what's this? prot actually doing stuff? :thinking:
I think Niv did a nice job of looking at the easier diffs, but I'd prefer to go over them via IRC to talk about what you can do for the graces since I dont think they're acceptable in an easy diff despite the low bpm.
boop
[General]
[Normals]
4K
00:17:556 (17556|1,17866|2) - Might consider stacking these notes since they're the same pitch, like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560690
00:26:680 (26680|1) - I'd move this to col 3 to break the long stack at 00:25:288 (25288|1,25752|1,26216|1,26680|1) -
00:32:711 (32711|1) - Move this to col 1 to stack with the jump at 00:32:402 (32402|3,32402|0) - for pitch relevancy
00:34:025 (34025|2) - This actually belongs at 00:34:000 - on the 1/12 snap. Please change this in all difficulties as this is an incorrectly snapped note.
00:45:701 (45701|1) - Pretty sure this note is also a 1/12 grace and should be put on 00:45:752 - . Be sure that the note you move is the one with C#5 on it
00:58:690 (58690|0) - Move to col 2 to make a stack with the previous jump because they're the same pitch
01:00:005 (60005|3) - 1/12 grace at 00:59:979 - , and its pitch is wrong. The A#5 should actually be C#5, and the C#5 is actually C5, like so https://puu.sh/wGy2T.png
5K
00:17:556 (17556|3,17866|4) - Stack for PR?
00:32:402 (32402|2,32402|0,32711|3,32711|1) - I'd also stack these two for PR like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560781
00:33:987 (33987|4) - tfw use 1/16 here but used 1/8 in the 4K normal :veryhardthenk: Note that I already said in the 4k diff that it's a 1/12 grace so the rest of the graces in this diff should be 1/12
00:35:804 (35804|2,35804|0) - I'd make this [24] instead since the following chord at 00:36:422 - is a much lower pitch than the jump I just highlighted
00:38:278 (38278|1,38278|3) - Would move this left one column cause it's a different pitch from 00:37:659 (37659|1,37659|3) - so I think the difference in columns should be more pronounced
00:47:556 (47556|3) - Move to col 3 to stack with 00:47:092 (47092|2) - for PR?
00:58:381 (58381|1,58381|4,58690|3,58690|0,58690|2) - stack dat pitch relevancy fam
6K
00:17:556 (17556|3,17866|4) - Stack these in the same column for PR
00:32:402 (32402|4,32402|2,32711|3,32711|5) - Also stack these too. To make it a bit more balanced across both hands though, I'd just do it like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560822
00:38:278 (38278|5) - Would move this to col 1, and then move 00:38:278 (38278|1) - to col 4 since it's lower than the D#
00:40:134 (40134|1) - I'd move this to col 1 so that it isn't unused from 00:37:350 - to 00:43:845 - lol
00:47:092 (47092|3,47092|1,47556|2,47556|4) - stack for PR too, like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560832
00:58:381 (58381|2,58381|5,58690|4,58690|1) - Same suggestion as above
7K
00:11:680 (11680|2,12299|2) - Might move this to col 1 since it hasn't been used since the very beginning of the song. If accepted, I would move 00:11:989 (11989|3) - one col to the left to avoid a possible right hand bias for right spacers
00:17:556 (17556|4,17866|6) - stack for PR
00:19:721 (19721|0) - Move to col 2 as the pitch at 00:20:958 - is lower than the first timestamp given.
00:32:402 (32402|5,32402|2,32711|3,32711|6) - stack for PR, maybe this would work https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560987
00:47:092 (47092|4,47092|1,47556|3,47556|0,47556|6) - same thing as above
00:58:381 (58381|1,58381|5,58690|6,58690|3,58690|2) - ^
8K
00:17:556 (17556|5,17866|7) - Stack for PR. I wouldn't recommend stacking it on the pinky finger though, so I'd do stack it in col 7 instead on the ring finger
00:32:402 (32402|6,32402|3,32711|4,32711|7) - stack for PR =w=
00:47:092 (47092|5,47092|2,47556|4,47556|1) - ^
9K
00:10:443 (10443|0,10443|2) - Ok, in 9K, this pattern pretty much makes me want to kms because of the pinky + middle combination. It's cause of the ring finger that also tries to press down that makes it so annoying, so I'd either make this hand [247] or something close.
