inspectorscout wrote:

yo, from my queue

Lower hitsound volume, my ears are bleeding perfect B)

Easy

That's a long intro, consider cutting the mp3 the actual intro is 35 seconds longer; i already cut that off ;-; now it's the same length as https://osu.ppy.sh/s/199452 whcih worked out

This really isn't an easy, consider renaming it. may end up doing this if people complain about it. since the difficulty is "designed" as an easy by having only 1/1 spacing and low sv, it can still be named an easy technically. same as the easy here https://osu.ppy.sh/s/323961

Really nice and solid map, nothing to say about it.

Normal

Long intro, this is more a hard, you've heard this before. does that make my hard an insane lol

You had so many chances to do a blanket, yet you don't. I suggest going trough the map and making blankets where possible, it would really help. u serious

again, a nice diff, but this one seems a lot more messy because of the weird stacks. Looks horrible in editor, but plays pretty nice.

Hard

Why the sudden 1/3 if you mapped everything in 1/4 before? idk what this is referring to

01:48:618 (4) - place this somewhere else, it's way too low now. sure lol

Gosh why are you so good at this, I dont feel like having anything to say

Insane

01:42:285 (1) - This might be nazi modding, but place the lower anchor point more to the right so you alert the player for the next jump for whatever reaosn things don't really look that great at ~45degree angles, which is why everything on the map is about +-10 degrees on each axis. my mapping ideals are stupid

again, perfect map

extra

00:56:785 (1) - up with the right anchor point for flow easier to move 2 down isnteadz

02:35:618 (1) - maybe make this 2 notes since it would fit the sound much better i get your point but like i do the same thing 50 times it's nbd

Nice and intense map

Extreme

01:15:368 (7,8) - maybe stack these perfectly on the slider, right now they are easily lost doesnt really have the intended movement if i stack them:( people at this level can figure out where those objects are for sure tho

Sadly that's everything I can tell you. If it's me, I would say that this is already ready for ranking. Good luck, starred!

[Taiga] wrote:

Greetings pishifat,

Here is requested mod, wish it will help. If you will have truble with opening image or any link is broken, please contact me.

General

Default hitsounds/music volume settings: after many repeats of song, my ears.. arhg. I would suggest making main song hitsounds a bit lower (-10% sounds ok if you ask me) if necessary i will but changing volumes for 7 diffs is gonna take me years so ill see what others say lol.

Side note about difficulty names (just free idea):
To avoid confusion, i would name diffs like:
Easy -> Normal
Normal -> (let's say) Normal+ / Advanced
I already saw maps with this spread and they are named similar to my proposition. i need to make my lower difficulties easier damn changed them

Easy

02:16:285 (3,4) - I would personaly replace this part with single slider. Ex. http://puu.sh/jgXy6.jpg

02:21:618 (3,4) - ^
Following one time used slider to point this music part 02:10:951 (3) looks better for gameplay and create better flow. i actually prefer the circles so i changed the slider instances to circles consistency woo


Rest is nice and clean for me.

Normal

01:51:785 (4) - how you feel with moving this circle a bit higer ex. http://puu.sh/jh1ki.jpg, doesn't it look better in this pattern? (just cosmetic thing) goes against general spacing so cant really do it gg

Hitsounds:

01:05:451 (5) - whistle hitsound (addition drum) makes weird effect (or it's just over 50 repeats of this section with and without hitsounds Oo). I would change addition into auto, sounds right this way. there's some really high pitch drum thing so id rather emphasize that than using a normal whistle


Nicely done sir!

Hard

00:59:785 (2,3) - actual positioning is little confusing, to avoid this and make more intuitive follow, i would change them with places ex. http://puu.sh/jh2b1.jpg made it less confusing

02:14:285 (1,2,3,4,5) - repositioning this combo makes it easier to follow from 02:14:118 (5) and transitioning into 02:15:618 (1) combo later on, looks better imo. ex. after change - http://puu.sh/jh39B.jpg i think that screenshot just lowered the spacing of the jumps? if so, all jumps are the same thing (1.6x) while regular spacing is all 1.3x, so making these smaller kinda defeats the purpose

02:48:285 (3,4) - not nesesery, looks good, personaly i see good option to change this into slider (expl: music section started with 2 sliders and finished with slider, double in betwin might be too harrash) there's a new drum sound that comes in there so circles are there to bring it out ya


Nice job with this diff, reminds me fun to play grumd igorrr maps.

Apocalyptica is good :3
Good luck on ranking this! eythanks

Cheers!

