rust45 wrote:

[Daisuki!!]
No spinners, they aren't required, but I suggest you add some to break ties and because your other diffs have them. Nah, I think it's fine. XD I don't want to replace that last awesome-looking heart. =<

[Choosuki!!!]
I think the OD (just the OD) is a little high, I think you should lower it by one. I was actually trying to INCREASE it. lol Not doing so because...Garven lowered his OD by 1, and mine can't be higher than his. ;___;
00:57:930 (1,2) - This is absolutely no way to tell that those a 1/2 apart, it got me off guard this time, when it came up again, and a third time when I was testing my suggested OD. Not to mention in the same combo the spacing gets halved and that's, in fact, unrankable. Please fix this and the later occasion. Uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh. It was hanging with the storyboard, you see...Oh well, looks like we can't make people rage these days, can we? =< Reduced it a bit.


Great map and great looking yet non distracting SB. You get to have another star. I know, right. I can't really notice it while playing. =x=

rust45 wrote:

[Garven]
As usual great mapping by Garven.
However, you have an insanely high OD, may I suggest lowering that a bit, I think most my misses may had come from the fact that it was so high, but your choice, not mine.

k3nsh1n_H1mur4 wrote:

Legenda:

Change?
Change!

Suki!

SPOILER

Você deveria diminuir em 2 o 'HP Drain Rate' e 'Overall Difficulty'
00:42:073 (1) - Se a intenção é ser o Easy, essa nota é combobreaker fácil para os novatos. *fixes*
00:45:716 (1) - Move 1/2 beat na timeline pra trás. *fixes*
00:42:073 (1) - ^ Mas se eu mover 1/2 atrás, 'sa porra fica em cima do fim do slider. D:
02:24:930 (1,2,3,1) - Break entre elas? No, tá seguindo o SB / música.
03:10:145 (2,3) - Coloca uma em cima da outra. Na verdade, eu tinha deixado de propósito... Acho que vou deixa ar assim mesmo.[/color]

Daisuki!!

SPOILER

Você deveria diminuir em 1 o 'HP Drain Rate', 'Approach Circle' e 'Overall Difficulty' Diminui em 1 o AR. =p

Choosuki!!!

SPOILER

Você deveria aumentar em 1 o 'HP Drain Rate'. Não quero que seja uma diff lolh4x de passar, então eu deixei um pouco baixo pra ser agradável pra jogadores não tão pros.

Não é tão ruim como outras músicas de Vocaloid, o sb foi bem feito. No geral, é um mapa que será agradável de jogar ^^ Ah, é por que apesar de ser relacionado com a Miku, é um cover. Um ótimo cover, então é bem legal~ Thx for the modding. <3

Star!

k3nsh1n_H1mur4 wrote:

Garven's 1 2 3!
00:47:645 (2,3) - Switch positions of the hitcircles? Nah, though I'll space it out so it's easier to read.
01:00:823 (1,2) - Doublet? Consider remove one hitcircle, to maintain the flow of the map It's the lyrical variation that makes this more than just a drab 1/8th note run.
01:59:109 (1,2) - ^ ^
02:14:859 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - What is supposed to follow? I believe it ruin the flow of the map. Um, it's the guitar? Which I was following since 02:11:216 (1) - ?
02:24:930 (1,2,3,1) - Break between them?
03:06:395 (2,3) - Doublet? Consider remove one hitcircle, to maintain the flow of the map Same reasoning before
03:07:681 (1,2) - ^
03:13:252 (2,3) - ^[/color]

Odaril wrote:

Garven's 1 2 3!
00:47:216 (1,2) - This jump is unexpected and a bit confusing, though it's possible to catch the note soon enough.

lepidopodus wrote:

@Sanjenin Nagi -U:
몇번이나 말씀드렸던 것 같은데, 큰노트 1/4로 다른 노트에 겹치는 것은 SV가 매우 높지 않은 이상 금기사항입니다.

01:12:931 (352,1) - 그리고 태고에서는 스피너도 노트 하나로 간주되는 경향이 있기 때문에, 이런 식으로 '찍고 돌리면' 어색합니다.

Krisom wrote:

About the taiko diff...
-You have not added the taiko mapper to the tags
-The SB says "Beatmap by Garven" what?

