I think you can do that yourself next time you pass a modded version of your diff, eh?CDFA wrote:
Also, could you add CDFA to the tags?
forum
Corbin Bleu & Lucas Gabreel - I Don't Dance
posted
Total Posts
61
Shohei Ohtani
[General]
-Add Tags
-I like fast songs, but not those that are greatly exaggerated
-Maybe a skin or a ball of beysball in the spin^^
[CDFA's Normal]
-00:23:617 move the slider 1 square up (suggestion)
[Home Run!]
-00:12:511(2) <-> 00:12:799(3) different distance from 00:12:944(4) <-> 00:13:232(5)
-01:09:190 ----^
-02:28:232 to 02:30:540 very hard of get ^^u, maybe less distance
-I finish the song but ... very hard and fast, I can't get the combo and it's not fun =(
Good luck and my star
-Add Tags
-I like fast songs, but not those that are greatly exaggerated
-Maybe a skin or a ball of beysball in the spin^^
[CDFA's Normal]
-00:23:617 move the slider 1 square up (suggestion)
[Home Run!]
-00:12:511(2) <-> 00:12:799(3) different distance from 00:12:944(4) <-> 00:13:232(5)
-01:09:190 ----^
-02:28:232 to 02:30:540 very hard of get ^^u, maybe less distance
-I finish the song but ... very hard and fast, I can't get the combo and it's not fun =(
Good luck and my star
Offset is horridly early. Try 560.
[CDFA's Normal]
*Two inherited sections can be deleted since they're not used in this diff
*Tickrate 2 sounds too high. Try 1.
*Slider velocity is a little bit faster than I'd like to see for the easiest diff, but if you'll at least reduce the tick rate, I won't complain.
*I'm not a fan of some of the short sliders in this diff since they seem to speed it up and the lyrics don't fit with them 100%.
00:22:463 (2,3) - I'd make these a slider since (3) is an an unpredictable offbeat.
00:25:636 (1) - I'd move this back to the red tick and extend 1/2
00:53:617 (3,5,1) - Ugly overlap
01:01:694 (3,5) - ^ Maybe you could point (1-4) in different directions (or just move them up or down xp)
01:18:280 (4,1) - Expected (4), but still, perhaps make these a slider?
01:30:107 (1,2,3,4) - Yeah I've already said this xp
01:45:972 (5,6) - ^^^
01:55:203 (4) - ^
[Home Run!]
*Lower OD a tick please :< The inconsistent spacing/jumps are hard to read with it so high
*Bluh I actually really don't like the jumps/spacing here. It feels too rushed and doesn't play that well. =/
[CDFA's Normal]
*Two inherited sections can be deleted since they're not used in this diff
*Tickrate 2 sounds too high. Try 1.
*Slider velocity is a little bit faster than I'd like to see for the easiest diff, but if you'll at least reduce the tick rate, I won't complain.
*I'm not a fan of some of the short sliders in this diff since they seem to speed it up and the lyrics don't fit with them 100%.
00:22:463 (2,3) - I'd make these a slider since (3) is an an unpredictable offbeat.
00:25:636 (1) - I'd move this back to the red tick and extend 1/2
00:53:617 (3,5,1) - Ugly overlap
01:01:694 (3,5) - ^ Maybe you could point (1-4) in different directions (or just move them up or down xp)
01:18:280 (4,1) - Expected (4), but still, perhaps make these a slider?
01:30:107 (1,2,3,4) - Yeah I've already said this xp
01:45:972 (5,6) - ^^^
01:55:203 (4) - ^
[Home Run!]
*Lower OD a tick please :< The inconsistent spacing/jumps are hard to read with it so high
*Bluh I actually really don't like the jumps/spacing here. It feels too rushed and doesn't play that well. =/
offset 560-565, pick a value in there that sounds better to you.
Home Run!:
Lower HP Drain and OD by 1 tick? Please :< Kinda heavy to recover...
Other than that, great diff.
CDFA's Normal:
00:58:809 (4) - Move on grid?
Fine other words.
This would really use a diff in between. Jump is redic. Star cause HSM is cool.
Home Run!:
Lower HP Drain and OD by 1 tick? Please :< Kinda heavy to recover...
Other than that, great diff.
CDFA's Normal:
00:58:809 (4) - Move on grid?
Fine other words.
