I was finishing the answer when everything was deleted... I don't have enough faith to do it again (because it was really long) so I'll sum up the main ideas : NCs are following the song's construction (except 03:58:003 (8) - because I want white), I want to keep most vocal sliders with red anchors because aesthetics, There's many overlaps but I wanted to try it and turn it into an aesthetic thing.hi-mei wrote:
hello, from my queue
00:08:060 (4,5,6) - i think its a rhythm+flow issue, the thing is that hm... well ill better give an example: 00:05:332 (4,5) - this is good one, the spacing is cool and rhythm is nice. tho for this 00:08:060 (4,5,6) - one i think that slider end shud be a clickable note, and also these 3 00:08:401 - shud be emphasized with a proper spacing like u did before
i think that u got a general problem with new combos, its a rare thing to make a 9+ numbers in combos (it will also hurt players with custom skins that are using default.png numbers without hitcircles, u can try to find recia's skin if u dont know what im talking about), i think for example u could put nc here 00:15:731 (4) -
or here 00:18:287 (5) - for a new sound phrase
it occurs on thru the entire map
00:22:207 (10,11) - i think spacing here shud be higher, cuz 11 is a pitch
00:33:458 - not sure about this break, u put a circle on 00:33:458 - start of it, but then just skipped everything, and then mapped the ending of the sound phrase 00:37:549 (1,2) - here. i think its fundamentally wrong. and also this sound being skipped doent contribute to the map's quality 00:38:231 -
00:52:208 - here i think a rhythm issue
i think that 00:52:549 - is a start of new sound phrase, and the vocals are starting on 1/3 00:52:776 - here
00:56:128 (3) - i think this shud be further from 2 cuz its stronger than 00:55:617 (1) -
01:17:094 (1) - i think this shape doesnt represent the sounds behind it, u got a pitch on 01:17:435 - 01:17:776 - 01:18:117 - which can be represented with red anchors or/and the bends to change the slider path
01:37:945 - same,. this slider shape makes no sense, cuz the sound is plain there and i dont think u shud make any sharp angles as well.
03:36:696 (2,5,8) - i think they all shud have nc
etc
03:56:981 (7) - can u plz remap this slider, its ugly for me
03:58:685 (9) - nc
yea please fix combos
04:32:435 (9,1) - hm 1/8 gap?
04:33:799 (3,4) - ^ i dont think its possible in 4* maps tho, not quite sure tho
05:13:344 (7,8,1) - not sure about this flow break, i think (1) shud continue zig-zag flow tho.
05:17:094 (3,4) - this overlap is poorly done for sure, make some blankets like this atleast
05:24:594 (1,3,4) - im not a fan of this tripple-overlap
05:39:253 (2,3,4) - make 3 closer to 4? i think its too high right now
05:47:435 (4,5) - not a fan of this overlap
thats it, gl
(and people should change custom skin if it's bad for some maps :/)
I'm really sorry about this, I'm also annoyed (I nearly want to cry (mainly because I took the time to explain half of the suggestions))
(I'd say around 3/4 of the suggestions were denied)
Really sorry again :c