00:12:299 (12299|7,12299|1) - I get that this is for symmetry, but I think it's best to stack this with 00:11:680 (11680|6,11680|2) - since they're the same pitch. You've also been doing that in all the other normal diffs, so it's inconsistent to not do it now I guess.
00:17:556 (17556|6,17866|8) - Stack notes for PR? I think in this case, for hand balance, pinky in col 9 would be fine.
00:31:783 (31783|5,31783|2,32092|6,32092|3) - I'd shift this left by one column since the pitch is different from 00:30:855 (30855|2,30855|5) - , so like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8561420
00:34:567 (34567|0,34567|2,36422|2,36422|0) - Same thing I mentioned previously about these chords. I think it'd be better to use [14] instead as it's pinky + index which is easier to execute due to the fact that the middle finger isnt being anchored down by the press, which would cause the ring finger to wanna press too.
00:47:092 (47092|4,47092|1,47556|3,47556|6) - stack dem notes
00:54:979 (54979|8,54979|6) - Oh yeah, this too is eugh for the pinky + middle on the right hand. The entire chord is on the right hand actually, assumign the player is a right spacer :thinking:
00:58:381 (58381|2,58381|7,58690|8,58690|5,58690|3) - stack for pr
- I believe the offset is wrong. It should probably be more around 6774 or +42 to all timing points. I would check this with another BN though because pretty much anyone will tell you Im horribly awful at finding offsets. Im modding with the old offset though just in case Im wrong lol
- Tone down the OD/HP of all your easies cause 8/8 is way too punishing for the target audience this is aimed towards. Maybe OD/HP 6.5/6.5 is better since it's not very dense to begin with.
- Same thing goes for the normals, I would make them all OD/HP 7/7 cause they're all still considered easy diffs and you mostly just use 1/1 jumps
- Checked all samples and they're all used, so yay =w=)b
[Normals]
4K
00:17:556 (17556|1,17866|2) - Might consider stacking these notes since they're the same pitch, like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560690
00:26:680 (26680|1) - I'd move this to col 3 to break the long stack at 00:25:288 (25288|1,25752|1,26216|1,26680|1) -
00:32:711 (32711|1) - Move this to col 1 to stack with the jump at 00:32:402 (32402|3,32402|0) - for pitch relevancy
00:34:025 (34025|2) - This actually belongs at 00:34:000 - on the 1/12 snap. Please change this in all difficulties as this is an incorrectly snapped note.
00:45:701 (45701|1) - Pretty sure this note is also a 1/12 grace and should be put on 00:45:752 - . Be sure that the note you move is the one with C#5 on it
00:58:690 (58690|0) - Move to col 2 to make a stack with the previous jump because they're the same pitch
01:00:005 (60005|3) - 1/12 grace at 00:59:979 - , and its pitch is wrong. The A#5 should actually be C#5, and the C#5 is actually C5, like so https://puu.sh/wGy2T.png
5K
00:17:556 (17556|3,17866|4) - Stack for PR?
00:32:402 (32402|2,32402|0,32711|3,32711|1) - I'd also stack these two for PR like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560781
00:33:987 (33987|4) - tfw use 1/16 here but used 1/8 in the 4K normal :veryhardthenk: Note that I already said in the 4k diff that it's a 1/12 grace so the rest of the graces in this diff should be 1/12
00:35:804 (35804|2,35804|0) - I'd make this [24] instead since the following chord at 00:36:422 - is a much lower pitch than the jump I just highlighted
00:38:278 (38278|1,38278|3) - Would move this left one column cause it's a different pitch from 00:37:659 (37659|1,37659|3) - so I think the difference in columns should be more pronounced
00:47:556 (47556|3) - Move to col 3 to stack with 00:47:092 (47092|2) - for PR?
