forum

Reol - No title [Taiko|OsuMania]

posted
Total Posts
63
show more
CommandoBlack
Looking at KcHecKa's HD

Judging by 00:24:147: 00:21:747 is missing a note, 00:21:897 has one note to many, & The hold at 00:21:897 is too long. Should end here 00:22:197.
01:04:647 is missing a note.
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

CommandoBlack wrote:

Looking at KcHecKa's HD

Judging by 00:24:147: 00:21:747 is missing a note add note
00:21:897 has one note to many Delete note
The hold at 00:21:897 is too long. Should end here 00:22:197. Fix
01:04:647 is missing a note. For break point here. no change
Thank you for mod! :)
Raveille


tfw idk any of the modders that modded this map lmao (no offense to anyone, just funny) ok serious mode activated!

|1|2|3|4|

EZ
00:05:997 (5997|3,6447|3) - just a suggestion to move to 2
00:35:997 (35997|0) - why does the hold note only go until 00:36:897 - instead of 00:37:047 - ?
same goes for many hold notes afterwards
quite inconsistent on the holds, check them again

NM
00:02:397 (2397|2) - double
00:03:597 - double
00:19:197 (19197|1,19197|0,19347|0,19497|2,19497|3,19647|3) - no use for the 1 and 4 jack here
00:48:597 (48597|1,48747|1) - why the jack here? a little out of place
01:21:447 (81447|1,81597|1) - no use for this too
01:27:597 (87597|0,87597|1,87597|3) - ??????? why triple hold? end off with just one of these in lane 2.

HD
00:05:847 (5847|0,5997|0) - no need jack here :<
00:09:447 (9447|3,9597|3) - this too, 00:09:447 (9447|3) - to 3
00:23:697 - missing hold
00:26:097 - ^
01:06:597 (66597|1,66597|0,66747|1,66747|0,66897|1,66897|0,67047|1,67047|0) - WutFace
01:27:597 (87597|2,87597|3) - only one hold note needed at 3.

A little inconsistent in some jacks and holds. Overall, pretty ok.

All the best :D we need more reol
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

Raveille wrote:



tfw idk any of the modders that modded this map lmao (no offense to anyone, just funny) ok serious mode activated!

|1|2|3|4|

EZ
00:05:997 (5997|3,6447|3) - just a suggestion to move to 2 fix
00:35:997 (35997|0) - why does the hold note only go until 00:36:897 - instead of 00:37:047 - ? 
same goes for many hold notes afterwards many hold notes changed for keep Consistency. - for example, 00:31:197 end this hold notes at 00:32:097
quite inconsistent on the holds, check them again ok~

NM
00:02:397 (2397|2) - double
00:03:597 - double
00:19:197 (19197|1,19197|0,19347|0,19497|2,19497|3,19647|3) - no use for the 1 and 4 jack here
00:48:597 (48597|1,48747|1) - why the jack here? a little out of place
01:21:447 (81447|1,81597|1) - no use for this too
01:27:597 (87597|0,87597|1,87597|3) - ??????? why triple hold? end off with just one of these in lane 2.

all fixed~

HD
00:05:847 (5847|0,5997|0) - no need jack here :<
00:09:447 (9447|3,9597|3) - this too, 00:09:447 (9447|3) - to 3
00:23:697 - missing hold
00:26:097 - ^
01:06:597 (66597|1,66597|0,66747|1,66747|0,66897|1,66897|0,67047|1,67047|0) - WutFace The mystery((((;゚Д゚))))
01:27:597 (87597|2,87597|3) - only one hold note needed at 3.

all fixed :)

A little inconsistent in some jacks and holds. Overall, pretty ok.

All the best :D we need more reol
Thank you for mod!! :)
Eeveesenpai_4_u
Taiko 8-)


Kantann is okay but Hp 7 is a bit miep

Futsuu sup

Muzukashii sup

ONI

01:08:697 (405,406,407) - don don kat
01:08:997 (408) - don
01:09:222 (410,411) - kat don
01:09:447 (412) - kat
01:09:597 (413) - don
01:09:747 (414) - kat
01:10:347 (417) - kat
01:10:647 - why don`t add a kat?
01:10:797 (419,420) - don kat
01:17:547 (455,456,457) - kat don kat
01:17:997 (458,459,460) - why don´t a triple kat ? (you do not Need to do that)
Inner Oni

General:
00:02:397 - idk why you use a done for that but ok .-. i would use always a kat on that sound but miep

00:03:447 (4) - this filler should be a kat
00:04:647 - same
00:06:147 (14) - i would use a kat here
00:08:247 (22) - this filler should be a kat
00:09:147 (25,26,27,28) - kat kat kat don
to the streams i don´t to say snything .-.
p.s. you shouldn`t focus on the vocal .. this is taiko not Standard ^^
but nice; I hope this get ranked :)
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

Eeveesenpai_4_u wrote:

Taiko 8-)


Kantann is okay but Hp 7 is a bit miep

Futsuu sup

Muzukashii sup

ONI

01:08:697 (405,406,407) - don don kat
01:08:997 (408) - don
01:09:222 (410,411) - kat don
01:09:447 (412) - kat
01:09:597 (413) - don
01:09:747 (414) - kat
01:10:347 (417) - kat
01:10:647 - why don`t add a kat?
01:10:797 (419,420) - don kat
01:17:547 (455,456,457) - kat don kat
01:17:997 (458,459,460) - why don´t a triple kat ? (you do not Need to do that)
Inner Oni

General:
00:02:397 - idk why you use a done for that but ok .-. i would use always a kat on that sound but miep

00:03:447 (4) - this filler should be a kat
00:04:647 - same
00:06:147 (14) - i would use a kat here
00:08:247 (22) - this filler should be a kat
00:09:147 (25,26,27,28) - kat kat kat don
to the streams i don´t to say snything .-.
p.s. you shouldn`t focus on the vocal .. this is taiko not Standard ^^
but nice; I hope this get ranked :)
Thank you for suggestion :)
MrDorian
Helloo~~
KcHecKa's HD
00:12:747- there is sound
00:13:797- ^
00:16:347- ^
00:21:597 (21597|2) - from there to 00:26:097 (26097|2) - should be notes, like in previous part. It is the same "part" of the songs, so I have no idea why there isn't the missing notes
00:49:572 (49572|2,49722|3,49872|3,50022|2) - ghost notes
00:57:297 (57297|2) - move to 2, because it wasn't used for long time
00:58:947 (58947|0,59022|1,59097|2) - it's same as 01:08:397 (68397|1,68397|0,68472|2,68547|1,68547|0) - so add missing notes
sakajun's NM
00:02:397 (2397|2) - same sound as 00:02:847 (2847|3,2847|1) - so add note
00:50:247 (50247|1,50322|2) - ctrl+h this, move first note to 4 and move hold to 2
If is useful, don't kds
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

MrDorian wrote:

Helloo~~
KcHecKa's HD
00:12:747- there is sound add note.
00:13:797- ^ ^
00:16:347- ^ ^
00:21:597 (21597|2) - from there to 00:26:097 (26097|2) - should be notes, like in previous part. It is the same "part" of the songs, so I have no idea why there isn't the missing notes
00:49:572 (49572|2,49722|3,49872|3,50022|2) - ghost notes Delete.
00:57:297 (57297|2) - move to 2, because it wasn't used for long time ok
00:58:947 (58947|0,59022|1,59097|2) - it's same as 01:08:397 (68397|1,68397|0,68472|2,68547|1,68547|0) - so add missing notes
sakajun's NM
00:02:397 (2397|2) - same sound as 00:02:847 (2847|3,2847|1) - so add note ok
00:50:247 (50247|1,50322|2) - ctrl+h this, move first note to 4 and move hold to 2 ok
If is useful, don't kds
Thank you for mod! :)
Staravia
from my 25min queue
0 left; 3 right
if i tell you to move but i don't add a comment, it's because it feels more natural to play imo

kchecka's hard
00:07:647 (7647|1) - to 0 and 00:07:797 (7797|0) - to 1
00:08:097 (8097|0) - to 3
00:12:147 (12147|2,12147|3) - ctrl+left
00:13:197 (13197|3) - to 2
00:14:097 - i would remove 1
00:21:897 (21897|1) - i think here doesn't feel that good to play imo, maybe try this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4978029
00:24:297 - ^
00:23:697 (23697|1) - i would move to 0 and add dot at 1
00:26:397 - add at 1
00:27:297 (27297|0) - move to 1
00:28:497 (28497|1) - hold for 1 beat
00:28:797 - remove 3, i don't think u need 2 dots for bass drum, not consistent with map
00:31:047 (31047|1) - to 1
00:32:097 - add at 1
00:33:297 - add at 3
00:34:347 - add at 3
00:34:497 (34497|2) - to 1
00:35:997 (35997|1) - to 0
00:37:197 (37197|2,37347|3) - ctrl+g and 00:37:497 (37497|0,37497|1) - ctrl+right
00:37:797 (37797|2) - hold for a beat
00:38:097 - i would remove a dot
00:39:297 (39297|2,39297|3) - transform to dots
00:41:397 (41397|2,41397|3) - i would remove a slider
00:43:047 - turn 1 to slider maybe
00:45:447 - i notice you are not focusing on vocal here, i think it would be nice imo but its up to you if u wanna change
01:02:097 (62097|1,62097|2) - ctrl+left
01:08:247 (68247|2) - to 3
01:23:997 - i think the difficulty is too easy at here for the fade out, i might make it only a slider here 01:27:597 - and i mightdo this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4978064
sorry i only have time for 1 diff :(
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

