forum

I made a bot that recommends beatmaps. Try it!

posted
Total Posts
205
show more
Topic Starter
Tillerino

Tom94 wrote:

Maps around the recommended difficulty should give a good amount of pp, specifically because pp is based on (components of) the star difficulty. Mods are coming, too. :)

On topic: Nice bot, that you made. The feedback you are getting by itself speaks for it.
Thanks :)

I know that star difficulty and max pp are very similar, but my recommended star difficulty is simply to low. It's 4.58 I believe, which is around the star diff of my #40 play. Maybe you forgot to factor in mods?
Amedis

-GN wrote:

I haven't been trying this extensively(yet), but I think it's really cool, and the beatmaps it has given me are all pretty nice. Thanks for this!
I agree!
Tom94

Tillerino wrote:

Tom94 wrote:

Maps around the recommended difficulty should give a good amount of pp, specifically because pp is based on (components of) the star difficulty. Mods are coming, too. :)

On topic: Nice bot, that you made. The feedback you are getting by itself speaks for it.
Thanks :)

I know that star difficulty and max pp are very similar, but my recommended star difficulty is simply to low. It's 4.58 I believe, which is around the star diff of my #40 play. Maybe you forgot to factor in mods?
Your #9 best performance has 4.54 stars and you played it without mods. :P
I'll look into increasing the estimated difficulty, though.
casmith789
This is pretty cool.

I think its nomod picks are better than its mod picks, but maybe I'm just using the wrong mods :P
Topic Starter
Tillerino

Tom94 wrote:

Your #9 best performance has 4.54 stars and you played it without mods. :P
I'll look into increasing the estimated difficulty, though.
Wh... You're absolutely right! I think I somehow managed to look at exactly those maps where the star diff is unusually high. For the record my #39 play is in fact 4.63 :) Raising the estimated difficulty by a tiny bit might make sense, but I was under the impression that the difference was higher.
ballplay
maybe add more customization? e.g. !recommend bpm<230
all the maps i was recommended had high bpm that i cant handle
Mythras
Star diff = directly pp related ? Hmm I need to actually fc wahrheit instead of being amused by its A pp...
Gigo
I wonder what maps would your bot recommend to Cookiezi (if he was still playing)...
Topic Starter
Tillerino

Gigo wrote:

I wonder what maps would your bot recommend to Cookiezi (if he was still playing)...
The recommendations for any top player would be pretty much nonsense :)
Topic Starter
Tillerino

SloppySeal wrote:

maybe add more customization? e.g. !recommend bpm<230
all the maps i was recommended had high bpm that i cant handle
This is also a FAQ, I'll add it shortly. I'm not going to add any meta data to the request. I might display more meta data with the result so you can identify weird results without having to download the beatmaps.

Also I don't think that it was *all* the maps that had high bpm. Heavenly moon seemed pretty good :) This might be a long shot, but I think you might be able to beat NNRT as well. !recommend is a bit shaky with mods some times. I think I'll make !recommend beta the main thing now. Should probably have done that before I opened this thread.
Mythras
recommend beta (current recommend) is hard as fuck, stuff still seems remotely possible though, pp seems easier to get just getting 99%+ accuracy on all the stuff i already beat lol
xasuma
I really like it. I just tried it today for the first time (recommend beta) and I am really enjoying it. Songs go from at least a little challenging, to challeging enough that I cant quite fc them yet. But fun nonetheless.
Congrats on the bot, I hope you keep working on it , I am looking forward to it.

P.S : I would like a "!commands" command, so I could view them right in game instead of opening the browser. Just a little suggestion that you can certainly ignore. :)
Cocaine dog
I'll start using this! I've been looking for something to give me maps to play q,q <3
Topic Starter
Tillerino

xasuma wrote:

P.S : I would like a "!commands" command, so I could view them right in game instead of opening the browser. Just a little suggestion that you can certainly ignore. :)
That was the response to !help at some point. However, since I need to limit the rate at which I am sending messages, listing all commands would take quite a while and possibly delay other users who are using the bot.
Monstrata
I find that !recommend beta is more accurate in terms of gauging how difficult a map you can play successfully. It recommends songs that are difficult for me but are playable. However, those recommended songs are also songs I can't FC in a few tries. I've pretty much played all my top 20 songs at least 30-40 times. Some a lot more. The normal !recommend often recommends slightly easier songs that, when passed, do not give a boatload of pp, but can be passed in a few tries, maybe even as little as 1 depending on your sight-reading and consistency. You only receive like, 2-3pp maybe, per song.
silmarilen

Tillerino wrote:

xasuma wrote:

P.S : I would like a "!commands" command, so I could view them right in game instead of opening the browser. Just a little suggestion that you can certainly ignore. :)
That was the response to !help at some point. However, since I need to limit the rate at which I am sending messages, listing all commands would take quite a while and possibly delay other users who are using the bot.
you could just make it link a puush of all the commands or something (a .txt)

it linked me a couple of ar9 maps with low pp value (implying i have to DT it) but i dont have a single ar9 dt score in my top performances, i can barely even pass the easiest of them. is this intended (or just never looked at it before) or would it be possible to change that?
casmith789
Another suggestion - feel free to ignore

When I use /np to show pp values, it would be nice if when I /np when watching/playing a DT score for it to show the best/community pp for the DT score if possible

Been using this for a couple of days and I'm pretty pleased with how it works, I had a "fc later" collection with maps that give a lot of pp and it seems to have recommended most of them to me.
NinjaNick
Second beat-map I play, I got 13 PP. Thank you so much :)
Makou
i love this its so useful ;)
Topic Starter
Tillerino

monstrata wrote:

I find that !recommend beta is more accurate in terms of gauging how difficult a map you can play successfully. It recommends songs that are difficult for me but are playable. However, those recommended songs are also songs I can't FC in a few tries. I've pretty much played all my top 20 songs at least 30-40 times. Some a lot more. The normal !recommend often recommends slightly easier songs that, when passed, do not give a boatload of pp, but can be passed in a few tries, maybe even as little as 1 depending on your sight-reading and consistency. You only receive like, 2-3pp maybe, per song.
The new recommend (which used to be beta; it's the regular one now) tries to give you a potential top 10 play. I've had recommendations of that sort, which I FC'd after a couple of tries, but most of them I need to practice a bit, but I can feel that it improves my abilities. This makes them more valuable in my opinion. The old recommendations are still accessible with !recommend relax.

silmarilen wrote:

you could just make it link a puush of all the commands or something (a .txt)
Is that handled differently in the osu! client? I don't see how that would have any advantages...

silmarilen wrote:

it linked me a couple of ar9 maps with low pp value (implying i have to DT it) but i dont have a single ar9 dt score in my top performances, i can barely even pass the easiest of them. is this intended (or just never looked at it before) or would it be possible to change that?

See updated FAQ.

casmith789 wrote:

When I use /np to show pp values, it would be nice if when I /np when watching/playing a DT score for it to show the best/community pp for the DT score if possible
This will happen eventually.
xasuma
Can we have an alternative way of writing each command?

For example:
!recommend or !r
!recommend relax or !rr

lol. Im actual lazy, and so should you be as a programmer. :)
RaneFire
Time to integrate Tillerino with Bancho. :)

j/k
Rewben2

xasuma wrote:

Can we have an alternative way of writing each command?

For example:
!recommend or !r
!recommend relax or !rr

lol. Im actual lazy, and so should you be as a programmer. :)
I just have "!recommend beta" on my clipboard and ctrl+v spam it lol
theleoleole
Yay thanks for making this! Works like charm!
Topic Starter
Tillerino

Rewben2 wrote:

I just have "!recommend beta" on my clipboard and ctrl+v spam it lol

xasuma wrote:

Can we have an alternative way of writing each command?

For example:
!recommend or !r
!recommend relax or !rr

lol. Im actual lazy, and so should you be as a programmer. :)
I'm pretty lazy, but already satisfied with the fact that I can press the up arrow key to repeat my last command.

But you're just remarkably lazy, because neither did you read this to the very end nor did you simply try !r ;) On the other hand you weren't lazy enough to not write that comment, so it's tough to estimate your laziness :)
Mythras
its giving pretty good DT suggestions, some of them i can actually do, some of them are outrageously impossible

about to break into the 5ks because of this bot =D
xasuma

Tillerino wrote:

Rewben2 wrote:

I just have "!recommend beta" on my clipboard and ctrl+v spam it lol

xasuma wrote:

Can we have an alternative way of writing each command?

For example:
!recommend or !r
!recommend relax or !rr

lol. Im actual lazy, and so should you be as a programmer. :)
I'm pretty lazy, but already satisfied with the fact that I can press the up arrow key to repeat my last command.

But you're just remarkably lazy, because neither did you read this to the very end nor did you simply try !r ;) On the other hand you weren't lazy enough to not write that comment, so it's tough to estimate your laziness :)
Rofl!
My bad!! Gomen :D

I am indeed remarkably lazy 8-)
Sorarei
it would nice if recommended have 2 separated ways,

1. All of beatmaps that available on osu!

2. Beatmaps that you've only have in your song directory
Maxis

Reikosaka wrote:

it would nice if recommended have 2 separated ways,

1. All of beatmaps that available on osu!

2. Beatmaps that you've only have in your song directory
I think there's 2 problems with this, and it's that:

1. The bot has no way of knowing the maps you have, and

2. If it was limited to just your songs directory, you'd probably get a lot fewer maps recommended with less variety, and you've likely played a lot of it already.
xasuma

Reikosaka wrote:

it would nice if recommended have 2 separated ways,

1. All of beatmaps that available on osu!

2. Beatmaps that you've only have in your song directory
Get all maps. Solved.

I have them all ^^ its nice
- Marco -
When i /np this https://osu.ppy.sh/b/209285

It gives error (ULXEYK, GTNHDB)
_koinuri
It gives error for any unranked map, I don't think it can get data for unranked maps.
Vuelo Eluko

peppy wrote:

VioletMaid wrote:

I'm kinda surprised these kinds of things aren't built directly into the game to keep people focused.
3.86 stars?!
wat
is that my powerlevel or something, that kinda stings.
Blueprint
4.25 for me I suck :(
Topic Starter
Tillerino

marcostudios wrote:

When i /np this https://osu.ppy.sh/b/209285

It gives error (ULXEYK, GTNHDB)

Loli -[Koinuri] wrote:

It gives error for any unranked map, I don't think it can get data for unranked maps.
While it's true that you don't get any information for unranked maps, there should be a proper message instead of an error message. Thx for pointing it out!
timemon


I think it's incorrect.
xasuma
I think this thread should be in development forums. Staff, get to it. :shock:
JonQuy
This is excellent. The only downside to this I've seen so far is the maps it tends to give aren't very difficult. Though, that does make it excellent for just chilling and having some fun. (one thing that surprised me was that i enjoyed the music it gave me so used to stuff like this giving me good maps just i hate the music lol)
Kingkevin30

JonQuy wrote:

This is excellent. The only downside to this I've seen so far is the maps it tends to give aren't very difficult. Though, that does make it excellent for just chilling and having some fun. (one thing that surprised me was that i enjoyed the music it gave me so used to stuff like this giving me good maps just i hate the music lol)
i have the exact opposite, it only gives me Maps that im unable to even get through, quite depressing lol
otoed1

JonQuy wrote:

I have the exact opposite, it only gives me Maps that im unable to even get through, quite depressing lol
From What I've understood these maps are still "technically" in your skill level. The bot is supposed to give you maps that are potential top ten, so your top ten were probably very hard for you to achieve and its giving you similarly hard maps.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply