quick irc check discussing some issues with easy/normal and light modding of the lunatic
irc
20:44 tokiko: oh, maybe you can take a look on my map while you're online?
20:48 Plaudible: sure
20:48 Plaudible: i dont plan on nominating or pushing anything for a bit though
20:49 tokiko: that's fine
20:49 tokiko: i know that new bn's filled out with messages
20:49 Plaudible: XD
20:49 Plaudible: surprisingly not
20:49 Plaudible: i havent gotten any pms from strangers
20:50 Plaudible: just 2 requests from mutuals
20:50 Plaudible: im not well known so it works out for me :)
20:50 tokiko: secret bn
20:50 *tokiko is listening to [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1316417 UNDEAD CORPORATION - Hafuri]
20:50 Plaudible: underground bubbling
20:50 tokiko: B)
20:52 Plaudible: hmm
20:52 Plaudible: i dont like how little the motion in the streams in the beginning is
20:53 Plaudible: like 00:07:868 (3,4,5,6,7) - vs00:11:592 (1,2,1,2) -
20:53 Plaudible: even if the intensity is what you're emphasizing the difference here is huge
20:53 Plaudible: also note
20:53 Plaudible: how 00:13:247 (3,4) - repeats at 00:14:902 (7,8) - but how different they are
20:54 Plaudible: since you prioritize guitar it wouldnt be bad to go over 1/4 in some cases here
20:54 Plaudible: 00:24:833 (1,2,3) - rhythm is hard to determine here, maybe use NC's and SV changes to better highlight change here
20:55 Plaudible: 00:42:522 (3) - lotta sounds in here should be clickable imo, you're going over a lot
20:55 tokiko: the beginning of the map is 1 year old or something around that
20:56 tokiko: maybe i didn't clearly recognize some concepts!
20:56 Plaudible: 00:48:832 (3,4,5,1) - stream here? :O
20:56 Plaudible: ahh gotcha
20:56 tokiko: stream sounds like uhhh
20:56 tokiko: and i like to undermap!
20:57 Plaudible: 00:51:625 - strong drum needs clickable pls, sliderend isnt enough
20:57 Plaudible: well
20:57 Plaudible: you map the drums pretty densely
20:57 Plaudible: even at places like 00:54:625 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) -
20:57 Plaudible: i think doing it at 48s is pretty important
20:57 Plaudible: 00:58:795 (1,2,1,2) - make these a little more noticeably different
20:58 Plaudible: different rhythms, bit too identical
20:58 Plaudible: maybe stack 00:59:461 (2,1) - ?
20:59 Plaudible: 01:10:357 (2,3) - you don't really follow vocals this strongly with 1/4 sliders anywhere else in the kiai and it's out of place here given that it's the only place you do, i'd just make these circles
20:59 Plaudible: 01:15:012 (1) - streams in this section are a lot more fitting, compare to intro
21:00 Plaudible: 01:29:080 (7) - maybe make this a reverse 1/4 slider to cover that rhythm you're missing in between a bit
21:00 Plaudible: 01:42:632 (3) - again here need more clickables imo
21:01 tokiko: how did that turn into irc mod
21:01 Plaudible: LOL
21:01 Plaudible: srry
21:01 Plaudible: i got carried away
21:01 Plaudible: aiight well
21:01 Plaudible: overall im just concerned about how you neglect some rhythms here and there
21:01 Plaudible: you could definitely incorporate more into this
21:02 Plaudible: make some of the weird 1/3 rhythms more identifiable with NC's or some form of difference to make sure players can interpret them properly
21:02 tokiko: players can't handle 145bpm ar8.7
21:10 tokiko: thank you for check!
21:17 Plaudible: yee npnp
21:18 tokiko: alllso there's some other diffs that i think have some big problems
21:19 tokiko: because i only have an expirience to map extras/insanes
21:19 Plaudible: o kk i'll glance in a sec
21:25 Plaudible: kk
21:26 tokiko: why not kkk
21:26 *Plaudible is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1323285 UNDEAD CORPORATION - Hafuri [Easy]]
21:26 Plaudible: because das racis
21:26 Plaudible: since this bpm is pretty low you can justify 1/2
21:26 Plaudible: but
21:26 Plaudible: you should try to simplify odd 1/4 rhythms as much as possible
21:27 Plaudible: avoid things like 00:03:316 (3) -
21:27 tokiko: i can't ignore such a strong sounds!
21:27 Plaudible: 00:28:143 (3,4,5,6) - note that in an easy difficulty consecutive circles are huge difficulty spikes
21:27 Plaudible: oh yes you can
21:27 Plaudible: you ignore a lot in easy's trust me LOL
21:27 Plaudible: my solution would be just to get rid of the reverse and make it a unique shape slider
21:27 tokiko: maaybe
21:27 tokiko: but it hurts physically
21:28 Plaudible: ik it does
21:28 Plaudible: but bite the pillow
21:28 Plaudible: easy's are pain
21:28 Plaudible: 00:31:039 (8,2) -
21:28 Plaudible: oh yeah but on what i said earlier, avoid spamming too many circles
21:28 Plaudible: unless it's the absolute right moment
21:29 Plaudible: i dont think the slow part vocals are a good part to do that
21:29 Plaudible: be careful for making repetitive rhythms in easy
21:29 Plaudible: this is a bit boring to play 00:43:039 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,1) -
21:29 Plaudible: ok so since this repeats, basically same issues throughout
21:30 Plaudible: don't make excessive repeated rhythms since it's a bit boring to play
21:30 tokiko: D:
21:30 Plaudible: watch out for where your dense rhythms are, circle spam = diffspik and you want them in the right places
21:30 Plaudible: dont do complicated 1/4 rhythms even for loud sounds, it's not good for an easy
21:30 tokiko: painnn
21:31 Plaudible: yep :(
21:32 Plaudible: mm
21:32 Plaudible: iidk the normal im on the fence with
21:32 Plaudible: since this is low bpm you could probably uh
21:32 Plaudible: maybe space things a bit more, this barely overlapping design is a bit unattractive
21:33 Plaudible: dont change up the rhythm too suddenly like at 00:07:868 (2,3,4,1,2,3,4) -
21:33 Plaudible: fine for the most part though
21:33 Plaudible: maybe buff hard to 3.3 or 3.4 so spread is maybe a bit more even, idk
21:34 Plaudible: but from a quick glance it looks good
21:36 tokiko: thank you, mr plaudible!
21:36 Plaudible: o7 anytime :)
21:36 Plaudible: can i post for kudos :3c
21:36 tokiko: you can post it but without my scary messages