[Frostmourne]
This atmosphere wouldn't have existed if v2b hadn't mapped this song for his version in the past. you are very right about this.

By the way, I hope I can help a bit, these come from my opinion only from what I got while playing through the Gold and Chrome diff.
(you know that I can play these in real play, not only watch to the editor)

Platinum
01:04:633 (2,3,4,5) - this is my personal preference, I feel what Charles feels the same (maybe because I am really familiar with v2b version)
the reason in my opinion is
01:03:802 (5,6) - these 2 sliders' heads are following something like 01:04:558 , 01:04:860 - and so on<-(focus on these points)
They have heavier sound and beat in the music, and what people get recognized from 01:03:802 (5,6) - will conflict with these 01:04:633 (2,3,4,5) -
by the way, the way you map follows the music greatly too , just different rhythm , if I were you , I would replace these points 01:04:633 (2,3,4,5) - with 1/4 sliders instead to at least "introduce and guide" how the next rhythm will be, so this will be more expected

it's not really hard to learn in my opinion. It's actually pretty obvious that 01:04:633 (2,3,4,5) are 1/4 mainly because of the spacing. And maybe you're right about players getting used to v2b's version thingy.



these look awesome in my opinion , but when I play, I feel they are a bit hard to read because of how it stacks and my ability of playing.
however, I tried adding NC on these points and they became really easier and fun to read while playing (because of different combo's color indicates more clearly for these points)
but again, all about NC here will ruin the way you NC in the rest of the map.
fixed. And it now looks way readable XD

Good luck ! [/quote]

[quote="Garven"]Just doing a quick poke at the Platinum diff since that seems to be in contention. I started in IRC, but since your keyboard is having issues (?) here's your post.

Set your stack leniency to default. There's no reason for it to be so low.
00:12:110 (1) - Sudden .5x -> 1x is rather jarring and generally discouraged in modern mapping due to having much better options available to make such a transition much smoother.
I'm emphasizing the 'sudden' and loud drum beats in the music. And i believe using a x1 slider SV would pretty much fit with the music perfectly.

00:18:458 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Can you spread these out a bit more? Maybe do a slight rotate on them. They're pretty much covered up by hitbursts and a pain to read. "Extra" or not, you want the hit objects to be accessible and readable. Difficulty level doesn't matter.
fixed i guess.

00:34:177 (1,2,3,5,6,7,9,10,11) - Maybe have more obvious change in this curve so it gives the impression that there is a change like what you did at 00:27:224 (5,7) - and 00:37:956 (3,5,7,9) -
tried to fix by NCing stuff.

00:40:677 (7,8) - This gap in the rhythm is placed oddly. It feels like you're not finishing up the rhythmic phrase. Try deleting the 6 and the 13 for a more natural rhythm. Also on 00:41:810 (6) -
no change sorry. I like the present one rather than your suggestion.

00:44:455 (1) - More with the weird and unfitting .5x stuff. All of that super-slow movement kills any sort of flow you had for 00:53:222 (6,7) - since it's the same part of the same phrase you had mapped prior, but suddenly you have giant spacing for seemingly no reason at all.
have you tried playing it? try playing it instead. You'll notice a good flow of cursor movement without having the bother of giant spacing.

00:57:152 (1,2) - Shouldn't this be 1/3? Slow the song down and listen to it. 1/4 sounds wrong. The end of 2 is snapped right though. There's a bunch in here. You know what to do.
I prefer 1/4. I know it is 1/3. And I believe there is nothing wrong with that.

00:59:268 (2) - This slider is pretty much covered up by hitbursts. but it is much very predictable that the slider head is there. And it's just partly covered so i guess there is nothing wrong with that.


01:11:662 (1) - The emphasis is more on the on-beat rather than the offbeat, so these triples play really awkwardly. It'd play more naturally like this. I'm trying to do v2b style here. D:

Also the same suggestion about making the curve offset with each triple so that it reads easier and stays consistent with the previous patterns.
01:14:080 (1) - Same thing here, blah blah. Applies to other iterations
Same reason as well.

01:38:264 (1,1,1,1) - Please don't new combo spam
Fixed. I did (1,2,1,2) instead. i hope you would let me add a new combo here. This is because I want to help the player's hp go up a little bit before they enter the final part of the diff.

01:56:704 (2,3,4) - Kinda weird spacing considering the even spacing right before it but it is very predictable that it is 1/4.

okay, changed all the parts where it needs to be 1/3 according to Charles. Waiting for his response ~

Yeah I allow Philippines to copy some of my concepts.

thank you v2b <3

v2b wrote:

Yeah I allow Philippines to copy some of my concepts.

