no comment = fixed / changed
I also silenced some extended sliders in Pati's diff.
Asonate
Asonate wrote:
hey, random mod
[Insane][Hard]
- 00:08:022 (4,5,6) - maybe have all of these have same DS to each other? Like this the 4,6 overlap looks somewhat off in perspective to 5. (while i agree that 00:08:551 (1) - should have higher spacing, nicely done!)
- 00:33:257 (3,4) - blanketnaziing, please dont punch me ;w;
- 00:37:316 (3) - as stupid as it sounds, maybe Nc this, or make the "restart" in the chorus somehow differentiated to these 00:36:963 (1,2) - I see your point, but having the NC on the vocal start would just fit the best. Also, how is the chorus not any different. :v
- 00:48:787 (1,2) - damn, these are parallel, looks awesome
- 01:01:669 (4,5,6) - while it hits the song pretty well, a singletappattern with low angles like here could cause trouble for less experienced players. not saying you should change it, but maybe get a few testplays from your targetaudience if you havent yet :3 Well it's not that hard even for the target audience. At least they have an acute angle from 6 to 7.
- 01:14:552 - maybe make that hittable? feels so empty to me
[Advanced]
- 00:12:787 - this timing section isnt needed, right? might as well delete it if its possible for that to become an issue later on
- 00:23:198 (3,4,5,6,7) - is it intentional for 00:23:375 (5,6) - to be 1.3 DS apart? It's higher because of the stack. Enable stacks in editor to see it.
- 00:42:081 - i think that "yes" should definitely be made hittable, it being passive on a sliderend somewhat drowns the jumpy feel it creates
- 01:14:552 - same as in the insane :3
[Normal]
- Why not "Normal" ? (just wondering, not saying its wrong xD) Because the current Normal is not suitable for very new players as 1/1 spam can be hard without any breaks.
- Similarly to Adnvanced, why didnt you go with "Easy" here (i have a feeling as to why, just wanna know if im right haha)
WOOOO, awesome song, awesome mapset, take a star and good luck!
Sieg
Sieg wrote:
Hallo Privet
General
[]Hard
- Metadata: Not sure about ♪ in the title, apparently there is no in Hanatan's version? http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm26120993
- Hitsounding: well, I don't see any complains on this in the thread so take this as personal preference\get targeted opinions on this. Apart from finish sound everything else seems way to weak especially soft clap you used, I
don'tcan barely hear the difference with claps and without. Made the current one louder.
[]Insane
- 00:07:845 (3,4) - You can stress strong beats in the music 00:08:022 () - 00:08:375 () - with strong (clickable) objects here https://puu.sh/r1Huw/b836dfbf71.png I don't any reasons to avoid that. <- also can be done in advanced Wanna keep the current one in Advanced as the whole part is focused on vocals so changing it would make it difficult for beginners.
[]
- 00:08:022 (4,5,6) - jump 00:08:198 (5,6) - can be extended a bit to better stress strong beats https://puu.sh/r1HMj/0ede96170a.png
- 00:09:610 (8,9) - Spacing is too low, even slider-slider 00:08:551 (1,2) - uses 1.5x While here on strong triplet 00:09:787 (9) - you use 1x You can try something like https://puu.sh/r1HS6/8ab28dd158.png Used 1.5x with a bit different flow.
- 00:11:728 (2,3,4,5,6) - Pace of DS extend can be greater? the music kind of support for it, tho it mostly personal vision. <- compare intensity with 00:33:963 (1,2,3,4) - or 00:36:963 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) -
- 00:14:198 (1) - stream part until 00:25:492 (1) - Cool, but you can try to improve this part by spreading it across the playfield more, atm it's quite concentrated in the center https://puu.sh/r1I5P/d195f8da9d.png
- 00:45:610 (3,4) - since this is noticeable stanza in music it would be better to stress at as separated pattern not as part of previous. For example https://puu.sh/r1Igd/beffc3ed86.png nc is optional
- 01:11:022 (1,2,3,4) - they can use ds extending structure, since all the starting beats are strong in the music and emphasized with strong hitsounds in difficulty, also this is kind of climax of the song.
I also silenced some extended sliders in Pati's diff.