ykcarrot wrote:

[General]
I couldn't find any custom hitsound in song folder. So custom override is useless.

Custom override is cancelled now.

[Marathon]
As you know, this diff can be just approved.
I'm sorry. I won't mod for approved map.

Should I cut the length of this diff...? I'm not sure this diff will be approved or this map.

got the answer. thx for modding N and H

[Normal]
Change its name to Hard. done
00:00:613 ~ 00:17:019 - set audio volume 30 in this section done
00:07:456 (4) - new combo done
00:17:488 (1) - yes, no sound is good. XD
00:22:738 (1) - start at 00:22:925 and one more return with Finish sound.(audio volume 40?) done,but the sound is not very clear, so the volume is now 60.
00:36:587 (4) - spacing
00:39:587 (4) - ^
00:49:712 (5) - ^
01:29:087 (4) - new combo
01:33:024 (3) - spacing four done.


[Easy]
This diff is not easy. Change its name to Normal. done
00:35:462 - delete this green line. I changed the BPM to 0.5 with this line.
00:57:962 (2,3,4) - spacing. no good at Easy diff. now it's Normal
01:20:462 (2) - make this slider's end to 01:21:212
01:27:024 (1) - remove new combo
01:35:462 (6) - new combo
02:08:040 (1,2,1,2) - spacing for done

Please don't give kudosu to anyone. Give it to who helped you. (Mod post) got it

1. "Lyrics.txt" isn't used, please delete it and full submit.

1. Comboburst's width must not be higher than 500px. Please resize or crop it.

1. These files seem to be duplicates:
   
   1. Lyrics/op_21.png - Lyrics/op_22.png
   2. Lyrics/op_13.png - Lyrics/op24.png
   If they are truly the same, please delete them and use a single image instead.

1. Every difficulty must use the same offset.
2. Preview point must be the same for all difficulties.

1. I think this needs more hitsounds... other than that, it's fine.

1. Oh my god, six minutes...with that length this definitely won't get ranked. Maybe this can be a mixed set of ranked and approved difficulties, like bad apple. orz, I just saw you're aware of it

Gens wrote:

[General]

1. "Lyrics.txt" isn't used, please delete it and full submit.

　deleted days ago, but never full submitted

[Skin]

1. Comboburst's width must not be higher than 500px. Please resize or crop it.

　resized.

[Storyboard]

1. These files seem to be duplicates:
   
   1. Lyrics/op_21.png - Lyrics/op_22.png
   2. Lyrics/op_13.png - Lyrics/op24.png
   If they are truly the same, please delete them and use a single image instead.

i used to try this ,but failed. this tiime I made it...lol

[All Difficulties]

1. Every difficulty must use the same offset.
2. Preview point must be the same for all difficulties.

　done.

[Normal (Short Ver.)]

1. I think this needs more hitsounds... other than that, it's fine.

　i can hardly handle it... now i've tried my best.

00:35:462 - Instead of placing this green line here, move it to 00:48:212. If you leave it like this, it can cause bugs. Do the same to the other difficulties.
01:35:274 - Useless timing section...
01:47:462 - Useless timing section... set the previous section at 0.5x instead.
02:07:993 - Useless timing section...
02:08:087 (1) - Move this to the next white tick.

　done.

[Marathon (Full Ver.)]

1. Oh my god, six minutes...with that length this definitely won't get ranked. Maybe this can be a mixed set of ranked and approved difficulties, like bad apple. orz, I just saw you're aware of it

　i love this song so much cutting its length is too hard for me. really hope this can be a approved diff.

~ ~ ~

Well, it's not like I'm being lazy, but I'm running out of time at the moment. Please do these changes first so I can keep modding it. Call me back when you're finished.

EDIT: I accidentally starred it... oh well, it doesn't matter.

