I voted for Jojo's bizarre Adventure, didn't chose a second choice yet, for the movie I went with love live, this year was pretty awful overall, I even totally forgot that absolute trash was this year, I though it had been a year at least.
About Charlotte, I think you're wrong because even I, who's a fan of Maeda, am completely aware, he fucked up, he always been a bit overrated, but people saying that Charlotte was great are a case of people new to anime, you can't watch that, if you have at least a bit of experience, without seeing all the plot holes, mistakes, generic cliche and all, it wasn't extremely terrible, but if we consider the expectation, and the guy behind it, is was a huge disappointment and most people know and are aware of that, I would love to believe at least.