Hej, jeg vil gerne have et kondom! :^))))
(Trying to give this mod a "BN"-ish mindset (For BN application test practice >.<), so please help me by responding with a decent explanation as to why you agree/disagree to my suggestions :3 Thanks <3)
COLOURS:
Color coding:
The Widescreen support is inconsistent (As an example, it's not on in Racist's Easy, but is on in the beginner), either have it on on all diffs or don't have it at all
Consider adding "Commercial" and "Condom" to the tags, not everyone is Swedish :^)
Kondom.se might be the place it's from, but according to the ranking criteria, websites do NOT count as a source, please remove it from the source
The rest seems on point, so I think that part's good to go. (The spinner not following sound is probably gonna be discussed, but be stubborn, thank :^))
00:02:348 (2,1) - Some blankets that could look better would be stuff like this, since it's basically the only easy-to-make aesthetic in a beginner
00:06:188 (2,3,1) - Small DS inconsistency, you should especially move the 1 a bit closer.
00:18:668 (3,4) - There's more :3
^ Look into every non-1x DS in this map :3
00:27:308 - Add a circle here and start the spinner on 00:28:268 - (End it on the same spot) It feels a bit odd not to add that extra note don't ya think? ;o
Final thoughts on Beginner:
Look into EVERY DS inconsistency (even if it's by like 0,05x) and change it, and consider easy-to-make blankets like the first one
00:11:948 (2) - To follow the NC-per-measure thing you've been doing, NC this as well.
00:13:388 (1,2) - Odd emphasis since the slider end is on the downbeat at 00:13:868 -... consider a 4-way reverse from 00:13:868 - to 00:15:308 - or something else to mix it up, let yer imagination go wild yo (Basically just make sure that beat is clickable)
00:15:788 (3,1) - Switch NC, since the 3 is on the downbeat.
00:17:708 (2) - DS inconsistency
Final thoughts on Easy:
Like on the Beginner, fix the DS inconsistencies that vary by more than 0,05x (There are quite a few!), and try to fix the emphasis issue stated if you agree
00:08:108 (4) - NC for pre-measure emphasis
00:23:948 (1) - Remove NC, I don't really feel like it serves a purpose (If anything it makes the stack harder)
00:27:308 (4) - NC? Downbeat op :3
Final thoughts on Normal:
Some NC inconsistencies, that you should look into (There are probably more that I didn't spot), and some downbeat issues
00:03:068 (4,1,2) - There's a weird overlap on 2 and 4, and also, the notes before 4 are overmapping imo, since they don't really follow the music all too well (Maybe a slider from 00:02:348 (1) - to 00:02:708 -, a note on 00:02:828 - (Which you have atm)
00:05:708 (1,2) - Switch NC, 2 is on the downbeat, and following the pattern with NC's here doesn't really fit imo
00:07:388 (4) - Maybe follow the "double clap" sound and make a note on 7:388 and start the slider on 00:07:628 - ?
00:22:028 (4,5,1) - Consider giving this a turn, so the flow isn't linear.
00:24:908 (5,6,1) - Odd transition, linear + lower spacing near the end is odd to play for a typical Hard player, consider a small change
Final thoughts on Hard gigglez, kondom, hard, gigglez:
I feel that this diff has a few pretty messy sections that would benefit from some tiny reworks. (I explained stuff like awkward overlaps and overmapping, look into this over the entire diff and try to self-mod a few parts )
Final thoughts on all:
On lower diffs, fix the DS issues, and fix emphasis issues on Hard/normal, and get some more mods and you should be able to push this forward ^^ Good luck <3
(Trying to give this mod a "BN"-ish mindset (For BN application test practice >.<), so please help me by responding with a decent explanation as to why you agree/disagree to my suggestions :3 Thanks <3)
COLOURS:
Color coding:
Color coding
Unrankable if unchanged
Normal Suggestion/Comment
Strong Suggestion
Normal Suggestion/Comment
Strong Suggestion
General
The Widescreen support is inconsistent (As an example, it's not on in Racist's Easy, but is on in the beginner), either have it on on all diffs or don't have it at all
Consider adding "Commercial" and "Condom" to the tags, not everyone is Swedish :^)
Kondom.se might be the place it's from, but according to the ranking criteria, websites do NOT count as a source, please remove it from the source
The rest seems on point, so I think that part's good to go. (The spinner not following sound is probably gonna be discussed, but be stubborn, thank :^))
Beginner Collab
It doesn't really make sense that the HP is higher than on the Easy, reduce it to 2 or 2,5 plz :3 <300:02:348 (2,1) - Some blankets that could look better would be stuff like this, since it's basically the only easy-to-make aesthetic in a beginner
00:06:188 (2,3,1) - Small DS inconsistency, you should especially move the 1 a bit closer.
00:18:668 (3,4) - There's more :3
^ Look into every non-1x DS in this map :3
00:27:308 - Add a circle here and start the spinner on 00:28:268 - (End it on the same spot) It feels a bit odd not to add that extra note don't ya think? ;o
Final thoughts on Beginner:
Look into EVERY DS inconsistency (even if it's by like 0,05x) and change it, and consider easy-to-make blankets like the first one
Racist's Easy
00:06:188 (3,4) - Aesthetically, it looks a bit weird that these are not a "Ctrl+J" type pattern.00:11:948 (2) - To follow the NC-per-measure thing you've been doing, NC this as well.
00:13:388 (1,2) - Odd emphasis since the slider end is on the downbeat at 00:13:868 -... consider a 4-way reverse from 00:13:868 - to 00:15:308 - or something else to mix it up, let yer imagination go wild yo (Basically just make sure that beat is clickable)
00:15:788 (3,1) - Switch NC, since the 3 is on the downbeat.
00:17:708 (2) - DS inconsistency
Final thoughts on Easy:
Like on the Beginner, fix the DS inconsistencies that vary by more than 0,05x (There are quite a few!), and try to fix the emphasis issue stated if you agree
Normal
00:04:268 - A lot of downbeats are skipped, like this one, where it's not clickable; It adds odd flow and feels weird while playing, consider changing this and other similar ones (Seems consistent in the way you're doing it, but in some cases it throws the players off a lot more than it should)00:08:108 (4) - NC for pre-measure emphasis
00:23:948 (1) - Remove NC, I don't really feel like it serves a purpose (If anything it makes the stack harder)
00:27:308 (4) - NC? Downbeat op :3
Final thoughts on Normal:
Some NC inconsistencies, that you should look into (There are probably more that I didn't spot), and some downbeat issues
Hard
00:00:428 (1,2,3) - The emphasis here would be slider to slider to note, since you go on the off-beat with the slider the way you're doing it now, which flows oddly imo00:03:068 (4,1,2) - There's a weird overlap on 2 and 4, and also, the notes before 4 are overmapping imo, since they don't really follow the music all too well (Maybe a slider from 00:02:348 (1) - to 00:02:708 -, a note on 00:02:828 - (Which you have atm)
00:05:708 (1,2) - Switch NC, 2 is on the downbeat, and following the pattern with NC's here doesn't really fit imo
00:07:388 (4) - Maybe follow the "double clap" sound and make a note on 7:388 and start the slider on 00:07:628 - ?
00:22:028 (4,5,1) - Consider giving this a turn, so the flow isn't linear.
00:24:908 (5,6,1) - Odd transition, linear + lower spacing near the end is odd to play for a typical Hard player, consider a small change
Final thoughts on Hard gigglez, kondom, hard, gigglez:
I feel that this diff has a few pretty messy sections that would benefit from some tiny reworks. (I explained stuff like awkward overlaps and overmapping, look into this over the entire diff and try to self-mod a few parts )
havkz's Condom
Got nothing of importance here, nice jobFinal thoughts on all:
On lower diffs, fix the DS issues, and fix emphasis issues on Hard/normal, and get some more mods and you should be able to push this forward ^^ Good luck <3