show more
Noffy
Nomination Assessment Team
1,710 posts
Joined April 2012
Noffy
Trial & Error - Hoshizora Touhikou

When ranking Trial & Error's Hoshizora Touhikou, Shiguma and I ran into several issues

- two of the three slowdowns weren't timed in the full version (so the end of the song was completely off)
- only one of the two late piano notes were timed (this applies to the short version too)
- the bpms were doubled of what they should be, 152 sounded way too fast for the song even during the chorus, where snares properly landed on 2 and 4 if you put the bpm at 76 instead.


ranked map with fixed timing for full version ->
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/747331

osz with timing for short version ->
https://noff.s-ul.eu/xJrlbvFU


Trial & Error - DREAMING COLOR (Short Ver)

a map of this song ended up being dq'd because the offset provided was fairly off,
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/752435/discussion/-/generalAll#/408107

Trial & Error - Taiatari * Romance (Short Ver)

The end had to be adjusted slightly in the ranked version due to a guitar being a bit off,
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/796338#osu/1672217


the issues i mentioned for the short versions of the 2nd and 3rd songs i listed may apply to the full versions too, but I've not checked
Last edited by Noffy , edited 1 time in total.
Shmiklak
Elite Storyboarder
3,282 posts
Joined January 2015
Shmiklak
Some time before I wanted to map Moonlight Sonata Cranky Remix but timing there seemed really off so I couldn't map it. I guess you may check it
celerih
617 posts
Joined July 2014
celerih
When opening Emerald Waters from High Tea Music Vol. 4 I found that offset 148-150 was more accurate over the current offset of 160
tatatat
923 posts
Joined March 2015
tatatat
Hi again mister pishifat!
Cranky - Kirakira has incorrect bpm
TheKingHenry
1,665 posts
Joined October 2014
TheKingHenry
Rin - Lunatic set 09 ~ Faraway 380,000-Kilometer Voyage had some things as well.
Don't exactly remember what got changed, but in the process of pushing this Mentai's set forward some timing changes got done.
Noffy
Nomination Assessment Team
1,710 posts
Joined April 2012
Noffy
Circles (Piano Version) by KIRA is off by 1 bpm, it should be 141, not 140. the wrong bpm is causing the timing to be notably off as early as 15 seconds into the song
video offset should be more like -800 rather than -425, video is currently a bit late compared to the song (compare how it syncs to the youtube upload https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MLNIir9aoIE )

The offset for Magical Night by KIRA sounds early, like, super early. Like ~30ms early.

edit: also this isn't the right place probably but kankan dancin and sake beat are missing their japanese/unicode titles
Last edited by Noffy , edited 2 times in total.
Mirash
Nomination Assessment Team
707 posts
Joined June 2013
Mirash
update Cranky - Time Alter with timings from ranked set https://old.ppy.sh/s/847900
update Cranky - Crocus with timings from ranked set https://old.ppy.sh/s/847764
update Fractal Dreamers - With Every Wanderer's Breath with timings from ranked set https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1772879?m=0
also Wispx - Somewhere I'd Rather Be should have additional red line with 24983 offset for beats after to be timed correctly
Xinnoh
Elite Mapper
1,964 posts
Joined April 2014
Xinnoh
Happppy song is listed at 112 bpm, 224 fits better

libera me still has the wrong metadata
Noffy
Nomination Assessment Team
1,710 posts
Joined April 2012
Noffy
most of SOOOO's templates have meter issues

Sinnoh wrote:

Happppy song is listed at 112 bpm, 224 fits better

226, osz is 113 and the website says 112 for some reason

minus in the sun has the opposite problem, template says 218 but 109 is much more appropriate
in addition, the meter changes aren't timed
50056 - reset for meter
217395 - 7/4 meter here
263633 - 4/4 meter again
420512 - meter reset again
also the minus in the sun .osz mispells his name as SOOO instead of SOOOO ....


iiillluuuvvvUUU also has multiple meter issues, such as not noticing that a good portion of the song is in 3/4, and putting the first offset a beat late.

296,300,4,1,0,100,1,0
19796,300,4,1,0,100,1,0
77396,300,3,1,0,100,1,0
86096,300,3,1,0,100,1,0
94796,300,3,1,0,100,1,0
103196,300,4,1,0,100,1,0
105296,300,4,1,0,100,1,0
109796,300,4,1,0,100,1,0

Raven Haven - meter resets at 197998
also Raven Haven is missing it's japanese title, レイヴン・ヘイヴン which is prominently featured on both its nicovideo and youtube uploads as well as being how it's listed on the minus in the sun album. There's really no reason for it to be missing.

a decayed garden sinks into the isolated sea: over half the song is in 5/4 but it's timed using one 4/4 line...
71957 - 5/4 meter
103329 - 4/4
119015 - 5/4
197446 - 4/4
Last edited by Noffy , edited 12 times in total.
transcendental
160 posts
Joined September 2013
transcendental
Camellia - (The) Immortal Scream is timed at 150 but is almost certainly 149.5, with a metronome reset somewhere in the middle
jas
558 posts
Joined August 2016
jas
Camellia - Sulfide

first red line needs to be set one measure back, and second red line is unnecessary

Camellia feat. Nanahira - Usakick!

first red line fits better if set back by one measure
Asaiga
850 posts
Joined July 2013
Asaiga
Camellia - senpai, notice me

I believe the correct offset should be 775ms or so. The current one is 15~25ms early.
Pachiru
osu! Alumni
2,956 posts
Joined June 2013
Pachiru
SOOOO - iiillluuuvvvUUU

First offset is 276 instead of 296
axlcrius
5 posts
Joined July 2014
axlcrius
Not sure if this is the right place for this, but it is an issue with FA beatmap template.

