it was really reversed then the story would probably have involved adam's target killing him as opposed to some mysterious person sneaking up on him.Mashley wrote:
Stop worrying about the whole 'shot with his own gun' thing... It's probably just one of nohitter's stories, like the guy falling off a tree.
We're reading into the mafia variant of foam pellets. This is worse than not important.
Does anyone still suspect Quaraezha about odd phrasing? I kinda still do. But hey I was wrong about rust too. Thoughts?
Does anyone still suspect Quaraezha about odd phrasing? I kinda still do. But hey I was wrong about rust too. Thoughts?
Oh yey~ One less killer to have to worry about! Interesting how he got taken out on the first round though....
Although... I still have absolutely no clue of who the bad guys are, and whether or not there are other malicious independents ._. , so I guess I'll just wait through a bit of this round before making a vote.
EDIT: Judging by the other posts Quaraezha makes around the forums, I'm thinking he's just naturally like that. I don't really know actually, but I'm pretty sure there's somebody else here who'll turn up as a bigger risk.
Although... I still have absolutely no clue of who the bad guys are, and whether or not there are other malicious independents ._. , so I guess I'll just wait through a bit of this round before making a vote.
EDIT: Judging by the other posts Quaraezha makes around the forums, I'm thinking he's just naturally like that. I don't really know actually, but I'm pretty sure there's somebody else here who'll turn up as a bigger risk.
Wait a sec.
If I am not mistaken, we ALL received the same PM, with pieguy in the "To:" section. Why would you vote for someone who received the same message you did?DeathxShinigami wrote:
If anything judging from the PM I received at night I'm going to...
Vote: pieguy1372
this0_o wrote:
Wait a sec.If I am not mistaken, we ALL received the same PM, with pieguy in the "To:" section. Why would you vote for someone who received the same message you did?DeathxShinigami wrote:
If anything judging from the PM I received at night I'm going to...
Vote: pieguy1372
also posting to avoid being the prodding thing
Topic Starter
VOTE COUNT
pieguy1372 (1) - DeathxShinigami
Not Voting (11) - pieguy1372, dkun, BakaloidSky, 0_o, Mashley, iMuffin, Quaraezha, Wojjan, Kitsunemimi, MDuh, E-Hooker
--------------------------------------------------------
Note: I'll be out from May 25 to May 30. As such, the deadline may be arbitrarily moved forward to May 30, but if I can find any internet connection to where I'm going, the deadline stays. As for mod prods, etc. I may find a back-up mod.
pieguy1372 (1) - DeathxShinigami
Not Voting (11) - pieguy1372, dkun, BakaloidSky, 0_o, Mashley, iMuffin, Quaraezha, Wojjan, Kitsunemimi, MDuh, E-Hooker
--------------------------------------------------------
Note: I'll be out from May 25 to May 30. As such, the deadline may be arbitrarily moved forward to May 30, but if I can find any internet connection to where I'm going, the deadline stays. As for mod prods, etc. I may find a back-up mod.
Mod: I'll gladly do some backseat modding for you if you need me.
Also, could you let us know to when the deadline moves?
Okay so Quaraezha was sorta clear to me too, a lot of people speak of themselves as innocents. Of course they don't pay heed that we don't know that they know they are and blah blah blah blah words words words.
Still totally feeling for E-Hooker as mafia, but I won't vote on hunches. Let's just say I got my eyes on you.
Also, could you let us know to when the deadline moves?
Okay so Quaraezha was sorta clear to me too, a lot of people speak of themselves as innocents. Of course they don't pay heed that we don't know that they know they are and blah blah blah blah words words words.
Still totally feeling for E-Hooker as mafia, but I won't vote on hunches. Let's just say I got my eyes on you.
Aww, I'm not on Wojjan's hit list any more? :<
To me there are only 3 reasons why Person A would vote for Person B for receiving same message:
1: Person A is a third party who thinks that Person B must be a third party as well.
2: Person A is mafioso who thinks that Person B must be a third party (i.e. that message was sent to all the anti-town roles)
3: He's a jester who is screwing with us.
For now I'm willing to wager against a jester role, and vote DxS.
Also Mashley way to get me excited about strager's return for a brief moment >_>
1: Person A is a third party who thinks that Person B must be a third party as well.
2: Person A is mafioso who thinks that Person B must be a third party (i.e. that message was sent to all the anti-town roles)
3: He's a jester who is screwing with us.
For now I'm willing to wager against a jester role, and vote DxS.
Also Mashley way to get me excited about strager's return for a brief moment >_>
Ohohoho, i'm terribly mysterious!
I assure you, dear Wojjie, i'm a townie.
Of course, I suppose everybody will vote for me now and think that i'm bluffing, but i'm not.
I assure you, dear Wojjie, i'm a townie.
Of course, I suppose everybody will vote for me now and think that i'm bluffing, but i'm not.
It kinda doesn't help that your avatar is Mafia-ish lookin'.
And I'd also rage so hard if there was a Jester.
And I'd also rage so hard if there was a Jester.
You see, ever thought about what ability I could possess if I knew why to vote against pieguy? Just because it's a coincidence that he was first on the signup list and he was the only person on the "To" field. Doesn't mean I'm voting him because of that.
Due to the rules I really shouldn't reveal this information but in a short way of putting it...
You'll hurt town more if I go down in flames~
Due to the rules I really shouldn't reveal this information but in a short way of putting it...
You'll hurt town more if I go down in flames~
roleclaiming? DXDeathxShinigami wrote:
You see, ever thought about what ability I could possess if I knew why to vote against pieguy? Just because it's a coincidence that he was first on the signup list and he was the only person on the "To" field. Doesn't mean I'm voting him because of that.
Due to the rules I really shouldn't reveal this information but in a short way of putting it...
You'll hurt town more if I go down in flames~
So basically you're roleclaming aux?
Indirectly yes.
Still, wish you guys fun as you'd rather leave me behind and team up to finish me off.
Still, wish you guys fun as you'd rather leave me behind and team up to finish me off.
Now I'm not sure if we should target DxS or pieguy :<
pieguy is suspicious because his name was shown as 'To:' in the PMs instead of 'BCC:' like the rest of us. Terribly suspicious.
Meanwhile, DxS is acting/typing/speaking/what have you in a manner that makes you suspicious.
Meanwhile, DxS is acting/typing/speaking/what have you in a manner that makes you suspicious.
I'm practically positive DxS is a cult leader after a private conversation we had. I'd post the log but it seems to be against the rules to do so, so you'll just have to take my word for it. His last post shows traces of this as well, as he's trying to kill off the person who knows this.
vote: DxS
vote: DxS
Isn't it against the rules to have private conversations in the first place? Unless, of course, members of the cult are allowed to converse outside of the thread.
Yes that's right. Lynch me so we can have town lose!
Sounds like a good idea.
Vote: DeathxShinigami
Vote: DeathxShinigami
If he is cult leader, then it is my understanding that we should lynch him before the cult gets too big. I mean, I'm not exactly too sure about how the cult would work, but afaik they work against the town. Even if isn't, the line ' Lynch me so we can have town lose!' is inherently scummy.
Vote DeathxShinigami
Vote DeathxShinigami
Vote: DxS
Claim your aux role. No use being all cagey right now, you're dead by night.
Claim your aux role. No use being all cagey right now, you're dead by night.
+5 for me. Takes 7 to lynch.
A typical DxS answer would be "Switch vote and for self before NoHItter goes off for a few days." But no.
I can choose between both but...I'll come clean
I cheated. My role doesn't allow me to communicate to players at night. At first I messaged pieguy to see about the pm he got and asked if it was anything different from the BCC'ers. Could he have been told something differently from the host? Anyways, I went on and as soon I realized about his experience with the game I got trapped and lied my way to the point where I seem to be cult leader. But really...I'm
Claim: Townie
GG
A typical DxS answer would be "Switch vote and for self before NoHItter goes off for a few days." But no.
I can choose between both but...I'll come clean
I cheated. My role doesn't allow me to communicate to players at night. At first I messaged pieguy to see about the pm he got and asked if it was anything different from the BCC'ers. Could he have been told something differently from the host? Anyways, I went on and as soon I realized about his experience with the game I got trapped and lied my way to the point where I seem to be cult leader. But really...I'm
Claim: Townie
GG
Sorry, I'm missing something, why did you have to lie that you were cult leader?
Cause I would've hoped he'd fall for that (which he didn't) and it'd be an excuse to why I could chat at night.
Whatever.
Unvote
Vote: DxS
Whatever.
Unvote
Vote: DxS
*sigh*
another person votes for themselves?
another person votes for themselves?
Don't take this the wrong way, but you're kinda garbage at this.
Voting for yourself is a ridiculous way to say 'I can't be fucked to explain my way out of this'
Or, he's just mafia making up shit
Or, he's just mafia making up shit
I'd be out anyways when the mod comes to slash me off. So yeah. You're right.
@Wojjan
Still better than a one-shot player at least.
@Wojjan
Still better than a one-shot player at least.
since 1 less killer, out I'd say its safe to bandwagon @ day 2
unfortunately, he voted for himself so that makes me think he's a jester :L
It can also be that pieguy and DxS is on the same team and trying to sacrifice DxS to look that pieguy can be trusted
I don't want the one to seal off his death sooo..
vote: BakaloidSky
you sir is one very quiet and suspicious guy..
unfortunately, he voted for himself so that makes me think he's a jester :L
It can also be that pieguy and DxS is on the same team and trying to sacrifice DxS to look that pieguy can be trusted
I don't want the one to seal off his death sooo..
vote: BakaloidSky
you sir is one very quiet and suspicious guy..
I think DxS is already dead. I counted 7 votes for him (unless someone changed their vote and I overlooked it).
I'd rather get a guy who isn't as active overall in mafia games to become more active due to my gaffe that I made.
Indeed, he would look better from it afterall...Makes you wonder huh?
Indeed, he would look better from it afterall...Makes you wonder huh?
Topic Starter
FINAL VOTE COUNT OF THE DAY
DeathxShinigami (7) - 0_o, pieguy1372, E-Hooker, Mashley, Wojjan, DeathxShinigami, iMuffin
BakaloidSky (1) - MDuh
Not Voting (4) - dkun, BakaloidSky, Quaraezha, Kitsunemimi
--------------------------------------------------------
The sun hadn't even reached noon when everyone agreed that DxS was very suspicious. He claimed to have overheard something from pieguy - and even though the high one above confirmed that it was a mistake, he still insisted on it. Then he claimed that he wasn't an ordinary townie - which people didn't believe at all. In the end, he doubled back on it and just said he was a regular person.
Everyone else didn't like it one bit. DxS they thought, was crazy or something. I mean who claims aux then townie? They had enough of it - a show of hands confirmed it. They would get rid of DxS.
This time everyone was sure to tie DxS up before throwing him off the cliff - to avoid the fiasco yesterday with rust. Afterwards, everyone decided to return to the beach for lunch. It would be coconuts again - still coconuts were better than nothing.
Lunch was about to finish when suddenly, someone picked up a piece of paper from under the makeshift table they constructed. It was read aloud. "DxS was innocent. Too bad for you guys." Perhaps it was a taunt from the killers - who knew except for them? Maybe DxS had been innocent after all...
DeathxShinigami - Townie - pushed of a cliff - DAY 2. (Lynched)
Lunch was quickly ended. Everyone lost their appetite. Dinner was even shorter. Another night - they were all afraid.
--------------------------------------------------------
DO NOT CHAT OUT OF THE THREAD. THIS IS THE FINAL WARNING. ANYONE ELSE CAUGHT DOING SO WILL BE MODKILLED.
IT IS NOW NIGHT 2.
DEADLINE OF ALL NIGHT ACTIONS IS IN 1 DAY - MAY BE EXTENDED DEPENDING ON MY INTERNET SCHEDULE.
IF POSSIBLE SEND IN ACTIONS ASAP, SO I CAN PROCESS THEM BEFORE I LEAVE.
ALL ACTIONS NOT SENT WILL BE INTERPRETED AS A "NO ACTION".
DeathxShinigami (7) - 0_o, pieguy1372, E-Hooker, Mashley, Wojjan, DeathxShinigami, iMuffin
BakaloidSky (1) - MDuh
Not Voting (4) - dkun, BakaloidSky, Quaraezha, Kitsunemimi
--------------------------------------------------------
The sun hadn't even reached noon when everyone agreed that DxS was very suspicious. He claimed to have overheard something from pieguy - and even though the high one above confirmed that it was a mistake, he still insisted on it. Then he claimed that he wasn't an ordinary townie - which people didn't believe at all. In the end, he doubled back on it and just said he was a regular person.
Everyone else didn't like it one bit. DxS they thought, was crazy or something. I mean who claims aux then townie? They had enough of it - a show of hands confirmed it. They would get rid of DxS.
This time everyone was sure to tie DxS up before throwing him off the cliff - to avoid the fiasco yesterday with rust. Afterwards, everyone decided to return to the beach for lunch. It would be coconuts again - still coconuts were better than nothing.
Lunch was about to finish when suddenly, someone picked up a piece of paper from under the makeshift table they constructed. It was read aloud. "DxS was innocent. Too bad for you guys." Perhaps it was a taunt from the killers - who knew except for them? Maybe DxS had been innocent after all...
DeathxShinigami - Townie - pushed of a cliff - DAY 2. (Lynched)
Lunch was quickly ended. Everyone lost their appetite. Dinner was even shorter. Another night - they were all afraid.
--------------------------------------------------------
DO NOT CHAT OUT OF THE THREAD. THIS IS THE FINAL WARNING. ANYONE ELSE CAUGHT DOING SO WILL BE MODKILLED.
IT IS NOW NIGHT 2.
DEADLINE OF ALL NIGHT ACTIONS IS IN 1 DAY - MAY BE EXTENDED DEPENDING ON MY INTERNET SCHEDULE.
IF POSSIBLE SEND IN ACTIONS ASAP, SO I CAN PROCESS THEM BEFORE I LEAVE.
ALL ACTIONS NOT SENT WILL BE INTERPRETED AS A "NO ACTION".
Topic Starter
PLEASE DO NOT TALK AT NIGHT.
EDIT: NOR EDIT OR DELETE THEM.
EDIT: NOR EDIT OR DELETE THEM.
Topic Starter
It was midnight once again. MDuh was awake in his makeshift shelter. He could not sleep. I mean who could? There was a murderer among them. He had built his shelter in a cave he found. It was actually perfect. One entrance- there was no way the murderer could sneak up on him.
Suddenly, Mduh smelled something. It was a horrible stench. It was smoke! The culprit wasn't even going to meet him head on. MDuh hurriedly tried to get out, but he wandered in too deep. It would take him some ten minutes to get out. It would be too late.
The next morning, everybody gathered on the beach- except MDuh. Everybody rushed to the cave he was staying in. There was a fire burning at the mouth of the cave. The fire was put out and the cave was searched. There lay MDuh's body.
MDuh - Townie - suffocated by smoke - NIGHT 2 - (Nightkill)
One more person was down. They would have to get this over soon.
IT IS NOW DAY 3.
DEADLINE IS IN ONE WEEK.
Suddenly, Mduh smelled something. It was a horrible stench. It was smoke! The culprit wasn't even going to meet him head on. MDuh hurriedly tried to get out, but he wandered in too deep. It would take him some ten minutes to get out. It would be too late.
The next morning, everybody gathered on the beach- except MDuh. Everybody rushed to the cave he was staying in. There was a fire burning at the mouth of the cave. The fire was put out and the cave was searched. There lay MDuh's body.
MDuh - Townie - suffocated by smoke - NIGHT 2 - (Nightkill)
One more person was down. They would have to get this over soon.
IT IS NOW DAY 3.
DEADLINE IS IN ONE WEEK.
Oh wow, are you serious? o.o I was sure he was the cult leader
Anyway, I'm suspicious of BakaloidSky for the following reasons:
-Didn't vote in the first or second rounds
-MDuh voted him and MDuh ended up dead...perhaps trying to kill off the one who found out?
So I vote BalakoidSky.
Anyway, I'm suspicious of BakaloidSky for the following reasons:
-Didn't vote in the first or second rounds
-MDuh voted him and MDuh ended up dead...perhaps trying to kill off the one who found out?
So I vote BalakoidSky.
I highly doubt the mafia would kill someone off just for saying that one of its members was a "suspicious guy".pieguy1372 wrote:
-MDuh voted him and MDuh ended up dead...perhaps trying to kill off the one who found out?
Not necessarily just that, but also because MDuh was the only one voting anyone besides DxS. If he was allowed to live, he could have started a bandwagon day 3, and since no one else voted anyone besides DxS after he was pointed out on day 2, they might do the same thing with him day 3. From the mafia standpoint, it would be better to solve the problem before it gets too big.
That's still quite a bit of WIFOM though; to me it's just as likely that you killed MDuh so you could say "that's what Bakaloid would do."
On a sidenote, if NoHItter says it's ok could you post the conversation you had with DxS? Sure the conversation wasn't allowed, but the point of only posting in the thread is so that everyone has access to all the information so I think it would be for the best if it were out in the open.
On a sidenote, if NoHItter says it's ok could you post the conversation you had with DxS? Sure the conversation wasn't allowed, but the point of only posting in the thread is so that everyone has access to all the information so I think it would be for the best if it were out in the open.
Hmm... I think I agree with pieguy for this one, his reasoning sounds pretty decent. Although DxS sorta caused his own incident, I can't really see everyone suddenly deciding to side against Bakaloid if MDuh just survives through the night. Then again, the only other weird thing I see going on here is... dkun.. who's being even more quiet than Bakaloid...
...That's.. that's just like too quiet man. I don't even know if he's actually really busy or not.
...That's.. that's just like too quiet man. I don't even know if he's actually really busy or not.
I actually wanted to ask Mduh why he was suspicious of me, I was too late though.pieguy1372 wrote:
Oh wow, are you serious? o.o I was sure he was the cult leader
Anyway, I'm suspicious of BakaloidSky for the following reasons:
-Didn't vote in the first or second rounds
-MDuh voted him and MDuh ended up dead...perhaps trying to kill off the one who found out?
So I vote BalakoidSky.
anyways vote pieguy, I don't like how he starts the bandwagons.
In case I'll get lynched (which is likely to happen imo), I think the mafia guys are Wojjan, E-Hooker, pieguy and Mashley(not sure on this one though)
your accusations suckpieguy1372 wrote:
Oh wow, are you serious? o.o I was sure he was the cult leader
Anyway, I'm suspicious of BakaloidSky for the following reasons:
-Didn't vote in the first or second rounds
-MDuh voted him and MDuh ended up dead...perhaps trying to kill off the one who found out?
So I vote BalakoidSky.
someone not voting makes them baddie. u go sir baddie
vote pieguy1372
+ my reasons for being quiet is my personal life, you'll have to excuse me for that. but i'm sure i'll be getting more activity going on here.Kitsunemimi wrote:
Hmm... I think I agree with pieguy for this one, his reasoning sounds pretty decent. Although DxS sorta caused his own incident, I can't really see everyone suddenly deciding to side against Bakaloid if MDuh just survives through the night. Then again, the only other weird thing I see going on here is... dkun.. who's being even more quiet than Bakaloid...
...That's.. that's just like too quiet man. I don't even know if he's actually really busy or not.
tbh, pieguy's suspicions are completely baseless.
vote: pieguy1372
I would appreciate it if iMuffin made more contributions to the game than prod responses and random/bandwagon votes.
Anyone got any good reasons for voting pieguy? I'd have thought you'd learn from the last 2 guys you all bandwagoned on.
if we assume 4 mafia, we're on mylo.
Do we no lynch or have the cop claim?
Do we no lynch or have the cop claim?
and i would appreciate it if i did too0_o wrote:
I would appreciate it if iMuffin made more contributions to the game than prod responses and random/bandwagon votes.
Then why don't you contribute something now?
you mean other than the stuff that has already been said?
Yeah, you could, y'know...play.
I mean, it's Day 3 and we have basically NOTHING to go on. About half the town is already dead, and we got one bad guy.
Abstaining from voting in the meantime, I think, we got nothin' but accusations. After all, look at where said accusations and baseless claims have led us.
I mean, it's Day 3 and we have basically NOTHING to go on. About half the town is already dead, and we got one bad guy.
Abstaining from voting in the meantime, I think, we got nothin' but accusations. After all, look at where said accusations and baseless claims have led us.
roleclaim: Cop
Unfortunately, I haven't found any mafia yet. First night I checked Mashley and I couldn't complete my action, so perhaps we have a roleblocker in this game. Second night I checked E-Hooker and he's innocent.
Seeing as I'm almost dead, I practically have to do this.
Unfortunately, I haven't found any mafia yet. First night I checked Mashley and I couldn't complete my action, so perhaps we have a roleblocker in this game. Second night I checked E-Hooker and he's innocent.
Seeing as I'm almost dead, I practically have to do this.
Strikes me as something of a mafia last resort sort of thing to roleclaim the exact role Wojjan wanted to be roleclaimed... but I'm not going to vote because then some silly person will hammer it like last night. Still, FOS on pieguy.
Any particular reason for investigating E-Hooker? If I were a cop I probably would have targetted someone more vocal like Wojjan.
But yeah, unless someone counterclaims I really don't think lynching pieguy is a good idea at the moment.
But yeah, unless someone counterclaims I really don't think lynching pieguy is a good idea at the moment.
It seems odd that you claim cop, and suddenly have an innocent result on someone I suspected to be mafia. Nevertheless, you're pretty dang new if I remember correctly, and if you thought I knew what I was doing my fos could be worth a cop check.
Don't do that anymore. It's bad play, regardless of what side you're on.
Don't do that anymore. It's bad play, regardless of what side you're on.
Well... that's interesting... :< But yeah, you probably should've went for someone who could be of more risk.pieguy1372 wrote:
roleclaim: Cop
Unfortunately, I haven't found any mafia yet. First night I checked Mashley and I couldn't complete my action, so perhaps we have a roleblocker in this game. Second night I checked E-Hooker and he's innocent.
Seeing as I'm almost dead, I practically have to do this.
Still though, I think it might be a better idea if we pick someone else, because having a cop around could be really valuable, and I don't want us to lose another innocent because they were the only person who seemed suspicious at the very moment.
iMuffin made a weird response to faceman's comment up there, so I think he might be hiding something.
Vote: iMuffin
if anyone knew me they would know i make many weird comments
I was probably investigated because at least two people believed/do believe/think that I am Mafia. I already said that's not the case, but pieguy seems to have checked up on me last night. Curiosity, perhaps?
Either way, i'm a townie, sorry Wojjie.
Either way, i'm a townie, sorry Wojjie.
iMuffiin, do you have any intention of actually playing this game?
this roleclaim only made me more suspicious :<pieguy1372 wrote:
roleclaim: Cop
Unfortunately, I haven't found any mafia yet. First night I checked Mashley and I couldn't complete my action, so perhaps we have a roleblocker in this game. Second night I checked E-Hooker and he's innocent.
Seeing as I'm almost dead, I practically have to do this.
Topic Starter
VOTE COUNT
pieguy1372 (3) - BakaloidSky, dkun, Quaraezha
BakaloidSky (1) - pieguy1372
iMuffin (1) - Kitsunemimi
Not Voting (5) - 0_o, Mashley, iMuffin, Wojjan, E-Hooker
WITH 10 ALIVE, IT TAKES 6 TO HAMMER.
pieguy1372 (3) - BakaloidSky, dkun, Quaraezha
BakaloidSky (1) - pieguy1372
iMuffin (1) - Kitsunemimi
Not Voting (5) - 0_o, Mashley, iMuffin, Wojjan, E-Hooker
WITH 10 ALIVE, IT TAKES 6 TO HAMMER.
Upon further consideration I'm going to Vote iMuffin... he's just refusing to participate in the game at all.
Or you're providing a logical reason for pieguy to have checked you instead of pie himself, and he's not a cop.E-Hooker wrote:
I was probably investigated because at least two people believed/do believe/think that I am Mafia. I already said that's not the case, but pieguy seems to have checked up on me last night. Curiosity, perhaps?
Either way, i'm a townie, sorry Wojjie.
I don't think that's the case, but it's a possibility.
Meh.
I'm just kind of beginning to get pissed, some people are barely playing which isn't helpful at all.
don't sign up if you're not going to give a shit [there's a difference between being inactive and just passively lazing around].
Just sayin'.
Wojjie: I don't quite follow...do you still think i'm Mafia? I'm pretty sure you think pie isn't the cop, at least.
I'm just kind of beginning to get pissed, some people are barely playing which isn't helpful at all.
don't sign up if you're not going to give a shit [there's a difference between being inactive and just passively lazing around].
Just sayin'.
Wojjie: I don't quite follow...do you still think i'm Mafia? I'm pretty sure you think pie isn't the cop, at least.
Ah, I see.
I'm not going to vote at all during this day unless I see something solid against somebody.
I'm not going to vote at all during this day unless I see something solid against somebody.
I'm not participating? k maybe instead i should throw together poorly worded excuses that make me seem more suspicious than the other way around. inb4 people claim this makes me suspicious.Mashley wrote:
Upon further consideration I'm going to Vote iMuffin... he's just refusing to participate in the game at all.
Are you going to participate now?
I'll participate hardMashley wrote:
Are you going to participate now?
You'll have all night for that.Wojjan wrote:
I really just want to kill him.
Thing is I'm not sure how wise lynching someone based on inactivity is in a potential lylo situation..
At this point I'm more in favor of a no-lynch since there's an even number of players. An extra round of night actions may be useful.
if we lynched for inactivities i shouldn't really be the only one on the chopping block.0_o wrote:
You'll have all night for that.Wojjan wrote:
I really just want to kill him.
Thing is I'm not sure how wise lynching someone based on inactivity is in a potential lylo situation..
At this point I'm more in favor of a no-lynch since there's an even number of players. An extra round of night actions may be useful.
It's not inactivity I'm voting on, it's the complete vagueness of his posts and his determination not to get into any discussion. If you go through the thread more or less all his posts are bandwagon votes or, most recently, vague responses to me.0_o wrote:
Thing is I'm not sure how wise lynching someone based on inactivity is in a potential lylo situation..
