becareful about the notes snap
almost fixed, the rest.. i didn't reject it, and just delete the section rather than addHarbyter wrote:
[Extra]IRC17:27 Harbyter: update million
17:28 Remillion Cross: wait
17:29 Remillion Cross: done
17:29 Harbyter: k
17:29 Harbyter: going to have some irc with usagi and raika
17:29 Harbyter: then with you
17:30 Harbyter: so i can already qualify it
17:30 Harbyter: xd
17:30 Remillion Cross: okay
17:35 Harbyter: million
17:36 Harbyter: check your extra too
17:36 Harbyter: xD
17:36 Harbyter: 00:29:117 - 00:29:289 -
17:36 Harbyter: ca you hear something here?
17:36 Harbyter: can"
17:36 Remillion Cross: yea ?
17:36 Remillion Cross: ok then
17:37 Remillion Cross: nothing, it's just for.. well you know.. pattern works for the song, that's why bms had too much overnoted but it still fun
17:38 Harbyter: this is considered ghost note
17:38 Harbyter: 00:29:462 - here too
17:38 Remillion Cross: ok
17:38 Harbyter: i'm checking raika too
17:38 Harbyter: so i'm pointing out all the ghost notes at the moment
17:39 Remillion Cross: ok
17:39 Harbyter: 00:31:013 -
17:39 Harbyter: nothin ghere
17:39 Harbyter: sound in 1/6
17:39 Harbyter: 00:30:985 - 00:31:042 -
17:40 Remillion Cross: decided to delete all the notes
17:40 Harbyter: 00:30:841 - delete this too here
17:40 Harbyter: nothing here too
17:40 Remillion Cross: ok
17:41 Harbyter: 00:32:220 - here too
17:41 Harbyter: nothing
17:42 Harbyter: 00:32:479 - 00:32:565 - nothing here too
17:42 Harbyter: sound are in 1/6 here
17:42 Harbyter: 00:32:422 - 00:32:536 -
17:43 Remillion Cross: continue
17:44 Remillion Cross: can't add 1/6, it ruins the pattern ;-;
17:44 Harbyter: eh T.T
17:44 Harbyter: atm just fix the ghost notes
17:44 Remillion Cross: yea ofc
17:45 Harbyter: 00:32:910 - isn't here another 1/6
17:45 Harbyter: 00:32:881 - 00:32:939 -
17:46 Remillion Cross: ok
17:46 Remillion Cross: are you sure ?
17:46 Remillion Cross: well.. i don't wanna get the problem with the QATs, so make sure you heard it correctly
17:46 Harbyter: yep
17:46 Harbyter: 00:32:824 - 00:32:996 - listen
17:46 Remillion Cross: ok then
17:46 Remillion Cross: continue
17:46 Harbyter: 4 sound change
17:48 Harbyter: 00:35:238 - i think this LN is strange
17:48 Harbyter: no sound for a LN
17:50 Remillion Cross: lol
17:50 Remillion Cross: ok
17:52 Harbyter: 00:40:151 - 00:40:238 - 00:40:324 -
17:52 Harbyter: nothing
17:52 Harbyter: sound in 1/3
17:52 Harbyter: 00:40:180 - 00:40:295 -
17:53 Remillion Cross: ok
17:53 Harbyter: 00:42:048 - nothing here too
17:53 Harbyter: 1/6
17:55 Harbyter: 00:44:893 -
17:55 Harbyter: nothing
17:56 Remillion Cross: ok
18:00 Harbyter: 00:49:893 - add for piano
18:00 Remillion Cross: ok
18:00 Remillion Cross: btw, just point out everything that looks odd here
18:00 Remillion Cross: gonna afk for sec
18:00 Harbyter: 00:50:123 -
18:00 Harbyter: nothing here
18:00 Harbyter: k
18:01 Harbyter: oh
18:01 Harbyter: wrong
18:01 Harbyter: there's a piano in the last link
18:01 Harbyter: ignore it
18:05 Remillion Cross: :v
18:06 Harbyter: 00:50:640 - nothing here
18:06 Harbyter: 00:50:697 - piano start here
18:06 Harbyter: xd
18:06 Remillion Cross: continue
18:07 Harbyter: 00:57:134 -
18:07 Harbyter: nothing
18:07 Harbyter: 00:57:077 - 00:57:192 - sound in 1/3
18:08 Harbyter: 00:59:117 -
18:09 Harbyter: nothing
18:09 Harbyter: tick in 1/6
18:09 Harbyter: 00:59:088 - 00:59:146 -
18:09 Remillion Cross: delete
18:09 Remillion Cross: continue
18:09 Harbyter: 01:02:393 - nothing
18:10 Remillion Cross: i started to confused
18:11 Harbyter: why
18:11 Harbyter: ?
