forum
ESTi Remixed by NieN - OBLIVION (Rockin' Night Style)
posted
Total Posts
90
Mod by request:
[Hln's Easy]
01:20:883 (6) - new combo
01:39:394 (2) - IMO, either 1) add a note at next white tick, or 2) move this note to next white tick
01:42:798 (2) - ^
01:46:203 (2) - ^
[KIRBY Mix]
00:28:962 (1) ~ 00:34:919 (5) - personally I don't really find this section fitting the music...
01:10:132 (4) - IMO, this tiny jump breaks the flow of the stream
01:10:451 (7) - ^, yea, I suggest streamlining them
01:11:515 (1) ~ 01:14:493 (5) - (same as the first suggestion)
Whistle and finish attack!!! Lower the hitsound volume some notches and place them better. It's rather noisy.
[Sharon's]
00:20:451 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - these totally tricked me, I strongly suggest spacing them out...
00:52:791 (6) - one grid right
01:07:685 (6) - i suggest move this circle out
01:47:791 (6) - just personally don't like this...
I found some 1/16 notes appearing at seemingly unexpected places. This may be just me.
[Taiko]
Eh, I don't play taiko so I can't mod this.
But from what I can tell, this is a streamy map lol
Overall:
The difficulty spread is N I I, but the middle I is too hard to be a [Hard], as an intermediate diff between [Easy]/[Normal] and [Insane].
Do find some way to balance this mapset.
I am a bit reluctant to star this map, as my expectation was high.
But no worry, I will be watching this map regularly. I'll star when I think it's time.
[Hln's Easy]
01:20:883 (6) - new combo
01:39:394 (2) - IMO, either 1) add a note at next white tick, or 2) move this note to next white tick
01:42:798 (2) - ^
01:46:203 (2) - ^
[KIRBY Mix]
00:28:962 (1) ~ 00:34:919 (5) - personally I don't really find this section fitting the music...
01:10:132 (4) - IMO, this tiny jump breaks the flow of the stream
01:10:451 (7) - ^, yea, I suggest streamlining them
01:11:515 (1) ~ 01:14:493 (5) - (same as the first suggestion)
Whistle and finish attack!!! Lower the hitsound volume some notches and place them better. It's rather noisy.
[Sharon's]
00:20:451 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - these totally tricked me, I strongly suggest spacing them out...
00:52:791 (6) - one grid right
01:07:685 (6) - i suggest move this circle out
01:47:791 (6) - just personally don't like this...
I found some 1/16 notes appearing at seemingly unexpected places. This may be just me.
[Taiko]
Eh, I don't play taiko so I can't mod this.
But from what I can tell, this is a streamy map lol
Overall:
The difficulty spread is N I I, but the middle I is too hard to be a [Hard], as an intermediate diff between [Easy]/[Normal] and [Insane].
Do find some way to balance this mapset.
I am a bit reluctant to star this map, as my expectation was high.
But no worry, I will be watching this map regularly. I'll star when I think it's time.
irc mod. Star.
Red: You must fix this.
Blue: You'd better do sth with this imo.
Green: Just suggestions.
[Hln's Easy]
00:13:217 (4) - whistle at the start?
00:27:472 (1) - finish.
00:50:451 (1,2) - 不太好看。
01:35:345 (5) - nazi，下一格。
01:50:664 (5,6) - spacing.
[KIRBY Mix]
00:46:302 (8) - new combo
01:03:004 - 01:04:706 - break is too short, better to remove.
01:09:813 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - ....well a kirby mix.
01:20:876 (5,6,7,8) - what's this.
[Shalon's]
This diff has a kiai but other diffs not.
00:37:047 (5,1) - emm 1/4 jump?
01:25:345 (7,1) - too sudden for me. (don't have a "jump" feel)
[Taiko]
pretty nice.
Blue: You'd better do sth with this imo.
Green: Just suggestions.
[Hln's Easy]
00:13:217 (4) - whistle at the start?
00:27:472 (1) - finish.
00:50:451 (1,2) - 不太好看。
01:35:345 (5) - nazi，下一格。
01:50:664 (5,6) - spacing.
[KIRBY Mix]
00:46:302 (8) - new combo
01:03:004 - 01:04:706 - break is too short, better to remove.