I agree exactly.Mashley wrote:
It's not inactivity I'm voting on, it's the complete vagueness of his posts and his determination not to get into any discussion. If you go through the thread more or less all his posts are bandwagon votes or, most recently, vague responses to me.0_o wrote:
Thing is I'm not sure how wise lynching someone based on inactivity is in a potential lylo situation..
Nonetheless, I still say no-lynch is the way to go. If there are 4 mafioso then we can't afford a mislynch today as that would leave us tied 4:4 tomorrow, thus we would lose. On the other hand, if we no-lynch today then the auxes would get another round of night actions, as well as increase the odds of lynching a mafioso. (Chance that a random lynchee is a mafia today = 4/10; chance tomorrow after a no-lynch = 4/9) We really have nothing to lose by postponing the lynch.
Vote no lynch
Vote no lynch
How are you so certain that there's 4 mafia? :<0_o wrote:
Nonetheless, I still say no-lynch is the way to go. If there are 4 mafioso then we can't afford a mislynch today as that would leave us tied 4:4 tomorrow, thus we would lose. On the other hand, if we no-lynch today then the auxes would get another round of night actions, as well as increase the odds of lynching a mafioso. (Chance that a random lynchee is a mafia today = 4/10; chance tomorrow after a no-lynch = 4/9) We really have nothing to lose by postponing the lynch.
Vote no lynch
If you're wrong, we'll certainly lose an innocent overnight, while there was originally still room for error. In my opinion, it's not too hard to nail the Mafia by taking educated votes, we can't just sit around and let some people get killed until the odds are greater.
It's a game of "Do I chicken out or do I keep on?"Kitsunemimi wrote:
How are you so certain that there's 4 mafia? :<0_o wrote:
Nonetheless, I still say no-lynch is the way to go. If there are 4 mafioso then we can't afford a mislynch today as that would leave us tied 4:4 tomorrow, thus we would lose. On the other hand, if we no-lynch today then the auxes would get another round of night actions, as well as increase the odds of lynching a mafioso. (Chance that a random lynchee is a mafia today = 4/10; chance tomorrow after a no-lynch = 4/9) We really have nothing to lose by postponing the lynch.
Vote no lynch
If you're wrong, we'll certainly lose an innocent overnight, while there was originally still room for error. In my opinion, it's not too hard to nail the Mafia by taking educated votes, we can't just sit around and let some people get killed until the odds are greater.
Educated guesses seem the best at the moment, but in my standpoint, there's no one to vote for. I agree with faceman's approach, even if it's not the best way to go at it at the moment.
unvote
vote no lynch
I'm actually leaning towards there being 3 mafia, but I'm preparing for the worst case scenario. The townies need an odd number of players, so even if there are 3 mafia a no-lynch would still be beneficial since we would have to do it at SOME point.Kitsunemimi wrote:
How are you so certain that there's 4 mafia? :< If you're wrong, we'll certainly lose an innocent overnight, while there was originally still room for error.
In my opinion, it's not too hard to nail the Mafia by taking educated votesYou mean like our last two lynches? Sure there is skill in spotting the mafia, but there definitely IS luck involved and no matter how you look at it we have a better chance picking a mafia member out of 9 people than 10
we can't just sit around and let some people get killed until the odds are greater.An innocent is going be killed tomorrow whether we lynch someone or not. If there are 4 mafia then we only have one shot - a no lynch would only move us closer to the target before shooting.
unvote
vote no lynch
Good luck to those who has night actions
vote no lynch
Good luck to those who has night actions
The biggest problem with educated guesses, Harris, is that half the players haven't even been playing, iMuffin even explicitly stated he wasn't really paying attention.
You can't expect an educated guess when we have nothing to educate ourselves with.
Vote: no one
You can't expect an educated guess when we have nothing to educate ourselves with.
Vote: no one
No need to explain.
Vote: no lynch
Vote: no lynch
No lynch has been hammered. (if that's possible) Waiting for NoHitter to respond...
I think he mentioned he was away until the 30th, not sure.