18:11 Remillion Cross: if you said that those pattern were considered as ghost note
18:11 Harbyter: cause no sound there
18:11 Remillion Cross: then most of 4k also had more ghost note
18:11 Harbyter: depend
18:12 Remillion Cross: just look at bangin burst
18:12 Harbyter: bang is an old map
18:12 Harbyter: there are sure lot of ghost notes
18:13 Remillion Cross: what is the difference ?
18:15 Harbyter: mmm
18:15 Remillion Cross: nevermind
18:15 Remillion Cross: forget it
18:15 Remillion Cross: continue modding
18:15 Harbyter: rules on old map weren't so strict
18:15 Harbyter: but now those are important since the mapping community improved
18:15 Harbyter: another example is thunderbolt
18:15 Harbyter: in the 4k
18:15 Harbyter: last snap are totally wrong
18:16 Harbyter: and looooot of other wrong snap
18:16 Harbyter: xD
18:16 Harbyter: 01:03:082 - fix those LN
18:16 Harbyter: 1/4 the piano
18:17 Remillion Cross: ok
18:18 Harbyter: 01:05:065 (65065|3) - nothing move here 01:05:008 -
18:19 Remillion Cross: deleted
18:20 Harbyter: 01:05:496 - nothing ,that sound is here in 1/6 01:05:525 -
18:21 Remillion Cross: ok
18:22 Remillion Cross: er sorry, can you do it faster ? well.. because i got a work tomorrow, and should be sleep soon
18:23 Harbyter: oh
18:24 Harbyter: then update ,i will end in the forum cause there are lot of things to fix
18:24 Remillion Cross: ok
18:26 Harbyter: timezone sucks orz
18:26 Harbyter: xD
18:28 Remillion Cross: updated
18:28 Remillion Cross: yea, it sucks
18:28 Remillion Cross: btw just post this irc mod, plus the rest of the mod in thread
18:28 Harbyter: yep
01:05:755 (65755|2) - sound here in 1/8 01:05:712 -
01:05:841 (65841|4,65841|1) - piano start here 01:05:812 - 1/6
01:08:082 - 01:08:255 - nothing ,piano in 1/6 in this section
01:08:945 (68945|1) - nothing ,piano in 1/6 here 01:08:916 - 01:08:973 -
01:34:462 (94462|3) - nothing
01:56:660 (116660|4,116703|3,116746|2) - remove ,piano start here 01:56:789 -
02:00:324 - add note here for piano and remove here 02:00:669 (120669|3) - ,no sound
02:03:255 (123255|3) - no sound
02:22:048 (142048|5) - nothing here ,sound in 1/6 02:22:019 - 02:22:077 -
[Hyper]
00:57:134 (57134|3) - fix this ,nothing here tick in 1/3 00:57:077 - 00:57:192 -
00:59:117 (59117|0) - nothing here ,tick in 1/6 00:59:088 - 00:59:146 -
01:05:065 (65065|2) - remove ,nothing
01:06:876 (66876|4) - nothing in 1/4 sound in 1/6 01:06:847 - 01:06:904 -
01:56:660 (116660|5,116703|4,116746|2) - remove those too piano don't start here and i suggest to rearrange the stair like this cause that pattern is pretty hard for novice
01:59:031 (119031|4) - suggest to remove, just follow the piano here xd
02:03:427 (123427|2) - no sound in 1/4 but in 1/6 02:03:399 - 02:03:456 -
02:22:048 (142048|5) - no sound in 1/4 but in 1/6
[standard]
00:47:651 (47651|5) - suggest to move this note here 00:47:565 -
01:44:893 (104893|1) - fix this snap move here 01:44:807 -
01:45:123 (105123|5) - here 01:45:065 -
01:45:353 (105353|0) - here 01:45:324 -
ok thanks harby, we've fixed some incorrect snap, again in irc..Harbyter wrote:
01:09:117 (69117|5,69203|4,69289|2,69462|5,69634|3,69807|2,69893|5,70151|2) - ghost ,those sound that you can hear aren't in 1/4
01:11:186 (71186|2,71358|6) - ~
01:45:496 (105496|3) - ~ // keep..
all done.. <3Harbyter wrote:
check after updating the new mp3
[all diff]
00:25:434 - notes here in Standard /Usagi/Hyper and Asgard wrong snap should be in 1/6 here 00:25:463 -
00:37:015 - fix all those snap here too ,should be in 1/4 00:36:986 -
00:51:555 - remove notes here, ghost
01:08:538 - nothing here snare and piano in 1/6 01:08:509 - 01:08:566 - rearrange
02:09:428 - fix all the snap here too 02:09:400 -
02:09:917 - remove nothing
02:12:589 - 02:12:676 - nothing here too ,i can only hear something here 02:12:633 - in 1/8
02:26:440 - 02:26:497 - fix this snap again OTZ with this new mp3 this is a 1/8 lool
all done, thanks harby!Harbyter wrote:
[Beginner]
ok!
