1. Easy (1.45 stars, 231 notes)
2. Hard (3.08 stars, 514 notes)
3. Normal (1.86 stars, 329 notes)

Dasheroo wrote:

Man, I'm sorry... Try to post it in another queue..
Btw, I can give you a fast suggest.
00:23:365 (6) - This is a new combo, cause she starts singing at that point.
00:24:784 (4) - ^
00:26:609 (4) - ^
00:31:473 (2) - ^
00:36:136 (4) - ^
00:39:581 (4) - ^
Fix it ^^
Good luck for mods, and sorry me!

Tician wrote:

General

Timing - OK
Settings - some tags missing (f.e. country)
AiMod - OK

Hard

Testplay: Wow I like this diff, I don't think I can find many things to mod here ^^

00:21:744 (3) - Just a little thing but try to make the 2 bows exactly the same (no matter which ° you use for the middle) i think its okay, ii see what youre saying, but i do like it uneven
00:38:365 (2,3) - the head and tail of the slider should not overlap here fixed
00:39:379 I think the vocal is ending here changed, tried something new
00:57:622 Even if there is no sound I would use a circle to keep rhythm it's too hard to begin at a blue ticknooo, no beat, no circle
01:03:298 (3,1) - need a little bit more love and beauty i like this actually
01:23:163 (4,8) - The DS is fail here, move it a bit away it plays nice
03:37:554 (6,7) - confusing^^ ill change this is other people complain, i think its playable, i just put it in there so people who miss has to play the entire thing over again

normal

Testplay: This diff is nice too, but maybe a bit hard cause of the overlaps and stacks you did

00:34:919 (3) - symmetry tried!
01:29:244 (2) - ^ its good enuff
00:54:176 (3) - Let this start on the white tick did not do any of these, i want to catch the beat on the blue tick
01:49:311 (3) - same ^
03:10:392 (3) - same ^

Easy

I think this diff is nearly perfect I like it

00:26:811 (1,2) - blanket could be better tried

Hum that was it, I don't want to give any stupid advices cause I can't find anything wrong^^

Missing a spinne rin normal and hard i dont think this map needs spinners, but i just put one on easy so people cant perma #1, normal will be interesting because itll be harder to 4mod so

Good luck with the map, it's great, a star for it =)

ego_17 wrote:

elements on hard look like they roughly placed.. it can be better... nice song,playable map - liked it

ego_17 wrote:

elements look like they roughly placed..

Estellia- wrote:

From M4M~

• 
  [Easy]

1. 00:38:163 (1,2) - Transition of sliders are kinda weird
2. 00:47:487 - I feel a note over here
3. 00:54:379 (4) - Suggest a Ctrl + G
4. 01:18:703 (1,2) - Make the flow more circular, bend the front bit of slider 2 more
5. 02:04:919 (2,3) - If I'm not wrong, the blanket here is kinda off
6. 02:08:163 (2) - Bend second bit of slider more
7. 02:09:784 (4,2) - Blanket 2 better to 4
8. 02:30:865 (2,4) - Blanket 4 better to 2
9. (If there were stuff fixed in first/second kiai I didn't mention, just fix for both)
10. Dunno why the back was empty i like where it ends now, feels good. also, you can have the last part play while looking at the score screen. (also cause im lazy.)
    
    Nice Easy, loved it for its flow and slider shapes
    
    fixed everything
    
    [Normal]
11. 00:26:811 (1,2,3) - Make flow more circular? Make 3 flat not sure wht you mean
12. 00:29:041 (4,5,6,1) - ^, shift 6 more towards the right still not sure what you mean
13. 00:34:919 (3,4) - Transition of sliders feel weird i think its okay
14. 00:54:176 (3) - Shift this note forward in the time line by one beat and shorten it by one beat. Fix DS changes (I feel that this way the rhythm fits better) id like to catch the beat on the blue tick
15. 01:41:406 (1,2) - Blanket?
16. 01:42:216 (2,3) - ^
17. (Fix flipped kiai if missed anything)
18. Still dunno why the back is empty
    
    Feels like a very good Normal. One of the easier mapsets I've modded so far
    
    [Hard]
19. 00:25:190 (6,7,8) - The intersecting sliders here look weird, try to make one of these: did it!
    