Staravia wrote:

from my 25min queue
0 left; 3 right
if i tell you to move but i don't add a comment, it's because it feels more natural to play imo

kchecka's hard
00:07:647 (7647|1) - to 0 and 00:07:797 (7797|0) - to 1
00:08:097 (8097|0) - to 3
00:12:147 (12147|2,12147|3) - ctrl+left
00:13:197 (13197|3) - to 2
00:14:097 - i would remove 1
00:21:897 (21897|1) - i think here doesn't feel that good to play imo, maybe try this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4978029
00:24:297 - ^
00:23:697 (23697|1) - i would move to 0 and add dot at 1
00:26:397 - add at 1
00:27:297 (27297|0) - move to 1
00:28:497 (28497|1) - hold for 1 beat
00:28:797 - remove 3, i don't think u need 2 dots for bass drum, not consistent with map
00:31:047 (31047|1) - to 1
00:32:097 - add at 1 Nope. following to vocal here.
00:33:297 - add at 3^
00:34:347 - add at 3
00:34:497 (34497|2) - to 1
00:35:997 (35997|1) - to 0
00:37:197 (37197|2,37347|3) - ctrl+g and 00:37:497 (37497|0,37497|1) - ctrl+right
00:37:797 (37797|2) - hold for a beat
00:38:097 - i would remove a dot
00:39:297 (39297|2,39297|3) - transform to dots
00:41:397 (41397|2,41397|3) - i would remove a slider
00:43:047 - turn 1 to slider maybe
00:45:447 - i notice you are not focusing on vocal here, i think it would be nice imo but its up to you if u wanna change
01:02:097 (62097|1,62097|2) - ctrl+left
01:08:247 (68247|2) - to 3
01:23:997 - i think the difficulty is too easy at here for the fade out, i might make it only a slider here 01:27:597 - and i mightdo this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4978064 I tryed https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4978689
sorry i only have time for 1 diff :( okok :)
Thank you for mod :)
toara_fict
Hi. via #Modreqs

[ General]
  1. BGをずらしてあげましょう :3
    現在の状態だとBGの女の子が写ってないので

    Editで Fire -> Open .osu in Notepad を開いて約40行目の
    [Events]
    //Background and Video events
    0,0,"BG1.jpg",0,0
    の数値を
    [Events]
    //Background and Video events
    0,0,"BG1.jpg",0,40

    くらいにすると このように 女の子が写ります :3
    *ワイドとワイドではないのとでは見え方が少し異なるので微調整は自分でお願いします~
  2. Inner Oni の Widescreen support はミスかな?で外れてないので一応
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Kantan]
  1. SV 1.10 -> 1.20 (今は新しいルールとかでokになってたらスミマセンになりますが確か1.2 or 1.4 BPMによっては1.00がテンプレだった気がする )
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Futsuu]
  1. SV 1.10 -> 1.20 ( Kantan to onazi desu :3 )
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Muzukashii]
  1. なんかFutsuuとのdiff差が気になる(ような)

  2. 00:11:397 (24) - delete ( Muzuだしサビじゃないし単発の4 2でいいかなあって )

  3. 00:14:247 (38) - delete ( 上と似たような感じです )

  4. 00:19:347 (62) - move 00:19:647 (63) - & 00:19:947 - delete ( 00:19:197 (61) - ここから ddd kkk よりも d ddk k のほうがいい気がしました )

  5. 00:27:747 (95) - move 00:28:047 (96) - ( 上と同じだけど00:28:347 (98) - ここは消さないでd ddkdkでいい感じになるんじゃないかな?)

  6. 00:29:547 (104) - move 00:29:847 (105) - にして 00:29:697 (104) - ここがkddddになるけどそれをkdkdk or dkdkk ? (kdkdk or dkdkkの部分は自分の音の拾い方でどっちかにしていただければ :3 )

  7. 00:31:197 (112) - move 00:31:047 (112) - ( follow Vo. 00:32:247 (116) - 00:33:447 (122) - 中略 00:45:447 (182) - こっちはVocalに沿ってあるので)

  8. 00:35:847 (134) - 00:40:797 (157) - ^

  9. 01:07:497 (300) - move 01:06:597 (296) - ? ( 完全な主観です 01:07:947 (303) - ~ 01:09:597 (312) - この辺見てこうしたほうがいいかなあって思いました )
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Oni]
  1. 01:01:872 (359) - change k & 01:02:247 (363) - add note here ? ( 00:52:647 (300) - こっち置いてるのと ここにadd noteしたらkdddkよりkkddkのほうがいいかなあって思いました )
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Inner Oni]
  1. 00:31:047 (190) - ここからFinishの配色がバラバラな気がします ( 特に00:32:247 (198) - 00:37:047 (231) - 00:41:847 (266) - )なので00:32:247 (198) -はDでいいかなあ・・・

  2. 00:49:572 (325) - 00:49:722 (326) - Delete 繋げるような音はないと思います_(:3JL

  3. 01:02:247 - add d & 01:02:397 (423) - change K ( 00:52:647 (350,351) - ここと同じでいいと思います )

  4. 統一性がなんかないかなあ・・・って思いました
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

toara_fict wrote:

Hi. via #Modreqs

[ General]
  1. BGをずらしてあげましょう :3
    現在の状態だとBGの女の子が写ってないので

    Editで Fire -> Open .osu in Notepad を開いて約40行目の
    [Events]
    //Background and Video events
    0,0,"BG1.jpg",0,0
    の数値を
    [Events]
    //Background and Video events
    0,0,"BG1.jpg",0,40

    くらいにすると このように 女の子が写ります :3
    *ワイドとワイドではないのとでは見え方が少し異なるので微調整は自分でお願いします~
    BGの配慮は全く考えていませんでした…ありがとうございます!
  2. Inner Oni の Widescreen support はミスかな?で外れてないので一応
fix

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Kantan]
  1. SV 1.10 -> 1.20 (今は新しいルールとかでokになってたらスミマセンになりますが確か1.2 or 1.4 BPMによっては1.00がテンプレだった気がする )
ガイドラインは1.00 or 1.20のようですね。1.20に直しました。

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Futsuu]
  1. SV 1.10 -> 1.20 ( Kantan to onazi desu :3 )
Kantanと同じです :3
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Muzukashii]
  1. なんかFutsuuとのdiff差が気になる(ような)確かに難しく作りすぎた感が…^^;

  2. 00:11:397 (24) - delete ( Muzuだしサビじゃないし単発の4 2でいいかなあって ) fix

  3. 00:14:247 (38) - delete ( 上と似たような感じです ) fix

  4. 00:19:347 (62) - move 00:19:647 (63) - & 00:19:947 - delete ( 00:19:197 (61) - ここから ddd kkk よりも d ddk k のほうがいい気がしました ) fix

  5. 00:27:747 (95) - move 00:28:047 (96) - ( 上と同じだけど00:28:347 (98) - ここは消さないでd ddkdkでいい感じになるんじゃないかな?) fix

  6. 00:29:547 (104) - move 00:29:847 (105) - にして 00:29:697 (104) - ここがkddddになるけどそれをkdkdk or dkdkk ? (kdkdk or dkdkkの部分は自分の音の拾い方でどっちかにしていただければ :3 ) kddddではなくk kddの形にしました。

  7. 00:31:197 (112) - move 00:31:047 (112) - ( follow Vo. 00:32:247 (116) - 00:33:447 (122) - 中略 00:45:447 (182) - こっちはVocalに沿ってあるので)vocalに合わせるため00:31:347にdを置きました。and fix

  8. 00:35:847 (134) - 00:40:797 (157) - ^ fix

  9. 01:07:497 (300) - move 01:06:597 (296) - ? ( 完全な主観です 01:07:947 (303) - ~ 01:09:597 (312) - この辺見てこうしたほうがいいかなあって思いました )dに変えてから移動しました。
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Oni]
  1. 01:01:872 (359) - change k & 01:02:247 (363) - add note here ? ( 00:52:647 (300) - こっち置いてるのと ここにadd noteしたらkdddkよりkkddkのほうがいいかなあって思いました ) 01:02:397 - ここをkに変える形で直しました。
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Inner Oni]
  1. 00:31:047 (190) - ここからFinishの配色がバラバラな気がします ( 特に00:32:247 (198) - 00:37:047 (231) - 00:41:847 (266) - )なので00:32:247 (198) -はDでいいかなあ・・・むっちゃばらばらでした;;すいません(´・ω・`)

