You have to realize that this thread is 4 pages of exactly what you just said. He has responded with nothing but REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE_Toxi wrote:
Now for the criticism.
This could almost be done by re-skinning Mania and making the notes not move. not only that, but the 2-row of keys is an amazing way to ruin your wrist. There are two other game modes that don't have any jumps, Mania and Taiko, so instead of making a mix between them because you don't like standard jumps, practice and get better like everybody else that can make jumps. If you want want to do that, play another game-mode.
forum
[invalid] New GAMEMODE!!! CHECK IT OUT!
posted
Total Posts
72
Any idea, except for a poisonous one, is a gold bar for the osu!community, and this is an example. Your locking threat is very CHAOtic, if you get the pun.Chaos wrote:
First, bashing anybody who has given you undesirable feedback is not a way to garner support for your suggestion. They are legitimate concerns and questions and should be addressed as such.
Second, this proposed mode does not add any notable difference in gameplay compared to the parts of mania and standard you have cobbled together. I don't see how this is supposed to be different enough to warrant discussion about adding such a mode into the game.
While I would personally dismiss this simply as an unnecessary request, I will hesitantly keep this thread open for now with the hope that people will behave appropriately. I will not hesitate to lock it if the insults and such continue.
NattyC, however, Chaos was right about your explosive reactions to criticism. Chill out, consider their suggestions.
Anyways, like this idea. Reminds me of that game where you have a circular plate, and you have to swipe up/down and rotate the plate even in order to harmonize.
I see why this is resembled to mania but yet it isn't. But I do have a few suggestions:
- Allow rotation or movement of circle positions
- Spinners similar to all game modes: hit keys in sequence, minimum required, bonus before spinner end
- Show (Silver)S/SS comboburst, guidelines same as osu!standard
- TAG Maps = Many circles going around
This is mania. No way around it.
Sorry, pal; better luck next time.
Sorry, pal; better luck next time.
Do you have evidence?johnmedina999 wrote:
This is mania.
No way around it.
I can preview this "new" game mode by doing this:DJ Enetro wrote:
Do you have evidence?
So then what would you do to make it not a mania clone?johnmedina999 wrote:
I can preview this "new" game mode by doing this:
Nah, you wouldn't get the same feel as the idea. Mania is top down but this is center putjohnmedina999 wrote:
I can preview this "new" game mode by doing this:DJ Enetro wrote:
Do you have evidence?
Nothing. This is styled as jubeat with the hitcircles coming in from the center, and also styled like mania where you use 4+ keys to hit 4+ targets. You can't change this so it doesn't copy either jubeat or mania.UnNVus wrote:
So then what would you do to make it not a mania clone?
This is jubeat or this is mania, take your pick.
So this is a reskin of mania? Gotcha.DJ Enetro wrote:
Nah, you wouldn't get the same feel as the idea. Mania is top down but this is center put
Did you not read? I said nothing about this being a ripoff of osu!mania.
You scrub, read between the lines
You scrub, read between the lines
...DJ Enetro wrote:
Did you not read? I said nothing about this being a ripoff of osu!mania.
You scrub, read between the lines
DJ Enetro wrote:
Mania is top down but this is center put
Read what you write before you post.DJ Enetro wrote:
"Mania is top down, this is a slight variation of mania"
Stop trying to deny it, you can't get around it.
You can implement this game mode with a custom osu!mania skin and storyboards.
In a similar way they did with osu!DIVA t/365396
In a similar way they did with osu!DIVA t/365396
I dunno, as john said, it sounds like modified jubeat..
If you read page 3 you can see he didn't even answer a simple question as to 'how is this unique'DJ Enetro wrote:
Nonetheless, this idea has potential
I doubt this has potential at all
Well, i'll start making the ideas and help.
first of all, osu!taiko and osu!mania targets are static. You press the keys once the dons/notes reach the drum/bottom row. That doesn't move in osu!taiko or osu!mania. osu!standard has circles, sliders, and spinners. that's it.
So he could have the notes/holders/spinners come from different directions and the targets can move during the song. Do you get this?
EDIT: also, on osu!diva, the targets change, moving across the screen. in this gamemode there is one location that moves per button.
and yes the keybinds can be osu!mania style.
EDIT 2: If you really doubt it, I'll make you see the good side. Don't hate on _Mee, P_lease.
first of all, osu!taiko and osu!mania targets are static. You press the keys once the dons/notes reach the drum/bottom row. That doesn't move in osu!taiko or osu!mania. osu!standard has circles, sliders, and spinners. that's it.
So he could have the notes/holders/spinners come from different directions and the targets can move during the song. Do you get this?
EDIT: also, on osu!diva, the targets change, moving across the screen. in this gamemode there is one location that moves per button.
and yes the keybinds can be osu!mania style.
EDIT 2: If you really doubt it, I'll make you see the good side. Don't hate on _Mee, P_lease.
Different directions? What are you talking about? Didn't you see http://imgur.com/QIZAEKB ?DJ Enetro wrote:
Well, i'll start making the ideas and help.
first of all, osu!taiko and osu!mania targets are static. You press the keys once the dons/notes reach the drum/bottom row. That doesn't move in osu!taiko or osu!mania. osu!standard has circles, sliders, and spinners. that's it.
So he could have the notes/holders/spinners come from different directions and the targets can move during the song. Do you get this?
EDIT: also, on osu!diva, the targets change, moving across the screen. in this gamemode there is one location that moves per button.
and yes the keybinds can be osu!mania style.
EDIT 2: If you really doubt it, I'll make you see the good side. Don't hate on _Mee, P_lease.
Also,even if they are static, I already stated that they have their own specific SV manipulation, you didn't read it fully.
Have the targets move during the song is ultimately the worst thing you can ever ask for in a rhythm game. What I'm saying is: In standard, you can move your mouse and aim the target on your free will. However in a game mode where the targets move AND the circles have to be clicked at the same instance? That's too hard of a job for almost anybody to do. https://play.google.com/store/apps/deta ... estrel.BBV This game is very similar to this idea (except that it's on the phone and no usage of the keyboard) ,however the notes don't simply 'move around', but appear in random places, and that the notes don't simply stay in one place. This phone game is already more interesting than this idea that you have just proposed ;/
don't worry dj i don't hate ya, just saying facts that this 'game designer student' should know about.