xxheroxx wrote:

Mod Info's:

Green: Suggestions.
Orange: I think you should fix this.
Red: You must fix this.

Starts Suggestions:

All seems ok.

[Crackers]

It's ok

[Nuts]

It's ok

[Angry Banana]

01:10:078 (2) - spacing

Starred~

thepianist wrote:

Woohoo 24 stars (not counting my own.) hahaha just under the threshold.

Anyways: viewtopic.php?t=15539

Thanks in advanced!

Tanmak wrote:

thepianist wrote:

Woohoo 24 stars (not counting my own.) hahaha just under the threshold.

Anyways: viewtopic.php?t=15539

Thanks in advanced!

Yeah, You are lucky~ hahaha. (>w<)
Then, I begin modding.

[Crackers]
01:07:674 (3) Extend slide note like picture. MMkay
[attachment=1:24d92]setsumei10.png[/attachment:24d92]

[Nuts]
00:30:391 Put in Break.
00:54:803 (6,7) 1 grid down. Fixed
01:07:729 (3) Move back white tick and same modding which is [Crackers]; 01:07:674.
01:30:545 (3) Make like picture. Tried best to read
[attachment=0:24d92]setsumei11.png[/attachment:24d92]
01:57:926 (4,5,6) Check spacing. It's fine?

[Angry Banana]
01:07:838 (5) Move to 01:07:947 Ehhh moved to one tick before. :]
01:13:439 (7) Unsnapped. fixd
01:13:630 (9) ^ fixed
03:02:232 (Suggestion) Put in Break? Found alternate solution

Great song~~!
Starred~

Shinxyn wrote:

whoa, messy timing xD
look through the map and remove all whistle-sliderslide hitsounds please
Don't max volume the normal hitsound sections (or single notes), its too loud
UM... the timing given to you shouldn't need so many 1/6th notes... then again, the whole timing is... messy

Crackers-

SPOILER

00:08:058 (1) - snap to white ticks Note's snapped, the spinner goes better a bit before :\
00:57:005 (3) - ^ Fixed
01:04:001 (1,2) - ^ It comes in late?
01:05:070 (3) - if this was to vocal, then back 1/2 beat fixed
01:07:001 (2) - snap to white ticks and extend fixed
01:07:067 (3) - end on red tick ends early?
01:08:071 (1,2,3) - snap to white ticks 1,2 moved. 3 works fine?
01:10:062 (1) - snap to white tick singer comes in early.
01:14:034 - V seeing so many odd timing parts here, so... have someone recheck this BPM, I think D: iono there were timings by tieff, awp, and etc...
01:26:016 (1) - end on 1/4 extended
01:27:060 (1) - .....maybe keep this on 1/6, I'm not too sure
01:27:088 (2) - snap to blue tick, and end on either red or white tick V rounded to the 6th, since if i ever resnap the map it becomes a mess...
01:29:093 (1) - same as 01:27:060 (1)...
01:30:026 (2) - start on blue tick, end on red
01:31:026 (3) - white tick
01:31:059 (4) - start on white, end on red
01:32:057 (1) - start on blue
The map keeps playing on cuz you have storyboard, make the rest of storyboard difficulty specific for Nuts and AngryBanana? oops

Nuts- lower slider tick rate?
ahhhhhhh

SPOILER

00:10:009 (2) - blue tick
00:56:023 (2) - red tick fixed
01:04:034 (2) - blue ticks? Redone
01:04:083 (3) - start on red tick. ^
01:11:060 (3) - end on white tick early
01:23:025 (4) - start on white tick, end on white tick fixed
01:57:092 (4) - snap to blue tick back? or the 1/6 note back k
01:59:008 (1) - snap on red tickkk
Oh my god @_@ I'm sure I missed some or something... theres always something missed in this map x.x

AngryBanana-

SPOILER

00:06:005 (3,4,5,6) - sounds the same as 00:08:075 (3,4,5,6), but the timing is different? 00:08:075's sounds more correct bleh moved it a bit?
00:20:036 (1) - end on red tick?
00:57:038 (2) - snap on white tick
01:00:095 (1) - red tick
01:01:012 (2) - white tick
01:01:061 (3) - red tick
01:03:026 (4) - red tick
01:13:033 (6,7,8,9) - too fast (compared to the music)
01:25:074 (7) - blue tick?
01:27:057 (1,2) - blue ticks
01:28:016 (3) - red ticks
01:29:010 (6,7) - start on red tick
01:45:051 (4,5,6,1) - sounds like one note too many here
@_@ ahhh swirling bananas
01:56:082 (2) - blue tick
01:57:043 (2) - red tick??
02:03:057 (2,3,4,5) - sounds early, maybe 1/6 notes later?
02:20:055 (3) - start on red tick
02:25:078 (2) - ^
02:27:004 (1) - why start on 1/6?
03:04:046 (1) - start on blue tick? (not that it matters for spinner)