00:58:381 (58381|1,58381|4,58690|3,58690|0,58690|2) - stack dat pitch relevancy fam
6K
00:17:556 (17556|3,17866|4) - Stack these in the same column for PR
00:32:402 (32402|4,32402|2,32711|3,32711|5) - Also stack these too. To make it a bit more balanced across both hands though, I'd just do it like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560822
00:38:278 (38278|5) - Would move this to col 1, and then move 00:38:278 (38278|1) - to col 4 since it's lower than the D#
00:40:134 (40134|1) - I'd move this to col 1 so that it isn't unused from 00:37:350 - to 00:43:845 - lol
00:47:092 (47092|3,47092|1,47556|2,47556|4) - stack for PR too, like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560832
00:58:381 (58381|2,58381|5,58690|4,58690|1) - Same suggestion as above
7K
00:11:680 (11680|2,12299|2) - Might move this to col 1 since it hasn't been used since the very beginning of the song. If accepted, I would move 00:11:989 (11989|3) - one col to the left to avoid a possible right hand bias for right spacers
00:17:556 (17556|4,17866|6) - stack for PR
00:19:721 (19721|0) - Move to col 2 as the pitch at 00:20:958 - is lower than the first timestamp given.
00:32:402 (32402|5,32402|2,32711|3,32711|6) - stack for PR, maybe this would work https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8560987
00:47:092 (47092|4,47092|1,47556|3,47556|0,47556|6) - same thing as above
00:58:381 (58381|1,58381|5,58690|6,58690|3,58690|2) - ^
8K
00:17:556 (17556|5,17866|7) - Stack for PR. I wouldn't recommend stacking it on the pinky finger though, so I'd do stack it in col 7 instead on the ring finger
00:32:402 (32402|6,32402|3,32711|4,32711|7) - stack for PR =w=
00:47:092 (47092|5,47092|2,47556|4,47556|1) - ^
9K
00:10:443 (10443|0,10443|2) - Ok, in 9K, this pattern pretty much makes me want to kms because of the pinky + middle combination. It's cause of the ring finger that also tries to press down that makes it so annoying, so I'd either make this hand [247] or something close.
00:12:299 (12299|7,12299|1) - I get that this is for symmetry, but I think it's best to stack this with 00:11:680 (11680|6,11680|2) - since they're the same pitch. You've also been doing that in all the other normal diffs, so it's inconsistent to not do it now I guess.
00:17:556 (17556|6,17866|8) - Stack notes for PR? I think in this case, for hand balance, pinky in col 9 would be fine.
00:31:783 (31783|5,31783|2,32092|6,32092|3) - I'd shift this left by one column since the pitch is different from 00:30:855 (30855|2,30855|5) - , so like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8561420
00:34:567 (34567|0,34567|2,36422|2,36422|0) - Same thing I mentioned previously about these chords. I think it'd be better to use [14] instead as it's pinky + index which is easier to execute due to the fact that the middle finger isnt being anchored down by the press, which would cause the ring finger to wanna press too.
00:47:092 (47092|4,47092|1,47556|3,47556|6) - stack dem notes
00:54:979 (54979|8,54979|6) - Oh yeah, this too is eugh for the pinky + middle on the right hand. The entire chord is on the right hand actually, assumign the player is a right spacer :thinking:
00:58:381 (58381|2,58381|7,58690|8,58690|5,58690|3) - stack for pr
I think Niv did a nice job of looking at the easier diffs, but I'd prefer to go over them via IRC to talk about what you can do for the graces since I dont think they're acceptable in an easy diff despite the low bpm.