forum

The Mafia Tree - Game Over

posted
Total Posts
1,971
show more
sLaiNi
Okay if there's no way around this:

I don't see any reasons to suspect MB at all. Same goes to RB.
Haneii isn't suspicious for his behaviour, the whole bolded thing makes me wonder though. But scum would never target themselves if it's something like "you cant hear me", rather they would use it to shift suspicion.


NS is still my number one scum. He made sounds today, kill occured and noone claimed to target him. He IS scum and all reason why I get lynched now is, that he said I lie. One of us lies so he is scum. Don't even dare let him excuse himself tomorrow. Lynch him.

Setsuen shifting suspicion and reading only half of the game is suspicious.

Amianki claims town doctor. Seems believable.

I create this list in case the game doesn't end after NS lynch.
sLaiNi
Okay, I was in a hurry writing the post above, in case I get hammered in the meanwhile.


Basically NS is 100% scum, lynch him. He played his whole cards on getting me off of him.

I had doubts, because scum would never ever play so aggressively and making obvious ML tries.

For explanation AGAIN why you need to kill him:

He made sounds today, and he said I would lie. Noone targeted him (town should've already claimed if they did) so he made the NK.

Then again there is a high chance of Amianki lying for some reason, as I don't understand no kill happening after she targeted NS. There are two things that could've happened:
1. Amianki is doc and actually targeted NS but NS didn't NK then for whatever reason
2. Amianki is scum and lied to create confusion either way to give NS towncred (if they are team) or for creating a ML
So either Amianki is scumteam with NS or in any way she is the scum instead. (or he, sorry for calling you "she" then :x)
Topic Starter
Sakura
I'm tired and gonna take a nap, even if i wake up past the deadline, only votes and unvotes made before the deadline will count.
MBomb
Ok, glad I waited. Still gonna hammer though if no one else changes their vote in the next like 10 minutes. I would rather have a mislynch that gives us enough information to secure a win in the next 2 days than no lynch.
MBomb
If you flip town though, we will lynch NS.
sLaiNi

- Magic Bomb - wrote:

If you flip town though, we will lynch NS.
Thank you that we're clear about that one :D
sLaiNi

Sakura wrote:

I'm tired and gonna take a nap, even if i wake up past the deadline, only votes and unvotes made before the deadline will count.
Thanks for modding this game, it was a lot of fun and your small little texts on each deadline, which represent the events of the day, just made me laugh every single time, because they exactly describe what was stupid/funny about the day. Keep up the good work :)
MBomb
Ok, let's see then.

Vote: Slaini
notscience
I just woke up from a nap.
sLaiNi
Still have fun guys and good luck.

And finally I get the good feeling of showing Setsuen how much he was right with his, I quote, "Pro scumhunting abilities" due to which "sLaiNi is obviously scum"
notscience
Your posts feel very much like you know the game just ended.
sLaiNi

notscience wrote:

Your posts feel very much like you know the game just ended.

Don't try to post some last townish posts to begin tomorrow with "OMG read this post of me '>>your posts feel like [...]the game just ended<<'.
notscience
lol.
MBomb
Oh also I'm pretty sure I know exactly who's gonna die tonight, Amianki if you could protect them that'll be great (Hopefully you know).
Raging Bull

Amianki wrote:

Sorry, I can only see two possibilities right now:

1. Notscience was targeted for a kill and survived.
2. Scum no-kill gambited. This actually incriminates sLaiNi, if anyone, because he was the one who was trying so hard to get a massclaim of sounds.

Vote: sLaiNi

I really think we're overthinking this game by a massive amount.

What. Why did you protect a scum read then??
Topic Starter
Sakura
Final Vote Count Day 5

sLaiNi (4) - notscience, Setsuen, Amianki. - Magic Bomb - [LYNCH!]
notscience (2) - sLaiNi, Raging Bull
Raging Bull (1) - Haneii

With 7 Alive it takes 4 to Lynch
Raging Bull
God damnit guys. I dont see this slaini lynch even good at all.

Is 4 scum in 13p setup common? If not then CB cant be scum at all.
Topic Starter
Sakura
notscience: But you're a double voter, you can't be making sounds!
sLaiNi: But no one has claimed targeting you either!
notscience and sLaiNi step into the ring.
3
2
1
FIGHT!
notscience launches an uppercut, which is dodged by sLaiNi who then headbutts notscience on the belly, notscience a little dazed gets up, who then does a flying kick at sLaiNi, sLaiNi dodges and notscience almost falls then sLaiNi tries to headbutt again, notscience trips to the side, and sLaiNi falls off the treehouse...

Or maybe he was just voted out


sLaiNi Treehouse Early Bird (Town D1 Double Voter) was lynched Day 5
sLaiNi

Sakura wrote:

Hi, you are a Treehouse Early Bird (Town D1 Double Voter)
You always wake up early and this gives your arguments more confidence in the early game.
D1 Double Voter: During Day 1 your votes will count as 2, you may only be voting for one player at any given time.