　I'm doing my best

1. Hard的Preview time跟其他两个难度不一样,请保证他们是一致的(现在hard是101462而另两个难度是101368
   )
2. Source不知道么?专辑名或者其他什么的来源,如果知道的话可以加到source里

1. 01:35:462 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Normal里不建议使用非常规的spacing

1. 有很多unsnapped note, resnap all notes
2. 开始部分0.5xBPM改了timing后忘设定了吧?
3. 00:35:462 (T) - 这里用0.5xBPM就好了,不必用新的红线
4. 00:47:462 (T) - 这里改回1xBPM即可
5. 01:14:462 (S) - 这里finish都行,别用clap
6. 01:35:462 - 01:38:087 - 这一串别用clap,不好听

1. 第一条红线后所有的红线都应该用绿线代替的
2. 00:11:086 (1,1) - 这两个应该1/6 beat snap divisor来snap
3. 00:15:211 (2) - 后移1/4拍
4. 02:57:966 (3) - spacing太远了,要jump的话最好new combo表明spacing改变
5. 03:05:466 (3) - ^
6. 03:08:466 (3) - ^
7. 03:19:716 (4) - 被挡住的slider,这个不好
8. 03:23:466 - 03:27:216 - 这一串摆法不错,但是每个(4)和另一个(1)之间感觉太远了 :/

Breeze wrote:

只有红色部分是我觉得你应该改的,其他的都只是建议

[General]

1. Hard的Preview time跟其他两个难度不一样,请保证他们是一致的(现在hard是101462而另两个难度是101368
   )

这个很奇怪...大概是红线导致的吧 在.osu里改掉了.

1. Source不知道么?专辑名或者其他什么的来源,如果知道的话可以加到source里

Pending Maps版的置顶说是专辑名不算来源, 这首歌是一张单曲专辑, 目前还没有出现在其他地方.

[Normal]

1. 01:35:462 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Normal里不建议使用非常规的spacing

改掉了.

[Hard]

1. 有很多unsnapped note, resnap all notes
2. 开始部分0.5xBPM改了timing后忘设定了吧?
3. 00:35:462 (T) - 这里用0.5xBPM就好了,不必用新的红线
4. 00:47:462 (T) - 这里改回1xBPM即可

这些都是刚开始摸索EDIT怎么用时加的...成历史遗留问题了

1. 01:14:462 (S) - 这里finish都行,别用clap
2. 01:35:462 - 01:38:087 - 这一串别用clap,不好听

改掉了.

[Marathon]

1. 第一条红线后所有的红线都应该用绿线代替的
2. 00:11:086 (1,1) - 这两个应该1/6 beat snap divisor来snap
3. 00:15:211 (2) - 后移1/4拍
4. 02:57:966 (3) - spacing太远了,要jump的话最好new combo表明spacing改变
5. 03:05:466 (3) - ^
6. 03:08:466 (3) - ^
7. 03:19:716 (4) - 被挡住的slider,这个不好

改掉了.

1. 03:23:466 - 03:27:216 - 这一串摆法不错,但是每个(4)和另一个(1)之间感觉太远了 :/

这里是把曲度又改大了点 这样距离就少了大概1/3~1/4.

第一次作图能做到这样相当不错了
hitsound还有待加强
这里给你提供个custom softclap
可以试试
另外我试着帮你在hard里前面部分加了一些音效,可以参考下

很好用

ignorethis wrote:

Offset is early by ~3-5 ms? not sure, but the metronome clicks sound off in the beginning part, so I guess you should remove the notes there..

ignorethis wrote:

Offset is early by ~3-5 ms? not sure, but the metronome clicks sound off in the beginning part, so I guess you should remove the notes there.

btw a length of 6 mins is not rankable, be sure to ask BATs to seperate it from your mapset when ranking.

[00:14:278-00:22:715] these notes were deleted. left a back-slider at 00:22:903 to make the break not too long.

<Marathon>
add some more hitsounds to this map
01:54:023 (2,1) - wth is this
05:11:466 (9) - this one is lol, remove the 2x BPM
06:02:653 (1) - remove

done. now the length is less than 6 minutes :3

Others are ok, although there are some spacing problems (and some of which are very misleading) but I don't feel like nazing others' maps.

star'd, call back for recheck and pubble.

thx~

Garven wrote:

[Normal]
01:04:337 It looks like you were going for bends right when the singer changes notes, but it feels like it's curving a little early. Maybe manipulate when the bends hit so it matches up with the beat. I messed with it and moving each bend out one more grid (at 3 zoom) felt better.

done. can't believe u found this...

01:53:462 Maybe it's more of a style thing to me, but perhaps switch these four sliders with the pattern at 01:59:462. With the way the song goes, it just fits a lot better.

reeditted the hitsounds and it may feel better [01:52:341(1)] is replaces with a slider.

