CptSqBany wrote:
Updating my mod because you've added a new diff
[General]
Update your description
[Skystar's Tragic Love Extra]
[General]
It's not as much Skystar-ish as your other maps that's sad
Also on the other hand it's FINALLY SOMETHING NEW HERE. Only thing i see on this map is non stop | Triple, Circle, Circle | Triple, Circle, Circle |...
[Mapping]
00:09:031 (2) - too short imo it follows the bass
02:13:122 (1) - wut this hitsound? what?
02:51:303 - and this has fcking sense... SV slowly increases as Kiai time is coming.. Briliant idea!
02:51:303 - Finally somebody mapped this part! omg ty <3
Rumia- wrote:
water touch
just look out through the higher diffs as i really want to see this qualified asap ;w;
these are just suggestions ~
[Skystar]
00:09:031 (2) - i think this would be better if you move it to 00:09:167 - it follows the bass
00:13:735 (2) - just opinion that this triplet isnt really needed , i think better add a circle at 00:14:144 - would feel better it plays kinda well actually
00:35:553 - i kinda hear a bass kick here though but im not sure how to suggest xD yeah its off and weird
01:43:394 (4) - i think this change to a normal sample ? i think 01:42:849 (2) - this one should be finish imo
01:44:758 (1) - maybe lower this tail's volume , kinda sound weird
01:55:667 (1,2) - no slow sv www the bass here doesn't suddenly "stop" like the other kiais, so yeah
01:59:076 (1,2,3) - i think this triplet is kinda too far away from the previous object , considering this is 220 bpm kinda easy to choke
02:18:985 (2) - nc this ? i 2 times misread this xD weird
03:07:667 (1) - hmm i think maybe shorten this by 1/4 and add a circle on 03:07:940 - ? its really a strong beat , pressing it feel so shuang i prefer the present vibe, sorry ;;
With highscore as wellXOlifreX wrote:
Damn, if this map gets ranked,then it will be probably #1 on the Most Played Beatmaps for weeks xd
thanks for help, fixed most of these except things about 3/4s because I really hope to keep it... T_TAsphyxia wrote:
Nice map, but the usage of 3/4 sliders in the later parts of the map on Final Reverberant Gonkanau feel rather excessive, forced and inconsistent instead of fun. Personally speaking, changing the rhythm to mainly 1/2 like you have on your first and second kiai would feel much more ''on-going'' and more fun, especially when the song doesn't necessarily support every extension you have.
[Final Reverberant Gonkanau]That's about it. I decided to pop the bubble for now so no one can sneak rank it with ignoring this post, especially when there's a wrongly snapped slider. The ''overmapped'' parts are rather consistent throughout the map, but especially those two stood out the most. Please consider these suggestions, and if you want to, you could ask more opinions about the extended sliders. Anyhow, let's hope we find an agreement here and afterwards I'll rebubble!
- 02:17:485 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - This highlighted area feels really big and weird compared to the rest of the jumps you had. Might be due to their angle they have, but reducing them a little or trying to find a better place for them could be an option! I reduce a little distance, though looks not that different? hah
- 03:00:031 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - All of these extensions could be toned down a little, especially when some, if not most don't really follow the vocals as well as they could. If you want to, you could consider changing the rhythm up a little. symmetry rhythm here looks cooler imo lol
- 03:00:849 (4) - Unsnapped, please snap it back to 1/4 instead of 1/8.
- 03:02:212 (3,5,6) - Here too, I honestly don't think you need all of these extensions when it could play better as 1/2. Do consider 03:03:576 (5,6) - strongly though, as the vocals kind of stop being strong at 03:03:712 - , so ending the slider there would make a lot of sense, and 03:03:985 - has a clear beat to it, so I don't think it's wise to skip over it.
- 03:04:394 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Same here as the first one, despite it being consistent here. As the final kiai, you could use more 1/2 sliders and notes to boost up the intensivity a bit.
- 03:08:758 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6) - Same would apply here too!
- 03:23:758 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - I do like a little variation, but the fact that I can't hear ANYTHING that would justify this stream. I even played the part with 25% playback rate. The others fall under this case too, so you could consider fixing 03:27:712 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - stuff like this too.