Mackenzie wrote:

quick m4m

General

1. should disable widescreen support doesnt matter but yea
2. in case you did a break in the lower diffs,you should also do in the higher diffs(or fill the lower diff breaks),see previous dq example: t/307620/start=60

qat pls

Normal

1. not necessary,but better hitsound the sliderticks when clap by using green lines like 01:08:951 (1) - 01:45:618 (2) - or whatever,im sure that gives a quality bonus to the diff it self i find slidertick hitsounds kinda misleading, so i try to never use them
2. 02:16:618 (4) - this touch the hp bar,lower it down a bit did

Advanced

1. fine

Hard

1. 02:01:951 (5) - this is the only slider that doesnt parallel with the previous one in this part lol,suggest keep doing parallel,ik the rhythm is different,but still it's to indicate how many repeats there are, since having them parallel makes them seem like they should be the same
2. 02:08:951 (1,2) - better avoid overlap like this,overlapping 60% of the hit circle is too much for hard imo 0k
3. 02:57:618 (3) - yeah you should do something similar to you did in the other diffs ol

Insane

1. 01:17:618 (3,4) - i think you also need a jump here, yes,it sounds different than 01:17:951 (5,6) - ,but you did a jump 00:49:618 (3,4) - well not jump but at least dont do a stack here, suggest do like a triangle shape for 01:17:618 (3,4,5) - or something else,yea dont stack them unstacked
2. 02:16:285 (1,2) - kinda like ^, but the reason is kinds different because those drums are high tone drum beats and shouldnt be stacked imo,really suggest separate them a bit this one should be fine since it's a stack on a sound that repeats for both objects

Collab Insane

1. 01:05:951 (1,2,1) - kinda subjective but i dont feel that kind of turn is nice, you did 1 and 2 same as the previous pattern and some player may thought that this pattern is similar to 01:04:951 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - too, so they may just move to 417,304 because of their muscle memories,i do suggest you do the pattern here in a same way of 01:04:951 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - made it more triangular

Extra

1. 00:42:787 (2) - why not nc due to the instant spacing and speed change :< 2 ncs iin a row is pretty eh
2. 01:23:285 (1,2,3,4,1) - actually plays not fine lol truuuuuuuu
3. 01:56:785 (8,1) - distance of this should be larger than 01:56:451 (6,7) - since what youve did for your previous downbeats lol it was like barely different
4. 02:14:951 (2) - if you are really following the music i would suggest you nc at here lol but i saw your patterns,so do nc here if you still want take my suggestion made stuff less shit

Extreme

1. 02:04:285 (6,7,8,9) - should turn these into stream because what youve did at 01:59:951 (3,4,5,6,1) - ,always keep your rhythm and pattern unified lol the 2 parts you linked aren't the same thing tho. 02:04:618 (1,2,3,4) - should be the same as 01:59:951 (3,4,5,6) - , but 02:04:285 (6,7,8,9) - relates more to 01:59:452 (10,11,1) - so stuff is unified i guess
2. 02:20:785 (10,11,12,13,1) - ^
3. 02:54:285 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - i feel those sliders are too loud, try 02:54:285 25% 02:54:951 35% 02:55:618 45% 02:56:285 55%,much better lowered the section overall

anyways nice map
take my star and good luck

Cherry Blossom wrote:

Hello from my queue.
Please, reply to this mod and tell me why you didn't change without saying "it's my style" or "there are already ranked maps with the same kind of pattern" or other reasons like this.

Normal

• 
  Nothing to say.

Advanced

1. 02:12:951 (4,5) - It could be better if you keep the consistency with other patterns, i mean these objects should be stacked, i didn't see another pattern like this which has unstacked objects like this. yo

Hard

1. 01:21:618 (4,5) - I don't really agree with these 2 kick sliders, this part is enough stressful for hard players with the previous 1/4, and note that a reversed slider with 2 reverse is fast and surprising, the player should play them with alternating fingers. It could be better if you get rid of this reversed slider 01:21:951 (5) - and extend 01:21:618 (4) - to 01:22:201 -. There will be the same sliders with the same length, and it will be less confusing and stressful to the hard player. Same for 02:04:285 (4,5) - yoooooooo

Insane

• 
  Nothing to say.

Collab Insane

• 
  Nothing to say. ringating is a professional mapper right

Extra

1. 00:55:118 (2,1,2) - This looks a little confusing because of the antijump here 00:55:285 (1,2) - , there is nothing really outstanding on the song which can justify that, excepted the way you used hitsounds. Also, it will be more logical if there is a higher distance between 00:55:285 (1,2) - , because the notes are stronger than 00:54:951 (1,2) - or equivalent, and i didn't really get why there is an antijump here. the second grouping is smaller to represent instrument pitches getting lower. it's like this on extreme too. similar thing with slider velocity represnting that on insane as well
2. 01:33:451 (5,1) - There should be a higher distance between these streams because there is a high distance here between 01:32:951 (5,1) - , and it makes the player hit this stream too early 01:33:618 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - (I hit it too early too). The distance between 01:33:451 (5,1) - looks like an antijump between streams, so a little slowdown. And if the player is not accurate at all, he will just hit this stream too early and spam a little if he doesn't know how to aim this shape, which is a little dificult to aim. A higher distance could help the player to read it properly. Same for 02:26:451 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - yeeeee

Extreme

1. 01:20:618 (7,8,9,10,1) - If you don't really want to make the next pattern a little difficult to read, expecially with 01:20:951 (1,5) - , just change a little this 5 circles stream shape and make it manually straight like this : does that one angled circle actualy make things more difficult to read lol
   
   SPOILER

   

Nothing much to say.
Call me back. pls