[Hard]
The beginning is just mistimed. The ritardando (slowing of the tempo) makes this really hard, as you're going to have to have several re-timing spots.

Keep in mind a lot of this is pretty rough timing. You may want to go in and fine tune them if you can.

The beginning, I have an offset of 661, BPM 160.
00:08:204 BPM 157.00
00:09:841 BPM 150.00
00:11:077 BPM 110.00
00:11:647 BPM 95.25
00:14:166 BPM 160.00
00:15:291 BPM 140.00
00:17:461 BPM 160.00

This might throw a bunch of your beats off at the beginning section as well.

BPM & notes at beginning are fixed. the offset was wrong before fixing.

00:58:337 [3, 4] The spacing here is really deceptive. I'm not sure if that's what you were going for, but it didn't feel natural at all.

ye, done.

The spacing goes all over too with the BPM x.05 and x2's. Try to keep it more standardized with occasional jumps with the music.

trying to make it feel better

[Marathon]
I just spent a bunch of time getting that timing done... I'll take a peek later on if I remember.

i'm quite moved cause u put so much time on my map~

Nice storyboarding, btw. Looks really smooth.
Star~

SB costs me over 10 hours XD thx for your help

Astom wrote:

[general]
-use same kiai time in hard and normal

done.

[Normal]
-100% Acc =) I don' t see problems

[Hard]
-97% Acc
-00:46:716 maybe u can finish this spinner in 00:47:466 or move this 00:47:091 (1) to 00:47:466
-01:15:403 clean this break?

done.

[Marathon]
-I only play this in edit mode (too long) and check hardest part and i don't see problems

Nice song >;3 star

thx~

al2e10 wrote:

By AL2e's mod ~

[Hard (Short Ver.)]
00:08:934 (1,2) - Turn to 00:09:028 and 00:09:403 呃 这个错误太差劲了``
00:41:466 (1,2,3,4) - Don't use clap many times `
01:42:216 (1) - Remove new combo
01:42:966 (1) - ^
01:45:216 (1) - ^
01:46:903 (1) - ^
01:56:278 (5) - New combo
Your clap sound is not that good. 非常明显

[Normal (Short Ver.)]
Clap sound problem only. 改良了一下~

[All]
Your sound puting should make it better. 正在Marathon奋战中 =)
But that good already, STAR !!

orioncomet wrote:

[General]
- TAG: Sayonara Memories

that's the katakana "メモリーズ"

[Normal]
- This diff don't need Audio lead in ye,but the storyboard o_0`
00:58:903 (3) - spacing? or new combo done.

[Hard]
00:17:394 - this timing selection seem useless removed.
00:13:899 - delete this timing selection? removed
01:47:466 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - seem like spam new combo, but fine.. imo :P

[Marathon]
- Resnap all note on this diff and check the note on the frist timing selection this place need some timing help
00:58:902 (3,4) - spacing? done.
01:27:683 (5) - remove sound clap at begin of silder done.
02:54:970 (8) - new combo? ok
03:29:469 - start kiai time here? ye
04:35:376 (16) - remove sound clap changed to a whistle
05:02:282 - start kiai time here? done.
05:17:470 (17) - replace sound whistle and clap with finish? better
05:30:407 (3) - spacing? or new combo done.
05:37:626 (16) - remove sound clap done.
05:53:657 (1) - end this spinner at 05:58:157? ee

Starrr ~

YGOkid8 wrote:

General
Hm... to me...
00:48:966 - Add a New Timing Section here (don't inherit previous timing sections), for this is the first beat of the bar

i used to do that before, but in most people's opinion, that was useless...

Normal

Combo Mod~
01:09:591 (5) - New Combo?

02:00:216 (1) - No New Combo.
02:00:966 (1) - ^
02:01:716 (1,1) - ^

Normal Mod~
01:35:466 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Why the sudden spacing change?

done. the x0.5 line was removed but forget to change the spacing

Hard

Combo Mod~
01:47:841 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - Remove New Combo. done.
02:03:497 (1) - Don't change spacing, and No New Combo. i just put a new combo there for the change of spacing...

Normal Mod~
00:22:903 (1) - Place in middle of playfield this don't matter...

Marathon
Marathon...? IMO, a Marathon should be at the very least 7 minutes. 5 minutes isn't a marathon
And by putting a Marathon diff, your intention is approval?
Answer my question, and I'll do a quick mod of this diff.

just an approval level. [Normal]&[Hard] would be applied for rank and this diff for approval.

But for now, here's your star ~ ☆

Colin Hou wrote:

i used to do that before, but in most people's opinion, that was useless...

Leorda wrote:

NI HAO!

[General]
1) Source? This song is in just a single album. According to this post, the Source should be blank.

[Hard (Short Ver.)]
02:03:497 (1) - Ugly Slider replaced it with a spinner

[Marathon (Full Ver.)]
Check AIMod there's some spacing issue several fixed
04:00:594 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19) - The combo are too long, crop it?! done.

Nice song
STAR

fartownik wrote:

The title should be "Sayonara Memories". It's even in the lyrics (02:03:590).

That's really a HUGE mistake...

[Normal]

[00:58:528] - Add here the same slider like this 00:57:966 (2). done.
00:58:903 (1) - Move 1/4 forward. this makes the combo quite hard in Normal


[Hard]

00:04:341 (3,4,1,2,3) - Inconsistent spacing. Aren't these notes 00:02:091 (3,4,5) (for example) spaced in other Distance Spacing? It's an issue.
00:08:184 (2,1,2) - ^
00:09:778 (3,4,5) - ^
00:36:966 (1,2,1) - Spacing.
00:39:966 (1,2) - ^ spacing all fixed
01:38:278 (1) - Hidden slider repeat. done.
01:48:966 (5,6,7,8,1,2,3,1,2,3) - Inconsistent spacing. new combod there.
02:03:497 (1) - End it on red tick. done.


[Marathon]

The most important thing here is spacing. There's much this kinda issues.

The slow down is useless in some parts.

00:11:090 (1) - Delete and make the previous slider end here 00:11:090.
00:55:340 (1,2) - Spacing o.o.
00:56:090 (1,2) - ^
01:02:465 (1,1) - ^ spacing issues done.
01:27:496 (4,5) - Unsnapped. Move 1/4 forward and make the slider 1/4 shorter. done.
01:52:340 (3,1) - Spacing.
01:53:465 (1,2) - ^
02:05:465 (1) - Putting this note under this slider is confusing. Move it using Distance Spacing. spaing issues done.
02:34:340 (3) - Make it 1/8 shorter. nice!
02:36:965 (3,4) - Spacing.
02:54:969 (1,2) - ^
02:58:532 (4,1) - ^
03:30:969 (7) - New combo.
03:31:532 (9,10) - Spacing.
03:38:469 (13) - New combo.
04:12:032 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - I expected something... harder in this place? now there are EXTREME jumps
04:39:407 (2) - This slider makes no sense? o.o Yes, this part is boring a bit, but it's not the best way to make it more interesting. that's the piano sound. this part is just like a break. imo..


This map isn't ready to be proto-bubbled. Get another people to mod.

will do

1. "BackGround2.png" is unused, isn't it? You can use "BackGround.png" for both the storyboard and the background...
2. I still advise you against using an Inherited section with the same offset as the base section...

1. Make sure to recheck the map with correct spacing... for example, I think 00:36:591 (4,1) or 00:41:466 (1,2,3,4) is very unintuitive.

1. Don't use red timing sections unless is absolutely needed... I can't tell if it's for the timing. But if it is, then it should be set the same for all difficulties!
2. You should reduce the general use of new combo markers! (I mean, markers for single note and such)

Gens wrote:

[General]

1. "BackGround2.png" is unused, isn't it? You can use "BackGround.png" for both the storyboard and the background... done.
2. I still advise you against using an Inherited section with the same offset as the base section... removed most red lines.

[Normal (Short Ver.)]

01:11:466 (4) - New combo? done.

[Hard (Short Ver.)]

1. Make sure to recheck the map with correct spacing... for example, I think 00:36:591 (4,1) or 00:41:466 (1,2,3,4) is very unintuitive.

done.

01:38:091 (8,1) - Hidden slider. done.
01:42:966 (7) - The repeat in a blue tick doesn't sound quite right. Think you can do something about it? fixed.
02:03:497 (1,1) - Two consecutive spinners is like... meh, don't you think? done.

[Marathon (Full Ver.)]

1. Don't use red timing sections unless is absolutely needed... I can't tell if it's for the timing. But if it is, then it should be set the same for all difficulties! can't 100% understand what you mean but fixed.
2. You should reduce the general use of new combo markers! (I mean, markers for single note and such) removed many new combos

00:32:465 (1,1,1,1,1,1,1) - What are these new combos for? done.
01:18:965 - This break felt out of place... fixed.
02:10:715 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Maybe center this stack? done.

~ ~ ~

Well, something with timing definitely needs to be checked out... anyways, you improved your hitsounds a lot! I like them.

tonight i did quite a lot of spacing&timing work... really thx for your advice

• • Make the spacing linear. Keep "Distance Snap" active and recheck it.

• • 00:48:216 (1) - 2 squares to the left (grid level 3)
  • 00:57:966 (2,1,2,3) - Spacing
  • 01:00:966 (2) - 1 square to the left (grid level 3)
  • 01:24:966 (2) - 1 square up (grid level 3)

• • 00:02:841 (5) - 1 square up (grid level 3)
  • 00:08:184 (2) - BPM Adjustment:0.5x :S also, end this slider here 00:08:566.
  • 00:36:590 (4,1,2,1) - Spacing
  • 00:39:590 (4,1,2) - ^
  • 00:41:465 (1,2) - ^
  • 00:57:965 (2) - 1 square to the right (grid level 3)
  • 00:59:278 (6,1,2) - Spacing
  • 01:14:559 (x) - Add a break
  • 01:17:465 (4) - 2 squares to the left (grid level 3)
  • 01:48:965 (1,2) - Make the spacing linear; this jump is ugly
  • 01:50:465 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - Spacing
  • 02:06:028 (2,3,1) - ^

• • 00:08:184 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - Make the spacing linear; the spacing here is different than before
  • 01:14:559 (x) - Add a break
  • 01:49:715 (10) - 1 square up(grid level 3)
  • 01:50:465 (11) - 1 square to the right (grid level 3)
  • 02:11:465 (1) - End this spinner here 02:15:965
  • 02:55:715 (2,3,4) - Spacing
  • 03:27:028 (4,1) - This jump is ugly
  • 04:41:465 (5) - New combo

xxheroxx wrote:

[General]

• • Make the spacing linear. Keep "Distance Snap" active and recheck it.

will do a fully check tomorrow (today..) afternoon after my PE class.

[Normal]

• • 00:48:216 (1) - 2 squares to the left (grid level 3)
  • 00:57:966 (2,1,2,3) - Spacing
  • 01:00:966 (2) - 1 square to the left (grid level 3)
  • 01:24:966 (2) - 1 square up (grid level 3)

all done. quite sorry for my mistake.

[Hard]

• • 00:02:841 (5) - 1 square up (grid level 3)
  • 00:08:184 (2) - BPM Adjustment:0.5x :S also, end this slider here 00:08:566.
  • 00:36:590 (4,1,2,1) - Spacing
  • 00:39:590 (4,1,2) - ^
  • 00:41:465 (1,2) - ^
  • 00:57:965 (2) - 1 square to the right (grid level 3)
  • 00:59:278 (6,1,2) - Spacing
  • 01:14:559 (x) - Add a break
  • 01:17:465 (4) - 2 squares to the left (grid level 3)
  • 01:48:965 (1,2) - Make the spacing linear; this jump is ugly
  • 01:50:465 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - Spacing
  • 02:06:028 (2,3,1) - ^

all done.

[Marathon]

• • 00:08:184 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - Make the spacing linear; the spacing here is different than before
  • 01:14:559 (x) - Add a break
  • 01:49:715 (10) - 1 square up(grid level 3)
  • 01:50:465 (11) - 1 square to the right (grid level 3)
  • 02:11:465 (1) - End this spinner here 02:15:965
  • 02:55:715 (2,3,4) - Spacing
  • 03:27:028 (4,1) - This jump is ugly
  • 04:41:465 (5) - New combo

all done. really thx !

1. There is only "j-pop" in the tags. Is there anything else you can put in there?
2. As far as I can see, the part of the song from the start up to 00:23:53 is not set to a BPM, so it is impossible to time right. so I wouldn't map in that part. Migh be wrong, but I don't think I am
3. If you do remove the intro, delete your timing sections and just have one timing section, Offset: 23,463, BPM: 160.00. Works for me. You will also have to move all of the notes on the map onto the white ticks, as they will all be on blue ticks

Normal:

01:04:338 (6) - A pretty ugly slider, reshape it.
02:10:713 (1) - Hm, I am a bit afraid of this part. Because it's a 2x timing section on a normal diff, with notes on 1/8. This is pretty hard on Taiko, so I recommend you change it somehow.

Hard:

02:10:713 (1) - Same thing as normal.

Marathon:

I didn't really take a look at it, but I will point out some things.

Small hitcircles sucks, make them bigger. :/
Turn up the OD by one or two ticks.
05:53:650 (1) - Silence the final part at this spinner.

FuukoLover wrote:

Fuuko's mod DEKIMASHITA! <33'

Normal:

01:04:338 (6) - A pretty ugly slider, reshape it. replaced with circle and slider.
02:10:713 (1) - Hm, I am a bit afraid of this part. Because it's a 2x timing section on a normal diff, with notes on 1/8. This is pretty hard on Taiko, so I recommend you change it somehow. done.

Hard:

02:10:713 (1) - Same thing as normal. get done in the same way :)

Marathon:

I didn't really take a look at it, but I will point out some things.

Small hitcircles sucks, make them bigger. :/
Turn up the OD by one or two ticks. well, bigger circle and lower OD.
05:53:650 (1) - Silence the final part at this spinner. good idea.

That's it, a nice star for the awesome SB, and keep up the good work.

Ps: I want a diff. ): Can I map one?

if you want, then do it. :)

Small hitcircles sucks, make them bigger. :/
Turn up the OD by one or two ticks. well, bigger circle and lower OD.

FuukoLover wrote:

Small hitcircles sucks, make them bigger. :/
Turn up the OD by one or two ticks. well, bigger circle and lower OD.

I said up, not down. >_<

Oh...my poor english *_*

Mapping.

inform me when you finish :)

Doomsday93 wrote:

[HARD (SHORT VER)]

02:06:025 (2) - This is 1/4 too long now. make this 1/4 shorter (so it ends on the red tick). Sorry if I confused you there :( .

oh, never mind.

Thats all I can find currently. Maybe Im tired and I'm missing things, but I don't think I am.

Now you get a star from me ;)

Shulin wrote:

General:

-- Imo you should remove "Short Ver." and "Long Ver." from the difficulty names "Marathon" implies it's going to be long anyway and since you have two "Short Ver." I don't think its necessary. done.
-- You should make the volume level the same for all difficulties. basic volume is the same now.
-- Kiai + white notes + light BG =.=" :) got some changes.
-- Add FuukoLover to tags on all difficulties. done.

Normal (Short Ver.)

-- Remove audio lead in.

00:57:963 (2,3,4) - Respace this so it's easy to read, it wasn't very intuitive. (I guess you could remove the very small returning sliders completely...)
01:50:463 (5) - Remove new combo?
02:05:463 (1) - Remove custom clap?
02:06:588 (3) - ^
02:10:713 (1) - Use custom clap (reduce volume a little).

all done.

Hard (Short Ver.)

-- Remove audio lead in.

01:00:213 (1,2) - These two x2 sliders are quite unexpected, are they really necessary?
01:18:775 (5) - Sounds better with just a single beat at 01:18:963 imo.
02:10:713 (4) - New combo? (Like Normal...)

all done.

Sayonara Fuuko:

-- Remove audio lead in.
-- You should probably add "Short Ver." here to I guess =/

01:04:713 (2,3,4,5) - Tricky to read 5 because it's so close. Might work well if all was stacked?
01:32:463 (2,3) - Spacing? (Feels too close)
01:33:025 (3,4) - ^
01:33:588 (4,5) - ^
01:35:463 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Spacing? The slider velocity sped up but the spacing stayed as if it was x0.5 it didn't play very intuitively imo.
01:37:713 (4) - New combo?
01:39:025 (7) - Right one square?

notes placing issues will be done by Fuuko.

Marathon:

-- With a score of 25million I guess this is for approval? ye
-- Remove audio lead in.

02:05:463 (1) - Remove custom clap? (Or lower the volume I guess)
02:05:650 (2) - ^
02:06:025 (4) - ^
02:06:588 (6) - ^
02:07:713 (7) - ^ (Imo soft whistle would be more suited in these places)
02:10:713 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Custom clap might work well here. 6 above done.
04:06:213 (3,1) - Spacing? Jump felt a bit weird. so new combo there.
04:18:775 (5) - New combo.
04:20:463 (5) - ^
04:21:025 (1) - Remove new combo if you do ^
04:21:963 (5) - New combo?
04:23:275 (1) - Remove new combo. 5 above done.
04:39:400 (3) - Doesn't fit, two beats would be better imo. that feels strange.
05:36:213 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16) - The overlap with this stack doesn't look very good here, you might want to move it a bit further away from 05:36:025 (4) - done.

Nice mapset overall.
~ Star.

• • 00:58:056 (5) - Move this circle here 00:58:150 (red tick)

• 04:35:463 (x) - Add a circle
  05:37:713 (x) - ^

xxheroxx wrote:

[Sayonara Fuuko]

• • 00:58:056 (5) - Move this circle here 00:58:150 (red tick)
  
  Fuuko will consider this.

[Marathon]

• 04:35:463 (x) - Add a circle
  05:37:713 (x) - ^
  
  done.

1. 01:22:525 (5,6) - Hard to feel the rhythm. I have the solution: Make (5) into a slider, make it end at 01:23:463. Sounds much better!

1. 01:33:400 (4) - Make this slider a stack instead. Sounds better.
   

Real1 wrote:

[Normal]

1. 01:22:525 (5,6) - Hard to feel the rhythm. I have the solution: Make (5) into a slider, make it end at 01:23:463. Sounds much better!

done.and also did some change on (4)

[Hard]

1. 01:33:400 (4) - Make this slider a stack instead. Sounds better.
   
   done.

[Sayonara]
Nothing wrong with this. Except it gives less than Hard but is harder... But that's fine.


Star

1. Marathon has a slightly different preview point than the others.
2. (I assume) the storyboard makes the player wait when he finishes any other difficulty than [Marathon]. I don't think this is right.

1. I feel OD is too high though it's just my personal opinion. Is it just me or it went up? :<

Gens wrote:

[General]

1. Marathon has a slightly different preview point than the others. done. maybe caused by the change of timing.
2. (I assume) the storyboard makes the player wait when he finishes any other difficulty than [Marathon]. I don't think this is right. they can click skp, but fixed now

[Normal]

1. I feel OD is too high though it's just my personal opinion. Is it just me or it went up? :< nope, it's a little high. now turned down by 1.

[Marathon]

00:57:588 (1,2) - Spacing? I didn't get it was a slowdown until I played the slider, if you get what I mean.
01:47:088 (11,1) - Spacing?
03:30:963 (1) - IMO this slowdown doesn't fit the song.
05:53:275 (4) - I think it'd fit better if you move this slider 1/4 back.

all done .is 00:57:588 better now?
~ ~ ~

3rd remod, am I cool?
Obsolutely!
I'd happily pubble this when you do these changes. Also, I saw on IRC Fuuko was doing something with his difficulty, is that right?
Ibichi Fuko gives others wooden starfish and he gives others guest diff XD

Zekira wrote:

Whoever suggested the offset is win. *autostar*

[Normal]
00:58:525 (3,4,5,6) - ...kinda unintuitive for a Normal... maybe make slider instead?
01:14:463 () - IMO break unnecessary

[Fuuko]
I personally don't like how the spacing is almost half of the slider speed, especially the parts before the slowdown part.
00:57:963 (4,5) - This caught me off-guard. I suggest changing it or smth.

[Hard]
01:27:775 (3) - symmetry

[Marathon]
Turn up hitsound volume on first part pl0x
05:12:588 (1) - some parts after this one merit louder hitsound volumes. I'm pretty sure you know which ones. Add a few more green timing points pl0x.
Last part also needs more volume.

...lol, [Marathon] was the only diff. I liked.

Gens wrote:

Proto-bubbleddddd

Still a bit iffy about 00:57:588 though. Maybe you could try making the spacing closer after the first slowdown slider.

blissfulyoshi wrote:

A very late mod. Sry.
Not touching the p-bubble.