  2. 00:49:572 (325) - 00:49:722 (326) - Delete 繋げるような音はないと思います_(:3JL fix

  3. 01:02:247 - add d & 01:02:397 (423) - change K ( 00:52:647 (350,351) - ここと同じでいいと思います ) ここを治す代わりに01:02:022 - ここを削除しました。

  4. 統一性がなんかないかなあ・・・って思いました remapに近い形で見直しました。dとkは主にvocalに従う形で配置させていただきました。
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
とても助かりました!
modありがとうございます :)
newyams99
こんにちは、forum PM で来ました。れをるがめっちゃ好きで早速 mod をしちゃいました ^^ でも忙しいので mod って言うより一見したところの感想です。

Kantan

00:07:197 (5) - Finish の有無が他の譜面と一貫してません。この先も言いますが、その他にも finisher が一貫してない場所が何ヶ所かあるので、探してください。

00:26:397 (28) - これは d の方が良いのでは。ボーカルの音取よりインストの音取が d でピッタリです。00:25:797 (27,28,29) が k の三連続で少しつまらないかと思いました。

00:31:197 (34) - これは明らかに 00:31:047 の音を拾ってますね。だったらこのサークルを 00:31:047 に移動して下さい。赤目盛りにサークルを配置するのは大丈夫です。

00:33:597 (36) - 上記ど同様。Finish も必要ないと思いました。00:31:047 と比べてそっちはシンバル音が聞こえたのでこっちの finish を抜くと 00:31:047 を更に強調できると思います。これから00:43:197 (47) までの K を全て直前の赤目盛りにずらして、finish を抜くことができます。

00:52:797 (59) - 01:02:397 (71) に finish はなかったのでここもなしにしましょう。

Futsuu

00:07:197 (9,10,11,12,13,14) - 00:07:797 (11) と 00:08:997 (14) が不自然だと思いました。こんなリズムはどうでしょう。https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992252
難しすぎない様、少し後の部分も変更してみました。

00:23:697 - ここにサークルがないとインストの clap がすごく目立ちます。サークルを追加しましょう。

00:26:097 - ^

00:31:197 (63) - Kantan で提案した移動を考慮して下さい。

00:35:997 (74) - ^

00:40:797 (85) - ^ ま、Kantan と同じ提案なので、この他の移動もそれを参考にして下さい。

00:50:397 - Futsuu 譜面の気合タイムが全ての譜面の中で一番改善が必要だと思います。インストからボーカル、またはボーカルからインストへの音取の切り替えがはっきりとしてないです。例えば、00:51:597 にサークルがを追加することでボーカルの00:51:297 (111,112) からインストへスムーズに切り替えられると思います。で、この様なリズムが作れると思いました https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992548
サークル 114, 115 の配置が今の配置より正しいと思って変更してみました。こうして、色々なリズムを試して改良を求めて下さい。画像を参考にして変更してもいいし、自由に変更してもいいですが、変更を試みてください。どうすれば迷っているならいつでも僕に尋ねてください。

Muzukashii

00:07:647 (10,11) - 00:07:497 に移動した方がインストと合います。

00:08:847 (14,15) - ^

00:31:047 (109) - Kantan や Futsuu 譜面であった様に finisher を追加できます。

00:40:797 (157) - これを 00:40:647 に移動し、00:40:947 にサークルを追加するのはボーカルを拾うのに悪くないと思います。

00:48:297 - にサークルを追加して下さい。Oni 譜面と difficulty gap が広いです。Difficulty gap は各譜面の真上と真下の譜面の難易度の差です。00:48:747 も同じく。この difficult gap 概念は Inner Oni 譜面に適用しません。

01:08:397 (306) - 他の譜面で finish は無かったので finisher を抜くのを勧めます。01:08:997 (308) も同じく。

Oni

全体的にサークル密度を下げた方がいいです。さっき言った difficulty gap が Muzukashii 譜面と広いです。逆に、 Inner Oni 譜面に似すぎています。

00:07:197 (18) - Kantan と同様、finisher は必要ありません。

00:07:197 (18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29) - このリズムにサークルを追加しましょう。Muzukashii 譜面であったサークルが Oni 譜面では無かったので、それを確認して追加して下さい。Inner Oni 譜面も同じく。

Inner Oni

00:11:847 - ボーカルを主に拾っているのでここにサークルは悪くないと思います。

00:26:697 - ^

00:16:197 (77,78) - この間が少し突然と思いました。こんなリズムはどうでしょう https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992800
インストに合わせてみました。インストが良く聞こえる 00:16:497 などの場所を拾う様にしましょう。いい感じになると思いますよ ^^

00:28:497 (161,162) - ^

00:22:047 - 上記の理由でここにサークルを追加してみて下さい。

00:24:447 - ^

00:28:797 - ^

00:33:297 - ^

00:35:547 - ^ これでこの提案は十分でしょう。他に追加が可能なリズムを試して下さい。

気合タイムは良くできてると思います^^

以上です。意外と長くなりましたが、mod がnyanmi さんの役に立てたら嬉しいです。これからも modder を集めて改良を続けて下さい。約一ヶ月後にまた連絡ください。もしかしたらその時には太鼓 icon を貰える状態になってるかも ^^ そうじゃなくても、mod をちゃんとしてみたいです。詳しく説明して欲しい場合とか僕の日本語がおかしくて分からない場合は遠慮せずに話しかけて下さい。

では、頑張ってください 8-)
Acrith


[Oni]

click
00:15:822 - Add here kat, 00:15:897 (68) - make it don, 00:16:047 (70,71) - switch colors. It's easy for Oni, and emphatize rhythm.
00:16:497 - Consider adding don for rhythm
00:17:697 (81) - Switch to kat.
00:18:597 (87) - Switch to kat.
00:19:047 - Consider adding don, the whole part is Oni like anyway, and this don won't change anything but help with rhythm of Reol
00:22:197 - Consider adding kat for Reol rhythm
00:24:597 - Consider adding kat for rhythm (overall, as previously)
00:28:197 (145) - Would make it kat, and 00:28:497 (147) - this would make don.
00:31:047 (165) - Would make it kat cause of rhythm
00:38:097 (205) - Make it don?
00:38:247 (206) - Fiinisher?
00:40:047 (218) - Make it kat.
00:41:697 (229) - I would make it don, and 00:41:847 (230) - make it kat.
00:43:047 (239) - Would still make it kat.
00:45:447 (255) - Make it kat.
00:47:847 (269) - Kat (maybe? Not sure this time, it's same as others BUT it's different. Welp, nvm, make it kat :D)
00:50:172 (287) - Add here kat. For ddkkd. For rhythm. It's oni, not only triplets required.
00:54:747 (314) - Would make it kat, AND 00:54:897 (315) - make it don, add on two next 1/4 ticks don and kat, then change 00:55:197 (316) - to kat so overall rhythm goes: k ddk k ddk k which perfectly fits it.
01:04:572 - Would still add here kat, and on next 1/4 tick add don, to make it kkddkkd since it's kiai time, ending of chorus, and it's oni - so one harder part is in my opinion required. And kkddkkd pattern is not THAT tricky to not put it once :D
01:06:597 (398) - Would make it kat, THEN 01:06:897 (400) - would make it don THEN 01:07:047 would add here don AND 01:07:197 (401) - make it kat.