Okay, great!

Bubble! - Bubble! - Bubble!

/me cheers. o3o

Used qoot8123 and wmfchris mod. Thanks guys.
Also, I have finally my Taiko BG which is rankable. Just delete the SB in my difficultie please. After that everything is finished.

Download: http://puu.sh/2mvlY

Updated. Let's go.

Ranking BAT, please have an extra look at the taikos. The oni and muzu play well, but the iinner oni has some oddities that I can't put my finger on.
There isn't any reason to not bubble this, so yeah rebubbled.

Okay. Thanks Charles! XD

<erased post>

Amazing, masterpiece!

[Ono's Taiko Inner Oni]

1. 02:07:284 (1) - Not sure if this finish is fine. Just at the end of a 1/4 stream at 198 BPM so ...

[Gold]

1. 01:32:823 (2,1) - In my opinion this anti-jump is a bad idea, you can't really predict it, so it ight confuse the player. I'd rather you changed the spacing to something that feels more natural and intuitive.

That's all I have to say here ~

Kurai wrote:

[Ono's Taiko Inner Oni]

1. 02:07:284 (1) - Not sure if this finish is fine. Just at the end of a 1/4 stream at 198 BPM so ...

Unrankable, especially at this bpm, should be red.

http://puu.sh/2pk1j

fixed. no overlap anymore

Love wrote:

Kurai wrote:

[Ono's Taiko Inner Oni]

1. 02:07:284 (1) - Not sure if this finish is fine. Just at the end of a 1/4 stream at 198 BPM so ...

Unrankable, especially at this bpm, should be red.

Taiko Ranking Criteria wrote:

Finish notes

Finish notes must not be in the middle or at the beginning in a 1/4 or above stream.

At the end, finish streams may be allowed if there is a reasonable sound for it under following pattern constellations: xxxxxxxxO, xxxxooooX, xxooxxooX

Anyway, I told Philippines to delete note 02:07:209 (4) - so we have ddddkkk D. Didn't used any of these patterns before, that's the reason for deleting it.

Thanks!

Changelog:

1. [Gold] LKs fixed the overlap Kurai pointed.
2. [Platinum] Fixed the flow of circles in a stream on 01:49:071 (8,1,2).
3. [Platinum]Fixed the slider on 02:00:029 (1). I made it parallel again. (who made it unparallel? D:)
4. [Inner Oni] Deleted a note on 02:07:209 (4) to fix what Kurai pointed.

Updated. Let's go!

sshhh

WHAT THE! YOU SURPRISED ME! D THANK YOU KURAI!!

congratz

congrats Philippines

wow gj

Nice!

Can't defeat shitty stamina
gratz

Congratz. ;3

Congratz.

Nice that it is ranked but I have to say that I really dislike the hitclaps. They don't fit the song at all.
Good luck for me that you don't seem to use them in the silver and platinum (can't play that one though ... to hard) diff. but chrome sounds terrible because of them
Also something minor that botheres me a bit is in silver: 01:16:498 (1,2,1,2,3) -
I don't think it is that readable in the first play but since I have nothing against retrying until perfection I am not bothered that much by it.

Congrats Philli :3

Craaaaaazyyyyyyyy Stream/

congratulations

congrz!!!!!

bomber34 wrote:

Nice that it is ranked but I have to say that I really dislike the hitclaps. They don't fit the song at all.

I told you Philippines

lol

Congrats, Philippines!

hey congratz \o\

Just E.P.I.C.
Congratz~~

I didn't know that this song has a lyric, I always thought that it's AH~AH~ the whole time and I try to sing this...

Gz, pro beatmap

Orz, low star rating @_@

AsprikaQ wrote:

I didn't know that this song has a lyric, I always thought that it's AH~AH~ the whole time and I try to sing this...

This happened to me as well ^^

Quiz-chan wrote:

Orz, low star rating @_@

Too many downvoters D: Maybe because it's too hard. D: lol

Congratulations Philippines!

Great map

congratz /

nice map!

I love this map, it's a great one

but





Guess I'll clear it some other time :<

AzerFrost wrote:

I love this map, it's a great one

but





Guess I'll clear it some other time :<

pls dont spam me next tim pls tht wus very hurtful ; ;

Hahaha banchobot got upset too
Keep trying for it!

I lol'd so hard. HAHAHA! That was a great play <3

There's no sb in Gold diff?

And a sb for muzu and oni?

Or it was me?

sub error
Pow! got him in the eye
Plow got him in the eye.