20. 00:33:703 (2,3,4,5,6) - Feels a bit boring changed
21. 00:37:352 (3) - Make 3 blanket end of 2?
22. 00:46:271 (1,3) - Blanket 3 to 1 better
23. 00:57:825 (2) - Suggest shorten this by a beat and shift forward by a beat. The singer kinda starts in the middle of the blue and red point, but red makes it less confusing. feels a little too late if i move it to red.
24. 01:03:298 (3,5) - I don't really like the sliders overlapping each other, and I would suggest a circular flow, but you can keep it keeping it
25. 01:16:879 (4,5,6,7) - I kinda see a circle here, so shift the end of 7 more inwards so it feels more circular oky
26. (Kiai fix)
27. 02:18:906 (5,6) - Transition of sliders here feel weird i think it plays okay
28. 02:26:000 (7,1) - Stacking error
29. 03:37:554 (6,7) - Looks too confusing ill keep it for now, feeling evil
30. Why is the back empty???
    
    Consistent + simplistic hard. I liked most of it, other than the fact that its too vocal-based. Try to keep to bg rhythm more than vocals, although your mapping style is able to mask it. I spot an aspiring mapper right here

Amazing, easy-to-mod mapset. Some are just suggestions, so take your time and choose these mods wisely

thanks a bunch for the mod!! very helpful

1. i notice that there's a tiny pause in kiai between your two chorus sections that seems pretty unnecessary so i'd suggest removing it
2. AIMod says theres too many kiai times but i'll leave that up to you
3. there's a few errors in distance snapping that you should also check throughout the difficulties

1. 01:50:325 (5) - move this down to 452, 24 and move the last point on the slider to 480, 140 for better blanket
2. 02:47:892 (1) - move the last point (where the reverse arrow is) to 332, 88
3. 02:57:825 (2) - starting a slider on the blue tick instead of a beat will be confusing so i'd suggest changing this as it may be hard to recognize the timing if someone is unfamiliar with the music
4. 03:06:541 (2) - move first point to 140, 32
5. 03:11:811 (5) - move to 448, 304
6. 03:11:811 (5) - move 2nd point to 88, 280

1. 00:47:081 (2) - flip this
2. 00:54:176 (3) - curve the last point more towards (4)
3. 01:08:568 (3) - i'm not great w/hitsound advice but i noticed you used a whistle on the head of 01:06:946 (3) so maybe add one here too
4. 01:29:244 (2) - make this more symmetrical and blanket better with (5) like this
5. 01:56:000 (4) - curve this
6. 01:59:244 (4) - curve this to match 01:57:622 (1)
7. 02:57:825 (2) - this will be hard to time for the same reason i pointed out in easy, maybe put a circle on the beat before the blue tick
8. 03:23:568 (1) - curve this

1. 00:37:352 (3) - blanket this better with (2)
2. 00:57:825 (3,4,5) - spacing here is almost the same but the timing is different
3. 01:15:865 (2) - rotate this inward very slightly
4. 01:27:622 (7) - flip?
5. 01:51:136 (1,2,3) - bit too close to hp bar, move down a bit
6. 02:03:095 (2) - move to 360, 284
7. 03:33:298 (7,8) - i think you should continue the rhythm you used for 03:31:676 (1,2,3,4,5)

ankou wrote:

from mod queue
as always these are just personal suggestions
when i talk about blanketing and sliders the first point is always where the slider starts and the last point is where it ends

[General]

1. i notice that there's a tiny pause in kiai between your two chorus sections that seems pretty unnecessary so i'd suggest removing it using it for the sexy kiai fountain for the second half (for those who actually have kiai fountains on anyways ;_;
2. AIMod says theres too many kiai times but i'll leave that up to you i generally dont listen to AIMod about kiais, i think its just for accidental kiai times and timing errors
3. there's a few errors in distance snapping that you should also check throughout the difficulties fixified the ones on normal, hard should be okay