[Hyper]
01:04:658 (64658|2) - fix 1/6
01:05:980 (65980|2) - suggest to remove ,really awkward
02:11:641 (131641|1) - fix 1/6
[Standard]
ok!
[Raika]
00:49:141 (49141|3,49199|4,49256|1,49314|3,49371|5,49428|2,49486|3,49543|4,49601|2) - this pattern uhmm, try like this??
00:58:969 (58969|0,59026|4,59141|1,59227|3,59314|2) - suggest to rearrange like this
01:56:727 (116727|5,116770|3,116814|1,116857|4,116900|2,116943|0,116986|5,117029|3,117072|1,117115|6,117158|4,117201|2) - pattern like this is freaking hard for this diff ,suggest to apply a more simple stair
02:01:426 (121426|3,121426|6) - turn those LN in simple note and snap in the 1/12 02:01:411 -
[Usagi]
00:29:874 (29874|3) - fix here 00:29:831 -
02:11:598 (131598|4,131641|2,131684|1) - fix in 1/6
02:21:986 (141986|6) - fix this in 1/6
[Asgard]
00:38:883 (38883|3) - ghost
00:40:262 (40262|2) - ghost
01:07:130 (67130|0,67130|1) - end those LN here 01:07:474 -
01:26:986 (86986|1) - ghost
02:16:124 (136124|3) - ghost
[Hyper/Asgard//Raika]
00:57:072 - snap in 1/3 or 1/2 definitely wrong dunno what is this snap orz
Remillion Cross wrote:
All fixed. orz i'm tired with this lolol
All diffs updatedHarbyter wrote:
[All diff]
00:28:107 - 1/6
00:39:141 - 1/6
02:08:495 - 02:08:581 - remove nothing
[Asgard]
add a note here 00:30:865 - feel strange empty here
Remillion Cross wrote:
can you just point out all of those ? that's your job, in the case (or you can asking the other BAT for hitsound help, but don't ask Raika because he's busy)
Remillion Cross wrote:
for me, i already fixed it in my 4 Diff, and i don't see any problem (if you point out it, i bet that it will probably not so many fix to do) you're right ,just few things xD
if you see that the hitsounding in raika and usagi were a little bit different than mine, it's just because they had own hitsound, and i don't follow them
Raika use his personal hitsound (LR_blabla) in his GD, and usagi use raika hitsound. I only use kick normal finish cymbal and clap, because it's enough for me yep i understand that you didnn't followed they're hitsound, what i've checked was the hitsound in your diff ,and those are all the incosistence
Because i want to avoiding drama, so i won't reply this, but if you want to answer, i will say if this map is both ready or not ready, and that's it, you and the other BNs, was created for help make the map better, right ? Human will never perfect, anyways, but that's the way for me or the other to improve as many as we can.Harbyter wrote:
Remillion Cross wrote:
can you just point out all of those ? that's your job, in the case (or you can asking the other BAT for hitsound help, but don't ask Raika because he's busy)
indeed ,our job is to work on beatmap that looks ready for the rank.
aswer me honestly ,do you think this was really ready when i started to work on this?I think you can understand why other BN didn't started the qualify job here ,and i don't know how KK bubbled this with so many errors and hitsound incosistence
all fixed, and the previous mod, has already fixed tooHarbyter wrote:
SPOILER[Asgard]
00:46:900 (46900|5,46986|5,47158|4,47331|4) - soft-hitclap
00:47:503 - soft hitclap
00:51:038 - LR_CymbalSSF
01:06:383 - 01:06:555 - soft-hitclap
01:24:486 (84486|6,84486|2) - remove keysound
01:30:865 - add soft-hitclap
01:39:543 (99543|3,99773|3) - switch with soft-hitfinish
01:40:003 (100003|3) - switch with LR_CymbalSSF
01:44:831 - add LR_CymbbalSSF and soft-hitfinish
01:45:520 (105520|4) - LR_CymbalSSF
01:46:210 - LR_CymbalSSF
01:48:451 - soft hitclap
01:48:969 - soft hitclap
01:49:745 - LR_CymbalSSf
01:51:727 - soft hitclap
01:52:503 - LR_CymbalSSF
02:02:762 (122762|4) - switch with LR_Clap_Loud_L
02:06:038 - soft hitclap
02:08:538 - soft hitclap
02:09:314 (129314|0,129400|1) - soft hitclap
02:17:589 - soft hitclap
02:20:693 (140693|3) - switch with LR_CymbalSSf
02:24:831 - LR_CymbalSSF
02:26:426 (146426|1) - remove keysound
02:27:245 (147245|2) - remove keysound
[Hyper]
00:41:555 - add soft-hitfinish
00:46:900 - 00:46:986 - 00:47:158 - 00:47:331 - 00:47:503 - soft hitclap
00:51:038 - LR_cymbalSSF
01:06:383 - 01:06:555 - soft-hitclap
01:13:107 - LR_CymbalSSF
01:24:486 - add soft-hitfinish
01:36:038 - soft-hitclap
01:38:451 - soft hitclap
01:39:543 - 01:39:773 - add soft-hitfinish
01:45:089 - soft-hitclap
01:45:348 - soft-hitclap
01:45:520 - LR_cymbalSSF
01:47:158 - soft-hitclap
01:48:107 - soft hitclap
01:48:969 - soft hitclap
01:51:727 - soft hitclap
01:52:503 - LR_CymbalSSF
02:06:038 - soft hitclap
02:11:210 - soft-hitclap
02:11:555 (131555|0,131612|1,131670|2,131727|3) - soft hitfinish
02:13:796 - soft hitfinish
02:13:969 - soft hitfinish
02:15:951 - soft-hitclap
02:16:814 - soft hitclap
02:16:900 - soft hitclap
02:18:969 - soft hitclap
02:19:141 - soft hitclap
02:20:693 (140693|2) - switch with LR_CymbalSSF
02:22:762 - soft-hitclap
02:24:141 - soft hitclap
02:24:572 - soft hitclap
[beginner]
00:46:900 - soft hitclap
01:08:796 - soft hitclap
01:24:486 - soft-hitfinish
01:29:141 - soft hitclap
01:36:038 - soft hitclap
01:39:543 - 01:39:773 - switch with soft-hitfinish
01:45:348 - soft-hitclap
01:46:210 (106210|0) - switch keysound with LR_CymbalSSF
01:48:107 - soft-hitclap
01:48:969 - soft hitclap
01:49:745 (109745|1) - switch with LR_CymbalSSF
02:03:451 - soft hitclap
02:03:710 - soft hitclap
02:03:969 - soft-hitclap
02:07:417 - soft hitclap
02:08:279 - soft hitclap
02:09:314 - soft hitclap
02:11:210 - softhitclap
02:11:727 - soft hitfinish
02:13:969 - soft hitfinish
02:19:141 - soft hitclap
02:20:003 - 02:20:262 - 02:20:520 - soft hitclap
02:26:900 - soft hitclap
will recheck the standard after you apply those
Thank you, but sorry i'm afraid if i can't continue with this beatmap anymore (probably not going to be re-qualified)Roxas wrote:
I'm sorry but I have to disqualify this map. As other people pointed me out, there are some incorrect snapping.
[ Asgard]Then, other things:
- 00:55:865 (55865|0,55865|4) - Since they're following the piano, this snapping isn't correct. They should be moved in 00:55:908 - (you can leave a note on 00:55:865 - for the bells if you prefer).
- 01:02:762 (62762|0,63020|2) - This is wrongly snapped. This is how it should be (since you follow the piano) http://puu.sh/h2J5z/2186953705.png
- 01:08:279 (68279|0,68509|1,68566|3,68566|4) - This pattern doesn't have pretty sense for me. I mean, 01:08:566 (68566|4) - this LN follows... nothing. 01:08:509 (68509|1,68566|3) - those notes should be piano notes, and there are kicks. Okay, you can create the kicks, it's good, but at least put another note where the kick is present 01:08:624 - . Consider to repattern this part... The *minimal requirement* for me is to do something like this http://puu.sh/h2ILk/c433b127ab.png
00:24:314 (24314|6) - This part should be checked better. I tried to check the correct snapping with Audacity, but I couldn't hear correctly the notes (I can't find the correct frequency of the notes, lol). Surely that isn't 1/8 since the piano goes faster...
00:52:417 (52417|4,52417|6) - I think you might need a grace note like 00:52:460 - here.
00:55:176 (55176|2,55176|0,55176|5) - What about putting a grace note 00:55:147 - here?
Lastly, in LordRaika's diff, delete this green line http://puu.sh/h2JQY/43a466afaf.png, it seems it makes kiai buggy lol
And Ihopethink I said everything about this...