[Inner Oni]

click
00:11:547 (38,39,40) - You should extend this by two remaining notes (from ddk to ddkkd), because of the beat. For that, you need to add kat here: 00:11:772, and don here: 00:11:847
00:16:497 (80) - DON'T STOP THE RHYTHM, Insert don.
00:20:547 (113,114,115,116,117,118,119) - Make this a stream. The whole section of vocal is pretty long, and it's progressive by your mapping, to just do the culmination of stuff. Add kat here: 00:20:772 and don here: 00:20:922, go back to 00:16:497 and check how it looks! :D
00:21:597 (123) - Consider adding don/kat (prefer kat), since main beat.
00:22:197 (125) - Add kat, there is still a vocal here, and main beat.
00:23:997 - Same as two lines above
00:24:597 - Same as three lines above
00:25:572 - Suggesting to make a five note stream by adding kat here to rhythm
00:26:172 - Here (and two additional 1/4 ticks) add kat to vocal rhythm. And it fits with applying this above, and again - it's not hard to click out, pretty enjoyable.
00:28:797 (175) - Add don since main beat
00:33:297 (209) - Suggest to add kat.
00:35:472 - Here (and one more 1/4 tick) add dons to make triplet with dons before kat. This fits rhythm of song.
00:38:247 (242) - Maybe finisher, if you put it every "aaa". I mean the vocal "aaa!" xD
00:39:972 - Add kat to follow the beat stream in song.
00:45:447 (295) - Make it kat.
00:45:747 (295,296,297,298,299) - This comparing to vocal and song rhythm is bad. Let's rearrange it.
> 00:45:897 (296) - add kat here
> 00:46:047 (297) - make it kat, and for next two 1/4 ticks add in order: kat, don. The pattern should look: d k kkd kdd
00:54:972 - Add kat, and on next 1/4 tick add don, to get kkddkkd pattern. For rhythm sake!
00:59:172 - Add don for rhythm of Reol! :D
01:04:572 - Same as two lines avove. Add kat, on next 1/4 tick add don, to get kkddkkd pattern. For rhythm sake!
01:08:397 (470,471,472,473,474,475,476,477,478,479,480,481,482,483,484,485,486) - People will choke on this, but someone other will remod it. :D
01:11:547 (503) - KAT, PLEASE, RHYTHM <3
01:13:947 (523) - Same as above
01:16:347 (541,542) - Would change both to kats.

GOOD LUCK! \:D/
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

newyams99 wrote:

こんにちは、forum PM で来ました。れをるがめっちゃ好きで早速 mod をしちゃいました ^^ でも忙しいので mod って言うより一見したところの感想です。

Kantan

00:07:197 (5) - Finish の有無が他の譜面と一貫してません。この先も言いますが、その他にも finisher が一貫してない場所が何ヶ所かあるので、探してください。
fix. 一貫させました。少し違うところもありますが、それはdiffによって音の拾い方が違う(ただ、Kantan~Futsuu間と、Muzukashii~Inner Oni間は同じように拾うようにしています。)ので、許容してもらえる範囲でしょうか?^^;

00:26:397 (28) - これは d の方が良いのでは。ボーカルの音取よりインストの音取が d でピッタリです。00:25:797 (27,28,29) が k の三連続で少しつまらないかと思いました。
fix. dやkが続くのは確かにつまらないですね。気をつけます。それと、ボーカルの音取とインストの音取が混同しているのも後々確認していきます。

00:31:197 (34) - これは明らかに 00:31:047 の音を拾ってますね。だったらこのサークルを 00:31:047 に移動して下さい。赤目盛りにサークルを配置するのは大丈夫です。
fix. Kantanだと、赤目盛りを使うのはよくないと思っていました :o
配置しても大丈夫なのですね!ありがとうございます。


00:33:597 (36) - 上記ど同様。Finish も必要ないと思いました。00:31:047 と比べてそっちはシンバル音が聞こえたのでこっちの finish を抜くと 00:31:047 を更に強調できると思います。これから00:43:197 (47) までの K を全て直前の赤目盛りにずらして、finish を抜くことができます。
とても良かったので全てずらしました。
finishを置きすぎていましたね><


00:52:797 (59) - 01:02:397 (71) に finish はなかったのでここもなしにしましょう。
fix.

Futsuuと統一性を持たせるため、01:16:797 - 01:19:197にspinnerを配置しました。

Futsuu

00:07:197 (9,10,11,12,13,14) - 00:07:797 (11) と 00:08:997 (14) が不自然だと思いました。こんなリズムはどうでしょう。https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992252
難しすぎない様、少し後の部分も変更してみました。
それに加えて、00:08:097 にkを置きました。

00:23:697 - ここにサークルがないとインストの clap がすごく目立ちます。サークルを追加しましょう。
fix.

00:26:097 - ^ ^

00:31:197 (63) - Kantan で提案した移動を考慮して下さい。^

00:35:997 (74) - ^ ^

00:40:797 (85) - ^ ま、Kantan と同じ提案なので、この他の移動もそれを参考にして下さい。^

00:50:397 - Futsuu 譜面の気合タイムが全ての譜面の中で一番改善が必要だと思います。インストからボーカル、またはボーカルからインストへの音取の切り替えがはっきりとしてないです。例えば、00:51:597 にサークルがを追加することでボーカルの00:51:297 (111,112) からインストへスムーズに切り替えられると思います。で、この様なリズムが作れると思いました https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992548
サークル 114, 115 の配置が今の配置より正しいと思って変更してみました。こうして、色々なリズムを試して改良を求めて下さい。画像を参考にして変更してもいいし、自由に変更してもいいですが、変更を試みてください。どうすれば迷っているならいつでも僕に尋ねてください。
変更を確認して欲しいので、出来ればもう一度見て欲しいです><

01:09:597 からインストに合わせる形にしました。

Muzukashii

00:07:647 (10,11) - 00:07:497 に移動した方がインストと合います。

00:08:847 (14,15) - ^

00:31:047 (109) - Kantan や Futsuu 譜面であった様に finisher を追加できます。

00:40:797 (157) - これを 00:40:647 に移動し、00:40:947 にサークルを追加するのはボーカルを拾うのに悪くないと思います。

00:48:297 - にサークルを追加して下さい。Oni 譜面と difficulty gap が広いです。Difficulty gap は各譜面の真上と真下の譜面の難易度の差です。00:48:747 も同じく。この difficult gap 概念は Inner Oni 譜面に適用しません。

01:08:397 (306) - 他の譜面で finish は無かったので finisher を抜くのを勧めます。01:08:997 (308) も同じく。

All fixed.

Oni

全体的にサークル密度を下げた方がいいです。さっき言った difficulty gap が Muzukashii 譜面と広いです。逆に、 Inner Oni 譜面に似すぎています。

00:07:197 (18) - Kantan と同様、finisher は必要ありません。fix.

00:07:197 (18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29) - このリズムにサークルを追加しましょう。Muzukashii 譜面であったサークルが Oni 譜面では無かったので、それを確認して追加して下さい。Inner Oni 譜面も同じく。Muzukashiiに肉付けする感じで追加しました。

1/4出来るだけ減らしましたヽ(´▽`)/

Inner Oni

00:11:847 - ボーカルを主に拾っているのでここにサークルは悪くないと思います。
fix.

00:26:697 - ^
fix.

00:16:197 (77,78) - この間が少し突然と思いました。こんなリズムはどうでしょう https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992800
インストに合わせてみました。インストが良く聞こえる 00:16:497 などの場所を拾う様にしましょう。いい感じになると思いますよ ^^
fix.

00:28:497 (161,162) - ^
^

00:22:047 - 上記の理由でここにサークルを追加してみて下さい。
ボーカルには合わないので、インストに合わせるために、00:21:597 にも追加しました。

00:24:447 - ^
上と同じく、00:23:997 に追加しました。

00:28:797 - ^
fix.

00:33:297 - ^
fix.

00:35:547 - ^
fix.

これでこの提案は十分でしょう。他に追加が可能なリズムを試して下さい。
確認してみましたが、私には見つけられないのでほかの方に頼みます。

気合タイムは良くできてると思います^^
ありがとうございます!(n‘∀‘)η

以上です。意外と長くなりましたが、mod がnyanmi さんの役に立てたら嬉しいです。これからも modder を集めて改良を続けて下さい。約一ヶ月後にまた連絡ください。もしかしたらその時には太鼓 icon を貰える状態になってるかも ^^ そうじゃなくても、mod をちゃんとしてみたいです。詳しく説明して欲しい場合とか僕の日本語がおかしくて分からない場合は遠慮せずに話しかけて下さい。

では、頑張ってください 8-)
ありがとうございます。頑張ります :)
Thank you!!! :) :) :)
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

Acrith wrote:



[Oni]

click
00:15:822 - Add here kat, 00:15:897 (68) - make it don, 00:16:047 (70,71) - switch colors. It's easy for Oni, and emphatize rhythm.
ok

00:16:497 - Consider adding don for rhythm
Nope. follow the vocal here.

00:17:697 (81) - Switch to kat.
00:18:597 (87) - Switch to kat.
ok

00:19:047 - Consider adding don, the whole part is Oni like anyway, and this don won't change anything but help with rhythm of Reol
00:16:797 (72,73,74,75,76,77,78) and 00:17:997 (79,80,81,82,83,84,85) - is pattern.
No changed.


00:22:197 - Consider adding kat for Reol rhythm
00:24:597 - Consider adding kat for rhythm (overall, as previously)
It is not following Reol...><

00:28:197 (145) - Would make it kat, and 00:28:497 (147) - this would make don.
00:31:047 (165) - Would make it kat cause of rhythm
00:38:097 (205) - Make it don?
00:38:247 (206) - Fiinisher?
00:40:047 (218) - Make it kat.
00:41:697 (229) - I would make it don, and 00:41:847 (230) - make it kat.
00:43:047 (239) - Would still make it kat.
ok.

00:45:447 (255) - Make it kat.
Nope.

00:47:847 (269) - Kat (maybe? Not sure this time, it's same as others BUT it's different. Welp, nvm, make it kat :D)
00:50:172 (287) - Add here kat. For ddkkd. For rhythm. It's oni, not only triplets required.
ok.

00:54:747 (314) - Would make it kat, AND 00:54:897 (315) - make it don, add on two next 1/4 ticks don and kat, then change 00:55:197 (316) - to kat so overall rhythm goes: k ddk k ddk k which perfectly fits it.
01:04:572 - Would still add here kat, and on next 1/4 tick add don, to make it kkddkkd since it's kiai time, ending of chorus, and it's oni - so one harder part is in my opinion required. And kkddkkd pattern is not THAT tricky to not put it once :D
01:06:597 (398) - Would make it kat, THEN 01:06:897 (400) - would make it don THEN 01:07:047 would add here don AND 01:07:197 (401) - make it kat.
Nope.

[Inner Oni]

click
00:11:547 (38,39,40) - You should extend this by two remaining notes (from ddk to ddkkd), because of the beat. For that, you need to add kat here: 00:11:772, and don here: 00:11:847
00:16:497 (80) - DON'T STOP THE RHYTHM, Insert don.
00:20:547 (113,114,115,116,117,118,119) - Make this a stream. The whole section of vocal is pretty long, and it's progressive by your mapping, to just do the culmination of stuff. Add kat here: 00:20:772 and don here: 00:20:922, go back to 00:16:497 and check how it looks! :D
00:21:597 (123) - Consider adding don/kat (prefer kat), since main beat.
00:22:197 (125) - Add kat, there is still a vocal here, and main beat.
00:23:997 - Same as two lines above
00:24:597 - Same as three lines above
00:25:572 - Suggesting to make a five note stream by adding kat here to rhythm
00:26:172 - Here (and two additional 1/4 ticks) add kat to vocal rhythm. And it fits with applying this above, and again - it's not hard to click out, pretty enjoyable.
00:28:797 (175) - Add don since main beat
00:33:297 (209) - Suggest to add kat.
00:35:472 - Here (and one more 1/4 tick) add dons to make triplet with dons before kat. This fits rhythm of song.
00:38:247 (242) - Maybe finisher, if you put it every "aaa". I mean the vocal "aaa!" xD
00:39:972 - Add kat to follow the beat stream in song.
00:45:447 (295) - Make it kat.
00:45:747 (295,296,297,298,299) - This comparing to vocal and song rhythm is bad. Let's rearrange it.
> 00:45:897 (296) - add kat here
> 00:46:047 (297) - make it kat, and for next two 1/4 ticks add in order: kat, don. The pattern should look: d k kkd kdd
00:54:972 - Add kat, and on next 1/4 tick add don, to get kkddkkd pattern. For rhythm sake!
00:59:172 - Add don for rhythm of Reol! :D
01:04:572 - Same as two lines avove. Add kat, on next 1/4 tick add don, to get kkddkkd pattern. For rhythm sake!
01:08:397 (470,471,472,473,474,475,476,477,478,479,480,481,482,483,484,485,486) - People will choke on this, but someone other will remod it. :D
01:11:547 (503) - KAT, PLEASE, RHYTHM <3
01:13:947 (523) - Same as above
Nope><

01:16:347 (541,542) - Would change both to kats.
ok

GOOD LUCK! \:D/
Thank you for mod! :)
Q____X
Hi from my queue

Inner Oni

00:14:322 - d
00:16:647 - ^
01:04:647 - ^

Oni

00:11:847 - d
00:14:322 - ^
00:17:847 - ^
00:19:047 - ^

Muzukashii


00:25:647 - d

Futsuu

00:28:497 - k
00:29:697 (62) - delete 00:30:297 (63) - move to 00:29:997 -
00:30:297 - d
00:32:997 (69) - move to 00:33:147 -

Sorry for the short mod :o

Good map :D
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

Q____X wrote:

Hi from my queue

Inner Oni

00:14:322 - d
00:16:647 - ^
01:04:647 - ^

Oni

00:11:847 - d
00:14:322 - ^
00:17:847 - ^
00:19:047 - ^

Muzukashii


00:25:647 - d ok.

Futsuu

00:28:497 - k
00:29:697 (62) - delete 00:30:297 (63) - move to 00:29:997 - ok.
00:30:297 - d ok.
00:32:997 (69) - move to 00:33:147 -

Sorry for the short mod :o

Good map :D
Thank you for mod! :)
Aloda
Hello!

Kantan
In the 00:31:047 - 00:49:797 section some of your notes are mapped to the vocals while some are to the beat, which gets a little confusing. Consider the changes below to have it all mapped to the vocals.

00:32:397 (35) - Move to 00:32:247

00:33:597 (36) - Move to 00:33:447

00:34:797 (37) - Move to 00:34:647

00:37:197 (40) - Move to 00:37:047

00:41:997 (45) - Move to 00:41:847

Muzukashii
01:04:047 (285,286,287,288) - d ddd -> ddd d What you have is fine but I think this is better

Oni
If you're going to have the finisher at 00:31:047 (155) I think that you should also have finishers at 00:32:247 (161) 00:33:447 (167) 00:34:647 (174) 00:35:847 (180) 00:37:047 (186) 00:38:247 (192) 00:40:647 (207) 00:41:847 (215) 00:43:047 (223) 00:45:447 (237) and 00:47:847 (250) for consistency. Consider either removing the finisher at 00:31:047 (155) or add the others.

Futsuu and Inner Oni have no issues.

Nice song and good map. Good luck with getting ranked :)
newyams99
先日の mod の返信を見ました。Kudosu 無しでお願いします。

Futsuu

nyanmi-1828 wrote:

00:50:397 - Futsuu 譜面の気合タイムが全ての譜面の中で一番改善が必要だと思います。インストからボーカル、またはボーカルからインストへの音取の切り替えがはっきりとしてないです。例えば、00:51:597 にサークルがを追加することでボーカルの00:51:297 (111,112) からインストへスムーズに切り替えられると思います。で、この様なリズムが作れると思いました https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992548
サークル 114, 115 の配置が今の配置より正しいと思って変更してみました。こうして、色々なリズムを試して改良を求めて下さい。画像を参考にして変更してもいいし、自由に変更してもいいですが、変更を試みてください。どうすれば迷っているならいつでも僕に尋ねてください。
変更を確認して欲しいので、出来ればもう一度見て欲しいです><
気合タイムは結構良かったと思いました。ただ、2/1 休息時間の位置を変更したらどうかと思いました。休息時間は大概、小節の一泊目に現れます。なので、00:55:497 (126) を 00:56:097 に移動したらどうでしょう。01:05:097 (153) も同じ様に 01:06:897 への移動が可能です。その他、00:56:697 (129) を 00:56:847 に移動することで 00:58:797 (135,136) と一貫したリズムが出来上がります。最後に、01:16:797 (1) を 01:18:897 までの延長ができます。

Oni

nyanmi-1828 wrote:

1/4出来るだけ減らしましたヽ(´▽`)/
割と良くなりました。これからは 1/4 を削るだけでなく、 1/2 休息時間を増やすこともできるのでそういう手も使ってみて下さい。

Inner Oni

nyanmi-1828 wrote:

確認してみましたが、私には見つけられないのでほかの方に頼みます。
良く出来上がってます。Inner Oni 譜面全体について一つ言い忘れたことがありました。譜面を overmap する場合は 1/4 リズムが整っているか確認してください。例えば、00:32:547 (202,203,204,205,206,207,208,209,210,211,212,213,214,215,216,217,218,219,220,221,222,223,224,225,226) の三つのリズムは似たボーカルと合わせているのに 1/4 配置に相違にあるのは良くないです。色は特に関係ないです。こういう似た様なところは overmap を似せると譜面を整理できると思います。

その他の提案:00:37:347 (235,236,237,238,239,240) - これを 00:36:147 (227,228,229,230,231,232,233,234) にリズムを合わせるtいいと思います。

00:46:197 - ボーカルを拾うためにサークルを追加できます。


以上です。頑張ってね~
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

Aloda wrote:

Hello!

Kantan
In the 00:31:047 - 00:49:797 section some of your notes are mapped to the vocals while some are to the beat, which gets a little confusing. Consider the changes below to have it all mapped to the vocals.

00:32:397 (35) - Move to 00:32:247

00:33:597 (36) - Move to 00:33:447

00:34:797 (37) - Move to 00:34:647

00:37:197 (40) - Move to 00:37:047

00:41:997 (45) - Move to 00:41:847

All fixed.

Muzukashii
01:04:047 (285,286,287,288) - d ddd -> ddd d What you have is fine but I think this is better
umm...nope

Oni
If you're going to have the finisher at 00:31:047 (155) I think that you should also have finishers at 00:32:247 (161) 00:33:447 (167) 00:34:647 (174) 00:35:847 (180) 00:37:047 (186) 00:38:247 (192) 00:40:647 (207) 00:41:847 (215) 00:43:047 (223) 00:45:447 (237) and 00:47:847 (250) for consistency. Consider either removing the finisher at 00:31:047 (155) or add the others.

removed the finisher at 00:31:047 (155) .

Futsuu and Inner Oni have no issues.

Nice song and good map. Good luck with getting ranked :)
Thank you~~! :)
Thank you for mod! :)
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

newyams99 wrote:

先日の mod の返信を見ました。Kudosu 無しでお願いします。

Futsuu

nyanmi-1828 wrote:

00:50:397 - Futsuu 譜面の気合タイムが全ての譜面の中で一番改善が必要だと思います。インストからボーカル、またはボーカルからインストへの音取の切り替えがはっきりとしてないです。例えば、00:51:597 にサークルがを追加することでボーカルの00:51:297 (111,112) からインストへスムーズに切り替えられると思います。で、この様なリズムが作れると思いました https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4992548
サークル 114, 115 の配置が今の配置より正しいと思って変更してみました。こうして、色々なリズムを試して改良を求めて下さい。画像を参考にして変更してもいいし、自由に変更してもいいですが、変更を試みてください。どうすれば迷っているならいつでも僕に尋ねてください。
変更を確認して欲しいので、出来ればもう一度見て欲しいです><
気合タイムは結構良かったと思いました。ただ、2/1 休息時間の位置を変更したらどうかと思いました。休息時間は大概、小節の一泊目に現れます。
それを参考にして、00:58:497 と 01:07:497 を削除し、休憩時間を設置しました。

なので、00:55:497 (126) を 00:56:097 に移動したらどうでしょう。01:05:097 (153) も同じ様に 01:06:897 への移動が可能です。その他、00:56:697 (129) を 00:56:847 に移動することで 00:58:797 (135,136) と一貫したリズムが出来上がります。
なるほど。全て直してみました。

最後に、01:16:797 (1) を 01:18:897 までの延長ができます。
Spinnerの後、すぐに音符が来るとやりにくいと思って01:18:897 までにしたのですが、大丈夫みたいなので直しました。

Oni

nyanmi-1828 wrote:

1/4出来るだけ減らしましたヽ(´▽`)/
割と良くなりました。これからは 1/4 を削るだけでなく、 1/2 休息時間を増やすこともできるのでそういう手も使ってみて下さい。
ありがとうございます!休息を増やす手も考えてみます。(`・ω・´)ゞ

Inner Oni

nyanmi-1828 wrote:

確認してみましたが、私には見つけられないのでほかの方に頼みます。
良く出来上がってます。Inner Oni 譜面全体について一つ言い忘れたことがありました。譜面を overmap する場合は 1/4 リズムが整っているか確認してください。例えば、00:32:547 (202,203,204,205,206,207,208,209,210,211,212,213,214,215,216,217,218,219,220,221,222,223,224,225,226) の三つのリズムは似たボーカルと合わせているのに 1/4 配置に相違にあるのは良くないです。色は特に関係ないです。こういう似た様なところは overmap を似せると譜面を整理できると思います。

なるほど。1/4の位置を合わせるのも重要になってくるのですね。直しました。

その他の提案:00:37:347 (235,236,237,238,239,240) - これを 00:36:147 (227,228,229,230,231,232,233,234) にリズムを合わせるtいいと思います。
合わせましたが、ボーカルが00:37:347より音の数が少ないので1/4の設置は控えました。

00:46:197 - ボーカルを拾うためにサークルを追加できます。
fix.

以上です。頑張ってね~
2度も見ていただきありがとうございます!

頑張ります(n‘∀‘)η
Gemu-
Hi! nyanmi-1828

From my queue


[Taiko Mod]


d
k
D (Big d)
K (Big k)

  • [ Kantan]

    HP: 8
    OD: 2
  1. 00:45:597 (50) - Put a finish to follow the high voice. Also, to keep consistency with 00:31:197 (34) - , 00:35:997 (39) - , 00:40:797 (44) - , 00:43:197 (47) -
  2. 01:02:397 (71) - Put a finish to keep consistency with 00:52:797 (59) -
  3. 01:13:797 - If you want can you add a k because the voice is increased in this part with 01:11:997 (86,87,88) -

  • [ Futsuu]

    HP: 7
    OD: 3
  1. 00:23:697 - You forgot add a note here, I suggest you add a k because can hear a similar song to a "Clap" in this part. Also, to follow the voice.
  2. 00:50:397 (109) - Change to finish K to emphasize with the previous note 00:50:097 (108) - Also, is the begining of the kiai and is perfect start with a high finish.

  • [ Muzukashii]

    HP: 6
    OD: 4
  1. 00:35:247 (129) - Change to k to not repeat the same rhythm how do you have it here 00:33:747 (121,122,123,124) -
  2. 00:42:447 (165) - Change to k for the previous reason, also, it goes very good with the voice.
  3. 01:14:697 (333) - Change to k because this is a high tone and later come a low tone 01:14:847 (334) -
  4. 01:15:897 (338) - Change to k for the previous reason^
  5. 01:19:197 (356) - This is the end of the kiai, I suggest you change to finish K to manifest it.

  • [ Oni]
  1. 00:37:647 (202) - Change to k to not repeat the same rhythm because you have the same here 00:36:147 (194,195,196,197) -
  2. 01:19:197 (467) - How I said previously This is the end of the kiai, I suggest you change to finish K to manifest it.

  • [ Inner Oni]
  1. 00:56:097 (352) - Change to k to keep the rhythm you're doing with 00:55:197 (344,345,346,347,348,349,350,351,353,354,355,356,357,358) -
  2. 01:05:697 (422) - The same here ^

[Mania Mod]


Columns:

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |


  • [ KcHecKa's EZ]

    HP: 6
    OD: 7
  1. 00:09:597 (9597|2) - End this here 00:10:047 - and move this 00:10:197 (10197|0) - here 00:10:047 - both in the same column because in this part can hear a drum.
  2. 00:23:697 - Add note in the column 2, because here there a sound similar to a "Clap".
  3. 00:26:097 - Here too, add in the column 3.
  4. 00:28:497 - The same, add in the column 2.
  5. 00:30:897 - The same, add in the column 1.
  6. 00:31:197 - Add in the column 4 because there a big sound. Also, can you put finish in this part, the same reason.
  7. 00:32:397 - Add in the column 1 (Also I explained the reason before.).
  8. 00:33:597 - Add in the column 4.
  9. 00:34:797 - Add in the column 1.
  10. 00:37:197 - Add in the column 2.
  11. 00:38:097 - ^
  12. 00:38:397 - Add in the column 3.
  13. 00:39:297 - ^

  14. 00:32:397 - 00:39:297 - The reason is to keep a consistency and a density with this parts from here 00:40:797 - 00:46:497 -

  15. 01:02:397 - Add a lane in the column 4 to kepp consistency with 00:50:397 (50397|3,50397|0) - , 00:52:797 (52797|1,52797|2) - , 00:59:997 (59997|1,59997|0) -
  16. 01:09:597 (69597|2) - Remove, for me two lane are hard for this difficulty.
  17. 01:10:797 (70797|2) - The same here^
  18. 01:11:997 (71997|3) - Here too^

  • [ sakajun's NM]

    HP: 7
    OD: 7
  1. 00:23:697 (23697|0) - I see not necessary this lane, because you have a lane here 00:23:697 (23697|1) - so remove.
  2. 00:46:647 (46647|1) - Move to the column 3.
  3. 00:46:797 (46797|2) - Move to the column 2.
  4. 00:47:247 (47247|1) - Move to the column 4.

  • [ KcHecKa's HD]

    HP: 7,5
    OD: 7,5
  1. 00:52:797 - Add a note in the column 2 to manefest the lane and the finish 00:52:797 (52797|3) -
  2. 01:28:047 - You forgot follow the sound here, I suggest you add a note in the column 2.

Excelent Beatmap! I hope my mod has been helpful :33, Good Luck!
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

game rock wrote:

Hi! nyanmi-1828

From my queue


[Taiko Mod]


d
k
D (Big d)
K (Big k)

  • [ Kantan]

    HP: 8
    OD: 2

    umm...No change.
  1. 00:45:597 (50) - Put a finish to follow the high voice. Also, to keep consistency with 00:31:197 (34) - , 00:35:997 (39) - , 00:40:797 (44) - , 00:43:197 (47) -
    Nope. because have Consistency at other difficulty.
  2. 01:02:397 (71) - Put a finish to keep consistency with 00:52:797 (59) -
    why? I think not need finish here.
  3. 01:13:797 - If you want can you add a k because the voice is increased in this part with 01:11:997 (86,87,88) -
Nope.