You win when all the invaders have been kicked out of the treehouse
Topic Starter
Sakura
~Night 5~
- Sorrow -
Current Housing

[-VACANT-]
[Setsuen]
[- Magic Bomb -]
[Haneii]
[Raging Bull]
[-VACANT-]
[Amianki]
[-VACANT-]
[-VACANT-]
[notscience]
[-VACANT-]
[-VACANT-]
[-VACANT-]


All actions are due in my inbox with 24 hours, all alive parties with night actions may also let me know if they want to end the night early.
Topic Starter
Sakura
Apparently someone never got their papers on time... too bad they died before they got formalized

Setsuen Treehouse Outsider (Town Miller) has been killed Night 5
Setsuen

Sakura wrote:

Hi, you are a Treehouse Outsider (Town Miller)
Being an outsider you don't appear on the records so you may be easily confused for one of the treehouse invaders.
Miller: You appear as guilty to all cops.

You win when all the invaders have been kicked out of the treehouse
~Day 6~
- Impending Doom -
Current Housing

[-VACANT-]
[-VACANT-]
[- Magic Bomb -]
[Haneii]
[Raging Bull]
[-VACANT-]
[Amianki]
[-VACANT-]
[-VACANT-]
[notscience]
[-VACANT-]
[-VACANT-]
[-VACANT-]


Deadline for hammer is 9/22 16:00 GMT-5

Vote Count 6.0

Not voting (5) - - Magic Bomb -, Raging Bull, Haneii, Amianki, notscience

With 5 Alive it takes 3 to lynch
MBomb
vote:notscience
Amianki
Waiting to see if anyone has interesting info to share first.
Raging Bull

Amianki wrote:

Sorry, I can only see two possibilities right now:

1. Notscience was targeted for a kill and survived.
2. Scum no-kill gambited. This actually incriminates sLaiNi, if anyone, because he was the one who was trying so hard to get a massclaim of sounds.

Vote: sLaiNi

I really think we're overthinking this game by a massive amount.
Break this down for me. But if scum incriminates slaini, then you should know he wont be scum? Also why did you vote slaini when you protected him?

@MB why did you change your original vote?

vote NS
Amianki
We were in a situation where NS and sLaiNi both heard each other two nights in a row and claimed actions didn't account for the discrepancy. Occam's razor says that sLaiNi is the scum in that scenario because of who was protected from kills at the time as well as his play after the kill was blocked.

This conclusion could only have been reached after night 4 since Ace Timing's scum flip kind of cleared up the air by itself and sLaiNi looked like the strongest contender for the nightkill at the time.
Amianki
btw I'm protecting Haneii tonight if notscience lynch doesn't end the game somehow.

If there are any other town PRs left, don't use it.
Amianki
Actually, now I'm thinking Haneii is the reason there was no kill night 3, not me.

Haneii 100% should claim before day ends.
Topic Starter
Sakura
Vote Count 6.01

notscience (2) - - Magic Bomb -, Raging Bull [L-1]

Not voting (3) - Haneii, Amianki, notscience

With 5 Alive it takes 3 to lynch
Amianki
Last thing.

Amianki wrote:

Waiting to see if anyone has interesting info to share first.
I'm treating a hammer on notscience before everyone has been able to post (for the above reason) and Haneii has claimed as a scumclaim. Just fyi
Haneii

Amianki wrote:

Actually, now I'm thinking Haneii is the reason there was no kill night 3, not me.

Haneii 100% should claim before day ends.
*sigh* D3 DV


Goodnight.
Raging Bull

Amianki wrote:

We were in a situation where NS and sLaiNi both heard each other two nights in a row and claimed actions didn't account for the discrepancy. Occam's razor says that sLaiNi is the scum in that scenario because of who was protected from kills at the time as well as his play after the kill was blocked.

This conclusion could only have been reached after night 4 since Ace Timing's scum flip kind of cleared up the air by itself and sLaiNi looked like the strongest contender for the nightkill at the time.
Ok. I understand first part. Second part, why is slaini kill more likely? Due to him being the secnd major wagon? So you only protected slaini n4, but his play d5 made you see him as scum? What about the noise NS made?

Amianki wrote:

btw I'm protecting Haneii tonight if notscience lynch doesn't end the game somehow.

If there are any other town PRs left, don't use it.
Best to protect yourself if you can so we can have one conf town at least. As for other PR, assuming MB isnt lying, he and I are now VT.

Imo, its odd enough both hear noises, but even weirder is that on different days, they only had one confirmed action on both. Im sure enough that there should be one more PR hidden in either NS or Haneii if NS is town.
MBomb
NS, roleclaim now.
Raging Bull
Why did you change your original vote?
MBomb

Raging Bull wrote:

Why did you change your original vote?
Because I wanted a lynch.
Haneii
prod notscience, please.
Topic Starter
Sakura

Haneii wrote:

prod notscience, please.
notscience has been prodded!
notscience
I'm VT.
notscience
Haneii is probably town.

Ank is town.

Ank probably dies, haneii is left to decide between theo ther two.
MBomb

notscience wrote:

I'm VT.
Ok yeah, lynch then. Sorry if this claim is true but I don't see any reason Slaini would lie about hearing sounds.
Amianki
Vote: notscience
Topic Starter
Sakura
Vote Count Day 6 Final

notscience (3) - - Magic Bomb -, Raging Bull, Amianki [LYNCH]

Not voting (2) - Haneii, notscience

With 5 Alive it takes 3 to lynch
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply