Hello again everyone! \o/
I see that the main points of Comfort are to provide both
challenge and the feel of
franticness to both fit the songs nature whilst still being appealing to players. I'll address my concerns being someone who has played this a bunch of times and what felt -fitting- to my eyes and what did not and just some other points.
FORMATTING[Comfort]
00:02:895 (3,4) - 00:06:228 (1,2) - 00:09:561 (1,2,3) - The last one here has a 1/4 slider and a note, I'm not sure if you did this by accident, or if someone else told you to do this, but its a bit out of place after the last two! Also at the end of the map all 3 times this sound comes up is also the same note + 1/2 slider unlike the case mentioned \o/
00:13:936 (1,2,1,2,1,2,3) - Fort mentioned this jump pattern before, and I do feel as though his point is valid -in a sense- however the justification is also valid. I however propose that each of the notes here are of
increasing spacing starting off fairly normal (say 1.5x) and ending at the speed you have, this way the player can adjust easier to the high spacing instead of it coming off suddenly, whilst -still- showing that there will be high spacing as you wish to show here. If you wish to justify it with 00:12:895 (1,2,3,4) - this pattern being high, well this pattern isn't really a good indicator that there will be high spacing later, as it comes off too fast for the player to really notice and it is also a burst jump.
tl;dr make the pattern increasing spacing instead of all high spacing (also it makes it feel more like a "transitional" stage to the next part of the map)
00:17:270 (2,1) - The short slider here is 1/2 but there isn't actually any 1/2 sound here! I very clearly hear 4 1/6 notes, not a 1/4. Something like the ahead screenshot can show a way to add in the 1/6, as it keeps the near-but-not-perfect flow.
(as addition to above, see 00:23:728 (1,2,3,4,5) - that has same sound but you mapped the 1/6 here)
FORMATTINGI would LOVE, and I mean LOVE if the 4-note star pattern here 00:17:895 (3,4,5,6,7) - started at this sound 00:17:999 - instead of at 00:18:103 - since 00:17:999 - to 00:18:311 - all share the same kind of sounds and seem like they should be in the same pattern, not starting on a slider end, and should all share a click. If you shift the notes back 1/2 it should work fine, and also allow 00:18:415 (7) - to be emphasised differently since its a more bassy sound that doesn't really fit being in the same pattern as the last 4 sounds.
00:26:645 - This sound is completely inaudible if there is one, I'd see if you can come up with a change here where this sound is left out as there is no sound here, or least clickable sound.
FORMATTING00:29:040 (5,6) - Blank- *shot* I'm just jokin with ya, dw about these petty blankets
00:30:603 (2,3) - Well I can hear the 1/2 here, but I'm just gonna say it feels more hectic but still more logical and fun to play at the same time if this is 1/6. 1/2 just ruins the mood when the 1/6 is quite audible even at fullspeed, and there are a lot of sliders around here.
Small suggestion, but
I feel as though 00:34:457 (1,2,3,4) - would be more enjoyable if the slider was removed and 4 spaced a lot, as the sounds here are punchy and the slider here removes that "punch" from both 3 and 4. Just my 2 cents tho, its fine as is.
Another small suggestion, but there is a faint 1/6 sound on 00:42:895 (3) - so you can turn this into a 1/6 repeat. Since there are two sets of 1/6 sounds here you can either two repeats, a repeat then 4 1/6 notes, or a 7 note 1/6 stream.
God I'm trying to make you map all the 1/6 what am I doing kill me xd
00:55:186 (2,3,1) - Due to the quite jagged movement here, the NCd slider is actually a lot less nice to get to than it looks, since it requires not only extreme-angle snapping from slider 3 to it which breaks its curve, but the actual NCed slider is
really close compared to the distance of 2 and 3. All I can say is that it'd feel better, at least to me, if the NCed slider was further, due to the fact that the harsh angle here would work better with a larger spacing and not a smaller one.
FORMATTING(00:56:020 (3,4,5) - going to agree with Fort on this one, having a lowering spacing per slider here would make 00:56:645 (1) - more punchy (gah i say that word too much) whilst providing a smoother transition to the lowered spacing of 00:56:436 (5,1) - . Likewise, you can make the sliders -really low spaced- in order to make 00:56:436 (5,1) - seem a much larger jump, thus emphasising the sound at the start of 1 more)
00:59:978 (1,2) - Slight overlap trigger LOL dont judge miii
01:16:228 (4,5,6,7,1) - I know I said this once some time ago but I have to repeat, can you possibly make this instead of increasin spacin on the notes, make it decreasin? Goin with the pitches here would make most players feel more in sync with the music, and I'm sure that's an effect you want!
FORMATTINGDon't see all the h8, I like this map. I hope my few suggestions for this diff were detailed/justified enough for ya Shiirn!
[Extra]
Ok lets get this start consistent just to avoid DQ bait
00:03:728 (2,3,4,5) - and 00:10:395 (5,6,7,8) - should be same spacing
00:04:978 (1,2,3,4,5) - Both other cases of this sound had
way lower spacing so if you want to keep this DS increase it can't be so much higher!
k thats it for there
(00:24:665 (5,6,1,1,2,3,1,1) - someone tell me why I CANT READ THIS hahah i succ)
00:27:895 (1,2,3,4) - Try replacing this with a single 1/6 hold?
Ok people, take a note here, THIS is how you map true sliders -> 00:36:228 (6) - love it
00:59:665 - Is it just me or is there a sound here? How about making a 1/2 hold at that point instead of 00:59:561 - ? Seems to encapture the hold sound nicer, and you can have 00:59:874 - this sound on the tail!
01:23:311 (1,1) - xd move second slider 5 pixels to the right aesthetics xdxd
[Tenga- Ongaku Insane]
I would try to not ignore 00:38:832 - this sound here, I mentioned this in Shiirn's star pattern afaik. How about a 5 note stream here instead from 00:38:728 - to 00:39:145 - ?
00:46:020 (1,2,3) - Little thing but can ya make the distance between the sliderbody of 1 and 2 a little bigger? Like the distance in the blanket shown ahead. Just looks a little neater is all \o/
Love it! Keep it up!
[Hype(r)]
gr8 diff
If u want me 2 check the lower diffs just ask. Hopefully this is the last time I feel like I need to say anything tho \o/
Good luck to you blah blah YOU GOT THIS!
Your friendly neighborhood friend,
Shape