  • [ Futsuu]

    HP: 7
    OD: 3

    ok.
  1. 00:23:697 - You forgot add a note here, I suggest you add a k because can hear a similar song to a "Clap" in this part. Also, to follow the voice.
    Nope.I think "d" better.
  2. 00:50:397 (109) - Change to finish K to emphasize with the previous note 00:50:097 (108) - Also, is the begining of the kiai and is perfect start with a high finish.
nope

  • [ Muzukashii]

    HP: 6
    OD: 4

    changed to hp:5 , od:4
  1. 00:35:247 (129) - Change to k to not repeat the same rhythm how do you have it here 00:33:747 (121,122,123,124) -
  2. 00:42:447 (165) - Change to k for the previous reason, also, it goes very good with the voice.
  3. 01:14:697 (333) - Change to k because this is a high tone and later come a low tone 01:14:847 (334) -
  4. 01:15:897 (338) - Change to k for the previous reason^
  5. 01:19:197 (356) - This is the end of the kiai, I suggest you change to finish K to manifest it.
All fixed.

  • [ Oni]
  1. 00:37:647 (202) - Change to k to not repeat the same rhythm because you have the same here 00:36:147 (194,195,196,197) -
  2. 01:19:197 (467) - How I said previously This is the end of the kiai, I suggest you change to finish K to manifest it.
All fixed

  • [ Inner Oni]
  1. 00:56:097 (352) - Change to k to keep the rhythm you're doing with 00:55:197 (344,345,346,347,348,349,350,351,353,354,355,356,357,358) -
  2. 01:05:697 (422) - The same here ^

    All fixed.

[Mania Mod]


Columns:

| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 |


  • [ KcHecKa's EZ]

    HP: 6
    OD: 7
  1. 00:09:597 (9597|2) - End this here 00:10:047 - and move this 00:10:197 (10197|0) - here 00:10:047 - both in the same column because in this part can hear a drum.
  2. 00:23:697 - Add note in the column 2, because here there a sound similar to a "Clap".
  3. 00:26:097 - Here too, add in the column 3.
  4. 00:28:497 - The same, add in the column 2.
  5. 00:30:897 - The same, add in the column 1.
  6. 00:31:197 - Add in the column 4 because there a big sound. Also, can you put finish in this part, the same reason.
  7. 00:32:397 - Add in the column 1 (Also I explained the reason before.).
  8. 00:33:597 - Add in the column 4.
  9. 00:34:797 - Add in the column 1.
  10. 00:37:197 - Add in the column 2.
  11. 00:38:097 - ^
  12. 00:38:397 - Add in the column 3.
  13. 00:39:297 - ^

  14. 00:32:397 - 00:39:297 - The reason is to keep a consistency and a density with this parts from here 00:40:797 - 00:46:497 -

  15. 01:02:397 - Add a lane in the column 4 to kepp consistency with 00:50:397 (50397|3,50397|0) - , 00:52:797 (52797|1,52797|2) - , 00:59:997 (59997|1,59997|0) -
  16. 01:09:597 (69597|2) - Remove, for me two lane are hard for this difficulty.
  17. 01:10:797 (70797|2) - The same here^
  18. 01:11:997 (71997|3) - Here too^

  • [ sakajun's NM]

    HP: 7
    OD: 7
  1. 00:23:697 (23697|0) - I see not necessary this lane, because you have a lane here 00:23:697 (23697|1) - so remove.
  2. 00:46:647 (46647|1) - Move to the column 3.
  3. 00:46:797 (46797|2) - Move to the column 2.
  4. 00:47:247 (47247|1) - Move to the column 4.

  • [ KcHecKa's HD]

    HP: 7,5
    OD: 7,5
  1. 00:52:797 - Add a note in the column 2 to manefest the lane and the finish 00:52:797 (52797|3) -
  2. 01:28:047 - You forgot follow the sound here, I suggest you add a note in the column 2.

mania mod all fixed! :)

Excelent Beatmap! I hope my mod has been helpful :33, Good Luck!
Thank you~!! :)
Thank you for mod! :)
DeletedUser_6637817
Mod from queue, ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Dont expect quality, i have M4M's with high priority waiting, sorry

K a n t a n
01:02:997 (72) - doesnt seem to fit with the previous leitmotif, remove?

Footsuu
00:23:397 (46,47) - CTRL+G? the 5th note is a clap and could be mapped that way
00:26:997 - this spot feels really weird HS wise, i suggest mapping like:
to make it fit with the background

Mustardkashii
Nothing big found

Oni
Nothing, well done!

Inner Öni
I dont understand this overmap. sorry this song is not moddable very much because i cant understand map :c

GL ranking!
HimemiyaChikane
Hi from my queue.sorry for so late.
[Oni]
00:25:947 (124) - change to d?
00:30:897 (154) - change to d?
00:33:147 (166) - change to d?

[Inner Oni]
00:32:247 (201) - change to k?
00:45:447 (291) - change to k?

your map is so excellent that I can hardly find a place to fix it.Well,I hope I can help you a little.Good luck for ranking and thanks for your modding! :)
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

Nepuri wrote:

Mod from queue, ehhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Dont expect quality, i have M4M's with high priority waiting, sorry

K a n t a n
01:02:997 (72) - doesnt seem to fit with the previous leitmotif, remove?
fix. but I circle put on 01:01:797 for pattern.

Footsuu
00:23:397 (46,47) - CTRL+G? the 5th note is a clap and could be mapped that way ok.
00:26:997 - this spot feels really weird HS wise, i suggest mapping like:
to make it fit with the background
fix.

Mustardkashii
Nothing big found

Oni
Nothing, well done!

Inner Öni
I dont understand this overmap. sorry this song is not moddable very much because i cant understand map :c

GL ranking!

HimemiyaChikane wrote:

Hi from my queue.sorry for so late.
[Oni]
00:25:947 (124) - change to d?
00:30:897 (154) - change to d?
00:33:147 (166) - change to d?

[Inner Oni]
00:32:247 (201) - change to k?
00:45:447 (291) - change to k?

your map is so excellent that I can hardly find a place to fix it.Well,I hope I can help you a little.Good luck for ranking and thanks for your modding! :)

All fixed.
Thank you for mod!! :)
hikiko-
aaaa i'm so late sorry
i actually originally made a super long mod for a version of this map that was a week old oops
anyways i'm only modding the upper 3 diffs in accordance with the rules of my queue
[Muzukashii]
00:06:747 and 00:06:897 - add ks to emphasize the synth? imo it's okay to have slightly higher density here since it's leading into the introduction of a lot of parts in the instrumental
00:21:747 - add a d here so that this note along with 00:21:897 (72) better reflects the vocals?
00:24:147 - same thing here
00:40:647 (158) - finisher D? to match 00:31:047 (110), also to emphasize this particular note since the vocal part actually has a higher harmony that isn't present in any of the corresponding parts
00:52:797 (226) - this k seems really out of place especially since you don't use ks on the downbeat very much, if at all, anywhere else in the map. in addition the chord progression actually goes down in pitch here, so a d fits better
00:59:847 - there should be a k here since it's leading into another repetition of the chorus

[Oni]
00:45:447 (237) - is there some reason this isn't k? it isn't consistent with what you do before, e.g. at 00:45:447 - all the other corresponding doubles are alternating colors

[Inner Oni]
00:59:847 - similar reasoning as in the muzukashii, there should be a k here because this is leading into the second repetition of the chorus
01:13:947 (513,514) - change these two to k to contrast with the pattern at 01:10:197 (481,482,483,484,485). it works out because this particular measure's placement in the chord progression has a higher-pitched chord than the previous five-note pattern, so the greater number of kats helps to differentiate the two parts

sorry this is a rather short mod, but the maps are great! good luck with rank c:
Topic Starter
nyanmi-1828

hikikochan wrote:

aaaa i'm so late sorry
i actually originally made a super long mod for a version of this map that was a week old oops
anyways i'm only modding the upper 3 diffs in accordance with the rules of my queue
[Muzukashii]
00:06:747 and 00:06:897 - add ks to emphasize the synth? imo it's okay to have slightly higher density here since it's leading into the introduction of a lot of parts in the instrumental
00:21:747 - add a d here so that this note along with 00:21:897 (72) better reflects the vocals?
00:24:147 - same thing here
00:40:647 (158) - finisher D? to match 00:31:047 (110), also to emphasize this particular note since the vocal part actually has a higher harmony that isn't present in any of the corresponding parts
00:52:797 (226) - this k seems really out of place especially since you don't use ks on the downbeat very much, if at all, anywhere else in the map. in addition the chord progression actually goes down in pitch here, so a d fits better
00:59:847 - there should be a k here since it's leading into another repetition of the chorus

[Oni]
00:45:447 (237) - is there some reason this isn't k? it isn't consistent with what you do before, e.g. at 00:45:447 - all the other corresponding doubles are alternating colors

[Inner Oni]
00:59:847 - similar reasoning as in the muzukashii, there should be a k here because this is leading into the second repetition of the chorus
01:13:947 (513,514) - change these two to k to contrast with the pattern at 01:10:197 (481,482,483,484,485). it works out because this particular measure's placement in the chord progression has a higher-pitched chord than the previous five-note pattern, so the greater number of kats helps to differentiate the two parts

sorry this is a rather short mod, but the maps are great! good luck with rank c:
Thank you for mod! :)
numbermaniac
[KcHecKa's EZ]

As an osu!mania noob, this is too hard for easy IMO
In general I don’t really like how there’s a lot of 2 notes at once….

00:11:247 (11247|0) - This is unnecessary for easy. The pattern of left to right (without that note) is much nicer.
00:12:597 (12597|2,12897|1) - These feel easier to play if you swap them around.
00:14:097 (14097|2,14097|0) - One of these should be enough.
00:21:597 (21597|1,21597|0) - Do these need to be here? A short break without those notes feels better.
00:22:497 (22497|3) - Put this in the 3rd lane so it kinda makes a pattern with the 2 notes below it.
00:39:597 (39597|1,39597|0,39897|3,39897|0,40197|2,40197|0,40497|1) - This feels too fast for easy. Maybe make some of them one note only, or remove some of the lines.
00:45:897 (45897|3) - Too much here. Maybe delete this one.

The rest of the song isn’t too bad. I think it starts too difficult though.
Protastic101
Wee~ Modding time!!! ...for Mania that is. I don't know how to mod taiko T.T
Wait, is this GDer still checking his mods?



Column 1|2|3|4

General Stuffz
I think the HP of EZ is a bit too low. Since it's not a constant drain, increase HP to 6.5 at least?
Increase timeline zoom...? That's just me complaining as a modder when I look at this in the editor and everything is all scrunched together.
Well, nothing else here I guess.

HD
Quick Note: So, this difficulty (from my test play so far) is a bit LN heavy when most sounds are pretty short and not sustained. Also, there are some moderate difficulty spikes/gaps in this difficulty where you stop mapping the instrument or part you had before and start mapping a calmer/harder part. I think rather than doing that and creating those unneeded gaps, you should layer one part on top of another. I won't give examples here as they're further down in the mod. Lastly, there's a lot of parts that should be accented with doubles or triples, but are single notes, and lots of parts with generic sounds that are accented by doubles, and I'll point some of them out in the mod. That's basically all I'm concentrating on here.
00:05:547 (5547|1,5847|1) - Make these doubles? On top of the normal sound you hear is another accented one.
00:06:147 (6147|3) - ^^
00:07:497 - Add a double for the clap sound?
00:06:447 (6447|3) - I think this should be at 00:05:997 due to all your previous LN's being at the beginning of each measure. Or, alternatively, add an Ln here and end it at 00:06:447
00:09:297 - Make a double since the sound is accented.
00:11:022 - Add note here for the synth (1/4 snap).
00:12:597 - Add a note in 1 for consistency? it also feels a little odd to play an LN without a note accompanying it in a HD diff.
00:13:497 (13497|2,13497|3) - Why's this a double? There's not an accented sound. Make it a single?
00:14:847 (14847|2) - Make double because it's accented.
00:14:997 (14997|0,14997|3,15297|0,15297|2) - Make single because they're unaccented. Actually, are you mapping to the vocals here? In Mania, that's not really recommended, unlike other game modes.
00:21:297 (21297|0,21297|3,21297|1) - 3 LN's might be kind of overkill considering the only sustained sound here are the vocals
00:21:297 and 00:21:447 - If you remove the above LN's, add notes here for the background sounds.
00:21:897 - Add note in 4 to represent the "tch" sound.
00:22:497 - ^^
00:23:847 - Add note, pluck sound here (or whatever it's called).
00:23:997 - ^^ but for drums now.
00:24:897 - ^^
00:26:097 - Add note in 4 to make a double because there's a clap sound here.
00:28:497 (28497|1) - Should end at 00:28:797
00:30:222 - Add note for synth sound.
00:30:897 - Make double to represent clap sound?
00:31:047 (31047|1) - I'd suggest moving this to 1 because I think it plays a little easier and so it's not jacked with 00:30:897 (30897|1) since they aren't the same sound.
00:32:097 - Add a single note for drum.
00:31:197 to 00:35:697 - Ok, so this is where you start mapping to vocals, which, as I said above, isn't really common in Mania. Because you map to vocals, there's a lot of notes that you ignore, and it feels like a bit of a rough transition from harmony to melody imo (but I guess I'm just being influenced by the way I approach mapping lol). What I'd recommend here is adding notes where the drums play and also keeping the vocals there, but maybe toning it down a bit by making doubles singles, adding notes during LN's, etc.
00:21:897 and 00:22:497 - Add note for drums.
00:22:947 (22947|2) - move to 2. Since this is the only jack of the measure, it doesn't look fitting here, so either move this to 2 or jack 00:23:247 (23247|2,23547|2) with the notes below/above it.
00:23:997 - Add note for drum.
00:24:297 and 00:24:897 - ^^
00:26:097 - Would suggest making this a double to represent the clap sound.
00:27:597 (27597|0,27597|2,27747|0,27747|3,27897|1,27897|2,28047|2,28047|0,28197|1,28197|3) -
Wow, I'm stupid.
00:40:497 (40497|1,40647|3,40647|2,40647|0) - Control J because the accent is on the downbeat rather than up.
00:40:797 - Also, add a note for the drum sound.
00:41:997 - ^^
00:43:047 (43047|0,43047|2) - Move up to 00:43:197 and add a note at 00:43:047 to represent the drum and accent.
00:47:252 - Add note for drum.
00:50:397 to 01:03:597 - Basically what I mentioned above about an unnecessary fall in difficulty? This is it. The parts in the background like the plucks and soft drums haven't gone away, yet you've stopped mapping them and opted for the melody instead. Try laying the patterns over each other.
01:08:322 - Add note for that slide/glissando sound.
01:08:622 - ^^
01:09:522 - ^^
01:09:597 (69597|3,69597|2,69597|0) - Reduce this to a double (not heavily accented).
01:17:922 - Add note for synth sound.
01:18:972 and 01:19:122 - Add notes for synth sound.
01:19:197 (79197|2,79197|3,79197|0) - Reduce to a double if above is accepted.
01:23:997 to end - Lower the volume of your hitsounds. They're too loud and this gradually fades out.

Ask for clarification in your reply if needed.
lenpai
really busy for the week soooo i wont be able to mod :c

have some stars
xtrem3x
Removing my lazyness ...


General:

don = d
kat = k
Big Don = D
Big Kat = K


  • Kantan:

    00:38:247 - Change to d ... your rhythm here is with blue notes each change ...
    00:43:047 - Same ^
    00:46:797 - Can be same here but is other rhythm -w- ... you choose.

  • Futsuu:

    00:32:397 (69,70,71) - ctrl+g ... that's all ...

  • Muzukashii:

    00:11:997 - Is possible add finish in this note ... Same reason as Oni.

    00:31:947 (116,117) - a ctrl+g in these 2 notes ... your rhythm now is with red notes but here is broken ...
    00:32:397 - Delete this note ... ^

  • Oni:

    00:10:872 - add note d here ... have sound for a 5-notes stream.

    00:11:997 - Is possible add finish in this note specifically for announce a new sequence in this point.

    00:20:622 - Add note d .. have sound for a triple in this part.

    00:27:672 - Move to 00:27:822- and leave as ddk this triple ... for consistence with previous rhythm.

    00:34:197 - Change to k...
    00:34:497 - ctrl+g with next note, your rhythm is based in vocal when say Ah!, but here is broken.
    00:35:697 - ctrl+g with next note ... ^
    00:35:897 - ctrl+g with next note ... ^
    00:40:497 - Same ^

    01:07:047 - need other k note here ...

    01:08:697 - move this triple to 01:08:547- starts better here ...
    01:08:847 - add a single note here ... specially d

  • Inner Oni:

    00:32:097 (200,201) - ctrl+g for consistence with next sequences ...

    00:35:547 - add note d ... have sound

    00:54:672 - Move this note to 00:55:047- .. is rare but this combination is more fluid.

    01:02:172 - add note k here to make combination with previous triple -w-

    01:04:272 - Move this note to 01:04:647- ... Same reason as 00:54:672- ...

    01:11:847 - Add note k here ... missing note (?)
    01:14:247 - Same ^
    01:16:647 - Same ^

    01:18:972 - Delete this note, don't follow nothing ...
2 stars for good taiko mapset (owo)/*
Please sign in to reply.

New reply