Camellia - Energy Drinking musume fein-chan! (Camellia's MONSTERISTIC Dempa Machinegun Psystyle Remix)

File name becomes too long after you first try to save the map, because it tries to add (username)[diffname] in the file name. I googled and it said max file name length on windows is 260, anything longer causes you to get an error.

Your file directory might look like this:

c:/users/user/appdata/local/osu!/songs/Camellia - Energy Drinking musume fein-chan! (Camellia's MONSTERISTIC Dempa Machinegun Psystyle Remix)/Camellia - Energy Drinking musume fein-chan! (Camellia's MONSTERISTIC Dempa Machinegun Psystyle Remix)()[]

This directory is already 252 characters long, which only leaves 8 characters for your osu username and diff name.

The way I got around this was changing the song name to this:

Camellia - Energy Drinking musume fein-chan! (Camellia's MONSTERISTIC D.M.P Remix)

After that the file directory looks like this:

c:/users/user/appdata/local/osu!/songs/Camellia - Energy Drinking musume fein-chan! (Camellia's MONSTERISTIC D.M.P Remix)/Camellia - Energy Drinking musume fein-chan! (Camellia's MONSTERISTIC D.M.P.Remix)()[]

Now it's only 212 characters long, which leaves you more room for your username and diffname.
Last edited by axlcrius , edited 1 time in total.
Mirash
Nomination Assessment Team
707 posts
Joined June 2013
Mirash
tieff Sense of Nostalgia offset+9
tieff We Are The Gems named as "We Are The Gems 2" 2 is not needed, also offset+12
tieff that love so far away offset+9
tieff Sunflower offset+10
tieff Our Story offset+5
tieff Library Girl offset+5
tieff Dancing in Blue offset+10
tieff By Holding You Close I'm Pushing You Further offset+8
tieff and here am I, forgotten generally offset+15 but it also has some occasional missnaps and thats another talk
Lasse
osu! Alumni
3,648 posts
Joined June 2011
Lasse
Ben Briggs - Yes (Maybe) offset -10 (new offset = -20)
Ben Briggs - Fearless Living offset -17 (new offset = -21)
Thaehan - Angry Birds Epic (Remix) offset -20 (new offset = 336)
Last edited by Lasse , edited 1 time in total.
Yugu
Elite Mapper
1,006 posts
Joined August 2013
Yugu
Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - Ankoku no Joukaku ni Shinkousaru Igyou no Kuruhime

the beginning part sounds should be like this.
not sure about the 6/4 signature is correct or not.
timing
Peter
802 posts
Joined June 2016
Peter
I think Kuba Oms - Love is my Drug offset is too late by ~ 10ms

it can be heard on 00:20:160 for example
Seijiro
osu! Alumni
3,438 posts
Joined April 2013
Seijiro
Fractal Dreamers - Kingdom of Silence offset should be something around -26

Mapping the first note (which probably anyone would map unless they skip an entire section) is impossible right now.
Last edited by Seijiro , edited 1 time in total.
VINXIS
Featured Artist
3,161 posts
Joined April 2014
VINXIS
Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - Tinu rareta Syuren Ni Fukeru Homura
The 04:36:704 - timing point should be at 04:12:704 - instead
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/964134/discussion/2018512/timeline#/941167

there were also multiple timing changes done and multiple offset changes in general for the map too
Irreversible
osu! Alumni
4,317 posts
Joined December 2011
Irreversible
The Flashbulb - DIDJ PVC

The ending part needs to be timed.
vergil chair
357 posts
Joined April 2016
vergil chair
IAHN - Transform (Original Mix)

Needs about +17 to offset
xenal
537 posts
Joined August 2017
xenal
SOOOO - minus in the sun

https://osu.ppy.sh/community/forums/topics/783985?n=12 are still not adressed, including a metadata error.

Will also add the fact that the offset is way too late, seems much closer to 503 or something along thoses lines (-12)
Last edited by xenal , edited 1 time in total.
Ephemeral
Inland Empire
3,947 posts
Joined April 2009
Ephemeral
Applied the following updates as per pishifat:

Ben Briggs - Fearless Living.osz
Ben Briggs - Yes (Maybe).osz
Camellia - (The) Immortal Scream.osz
Camellia - Energy Drinking Musume Fein-chan! (Camellia's MONSTERISTIC D. M. P. Remix).osz
Camellia - Sulfide.osz
Camellia feat. Nanahira - senpai, notice me!.osz
Camellia feat. Nanahira - Usakick!.osz
Cranky - Crocus.osz
Cranky - Libera me.osz
Cranky - Time Alter.osz
Fractal Dreamers - Kingdom of Silence.osz
Fractal Dreamers - With Every Wanderer's Breath.osz
IAHN - Transform (Original Mix).osz
Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - Ankoku No Jyoukaku Ni Shinkou Saru Igyou No Kyouki.osz
Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - Tinu rareta Syuren Ni Fukeru Homura.osz
KIRA - Circles (Piano Version) (feat. GUMI).osz
KIRA - Magical Night (feat. Hatsune Miku).osz
Kuba Oms - Love is my Drug.osz
L. V. Beethoven - Moonlight Sonata (Cranky Remix).osz
SOOOO - a decayed garden sinks into the isolated sea.osz
SOOOO - Happppy song.osz
SOOOO - iiillluuuvvvUUU.osz
SOOOO - minus in the sun.osz
SOOOO - Raven Haven.osz
Thaehan - Angry Birds Epic (Remix).osz
The Flashbulb - DIDJ PVC.osz
tieff - and here am I, forgotten.osz
tieff - By Holding You Close I'm Pushing You Further.osz
tieff - Dancing in Blue.osz
tieff - Library Girl.osz
tieff - Our Story.osz
tieff - Sense of Nostalgia.osz
tieff - Sunflower.osz
tieff - that love so far away.osz
tieff - We Are The Gems.osz
Trial & Error - DREAMING COLOR (Short ver.).osz
Trial & Error - Hoshizora Touhikou feat. Hatsune Miku (Short Ver.).osz
Trial & Error - Hoshizora Touhikou feat. Hatsune Miku.osz
Wisp X - Somewhere I'd Rather Be.osz