01:09:813 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - ....well a kirby mix.
01:20:876 (5,6,7,8) - what's this.
[Shalon's]
This diff has a kiai but other diffs not.
00:37:047 (5,1) - emm 1/4 jump?
01:25:345 (7,1) - too sudden for me. (don't have a "jump" feel)
[Taiko]
pretty nice.
Topic Starter
thanks~yongtw123 wrote:
Mod by request:
[Hln's Easy]
01:20:883 (6) - new combo
01:39:394 (2) - IMO, either 1) add a note at next white tick, or 2) move this note to next white tick
01:42:798 (2) - ^
01:46:203 (2) - ^
All fixed
[KIRBY Mix]
00:28:962 (1) ~ 00:34:919 (5) - personally I don't really find this section fitting the music...
01:10:132 (4) - IMO, this tiny jump breaks the flow of the stream
01:10:451 (7) - ^, yea, I suggest streamlining them
01:11:515 (1) ~ 01:14:493 (5) - (same as the first suggestion)
pattern-> taken into consideration, the stream have been made into stright lines.
Whistle and finish attack!!! Lower the hitsound volume some notches and place them better. It's rather noisy. <- Fixed
[Sharon's]
00:20:451 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - these totally tricked me, I strongly suggest spacing them out...
00:52:791 (6) - one grid right
01:07:685 (6) - i suggest move this circle out
01:47:791 (6) - just personally don't like this...
I found some 1/16 notes appearing at seemingly unexpected places. This may be just me.
No 1/16 not even 1/8 O_O" fixed some
[Taiko]
Eh, I don't play taiko so I can't mod this.
But from what I can tell, this is a streamy map lol
Overall:
The difficulty spread is N I I, but the middle I is too hard to be a [Hard], as an intermediate diff between [Easy]/[Normal] and [Insane].
Do find some way to balance this mapset.
imo the kirby mix is just a hard and even [Sharon's] is somehow between hard and insane.
I am a bit reluctant to star this map, as my expectation was high.
But no worry, I will be watching this map regularly. I'll star when I think it's time.
NR's mod all fixed.
easy: no hitsound? tick rate 0.5?
kirby: no hitsounds? but its ok..
sharon:
no hitsound also?
00:43:217 - remove break?
taiko:
no comment. i dont mod them
theres always alace sensei to teach you guys hitsounds~
kirby: no hitsounds? but its ok..
sharon:
no hitsound also?
00:43:217 - remove break?
taiko:
no comment. i dont mod them
theres always alace sensei to teach you guys hitsounds~
Topic Starter
There's hitsound and hitsound file in the song~James wrote:
easy: no hitsound? tick rate 0.5?
kirby: no hitsounds? but its ok..
sharon:
no hitsound also?
00:43:217 - remove break?
taiko:
no comment. i dont mod them
theres always alace sensei to teach you guys hitsounds~
other fixed, thanks >_<
BUBBLED
Hmm, due to time constraints, I can't exactly map a completely new one, and the old version is just for the sake of it being old. x3 Before any possible hearts though, would it be possible to rename it [Kirby's Hard]? A difficulty name shouldn't warrant any massive recheck. Forgive my tardiness, I don't know if I'm being a douche or something.
wfm already did that so im going to bubble it again.
Cool map 
My apologies for being late.
I guess I won't point out spots of concern here, butl here's a spoilerbox if you'd still like to check it out:
Other than those, a fair map this is. I give you my star.
I guess I won't point out spots of concern here, butl here's a spoilerbox if you'd still like to check it out:
SPOILER
Kirby's Hard
hitsounds are a tiny bit too loud
Sharon's
00:42:366 (11) - almost offscreen
01:25:345 (7) - unexpected jump
(no kudosu)
hitsounds are a tiny bit too loud
Sharon's
00:42:366 (11) - almost offscreen
01:25:345 (7) - unexpected jump
(no kudosu)
Other than those, a fair map this is. I give you my star.
Request Accepted
A couple of nazi spacing and other stuffs
sorry for the bubble break
STAR!