[Easy]

1. 01:50:325 (5) - move this down to 452, 24 and move the last point on the slider to 480, 140 for better blanket
2. 02:47:892 (1) - move the last point (where the reverse arrow is) to 332, 88
3. 02:57:825 (2) - starting a slider on the blue tick instead of a beat will be confusing so i'd suggest changing this as it may be hard to recognize the timing if someone is unfamiliar with the music i think this should be okay, everything is pretty much harder to hit after a long pause, but if more people say this ill change it,
4. 03:06:541 (2) - move first point to 140, 32
5. 03:11:811 (5) - move to 448, 304
6. 03:11:811 (5) - move 2nd point to 88, 280

fix all the blankets my own way, thanks for pointing them out
[Normal]
generally i think the NCs here should be when the vocal starts, like at 00:20:122 (5), 00:23:365 (5) and 00:26:609 (5)

1. 00:47:081 (2) - flip this i think its okay, plays nice into the next sliders.
2. 00:54:176 (3) - curve the last point more towards (4)
3. 01:08:568 (3) - i'm not great w/hitsound advice but i noticed you used a whistle on the head of 01:06:946 (3) so maybe add one here too
4. 01:29:244 (2) - make this more symmetrical and blanket better with (5) like this
5. 01:56:000 (4) - curve this i prefer these straight, i think it looks better
6. 01:59:244 (4) - curve this to match 01:57:622 (1) ^
7. 02:57:825 (2) - this will be hard to time for the same reason i pointed out in easy, maybe put a circle on the beat before the blue tick will change if more people complain
8. 03:23:568 (1) - curve this ^

fixed the rest o/
[Hard]

1. 00:37:352 (3) - blanket this better with (2)
2. 00:57:825 (3,4,5) - spacing here is almost the same but the timing is different
3. 01:15:865 (2) - rotate this inward very slightly
4. 01:27:622 (7) - flip?
5. 01:51:136 (1,2,3) - bit too close to hp bar, move down a bit (im lazy to remap ;_;)
6. 02:03:095 (2) - move to 360, 284
7. 03:33:298 (7,8) - i think you should continue the rhythm you used for 03:31:676 (1,2,3,4,5)

fixed/changed rest \o/

overall i really liked your slider shapes and everything was well mapped, good luck!

RokYang wrote:

I grace you with being the first person I shall mod.
I like this song and the beatmaps were nice
I'm not too fussed about positioning of notes unless it's outrageously silly

Easy

Timing - Seems perfect

00:35:730 Circles 4, 5 - I suggest putting a slider here changed

Normal

Timing - Spot on

00:20:325 Slider 4 - I suggest cutting that slider in half and adding a circle at 00:20:325 i like what i have better

00:27:419 Circle 2 - I'd remove the circle there and add a 1/2 beat slider at 00:28:636 i like what i have better

01:10:798 Slider 3 - I don't really like the flow of slider 2 and 3 right there, what I'd do is add a Circle at 01:10:798 instead and move silder 3 back 1/4 beat. Then select both and adjust their position to around x:64, y:200 i think this is fine, no change

01:33:298 Slider 4 - I suggest cutting this slider in half and adding a circle at 01:34:109 okay, i tried something new

02:05:325 Slider 3 - Same thing as I wrote before, the flow feels weird to me but may seem fine to everyone else. Again, I'd add a circle at 02:05:933 instead and move the slider back 1/4 beat. Then I'd adjust position as necessary.i think this is alright

Hard

Timing - Great

00:21:744 Slider 3 - I suggest making this slider 1/2 beat, pushing it back 1/4 beat then add a circle at 00:21:744. Then of course adjust position.tried something new

Maps are great, not much for me to say really. I'll check them out again later since I did this fairly quickly

1. Try to get a custom set of colours? The default ones don't really fit and they look a bit too bright/agressive, in my opinion.