Most of these are marked with the ?20190510 timestamp on the end of their files.
xenal
537 posts
Joined August 2017
xenal
SOOOO - Happppy song and
SOOOO - minus in the sun
The website does not match their new bpm from this update, still showing their old.
DeletedUser_6637817
DeletedUser_6637817
BilliumMoto - Rocky Buinne (Short Ver.)

There should be an extra 120 BPM uninherited point placed at 171725ms

The piano is slightly variable here but 120bpm is a good catch-all option without overcomplicating it, to be fair. Let your guys check over that in case of doubt!

Edit: HDHR also has an unrankable source, it should be only "osu!", "osu!remix contest" by no means is rankable as a source
Last edited by DeletedUser_6637817 , edited 1 time in total.
Pachiru
osu! Alumni
2,956 posts
Joined June 2013
Pachiru
The Flashbulb - DIDJ PVC

There is a missing 160 BPM timing point at 70154ms.
MBomb
MBomb
The Flashbulb - You Take The World's Weight Away

Intro is quite a bit more complex than the current .osz has, I did more accurate timing on it before we got Mismagius' set.
Cynplytholowazy
364 posts
Joined January 2014
Cynplytholowazy
UNDEAD CORPORATION - Death is just the beginning

Offset should be +15 (2136 -> 2151) since the current one is a bit too early.
Last edited by Cynplytholowazy , edited 1 time in total.
Baron
35 posts
Joined May 2017
Baron
"Under the scarlet sky pt. 1" - Undead Corporation

Sounds about 40ms too early
Last edited by Baron , edited 1 time in total.
-MysticEyes
Beatmap Nominator
490 posts
Joined April 2015
-MysticEyes
Camellia - In Black and White

Offset should be +22 (198 instead of 176). The current one sounds too early

Additionally the title should be "In Black & White" (source). Not entirely sure where I should put this but I just wanted to mention that
Last edited by -MysticEyes , edited 2 times in total.
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
Camellia's [diffraction] current timing feels a bit too early, +10-15ms would be better imo
Last edited by SaltyLucario , edited 2 times in total.
Usernametwo
75 posts
Joined January 2013
Usernametwo
KNOWER - Die Right Now has a separate timing section in the dubstep part at the end that's 176 bpm (just 1 bpm higher than the rest of the song);
in the template there's only 1 timing point at the start, which is incorrect.

As a reference, here's an old map I did of it.
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/1035294#osu/2164539

should be at 191476ms in the template's mp3.
Last edited by Usernametwo , edited 7 times in total.
oyu
480 posts
Joined March 2019
oyu
Camellia - Present (feat. Tsuko & Nanahira)
offset should be 1192
Last edited by oyu , edited 2 times in total.
daze16
68 posts
Joined April 2019
daze16
Aether Realm - One Chosen by the Gods

Timing starts to lag starting at 265,282, up until the 145 BPM timing point.

I got it working with a somewhat suspect BPM timing point (124.8 BPM?):

http://prntscr.com/p6lowf
Last edited by daze16 , edited 1 time in total.
Coppertine
126 posts
Joined October 2015
Coppertine
Camellia - We Could Get More Machinegun Psystyle! (And More Genre Switches)

There are found to be one speed up to 320bpm and a slow down to 32bpm
In the featured artist current timing, there doens't seem to be a speed up or slow down found in those sections.
Thanks to Sheepcraft's map, I think this could be the right timing.

Speed up Timing

49478,375,4,2,0,75,1,0
49843,333.333333333333,4,2,0,75,1,0
50176,307.692307692308,4,2,0,75,1,0
50483,285.714285714286,4,2,0,75,1,0
50768,279.06976744186,4,2,0,75,1,0
51047,272.727272727273,4,2,0,75,1,0
51319,255.31914893617,4,2,0,75,1,0
51574,240,4,2,0,75,1,0
51814,228.136882129278,4,2,0,75,1,0
52042,222.222222222222,4,2,0,75,1,0
52264,218.181818181818,4,2,0,75,1,0
52482,214.285714285714,4,2,0,75,1,0
52696,206.896551724138,4,2,0,75,1,0
52902,200,4,2,0,75,1,0
53102,193.548387096774,4,2,0,75,1,0
53295,187.5,4,2,0,75,1,0


Slow down Timing

224482,375,4,2,0,75,1,0
224857,400,4,2,0,75,1,0
225257,413.793103448276,4,2,0,75,1,0
225670,422.535211267606,4,2,0,75,1,0
226092,444.444444444444,4,2,0,75,1,0
226536,454.545454545455,4,2,0,75,1,0
226990,480,4,2,0,75,1,0
227470,500,4,2,0,75,1,0
227970,530.973451327434,4,2,0,75,1,0
228500,571.428571428571,4,2,0,75,1,0
229071,625,4,2,0,75,1,0
229696,666.666666666667,4,2,0,75,1,0
230362,749.999999999999,4,2,0,75,1,0
230737,769.230769230768,4,2,0,75,1,0
231121,810.81081081081,4,2,0,75,1,0
231526,845.07042253521,4,2,0,70,1,0
231737,937.499999999999,4,2,0,65,1,0
231971,983.606557377048,4,2,0,60,1,0
232216,1034.48275862069,4,2,0,55,1,0
232474,1111.11111111111,4,2,0,50,1,0
232751,1153.84615384615,4,2,0,45,1,0
233039,1237.11340206186,4,2,0,40,1,0
233345,1333.33333333333,4,2,0,35,1,0
233678,1500,4,2,0,30,1,0
234053,1714.28571428571,4,2,0,25,1,0
234481,1846.15384615385,4,2,0,20,1,0
234942,1875,4,2,0,15,1,0


Dictate - Oddity

Found out there's a signature change at 336022 to 4/4. (8/4 would do the same but intended effect)
Last edited by Coppertine , edited 2 times in total.
Furryswan
Beatmap Nominator
326 posts
Joined January 2017
Furryswan
Camellia - WHAT THE CAT!?

Offset should be 992. The current one sounds too early and this stands out clearly after 02:15:392 -
Last edited by Furryswan , edited 3 times in total.
Furryswan
Beatmap Nominator
326 posts
Joined January 2017
Furryswan
Camellia vs. Akira Complex - Railgun Roulette

Offset should be 170 (162 + 8) The current one sounds a bit early. This stands out after 03:00:638 - .
MBomb
MBomb
KIRA - Circles (Piano Version) ft. GUMI

Video offset is 0.4-0.5 seconds off. I was given -900 as a better offset, however that may need closer checking (My laptop can't run editor with videos so I can't tell myself).
Wanpachi
Elite Nominator
832 posts
Joined April 2018
Wanpachi
nekodex - aureole

BPM at the moment is 140. 70 fits the song more and matches the current ranked set.
FAMoss
osu! Alumni
1,175 posts
Joined January 2016
FAMoss
Native Construct - Come Hell or High Water seems has unnecessary a red line at 02:16:040 -
Explaination is HERE
Xinnoh
Elite Mapper
1,964 posts
Joined April 2014
Xinnoh
Camellia - Animal Rando (feat. Nanahira)
Animal Land is correct title
-Aku
268 posts
Joined May 2018
-Aku
Metadata mistake on Native Construct's Chromatic Aberration. In the template it's Chromatic Abberation: https://imgur-archive.ppy.sh/discord/469678589579624449-673836829627121664-unknown.png
Furryswan
Beatmap Nominator
326 posts
Joined January 2017
Furryswan
Camellia - illegal trap
The offset should be 1,991 ( 1. Offset: 1,991 ms BPM: 160.00 )

The current one sounds a bit early. This stands out clearly after 02:49:991 -
Last edited by Furryswan , edited 1 time in total.
xenal
537 posts
Joined August 2017
xenal
Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - Yomi yori Kikoyu, Koukoku No Hi To Honoo No Syoujo. (Orchestral Ver.)

Because of the length, windows allow only 7 charcters for the dif name and the mapper name (which is added to the .osu file name). This cause an not so easy to understand error for new mappers and force almost everybody to shorten the title. Can this be officially shorten?


Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - Fushoku Resentment, Fushi Yoku no Sarugakuza. (Orchestral Ver.)
Is also very long, giving only 13 characters.
Last edited by xenal , edited 3 times in total.
Usernametwo
75 posts
Joined January 2013
Usernametwo
Leaf - Poison AND/OR Affection
In the (non-romanized) title, there's two invalid/invisible characters between the last letter of AND and the division sign.
Raiden
osu! Alumni
2,419 posts
Joined January 2013
Raiden
Venetian Snares - Frictional Nevada

offset needs at least +20ms, current timing is early

Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - BRING+EYES=DEATH+INVITE

ending has signature shifts between 6/4 and 4/4 that are currently not timed
also post 2nd kiai

also Shuhei's drumming is very inconsistent, so the entire map needs a re-time. I'm currently working on it. Done: https://pastebin.com/rJwAfMeQ. These seem to be the most accurate as of now, will keep doing tests as I finish the map. For reference: https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/1132374#taiko/2365266

The timing provided above contains extra uninherited timing points to account for bar line omission in the osu!taiko game mode.

Updated as of 26/03/2020 20:48 UTC+1

Rivers of Nihil - Hollow

first offset is a little early, the signature resets give rounding errors and timing starts drifting early. Needs something like this (https://i.imgur.com/FS4FL0t.png):

00:00:218 - +4ms
00:51:909 - +8ms
01:14:063 - +7ms
02:13:140 - +6ms
02:33:909 - +13ms
04:44:062 - +18ms
Last edited by Raiden , edited 10 times in total.
pishifat
osu! Paragon
3,817 posts
Joined August 2013
Topic Starter
pishifat

Usernametwo wrote:

Leaf - Poison AND/OR Affection
In the (non-romanized) title, there's two invalid/invisible characters between the last letter of AND and the division sign.

any chance you could explain this one? i dont see it
ts8zs
2,124 posts
Joined May 2011
ts8zs
F-777 - He's a Pirate (Remix)
Timing maybe
1. Offset: 172ms BPM: 150.00
F-777 - 1up
1. Offset: 160ms BPM: 133.00
Last edited by ts8zs , edited 5 times in total.
Usernametwo
75 posts
Joined January 2013
Usernametwo

pishifat wrote:

any chance you could explain this one? i dont see it


Copy and pasting the title onto the site's text editor will look like this:

it doesn't show at all on the main font, nor does it show in the beatmap editor's song setup box. but it's there.

Ingame, it looks like this:

if you have the "prefer metadata in original language" option checked.
Last edited by Usernametwo , edited 8 times in total.
huu
1,246 posts
Joined February 2015
huu
Ben Briggs - Game Boy Color Envy

The current way it's set up has the offset at -12. With the current implementation, it requires either changing the mp3 or mistiming a couple of objects & resetting the metronome via additional red ticks to map the song properly, as the editor does not allow you to map objects to negative timing.
Daycore
Beatmap Nominator
959 posts
Joined January 2015
Daycore
Loki - With Fire and Sword (2013)

• An issue with first redline: beatmapsets/963872/discussion/-/generalAll#/1064095

There are two ranked maps for this song and both with only one redline.
GoldenWolf
2,983 posts
Joined May 2012
GoldenWolf
Thank You Scientist - Stranger Heads Prevail

.osz files: https://gowo.s-ul.eu/2aypM7OE

Timing checked the album, in short:
-Mostly a lot of minor offset/bpm changes because variable timing, mainly some ~+15ms because this was timed earlier this year on audio compatibility

-Some time signature changes here and there, most notably Rube Goldberg Variations & The Somnambulist going from 3/4 → 6/4, as it seems to fit better I think, but mostly tried to handle barlines properly for Taiko & Mania mapping

-Removed dupe .mp3 file for The Somnambulist
Davvy
osu! Alumni
90 posts
Joined April 2017
Davvy
I will do the entire timing of Terraformer in 3 sittings, with 4 songs each sitting and split this post up in 3 parts according to the sittings. So here's part 1 of my Terraformer timing adjustments.

Wrinkle was relatively easy, however there was one spot where the drums came in later than the measure line indicated, around 20-30 ms later and I fixed that accordingly. Were also a few spots with slightly variable timing but nothing big. I also fixed the slowdown and timed the saxophone solo at the end.

FXMDLR was fixed in some parts, variable in some others. Interesting to note is that it becomes mostly variable when there's just instruments playing and no vocals, some slower sections are also variable. The most variable part was a short drum lick before the chorus picked up again, so nothing major in this one.

In Son of a Serpent I timed the instrumental intro, since it had a swing feel I adjusted the bpm to be equivalent to 1/3 instead of 1/4, but didn't do it in the section when the vocals entered as that is where a stable drum beat enters, so it may or may not be a weird change. Here I also fixed a few timing signatures, for example a place with 5/4. Also one section where the time signature is inconsistent, with the same musical section switching from 3/4 to 6/4 out of nowhere, when it actually should be 6/4 throughout barring some additional time signatures. The guitar solo and many buildups (which seems to be a common theme in Thank You Scientist) were extremely variable and were way too simplified in its current timing.

Lastly I timed Geronimo, which was probably the toughest of them all, since only 2 sections seemed stable. Because of the unstable nature of this song, many offsets were also really wrong, and because it was simplified so much it is noticable even on 100% how inaccurate some places were. Otherwise not much to say about this song other than it was very hard to time well enough.

Link to the .osz (some have my name in them for some reason, dunno why)
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YXSITrkBXR7um7DvuJ_tCzbuZtifFyhe/view?usp=sharing
Pachiru
osu! Alumni
2,956 posts
Joined June 2013
Pachiru
IAHN - Welcome (original mix)

Offset is originally set to 0 but the accurate one should be -19.
Jason X
1,233 posts
Joined July 2013
Jason X
Yuyoyuppe - Emerald Galaxy (Featured under MOtOLOiD)

I noticed The Bpm too be off, here is what I think should be changed


00:18:277 - Wrong bpm, should be 160bpm
00:30:277 - Missing point, 200bpm
02:05:933 - Wrong bpm, should be 200bpm
02:44:333 - Wrong bpm, should be 160bpm
02:58:046 - Missing point, should be 140bpm
Offset for new (missing) points might be off!

Went to #help first (didn't know this forum was a thing), here is what I got there
Greenshell
Beatmap Nominator
329 posts
Joined July 2016
Greenshell
Ariabl'eyeS - Lament

all timing points +5

02:47:216 - missing 3/4 signature
02:56:983 - back to 4/4
Zoe
149 posts
Joined June 2011
Zoe
yuki. - Nadeshiko Sensation - Incorrect offset

Should be around 1181 to 1186 as per other ranked maps that had this issue.
McEndu
1,266 posts
Joined March 2019
McEndu
Camellia - NIGHTMARE CITY (from Blackmagik Blazing)

Seems to have variable BPM; Current timing only make sense from 00:41:316 (+-1ms) onwards.
Last edited by McEndu , edited 1 time in total.
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
Camellia - は～とび～と♥お～ば～ひ～～～～と！！！！
romanised title currently ignores the ranking criteria rule, which says "Loan words from other languages have to use the original words in their stead when attempting to romanise them."

so instead of "Wa~tobi~to o~ba~hi~~~~to!!!!", romanised title should be "He~artbe~at O~ver~he~~~~at!!!!" or "Hea~rtbea~t O~ver~hea~~~~t!!!!", depending on how you look at it (choose the one that makes more sense in english, im not a native speaker, i think first one feels more natural tho)

something like "Heeartbeeat Ooveerheeeeat!!!!" (or "Heaartbeaat Ooverheaaaat!!!!", also depending on how you look at it) could work to i guess, but omitting of "~" isn't something we would do on osu so yea prob first option is better - the important fact is that current one is wrong

even if not, "は" is still wrongly romanised as "wa" instead of "ha" - it gets romanised to "wa" only when used as a particle

//EDIT: what i also noticed right now, shouldn't "Bassline Yatteru lol" be changed to "Bassline Yatteru? w" ? we already have two ranked mapsets under that romanisation so imo would make for sense to follow it, especially when both versions are equally correct
even if not, the fa page is still missing the question mark
Last edited by SaltyLucario , edited 5 times in total.
Juuuuuuuuul
1,283 posts
Joined March 2018
Juuuuuuuuul
Helblinde - Memoria Reborn

Wrong offset, it's not 0.
Jonarwhal
1,227 posts
Joined November 2013
Jonarwhal
dark cat - CRAZY MILK 2
offset should be increased by 10
this was discussed here

thank u!
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
Silentroom - garland saga
BPM should be 130 with 4/4 signature instead of 195 with 3/4, as overall structure of the song fits more the 1/3 divisor, and some parts (like 0:59) are clearly 130 bpm (confirmed this with a BN as well)

edit: fa page on osu site still missing a question mark in Bassline Yatteru for some reason
Last edited by SaltyLucario , edited 2 times in total.
Giai tich 2
150 posts
Joined November 2016
Giai tich 2
beatmaps/artists/23
In Cranky's page, album RECORD5-SPEED, Ten no Jagi (天ノ邪鬼) should be Amanojaku.
Last edited by Giai tich 2 , edited 9 times in total.
gummibar
92 posts
Joined January 2016
gummibar
The Flashbulb - Passage D

the default timing is really, really weird at 01:16:154. like, really, really weird. i'm no timing whiz but it's not right at all. here is what i think it should actually look like. this took a tremendous deal of effort on my part.
look on my works, ye mighty, and despair!
155,333.333333333333,4,1,0,100,1,0

i could go on at length about how precisely and yet horribly incorrect the original timing is, but i keep stopping myself because its doesn't warrant a tirade in the slightest. seriously i've typed out and erased around 10 sentences making fun of it. i find this so funny. to balance that out, thank you so much for all of the effort you put into making this game amazing. it may not have even been you who made this, but damn. i've got to say something. <3

(21/11/2020: i'm not sure when this got fixed but it's already been fixed. neat!)
Last edited by gummibar , edited 1 time in total.
Tycani
486 posts
Joined July 2015
Tycani
UNDEAD CORPORATION - Yoru Naku Usagi wa Yume wo Miru

Small little missed thing here.
02:03:656 - 02:18:056 should be 3/4 -- and then go back to 4/4 afterwards.
Roasted Chicken
264 posts
Joined December 2016
Roasted Chicken
cYsmix - Classic Pursuit

mp3 bitrate averages 224kbps, I was told that this is unrankable even if it's on the FA listing

EDIT: I checked the other mp3s in the album and non are 224kbps, this is the only one
Last edited by Roasted Chicken , edited 1 time in total.
gummibar
92 posts
Joined January 2016
gummibar
many of SOOOO's songs have absolutely gigantic file sizes. every one except for Ruins in the Paradise and NORMAL HUMAN are massive for their length. minus in the sun is nearly 70mb - Aether Realm's The Sun The Moon The Star, nearly three times longer, nearly isn't even a third of the size, only being 26mb total. Something is massively wrong here, likely just an issue of audio quality being too high.

oh lmao it has a video nvm
Last edited by gummibar , edited 1 time in total.
McEndu
1,266 posts
Joined March 2019
McEndu
HyuN feat. Syepias - Cross Soul

Title in template file is not consistent in casing with title on the listing, aside from missing a dagger in UnicodeTitle.
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
not exactly related to templates, but description of aether realm says "19-minute collaboration map made by ItsWinter (now known as SILENCE PLAYER) and Ghouru"
mapper of that set reverted his nickname back to ItsWinter so you probably should delete the SILENCE PLAYER part
duski
192 posts
Joined May 2015
duski
hey, as i've been mapping plenty of Omoi lately, i stumbled upon something wrong, probably just outdated:

on the album "Night Confession" on the Omoi FA listing, there's a song called "Miracle", but when listening to the album on for example Spotify, this song was split into two songs - the intro is separated into a new song called "On Your Marks" and the rest of the song is still called "Miracle" - but it's literally the song "Kiseki Saemo" (which was released earlier as a single) but with a new name, which is "Miracle"

additionally, i verified that "Miracle" on album "Night Confession" is literally identical to "Kiseki Saemo" on single "Kiseki Saemo" so it's not like a new version or anything, just same song but new title

so i suppose the fix would be that the Omoi FA listing should update the album "Night Confession" and then i think due to being redundant, "Kiseki Saemo" could be removed (since it'd already be on the listing when the album is updated on FA listing)
Last edited by duski , edited 1 time in total.
Zelzatter Zero
4,031 posts
Joined October 2016
Zelzatter Zero
Se-U-Ra - 望影の方舟Six

The artist themselves have confirmed that the 望影 isn't "Mochi Kage", it's actually "Houyou".

Source: https://twitter.com/SeURa_Nue/status/1052730062074605569

So the actual romanization is "Houyou no Hakobune Six", not "Mochi Kage no Hakobune Six".
Hoshikuz
1,283 posts
Joined March 2017
Hoshikuz
polysha - Kyou ga Owaru Toki made-coda-

RC says,

Ranking Criteria wrote:

Artist names are to be romanised in the order they are printed in the unicode fields.
The romanised artist should be 'polysha feat. Takanashi Megumi', not 'polysha feat. Megumi Takanashi'
Last edited by Hoshikuz , edited 1 time in total.
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
another not exactly template related issue, but all albums on ne obliviscaris page have the same cover despite each having their own so it prob should be fixed ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Last edited by SaltyLucario , edited 1 time in total.
McEndu
1,266 posts
Joined March 2019
McEndu
siromaru + cranky - conflict (listed as Cranky - Conflict)

