helo
[General]
reeeeally nice map, i'd spend a bunch of stars here but i'm saving for a loved map
[General]
- Is 1680x1050 a rankable background resolution? I'm aware that stuff up to 1920x1080 is fine, but there's also aspect ratio to be taken into account.
- oXS8V8i.png seems to be unused.
- 00:23:753 (1) - Any reason for the NC to be here? I'd rather place it at 00:25:124 (2) - since the phrase begins at 00:24:781.
- 00:27:867 (2) - nazi: 1px down for perfect blanket
- 00:41:924 (2) - Would look cooler if you moved the last sliderpoint to x226 y64 so both head and tail are equally spaced in relation to (1)'s sliderend. Aesthetically better imo.
- 00:49:124 (3) - I'd rather move this note to 00:48:781 (3). It's a rhythm that's easier to keep for new players. You could also just add a note there and keep the one as it is.
- 01:15:524 (3) - nazi: 2px down for better blanket
- 01:16:896 (1) - Maybe make the edge happen exactly as the slidertick happens? Emphasizes the song better, I guess
- 01:25:124 (1) - I'd rather have this stacked with 01:23:410 (2) - and move 01:26:153 (2) - accordingly to fix the triangle. Looks a bit nicer, imo
- AR feels sliiiightly too low considering the slider speed and spacing, raising it a bit to 5.5 or even 6 would work better. Pretty tough map for a Normal though, feels a bit more like a Hard, but may just be me
- 00:45:353 (2) - Repeat is offgrid, I believe it doesn't fall off playfield but I'd move it a bit left just to be safe
- 00:54:953 (1,2) - pretty much every modder complained about these kinds of stacks on my Normal diffs so I'll just mention this once since they happen everywhere in this diff, I personally have no problem with stacking stuff on Normal diffs but just a reminder that people are probably gonna bother you about this
- 00:59:067 (1) - Is the NC here intentional? Just curious because the rhythm does change, but it's a bit inconsistent with the NC usage in this diff overall.
- 01:20:667 (4) - I believe this slider is going a bit off the playfield, not sure tho
- 01:42:439 (3) - 1px left (and 1 down i think?) for better blanketing
- 00:28:896 (1) - I'd move this to x327 y290 to make the pattern look nicer
- 00:49:124 (3) - nazi: move 1px to the right for perfect stacking :^)
- 00:56:839 (3,4,5) - nazi: move them 1px up to stack perfectly with 00:57:696 (1) - (the reason i don't ask you to move (1) instead is because it'd ruin a blanket)
- 01:03:181 (1,2,3) - Reeeeeeeally not sure about this, pretty sure this is almost unpredictable. I'd just rather have 4 sliders with 2 repeats each, works much better in this case. If you reeeeally want to emphasize the sound at 01:04:039, then maybe you could shorten (2) to a slider with 2 repeats and add a non-repeating slider at 01:03:867, but I'm pretty sure this wouldn't go through the ranking process.
Really nice diff
- There seem to be a lot of green sections that are supposed to lower volume for filler 1/4 sliderends, but they don't actually lower the volume. Is this intentional?
- 00:27:010 (1,2) - Why isn't the NC at (2) instead? I understand that you're basing if off the vocals, but this doesn't happen at 00:33:524 (2) - 00:38:153 (3) - etc.
- 00:41:067 (1) - Maybe move this (and the whole combo) to x271 y78? Makes the blanket look much nicer
- 00:49:981 (3) - Why is this slider the only 1/1 at this part? There's nothing really worth emphasizing here and for everything else you used a constant 1/2 rhythm.
- 01:03:867 (1) - Don't really agree with the NC usage here, it's basically the same phrase/pattern. Contrary to the other patterns where you NC'd everytime you indicated a change in spacing or pattern, this NC doesn't seem to do either.
- 00:25:639 (3) - nazi: 1px right and 1px down for perfect stacking k_hand:
- 00:30:610 (2) - 4px right for better blanketing?
- 00:32:324 (7,8) - Pretty awkward movement here imo, I'd rather do something like this even though it kinda kills emphasis
- 00:40:896 (7) - nazi: 1px right for better blanketing
- 00:50:496 (1,2,1) - Yellow combo (1) should be spaced at least equally as (1,2) from orange combo to preserve emphasis and movement. That'd kinda ruin your patterns now so well just let it pass
- 00:56:324 (1) - Move this to x40 y142 to make the stream straight
- 01:04:896 (3,1) - Spacing feels a bit too low IMO. Maybe move 01:05:067 (1) to x266 y155?
- 01:26:667 (2) - nazi: 1px right for better stacking
some pretty nice patterns at the second kiai, really liked it
- 00:23:239 (1) - nazi: 1px down for perfect stacking
- 01:23:753 (1,2) - Spacing here feels waaaaay too low especially considering this is a rather important beat, I'd place it somewhere around x440 y336 or something
- 01:32:496 (1,2,3) - I think these should be 1/4 instead, kinda ruins your pattern but I definitely heard it while playing ):
reeeeally nice map, i'd spend a bunch of stars here but i'm saving for a loved map