This would really use a diff in between. Jump is redic. Star cause HSM is cool.
OK this was tricky to get in sync to the song since the scene is directly ripped from the DVD.
Closest to syncing I got on the video offset is around 830+ms.
http://www.mediafire.com/?ntvdtzmmz3k
Just tell me if you want me to re-cut again, change quality etc.
Closest to syncing I got on the video offset is around 830+ms.
http://www.mediafire.com/?ntvdtzmmz3k
Just tell me if you want me to re-cut again, change quality etc.
Topic Starter
Added Nacho's video and mapped Home Run! to the end 
Overall
Around 5 seconds on video is not used at the end. Crop it?
Two .osb files in the song folder. Delete and resubmit.
CDFA's Normal
00:57:531 (2) - Follow distance snap (don't forget to adjust the rest)
01:14:234 (x) - Unused timing section
01:14:522 (x) - Unused timing section
Home Run!
02:18:993 (X) - Kiai doesn't start exactly on (1)
02:20:031 (3) - Kind of an unexpected jump...
Around 5 seconds on video is not used at the end. Crop it?
Two .osb files in the song folder. Delete and resubmit.
CDFA's Normal
00:57:531 (2) - Follow distance snap (don't forget to adjust the rest)
01:14:234 (x) - Unused timing section
01:14:522 (x) - Unused timing section
Home Run!
02:18:993 (X) - Kiai doesn't start exactly on (1)
02:20:031 (3) - Kind of an unexpected jump...
So I'm 95% sure this is supposed to be in 1/3 (most of it at least)
EDIT: proof: http://www.musicnotes.com/sheetmusic/mt ... =MN0058678
At the top it says the eighth notes are swung into triplets.
EDIT: proof: http://www.musicnotes.com/sheetmusic/mt ... =MN0058678
At the top it says the eighth notes are swung into triplets.
i was right then0_o wrote:
So I'm 95% sure this is supposed to be in 1/3 (most of it at least)
EDIT: proof: http://www.musicnotes.com/sheetmusic/mt ... =MN0058678
At the top it says the eighth notes are swung into triplets.
Edit: could you use 1/4 snaps and map it , " 1 e & a 2 e & a 3 e & a 4 e & a 1
Edit2: The way Larto's fairly oddparents map should have been mapped
Err, no? It would have to be 1/3ouranhshc wrote:
Edit: could you use 1/4 snaps and map it , " 1 e & a 2 e & a 3 e & a 4 e & a 1
Topic Starter
Uhhhhhh what.
Rage Rage Rage.
Download: Corbin Bleu & Lucas Grabeel - I Don't Dance (Agent Spin Here) [MB's Baseball Bat].osu
Download: Corbin Bleu & Lucas Grabeel - I Don't Dance (Agent Spin Here) [MB's Baseball Bat].osu
by request...
[MB's Baseball Bat]
00:19:021 (5) - Perhaps stack this on the end of (4) to keep the pattern? :S
01:10:079 (2,3,4) - uncalled for in this diff
01:10:944 (2,3,4,5,6) - ^
01:55:223 (7,8) - unexpected; perhaps make into a slider?
01:57:963 (3,4) - spacing
02:08:637 (5,6) - spacing
02:09:790 (1,2,3,4) - very tricky to read
02:13:252 (1,2) - spacing
02:32:290 (5,1) - spacing
02:40:367 (1) - finish the end? :V
[MB's Baseball Bat]
00:19:021 (5) - Perhaps stack this on the end of (4) to keep the pattern? :S
01:10:079 (2,3,4) - uncalled for in this diff
01:10:944 (2,3,4,5,6) - ^
01:55:223 (7,8) - unexpected; perhaps make into a slider?
01:57:963 (3,4) - spacing
02:08:637 (5,6) - spacing
02:09:790 (1,2,3,4) - very tricky to read
02:13:252 (1,2) - spacing
02:32:290 (5,1) - spacing
02:40:367 (1) - finish the end? :V
I take this back. I don't think the song and video is totally in sync with each other. Moreover, I assume the video isn't really for this version of the song.
+833 ms. is accurate at first, then +2243 at the middle, then I found other video offsets...
I don't think multiple video offsets is feasible.
Download: Corbin Bleu & Lucas Grabeel - I Don't Dance (Agent Spin Here) [0_o].osu
Just mapped a few sections as examples. I didn't bother making it look pretty because it's the placement on the timeline that matters. Though there actually ARE some red ticks every now and then, so basically the timing is just tricky in general. I blame inaccurate vocals >_>
Just mapped a few sections as examples. I didn't bother making it look pretty because it's the placement on the timeline that matters. Though there actually ARE some red ticks every now and then, so basically the timing is just tricky in general. I blame inaccurate vocals >_>
Round 2 of video cut
http://www.mediafire.com/?1nknzmkyd3z
It's really weird on why this is so hard to sync because the mp3 for this and the song in the movie/video syncs perfectly when compared, exact song length, timing etc.
Anyways here's a more cut one, where the offset should be earlier now. It seems to sync right around 3853-4100 this time on my side, try to experiment a bit.
Try to also to play the video outside of osu! while listening to your mp3 and try to find a time length where it syncs more perfectly if you want another re-cut.
http://www.mediafire.com/?1nknzmkyd3z
It's really weird on why this is so hard to sync because the mp3 for this and the song in the movie/video syncs perfectly when compared, exact song length, timing etc.
Anyways here's a more cut one, where the offset should be earlier now. It seems to sync right around 3853-4100 this time on my side, try to experiment a bit.
Try to also to play the video outside of osu! while listening to your mp3 and try to find a time length where it syncs more perfectly if you want another re-cut.
Shohei Ohtani
Offset 548 ?_?
Home Run:
02:19:730 (2) - Remove this note? =|
02:20:019 (3) - Move onto 02:20:019 (3) - (1/6 tick)
02:20:163 (1,2,3) - The spacing is way slower in this pattern, so I'm always tempted to click (3) too early. >.>
02:31:269 (2,3,4,5) - Make these sliders start on 1/4 ticks. Plays and sounds better.
MB:
New Combos are very ew in this difficulty.
01:09:790 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - What's with the suddenly increased spacing?
01:43:685 (6,7) - Eek, spacing. It's readable and I understand that you want to keep a pretty pattern, but it's still eek. Keep if you must, change if you can.
02:08:060 (2,3,4,5) - ^
02:13:252 (1,2,3) -
CDFA:
New Combos are very ew in this difficulty.
Home Run:
02:19:730 (2) - Remove this note? =|
02:20:019 (3) - Move onto 02:20:019 (3) - (1/6 tick)
02:20:163 (1,2,3) - The spacing is way slower in this pattern, so I'm always tempted to click (3) too early. >.>
02:31:269 (2,3,4,5) - Make these sliders start on 1/4 ticks. Plays and sounds better.
MB:
New Combos are very ew in this difficulty.
01:09:790 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - What's with the suddenly increased spacing?
01:43:685 (6,7) - Eek, spacing. It's readable and I understand that you want to keep a pretty pattern, but it's still eek. Keep if you must, change if you can.
02:08:060 (2,3,4,5) - ^
02:13:252 (1,2,3) -
CDFA:
New Combos are very ew in this difficulty.
I AM A MASSIVE FAGGOT these difficulty names suck
Home Run!:
00:16:137 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:17:002 (5) - New combo.
00:25:079 (5,1) - This spacing is annoying, can't you horizontally flip the next combo?
01:11:522 (1) - Remove new combo.
01:12:387 (5) - New combo.
01:14:406 (1) - Remove new combo.
01:25:079 (7) - Needs more slider.
01:28:829 (2) - Needs more slider.
02:24:790 (1) - What the fuck.
MB's Baseball Bat:
00:15:259 (4) - New combo.
00:15:548 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:23:625 (4) - New combo.
00:25:788 (2) - 1/3 snap.
00:27:807 (3) - 1/3 snap.
00:57:663 (4) - 1/3 snap.
01:16:028 (4) - 1/3 snap.
AAAAAA JUST SNAP IT PROPERLY YOURSELF
Home Run!:
00:16:137 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:17:002 (5) - New combo.
00:25:079 (5,1) - This spacing is annoying, can't you horizontally flip the next combo?
01:11:522 (1) - Remove new combo.
01:12:387 (5) - New combo.
01:14:406 (1) - Remove new combo.
01:25:079 (7) - Needs more slider.
01:28:829 (2) - Needs more slider.
02:24:790 (1) - What the fuck.
MB's Baseball Bat:
00:15:259 (4) - New combo.
00:15:548 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:23:625 (4) - New combo.
00:25:788 (2) - 1/3 snap.
00:27:807 (3) - 1/3 snap.
00:57:663 (4) - 1/3 snap.
01:16:028 (4) - 1/3 snap.
AAAAAA JUST SNAP IT PROPERLY YOURSELF
Topic Starter
Nah Jar... the snaps are fine...
poof I felt right to me
Shohei Ohtani
ranked
Omg. Please rename "Home Run!" to "Tablet Only". It's totally impossible to hit the notes using mouse at the end -.- I really hate maps like that, because it's really unfair to the people who don't have a tablet at all. Well NVM. Enough other Maps out there. Just wanted to say what was on my mind after i played it.
Topic Starter
Uhhh, no... you're just not good enough.eMkay wrote:
Omg. Please rename "Home Run!" to "Tablet Only". It's totally impossible to hit the notes using mouse at the end -.- I really hate maps like that, because it's really unfair to the people who don't have a tablet at all. Well NVM. Enough other Maps out there. Just wanted to say what was on my mind after i played it.
i know i should have replaced the totally with a nearly. But it's still VERY hard even for good players to FC insane using a mouse. but as i said nvm.
And I demand it to be unranked.
For the fact that my difficulty screwed up in the final slider art.
And other various things... Which I mean... 1/3 snap.
For the fact that my difficulty screwed up in the final slider art.
And other various things... Which I mean... 1/3 snap.
EDIT: yep it is 1/3
Shohei Ohtani
As much as I love this map, after doing some talking with people, there were some problems that happened.
BPM should be halved (I'm ok with the BPM, but Bop to the Top also got prevented from ranking because of the doubled BPM (even though it's a pretty fast sounding song) nevermind BPM is correct.
That jump in Home Run! mode (It's playable, but it's bad I guess. According to a person I talked to, this was mentioned in mod posts.)
MB's last slider should be 0.5x (I'm not sure how the hell this happened but it happened .-.)
2 useless timing sections in CDFA's Normal (They're during a break ~. Mentioned in Derekku's mod post.)
MB wants his map re-mapped to 1/3 (I feel my mode is pretty good with 1/2 (It's 1/4 right now but meh that's only for sliders).
So yeah sadly this might have to get unraked. ;~;.
That jump in Home Run! mode (It's playable, but it's bad I guess. According to a person I talked to, this was mentioned in mod posts.)
MB's last slider should be 0.5x (I'm not sure how the hell this happened but it happened .-.)
2 useless timing sections in CDFA's Normal (They're during a break ~. Mentioned in Derekku's mod post.)
MB wants his map re-mapped to 1/3 (I feel my mode is pretty good with 1/2 (It's 1/4 right now but meh that's only for sliders).
So yeah sadly this might have to get unraked. ;~;.
The BPM actually is correct - it's a fast song.
Shohei Ohtani
i don't think this will end well
Topic Starter
Sigh, we've been over this. If people insist on it getting unranked, I won't grieve for it, it'll just die. The song is stupid and all the vocals are just timed randomly. And I admit, that jump in Home Run!! was completely unintentional.
Basically, fuck this map. I haven't cared about it in a long time.
Basically, fuck this map. I haven't cared about it in a long time.
I like it.
The song sucks huge nuts due to High School Musical but the map is solid and challenging.
The song sucks huge nuts due to High School Musical but the map is solid and challenging.
That's really not a good attitude to have; I completely disagree with you. The map has a few small issues that can be easily fixed and reranked without much trouble.Agent Spin Here wrote:
Sigh, we've been over this. If people insist on it getting unranked, I won't grieve for it, it'll just die. The song is stupid and all the vocals are just timed randomly. And I admit, that jump in Home Run!! was completely unintentional.
Basically, fuck this map. I haven't cared about it in a long time.
the vocals aren't randomly timed. You were told several times which snap to use. I don't want to hear it about the vocals not being timedAgent Spin Here wrote:
Sigh, we've been over this. If people insist on it getting unranked, I won't grieve for it, it'll just die. The song is stupid and all the vocals are just timed randomly. And I admit, that jump in Home Run!! was completely unintentional.
Basically, fuck this map. I haven't cared about it in a long time.