A couple of nazi spacing and other stuffs
General
unused .osb file found, delete and full submit
Kirby's Hard
fix the tag "Starrokirby86" to "Starrodkirby86"
00:50:664 (6) - spacing issue
01:20:451 (4,5) - ^
01:22:153 (7,8) - ^
01:32:791 (2) - minor spacing issue
unused .osb file found, delete and full submit
Kirby's Hard
fix the tag "Starrokirby86" to "Starrodkirby86"
00:50:664 (6) - spacing issue
01:20:451 (4,5) - ^
01:22:153 (7,8) - ^
01:32:791 (2) - minor spacing issue
sorry for the bubble break
STAR!
Topic Starter
fixed~
i prefer offset 1716.
Sharon's:
01:32:886 (1) - : Hmm..It sound good, but I think it is confused that put it in blue tick with a jump... Well, it is just a complain :
01:52:460 (1) - : How about extend it to 01:55:758 and silent the end?
kirby's
01:52:460 (1) - : same o.o
01:32:886 (1) - : Hmm..It sound good, but I think it is confused that put it in blue tick with a jump... Well, it is just a complain :
01:52:460 (1) - : How about extend it to 01:55:758 and silent the end?
kirby's
01:52:460 (1) - : same o.o
[Hln's Easy]
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
01:52:354 (1) - This finish into this spinner sounds totally out of place.
[Kirby's Hard]
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
Use the same custom colours like the other difficulties? I highly suggest this.
01:09:162 (2,3,4) - This little stream is a bit hidden. Try to make it more visible.
[Sharon's]
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
[Taiko]
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
Slider velocity on a Taiko map should be at 1,4. Fix it and recheck all your sliders.
That's all, I guess. Popped for now.
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
01:52:354 (1) - This finish into this spinner sounds totally out of place.
[Kirby's Hard]
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
Use the same custom colours like the other difficulties? I highly suggest this.
01:09:162 (2,3,4) - This little stream is a bit hidden. Try to make it more visible.
[Sharon's]
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
[Taiko]
Add 1 second of Audio Lead-In at least and remove the unused Countdown.
Slider velocity on a Taiko map should be at 1,4. Fix it and recheck all your sliders.
That's all, I guess. Popped for now.
Topic Starter
All fixed except taiko's slider velocity as long as it isn't a must to be at 1.4 (This is not an authentic map) so it's my own choice to put this at 1.6.
Slider velocity on a Taiko map should be at 1,4. Fix it and recheck all your sliders. 100% No
mappers can pick what they want if the SV is reasonable (1.2~1.6 should be fine)
if 1.4 is the rule, we should stop taiko mappers to use any custom SV speed
mappers can pick what they want if the SV is reasonable (1.2~1.6 should be fine)
if 1.4 is the rule, we should stop taiko mappers to use any custom SV speed
As we newly discussed about that here, we no longer force 1.4 to other mappers. We only recommend it. If SV isn't too high or low, it would be ok. I'm very sorry about those confusions.
Topic Starter
My preferential choice is 1.6 while sometimes 1.4 and 1.8 =P
Anyways, you forget to remove the unused Countdown on every difficulty except the Taiko one.
Aaaand... Add the same custom colours on Kirby's Hard, please.
I will give your bubble back after that.
EDIT: Re-Bubbled~
good map~
should the BPM all the same on every diff.? I mean, kirby's is different...
Yes, BPM should be the same to all diffs.abalee wrote:
should the BPM all the same on every diff.? I mean, kirby's is different...
But on Kirby's It's 70.500, So if 70.5 x 2 = 141 = same as other diffs, i think?
It was just like 141/2
You can achieve the same effect by halving the slider speed instead of the BPM (except you get more ticks) so i don't see a reason as to why that would be ok, not going to pop the bubble without actually checking the map since i'm taking a break, but just wanted to comment on what you saidorioncomet wrote:
Yes, BPM should be the same to all diffs.abalee wrote:
should the BPM all the same on every diff.? I mean, kirby's is different...
But on Kirby's It's 70.500, So if 70.5 x 2 = 141 = same as other diffs, i think?
It was just like 141/2
mapper changed.
This works I suppose.
Ehh already ranked.....
sorry and grats ^__^
sorry and grats ^__^
Ooh yay, grats~
plss add the video
bit late for that nowr3yn41d0 wrote:
plss add the video
<3 this map though
와 이 노래 내가 정말 좋아하는 노래인데 ㅎ