1. Pretty sure that LEAVES.png is too big. The filesize is huge and it's not really necessary to keep them this huge.
   

   Storyboard images must be at a reasonable size for their usage. For most uses (e.g. full-screen images), the maximum is 800x600 pixels for 4:3 aspect ratio images, although 640x480 is highly preferred. For widescreen mode (recommended) the maximum is 960x540 pixels for 16:9 aspect ratio images and 960x600 for 16:10 images. The editor is 640x480 at default, so there's really no need to use anything larger for full-screen purposes.

2. The word "bitches" is counted as an offensive one. So, i would suggest to replace it with something more polite. Just to be 100% safe.
3. The epilepsy warning should be enabled. Some elements appear/move quickly and it may be dangerous.
4. Glitter.png is not used in the SB. Mind removing it?
   
   Creative, nicely done, entertaining. I love the SB!

1. 00:25:190 (3,1) - I wouldn't recommend this kind of placement for the easiest diff. (1)'s tail is too close to the previous hitobject and beginners might mistakenly hi the tail.
2. 00:34:109 (3) - minor - Slightly overlapped with the HP-Bar. Not a big problem, but avoiding it is better.
   Note: 01:09:379 (1) - 03:00:460 (3) - same.
3. 01:21:136 (4) - the rhythm here feels a bit off as both vocals and music are mapped in a bit confusing way. Try to stress the downbeat at 01:21:946 ? Example
   Note: 02:16:271 (4) - 03:24:379 (4) - 03:37:352 (4) - same. There're a few more patterns with similar problem, just testplay the map and you'll spot that they feel quite unnatural while playing.
4. 01:36:946 (4,5) - I believe that they sound way better if you Ctrl+G them. Give it a try and see if you like it.
   
   The rhythm could use some more work, but it is okay even as it is. Overall, that's a very enjoyable and nice Easy.

1. Try CS 3,2 to make the set more balanced. It won't affect the gameplay much and it will make stuff look better.
2. 00:19:717 - consider placing a circle here to make the rhythm mre intuitively playable.
   Note: Check this out. Basically, the main problem is that those 3/4 beats are confusing for players. Take alook at the video and see how you can make stuff more playable.
3. 01:04:919 (5) - a little overlap with the HP Bar again.
   
   So, everything is great with the diff except a few confusing 3/4 patterns. Either do something about them (preferable) or simply reduce the OD. Pretty nce diff.

1. Same polarity thing happens here.
2. 00:36:541 (1,3) - minor - the overlap here looks untidy to me. Probably it's jst me, but this looks much better.
3. 00:41:406 - I understand your intention to follow the vocals, but ignoring a strong beat in the music is not the best idea. I would try to map the instruments here as they sound stronger and feel more important.
   Note: 01:06:338 (3) - 02:01:473 (3) - same.
4. 01:24:176 (5,6,7) - these were the only 1/8 beats in the whole diff. Which gives me a feeling of inconsistency. Replace (5,6) with an 1/8 slider? That would play much easier + it feels better with the rest of the patterns.
5. 02:57:419 (4,5) - some kind of a jump between these two might help to represent the change in the music and fit great. Try it. example
   
   All cool. Just a bit more work on the rhythm and it'll be a perfect diff!

-Bakari- wrote:

As rquested. Sorry about the delay. delay? this is practically lightning fast compared to the other responses ive gotten

[General]

1. Try to get a custom set of colours? The default ones don't really fit and they look a bit too bright/agressive, in my opinion. right, tried some washed out colors.