The music IS in 1/3, I would bet my reputation on it (do I have a reputation? idk). The vocals were a little sloppy so on some parts it does sound a little like 1/2, and the high BPM also makes it a little tougher to tell. Nonetheless, if you were to look at the music they would have sung from, the entirety of it would be swung into triplets (though I'm not positive about some of the stuff about 2/3 of the way through) Go to 1:48 and listen to the drums in the background - you can hear the drums do a triplet in the final beat before "know".
Regarding the argument "it plays better" - One might think it plays better because 1/2 / 1/4 is what everyone is used to; it's a lot tougher to mentally split notes up into thirds than halves/quarters. But it just wouldn't sync right with the music, which is kind of a big deal in a rhythm game.
So yeah I don't wanna start a flame war or anything, I just wanted to get that out of my system. Take what you want out of it, I'm done talking about it now.
Regarding the argument "it plays better" - One might think it plays better because 1/2 / 1/4 is what everyone is used to; it's a lot tougher to mentally split notes up into thirds than halves/quarters. But it just wouldn't sync right with the music, which is kind of a big deal in a rhythm game.
So yeah I don't wanna start a flame war or anything, I just wanted to get that out of my system. Take what you want out of it, I'm done talking about it now.
Topic Starter
That's because the song is not in 1/3 timing overall. There are a few notes that loosely go onto 1/3 but overall the song is in 1/2.0_o wrote:
Regarding the argument "it plays better" - One might think it plays better because 1/2 / 1/4 is what everyone is used to; it's a lot tougher to mentally split notes up into thirds than halves/quarters. But it just wouldn't sync right with the music, which is kind of a big deal in a rhythm game.
Yeah, didn't think I would follow through with that0_o wrote:
I'm done talking about it now.
Anyway, I looked up probably 10 different sets of sheet music, and every single one says it's in 1/3. You can listen to the first 20 seconds or so of two different versions of it here and here (you'll have to install a plugin though.) It really does sound right.
I would think the people who write the sheet music to this stuff know what they are doing?
The song is definately all 1/3, but I don't think the map is confusing or sounds too bad beacuse it's in 1/4, so I don't think it warrants an unranking.
Topic Starter
I don't know or care about sheet music, but in practice, the map works a hell of a lot better snapped mostly to 1/2.
It's like Fairly Oddparents all over again.
Here's Home Run! mapped in 1/3 up to the first break. It feels much better and matches the lyrics, you'll notice.
Download: Corbin Bleu & Lucas Grabeel - I Don't Dance (Agent Spin Here) [13 Snapped].osu
Download: Corbin Bleu & Lucas Grabeel - I Don't Dance (Agent Spin Here) [13 Snapped].osu
Yep, if you play mb's diff its pretty obvious some of the notes end up LATE or EARLY.NoHItter wrote:
It's like Fairly Oddparents all over again.
faceman explained it to you in full BEFORE IT WAS RANKED, and right now this seems out of pure laziness on your part. Its not about wut "sounds" better, its about what is correct.Agent Spin Here wrote:
I don't know or care about sheet music, but in practice, the map works a hell of a lot better snapped mostly to 1/2.
Topic Starter
Jibber this isn't even in 1/3 whut
Give me an exaple of any point in the map that, slowed down to 50% actually sounds off from the music and then I'll listen to you, but don't bother because I've checked the whole map and it syncs to the music perfectly.
Don't fucking call me lazy. I listened to 0_o and he was wrong. Why would I change it? I don't give a shit about what you define as 'correct'. Its not about whatt sounds better or what's 'correct', it's about what plays better, and snapped to 1/2 this map is a hell of a lot better than in 1/3 snap.ouranhshc wrote:
faceman explained it to you in full BEFORE IT WAS RANKED, and right now this seems out of pure laziness on your part. Its not about wut "sounds" better, its about what is correct.
Give me an exaple of any point in the map that, slowed down to 50% actually sounds off from the music and then I'll listen to you, but don't bother because I've checked the whole map and it syncs to the music perfectly.
Topic Starter
Why should he? There's nothing wrong with the map.CDFA wrote:
Wow mrtn must be feeling pretty crappy right now.
except that jumpWhy? I know it's technically a 1/3 song but it plays better when mapped to 1/2 in my opinion so I didn't complain about it. And the jump is acceptable imo.CDFA wrote:
Wow mrtn must be feeling pretty crappy right now.
I'm not going to discuss the 1/3 or 1/2 anymore because we've been over this in IRC.