after a long talk with TicClick, we reached a consensus about how to do with the map:
some reply to the rest mods:
all diffs updated
P.S. the original extra diff is here
- there's actually some piano sounds from 00:19:138 - to 00:20:471 - , but they sound too weak. so I finally changed circle stacks to repeat sliders, and turned their volume down a bit except 00:19:138 - 00:19:638 - and 00:20:138 -
- changed 01:03:305 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - the stream shape to avoid hiding 01:03:305 (2) - under the sliderbody
- removed the note at 01:10:721 - , and changed 01:10:471 (6) - to slider, to avoid following nothing at the music
some reply to the rest mods:
TicClick
TicClick wrote:
- 00:09:805 - the stream actually starts here, on the white tick, but notes appear 1/2 later. I honestly don't know what to do, would try to remove or shorten the spinner
the heavy beats at this part are 00:09:805 - 00:10:305 - and 00:10:971 - , I think using spinner end and stream end to follow them is better than using stream head. so I want to keep the current rhythm- 00:53:138 (1,2) - could be a stream if you are generous but that single 1/4 note is just "wrong"
sorry but I don't any 1/4 note around here.. about the rhythm, I don't want to use complex(1/3 streams) at this short soft part. I prefer simple rhythm here, as a soft transition to the next part. simple rhythm here makes the next part feels more intense, it's better imo- 00:54:055 (2) - note doesn't fit anything; it is actually conflicting with the song.
I used more notes here to emphasize the loud vocal at 00:54:138 - , just like what I did at 01:04:721 -- 01:10:721 (8) - I could agree on removing this note as the last triplet can be seen as a valid addition. Maybe even keeping all 5 notes could be okay from a pure gameplay perspective as it keeps the tension in this part up - but that is really stretching the limits of what should be done.
removed the note
Asphyxia
thanks for the moddingAsphyxia wrote:
EXTRA MAGIC
- Kind of weird difficulty settings, don't you think OD 8,5 would be better because it's an extra after all? Also using Hp 7 or 6,5 could be a nice idea, adds more challenge.
the setting is hard enough for this diff imo.. the HP is for more people can pass the diff, it won't make the diff easier or harder to play- 00:15:138 (3,4,5,6) - Consider adding them more spacing, looking at 00:13:305 (3,6) - or 00:18:638 (3,6) - , that seems to be somewhat inconsistent (I'll admit that that's a completely different pattern). But if you ask me, having more spacing on those 1/4 sliders would make the pattern play overall a ton better instead of feeling cluttered.
raised spacing a bit- 01:08:805 (2,3,5,6) - Adding more spacing between these notes would definitely improve the gameplay, similar what you have at 01:06:971 (1,2) - or 00:56:305 (1,2) - . Feels weird to play because the part is really intense, yet you used such a low distance snap there.
the current spacing is fine imo. I broke the flow a bit here, it would be too hard to play if I raised the spacing- 01:17:471 (1,2,3,4,5) - This stream plays really, really weird. I don't hear the song decreasing gradually volume-wise at all, so in that sense this doesn't make too much sense. The song is pretty intense too, it doesn't lose it untill at 01:17:805 - (imo) which makes it even more weird to play this. Consider using something like this instead because it'd play better for sure;
the spacing changing is to indicate the slider speed changing to the next slider, the stream looks a bit odd but I think it's a nice reminder- Other than that it seems to be pretty good!
all diffs updated
P.S. the original extra diff is here