[Storyboard]

ill leave this to lanturn

[Easy]

1. 00:25:190 (3,1) - I wouldn't recommend this kind of placement for the easiest diff. (1)'s tail is too close to the previous hitobject and beginners might mistakenly hi the tail. right, i didnt really like it either. rotated it
2. 00:34:109 (3) - minor - Slightly overlapped with the HP-Bar. Not a big problem, but avoiding it is better.
   Note: 01:09:379 (1) - 03:00:460 (3) - same. fixed
3. 01:21:136 (4) - the rhythm here feels a bit off as both vocals and music are mapped in a bit confusing way. Try to stress the downbeat at 01:21:946 ? Example right, changed.
   Note: 02:16:271 (4) - 03:24:379 (4) - 03:37:352 (4) - same. There're a few more patterns with similar problem, just testplay the map and you'll spot that they feel quite unnatural while playing.
4. 01:36:946 (4,5) - I believe that they sound way better if you Ctrl+G them. Give it a try and see if you like it. i cant tell but ill go with your expertise
   
   The rhythm could use some more work, but it is okay even as it is. Overall, that's a very enjoyable and nice Easy. woo

[Normal]

1. Try CS 3,2 to make the set more balanced. It won't affect the gameplay much and it will make stuff look better. ok
2. 00:19:717 - consider placing a circle here to make the rhythm mre intuitively playable. added slider
   Note: Check this out. Basically, the main problem is that those 3/4 beats are confusing for players. Take alook at the video and see how you can make stuff more playable. going to keep most of these, i think theyre okay.
3. 01:04:919 (5) - a little overlap with the HP Bar again. right
   
   So, everything is great with the diff except a few confusing 3/4 patterns. Either do something about them (preferable) or simply reduce the OD. Pretty nce diff.

[Hard]

1. Same polarity thing happens here.
2. 00:36:541 (1,3) - minor - the overlap here looks untidy to me. Probably it's jst me, but this looks much better. nice idea
3. 00:41:406 - I understand your intention to follow the vocals, but ignoring a strong beat in the music is not the best idea. I would try to map the instruments here as they sound stronger and feel more important. changed it
   Note: 01:06:338 (3) - 02:01:473 (3) - same. fixified
4. 01:24:176 (5,6,7) - these were the only 1/8 beats in the whole diff. Which gives me a feeling of inconsistency. Replace (5,6) with an 1/8 slider? That would play much easier + it feels better with the rest of the patterns. right
5. 02:57:419 (4,5) - some kind of a jump between these two might help to represent the change in the music and fit great. Try it. tried itexample
   
   All cool. Just a bit more work on the rhythm and it'll be a perfect diff!

Duuuuuuuuuuude, this is awesome!

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Best of luck!

Feith wrote:

hello..
from mod q here
here is my (useless) result !

[easy]
00:35:730 (4) - the object is slashed by the screen size when played on another than pc (tablet,smartphone), move it inside
00:46:271 (1) - ^
00:56:000 (1) , 03:12:217 (1) , 01:51:136 (1) - remove nc or 00:58:433 (2) , 03:14:649 (2) , 01:53:568 (2) - add nc new measure, new combo. i think it makes a lot of sense. also, it provides a follow line for players to find the next note more easily on FL
02:50:325 (3) - slashed, move it
03:19:514 (2) - ^
03:27:622 (4) - ^
03:34:514 (4) - ^

no change to any of the hit objects off screen, honestly any other platform besides PC is a joke and shouldnt be bothered with.

[normal]
01:06:946 (3) - remove whistle ? changed
01:06:946 (3) - ^
01:16:676 (3) - slashed, move it
02:00:054 (5) - ^
02:09:784 (5) - ^

no change to objects

i think thats great but, seriously, why put the object outside until it get cut it plays fine on PC where it matters. ranking only applies on PC anyways.
no need to give KDS, just dont.... you tried, it was good
unsatified mods, even i'm not happy with this mod :v

wendao wrote:

can't do much, this beatmap for me is all clear.. seriously

[General]

• 
  lol sb, nice one, someone pls do censorship to that P**ky stuff lol i dont even know

1. Slider Tick 2 fit best ill look into this a little, though youre probably right

[Hard]

• 
  nice flows

1. OD +1 pls? since this is the hardest diff okay
   02:39:784 - move the break here moved it to the HAH, i think thats better.

[Normal]

• 
  Fine.

[Easy]

• 
  Fine.

good luck with rank! hope this mod helps!