There are two problems with this.
  1. The title is capitalized, but in other rhythm games the title is all lowercase. Also in all above linked sources the artist field is "siromaru + cranky"; Here siromaru is missing.
  2. There is a section of 7/4 signature, not reflected in the template timing. This is less a problem for non-scrolling rulesets or without barlines.
Here is a proposed solution:
osu file format v14

[General]
AudioFilename: audio.mp3
AudioLeadIn: 0
Countdown: 0
SampleSet: Soft
StackLeniency: 0.7
LetterboxInBreaks: 0
SpecialStyle: 0
WidescreenStoryboard: 1

[Metadata]
Title:conflict
TitleUnicode:conflict
Artist:siromaru + cranky
ArtistUnicode:siromaru + cranky
Creator:
Version:
Source:
Tags:featured artist fa
BeatmapID:0
BeatmapSetID:-1

[Events]
//Background and Video events
//Break Periods
//Storyboard Layer 0 (Background)
//Storyboard Layer 1 (Fail)
//Storyboard Layer 2 (Pass)
//Storyboard Layer 3 (Foreground)
//Storyboard Layer 4 (Overlay)
//Storyboard Sound Samples

[TimingPoints]
2986,375,4,2,0,0,1,0
86986,375,7,2,0,0,1,0
115861,375,4,2,0,0,1,0

The relevant entry name on the website should be renamed according to current conventions.
Last edited by McEndu , edited 4 times in total.
FAMoss
osu! Alumni
1,175 posts
Joined January 2016
FAMoss
title of HyuN - ENCOUNTER should be Encounter
according to offical site metadata https://xencount.com/sp/psyency_sorcerer/
Last edited by FAMoss , edited 1 time in total.
Tycani
486 posts
Joined July 2015
Tycani
Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - Uta seems to have volume and sampleset changes in its red lines, for some reason.
Last edited by Tycani , edited 1 time in total.
Zelzatter Zero
4,031 posts
Joined October 2016
Zelzatter Zero
Camellia - love yiff!

basically the title in the list and the template wrote it as "live" instead of "love"
FAMoss
osu! Alumni
1,175 posts
Joined January 2016
FAMoss
additional red lines on Diceros Bicornis - Siva is unused and should simplified
at 01:47:268 - should being 3/4, and end at 02:00:003 - as 4/4

the new overall timing
8778,283.018867924529,4,2,1,60,1,0
107268,283.018867924529,3,2,1,60,1,0
120003,283.018867924528,4,2,1,60,1,0
Last edited by FAMoss , edited 1 time in total.
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
fairly sure 1:31 onwards on MYUKKE. - Ginevra should be 255bpm 3/4 - currently synth just doesn't match up with 1/3 snapping as its 2+2 grouping instead of 1+3 (also from 1:43 there's clearly 255bpm beat)
McEndu
1,266 posts
Joined March 2019
McEndu
Getty vs DJ DiA - Grayed Out -Antifront- (Extended Mix)

Missing a space between grayed and out
SilentWuffer
293 posts
Joined December 2017
SilentWuffer

SaltyLucario wrote:

fairly sure 1:31 onwards on MYUKKE. - Ginevra should be 255bpm 3/4 - currently synth just doesn't match up with 1/3 snapping as its 2+2 grouping instead of 1+3 (also from 1:43 there's clearly 255bpm beat)
Well fuck the mbc this month then
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
UNDEAD CORPORATION - 百鬼夜行: wrong romanisation (should be Hyakki Yakou), see beatmapsets/1266306/discussion/-/generalAll#/2347366
from what i saw there was also provided a better quality audio to whats in the template
Last edited by SaltyLucario , edited 1 time in total.
[Ping]
499 posts
Joined April 2015
[Ping]
Inaccurate metadata issue on "WONDERLAND TRAVELERS" album of Yu_Asahina


I'm not entirely sure on this, but going by Twitter and Album sites, the following song should be written as follow:

Original Artist - Title: Yu_Asahina+ぺのれり - ロマンシングフィクションライフ！(twiples ver.) feat. みかん汁
Romanized Artist - Title: Yu_Asahina+penoreri - Romancing Fiction Life! (twiples ver.) feat. mikanzil

Changes are as follow

  1. add penoreri to the artist
    (penoreri composed and made the lyrics while Yu_Asahina arranged and mikanzil sang it)
  2. change romanization of Mikanjiru to mikanzil
    (source: Their Twitter)
  3. change "Romance" to "Romancing" as because the original katakana is 「ロマンシング」and not 「ロマンス」
-----------------------
Other nitpicky changes

  1. Bienvenue ～アパルトマンへようこそ～ feat. 後藤ハルキ
    (half-width space between feat. and co-artist for standardization in osu!)
  2. Glittering City Drop feat. Citrus and Ocean Colour
    (same as above, space between feat. and co-artist)
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
Pratanallis - 恋哀Fantasy

"恋哀" should be romanised as "Ren'ai" instead of "Renai" - 恋 reads as Ren and 哀 reads as Ai, so to distinguish the spelling you seperate the syllables with apostrophe (Renai would be correct if readings were Re+Nai for example)
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
Camellia's put' l'da is featured two times for some reason? (once as put' l'da, once as Ice Path). there should be only one ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ (template with Ice Path should be deleted as we already have ranked sets with put' l'da - and next sets will have to follow that according to RC)
Iceluin
215 posts
Joined November 2013
Iceluin
Metadata looks to be inaccurate in comparison to official sources for Pratanallis - Braking Down

Artist: Pratanallis feat. きょーこ
Romanised Artist: Pratanallis feat. Kyohko

Under Romanised Artist, shouldn't it be romanised as 'Pratanallis feat. Kyoko' instead?
Kyoko's twitter handle -> https://imgur.com/a/Cod9F2Y has it romanised like this, her webpage http://mumeria.web.fc2.com/ also romanises it like this -> https://imgur.com/a/HTAMlxa and her NicoNico profile which has her email romanises it like this -> https://imgur.com/a/v8AdaMh
I coudn't really find any sources dictating that "きょーこ" should be romanised as 'Kyohko'.