Krisom wrote:

About the taiko diff...
-You have not added the taiko mapper to the tags
-The SB says "Beatmap by Garven" what?
-Use Slider Velocity 1.4 please.
-Move Overall Difficulty, Circle Size and Approach rate to the middle. The later 2 won't change anything, but it's better to ahve them in the middle afaik. HP is a bit high for this kind of taiko map but w/e, that's up to you
00:07:574 (39,40,41) - Not "rankeable", you cannot add a finish with just 1/4 of distance with the previous or next note
00:14:431 (78,79,80) - ^
00:28:145 (141,142,143) - ^
00:35:001 (181,182,183) - ^
01:05:858 (318,319,320) - ^
01:19:574 (27,28,29) - ^
01:26:431 (67,68,69) - ^
01:40:145 (116,117,118) - ^
01:47:002 (155,156,157) - ^
02:04:144 (254,255,256) - ^
02:17:859 (308,309,310) - ^
02:31:573 (375,376,377) - ^
02:51:931 (458,459,460,461,462) - ^
02:59:001 (499,500,501) - ^
03:05:859 (539,540,541) - ^
03:12:715 (578,579,580) - ^
03:26:431 (652,653,654) - ^
The reason of these notes is that you're supposed to hit finishes with the 2 drums, and in a stream it becomes nearly impossible.

I was told this had a new taiko diff and I wanted to check it, if you're wondering the reason behind the mod

aston wrote:

Aesthetics :
On S. Nagi's Taikosuki, it's hard to see the SB in Taiko, but that's fine. Can't do anything about that... ;I
Also, in other diffs, everyone had a "!" after their name, need the same on taiko diff (?) ...Silly me who forgot that..

Garven's 1 2 3! :
- Well made, but i'd say +1 on the HP drain, maybe +2; can keep it like that though.　We decided to increase it by 1 tick. /o

Choosuki!!! :
- Lots of spacing differences in the beginning; its kinda minor though. (Example : 00:21:931 (1,2)) (So nothing really!) The others are pretty okay...Changing this one because they do look too close...

Daisuki!! :
- 03:23:216 (2) - Against spacing rules, i'd place it closer to 256,340 or 256,304 for a "Complete" heart. Not really...I spaced a bit more just because people may get it wrong.

Pretty beatmap, I like it; Heh, thanks. <3
star~

Niko- wrote:

&nbsp;

Sakura Hana wrote:

[Garven's 1,2,3!]
02:24:930 (1,2,3) - I'm standing at edge of yes and no on this, might be too harsh without any breaks in between, but the breaks would make each note be new combo >.< This is like a huge highlight of this map though. I did several tests with various HP drain values, and before it was lower, but with consideration towards this being the "hardest" difficulty of the set anyway it works fine. You lose about half of your health during this part, and the parts leading up to it aren't too bad. You regain the health fairly easily once the song picks up again. I'd rather not add breaks as it kills the effect, and combo hacking would be lame for this excuse.
03:23:002 (1) - With the current approach rate, the mapper might not be able to get ready in time to hit this note specially when they are spinning, considering spinners lighten up everything when they are cleared and the spinner BG isnt helping at all (more of this on general) I love these; it fits, and I don't have control over the skin. The for map, it works, and I don't intend on removing it. Funny thing is that I originally mapped this with AR +1.

Sakura Hana wrote:

[Skin]
You're missing approachcircle.png on your skin. Done. ~
You cant skin away important to gameplay elements like sliderpoint10.png and sldierpoint30.png. Eh...don't really care about these... Anyways, removed.

[General]
So bright!!! Main problem i have with this beatmap set is that the BG is white, the combo colors are light, and lightning is big enough to cause a blinding flash on kiai, if i were to make a suggestion, darken out the BG either by editing the BG or adding a slightly transparent black screen via SB, doesnt help specially on spinners since they flash very britghtly with their light BG when they are cleared making the notes harder to follow. I made them a bit darker, but not too much, because if it gets too dark, the lyrics get screwed up. Anyways, this will change accordingly to the brightness of the monitor...mine, for example, it's a bit dark-ish, so I don't have those problems. Thanks for pointing it up, anyways.

[Storyboard]
Remove unnecessary transparencies from: Lyrics10.png, heart.png, Lyrics34.png, star.png Removed.

[Suki!]
02:24:930 (1,2,3,1) - Same concern than on Garven's diff. As for these notes, I'm going to keep them. The previous notes are fairly easy to get. I mean, 1/1 close sliders and all... The notes after it are easy to get, as well.

Other diffs are fine, Good Luck!~

Garven wrote:

Bwuhahaha, I laugh at the spike of retries at the end of my diff. Probably where all the 1's came from ww

Garven wrote:

Bwuhahaha, I laugh at the spike of retries at the end of my diff. Probably where all the 1's came from ww