The storyboarded hitsounds sound weird to me. You have drums playing when the music is soft and the vocalist is holding lyrics.

sometimes i just add hitsounds in .osz of every diff. then after a submit, they come up in .osb >_< all messed up. and fixed now :3

Normal:
Normal/Nazi mod:
01:04:338 (6) - please move 1 grid (lvl 3) to the left (sorry for the nazing, this just annoyed me while I was playing)

Combo mod:
00:50:463 (4) and 01:02:463 (1) - I advise you make the combos in these areas consistent

Timing section mod:
02:10:713 - a quarter note before this timing section, make a timing section with the same settings but no kiai. (This is for the change in hitsound volume)

Hard:
Make the kiai timing in Normal and Hard the same
Combo mod:
01:01:713 (1) - remove new combo to be consistent with 00:49:713 (5)?
01:21:588 (4) - new combo for a new line of lyrics
01:57:213 (1) - remove new combo to be consistent with 01:44:838 (4)

Marathon:
Combo mod:
04:15:025 (5,1) - to make the combos sets of 4s, I would remove the purple 1's new combo and add a new combo to 5.

Timing section mod:
05:02:463 - a quarter note before this timing section, make a timing section with the same settings but no kiai. (This is for the change in hitsound volume)

=======================================
Nice map. Star.
Good luck on getting this ranked.

NoHItter wrote:

Normal
00:58:338 (x) - Sounds weird being empty. Add note?

done.

Hard
00:59:275 (6) - Clap at the end of slider?

add a note before (7) with clap.

Marathon
05:05:181 (1) - ??? that's the drum. the last back is for the spacing/rhyme so end at while line.

I myself don't like the usage of the x2 sliders at points where the it sounds more like random beats, but nothing really significant for me to pop.

this song is difficult for me to map >_<

Mafiamaster wrote:

[Marathon]
03:16:713 (7) - Remove clap from the end?
04:12:775 (3,4) - Mirror this with 1 and 2?
04:27:963 (4) - New combo?
04:34:713 (9) - New combo?
04:35:463 (17) - Add a whistle?
05:05:181 (1) - This sounds really bad. Maybe start this at 05:05:088? Then add another extending arrow thing to the next white line.

all fixed.

04:57:963 (1) - Timing seems to get iffy by this point and at some other points. You might need another uninherited timing section somewhere around here. Maybe a good timer can help with this?
05:51:400 (2,3,4,5) - These sound too early. But of course, the BPM gets slower in the song. You may need uninherited timing sections at this part too.

checked the time by myself and not very sure 3_3

100pa- wrote:

timing from 5:50:495

bpm 152.000
ofst 350,495

bpm 139.000
ofst 352,073

bpm 125.000
ofst 352,936


.osu file
[TimingPoints]
.
.
.
350495,394.736842105263,4,1,0,100,1,0
352073,431.654676258993,4,1,0,100,1,0
352936,480,4,1,0,100,1,0


good luck~

S i R i R u wrote:

:)

Davidz123 wrote:

Here ya go!

[attachment=0:10a9f]hitcircle.png[/attachment:10a9f]

Star!~

Mafiamaster wrote:

[Marathon]
02:10:691 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Can you move this stack to where this is? That way the stack doesn't appear under the note during gameplay.

SPOILER

05:36:191 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17) - Also this stack here. Could you move it so it's diagonal with 4. Across from 3.

SPOILER

After those are fixed, I'll give you a bubble for approval.

abalee wrote:

只是想说一句,就我(和mafia)的权利，似乎不能单独app一个diff.。烂苹果那个操作应该是老板才能做的。所以只能整张进app了。

abalee wrote:

bubbled #2 for Marathon

notes:
unsnapped note is snapped in its timing section;
05:19:456 (7,8,9) - it sounds better in this timing section.

Colin Hou wrote:

thx

finally got my first map ranked orz

and...

SPOILER

sorry for my poor mapping skills when I was working on it, I'll try my best to make the W.I.P fun to play.

those wrote:

When you go to play this map, it doesn't show that it's approved, not ranked.

Hermanni wrote:

Okay, my next post should send to some error topic maybe but i passed the marathon difficulty and i didn't get any ranked score but my hit rating dropped by this song.. the marathonl difficulty seems to be ranked but i just wonder is this an error or is this "ranked map" which doesn't affect to ranked score because of the huge points?