*Edit
Don't even think it should have 'feat. kyoko' at all and it's enough that the name is in tags.
Last edited by Iceluin , edited 1 time in total.
SaltyLucario
1,326 posts
Joined June 2015
SaltyLucario
Imperial Circus Dead Decadence - 邪神の婚礼、儀は愛と知る。
Title incorrectly romanised - should be "Jashin no Konrei, Gi wa Ai to Shiru." instead of "Jashin no Konrei, Giha Ai to Shiru" (particle incorrectly combined with a word and missing the dot at the end)
Last edited by SaltyLucario , edited 2 times in total.
Nyariri
81 posts
Joined October 2019
Nyariri
Usakick! (feat. Nanahira) - Camellia

03:19:946 timing point at this time is not necessary

03:16:490 and why remains a note in FA map templates
[Ping]
499 posts
Joined April 2015
[Ping]
Issue on the English Title of Se-U-Ra's "エリフィと白昏の夜 -Called-":

In the BMS Event Site (which was linked by Se-U-Ra's SoundCloud),
there is a hiragana to help read the song's name: "えりふぃとしろがれのよる" - which reads as "Elifi to Shirogare no Yoru"

The reason it is "Shirogare" and not "Shiro Gare" is because "昏" is normally only pronounced as "gare" when used as "黄昏 Tasogare" (which is likely what the artist is referencing) - see This kanji site (sorry that it's full Japanese. I can't find English friendly site)

Now we know later that "エリフィ" or "Elifi" part should be "Elif" from the album "Tree Called Elif" - here's the crossfade uploaded on Soundcloud

So, this song should be "Elif to Shirogare no Yoru -Called-"
Last edited by [Ping] , edited 2 times in total.
too
707 posts
Joined May 2018
too
ToYou & DJ Raisei - ADHD

bpm timing stuff

01:26:579 - We're at 160 bpm from here.
02:35:579 - The bpm is gradually getting faster from this point.

Red line that I think
1379,300,4,2,0,100,1,0
86579,375,4,2,0,100,1,0
155579,363.636363636364,4,2,0,100,1,0
157033,352.941176470589,4,2,0,100,1,0
158444,342.857142857144,4,2,0,100,1,0
159815,333.333333333334,4,2,0,100,1,0
161148,320.000000000001,4,2,0,100,1,0
162428,307.692307692308,4,2,0,100,1,0
164889,300,4,2,0,100,1,0
Jason X
1,233 posts
Joined July 2013
Jason X
Emille's Moonlight Serenade

Slain;Fate
- Downloadable file is missing .osz ending
(Downloads as a plain file, but works when renamed with .osz ending)
http://puu.sh/IgMJc/125dc7a9b3.png
arbiter of soup
13 posts
Joined May 2018
arbiter of soup
Vektor - Collapse

FA page shows the song length as 7:27, when the MP3 and official sources are 9:22
Usernametwo
75 posts
Joined January 2013
Usernametwo
Natsume Itsuki - Miracle Showtime

The timing on the template is at constant 220 BPM, but there's a portion of the song that slows down at around 3 minutes.

edit: I think the added timing points should be 204 @ 178341, then back to 220 @ 201870.
Last edited by Usernametwo , edited 3 times in total.
Civafu
38 posts
Joined November 2018
Civafu
KINEMA106

MP3s include a ~5MB cover art which doubles most of the mp3's size (easily removable using foobar2000 for example but will take some time for all of them)

I think all osz have the same issue, or at least I didn't find one without that issue but didn't look through all of them
sxnshine2020
237 posts
Joined September 2020
sxnshine2020
Rabbit In The Black Room - Rabbit House

-Original BPM is 270, not 135 (According to Arcaea).
[Ping]
499 posts
Joined April 2015
[Ping]
MisomyL - Mukishitsu Sekai ni Irudori o (無機質世界に彩を) - the romanization title seems to be incorrect:

彩 can be pronounced "Aya", "Sai", "Irodo(ru)" but never "Irudori". I think it is a typo and should actually be "Irodori" based on these two links: https://jisho.org/search/%E5%BD%A9# , https://jisho.org/word/%E5%BD%A9%E3%82%8A .

If possible, the best way is to discuss it directly with an artist on what they actually meant (but it is most likely not the current romanization "Irudori").
Mocaotic
Beatmap Nominator
735 posts
Joined December 2016
Mocaotic
Yunosuke - Loop

Both title and unicode title should include "(feat. WaMi)". therefore it should be Yunosuke - Loop (feat. WaMi) according to following links:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hln51dz0Kl4
https://yunosuke-official.bandcamp.com/track/loop-feat-wami
https://twitter.com/bass_ynk/status/1362718796830543873
Last edited by Mocaotic , edited 2 times in total.
akmal2232232123
115 posts
Joined October 2020
akmal2232232123
i found a duplicate issue on beatmaps/artists/32
iaport
380 posts
Joined July 2013
iaport
A? - Suimasen Sanshoku Cheese Gyuudon no Tokumori ni Ontamatsuki o Onegaishimasu

BPM change at 02:24:705 to 280 is not included.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
54 / 211
/