Oh, my, gosh.
Storyboard's nice, map's okay, skinning is funny, timing is.... T.T

Takuma wrote:

First off, please remove all kiai time. I don't believe anything in this song merits a kiai time part. Second, I think you should remove the fade out at the end - it's really unnecessary, especially since there's nothing really fading out in the song. fade out? iono - never edited the mp3 in this map -__- I'm no expert at timing, but are all those timing sections really needed? x.x

-Angry Banana:
That's a fucking crazy SB.
00:49:622 (3) - 1/6th forward. fixed
01:00:957 (1,2,3) - ^?
01:08:494 (1,2,3,4) - I'm not quite sure what this follows. kinda anticipates the word 'cellular'
01:09:313 (6,7) - 1/6th forward. kk
01:10:625 (1,2,3,4) - ^ 1,2 moved.
01:13:330 (6,7,8,9) - I don't know what this follows either, plus its noisy. D: kinda follows harmony toned dwn.
01:27:549 (1) - 1/6th forward.

-Nuts:
01:11:608 (3) - The whistle at the end sounds ugly. @__@
01:50:572 (7) - Hmm, shorten to red tick?
02:19:901 (1,2) - 1/6th forward.

Have a star.

minyeob wrote:

[Nuts]
00:09:057 (1,2) - I suggest using 1/4 beat snap divisor

[Angry Banana]
00:48:079 (4) - Timing is incorrect(Compare with 00:49:067 (3)
01:01:061 (3) - Timing is incorrect(Compare with 00:40:044 (2)
01:07:089 (5) - If you want to follow vocal, use 1/6 beat snap divisor
01:08:049 (1,2,3,4) - These should be started from 1/6 beat earlier
01:08:098 (5) - This should be started from 1/6 beat later
01:09:064 (1) - This spinner breaks autospin 2000 rule.
01:32:054 (1) - This should be started from 1/6 beat later

Frankly speaking, this map has less hope(Unless you can make accurate timing)......
orz

minyeob wrote:

[Nuts]
00:09:057 (1,2) - I suggest using 1/4 beat snap divisor fixed

[Angry Banana]
00:48:079 (4) - Timing is incorrect(Compare with 00:49:067 (3) Fixed
01:01:061 (3) - Timing is incorrect(Compare with 00:40:044 (2) Fixed
01:07:089 (5) - If you want to follow vocal, use 1/6 beat snap divisor Fixed
01:08:049 (1,2,3,4) - These should be started from 1/6 beat earlierFixed
01:08:098 (5) - This should be started from 1/6 beat laterFixed
01:09:064 (1) - This spinner breaks autospin 2000 rule. Oopsfixed.
01:32:054 (1) - This should be started from 1/6 beat later Fixed

Frankly speaking, this map has less hope(Unless you can make accurate timing)...... I know right? Slightly regretting the decision x) blehhhh whatever. it's still fun.
orz

NoHItter wrote:

Ask Cyclone to help you with the timing...

tmokb93 wrote:

Mod's Info:
Mine are all suggestions. You're free to follow or not this mod :3
I'll just mod the beats in your map, in all its forms, will not tell you to add or remove the beat <3
Remember to fix spacing after all modfiy :3

[General]
Add some Source and some Tags.

[Crackers]
It's ok!

[Nuts]
It's ok!

[Angry Banana]
01:29:241 (7) Extend it by 4/6 I hope you meant 1/6.

And that's all for your map! I'm glad to star it! Hope you will ask me again for other maps-moddig x3

xxheroxx wrote:

Mod Infos:

Green: Suggestions.
Orange: I think you should fix this.
Red: You must fix this.

Start Suggestions:

All seems ok.

[Crackers]

Resnap all notes

00:08:020 (1) - 1/6 -> (move this circle here 00:08:257)[/color] Fixed (I think. Times don't match)

[Nuts]

Resnap all notes
00:06:005 (3,4) - 1/6 -> (move these sliders: 1 tick to the right, like Crackers)
00:07:037 (2,3,1) - ^ Sounds late
01:04:028 (2,3,4) - ^ Fixed
01:24:060 (1,2,3,4) - ^[/color] Fixed

[Angry Banana]

Resnap all notes
00:06:038 (5,6) - 1/6 ->
00:07:070 (8,9) - ^ Moved
00:09:052 (7,8,9) - ^[/color] Moved
01:08:043 (1,2,3,4) - wtf? fixed
02:07:025 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - 1/6 ->
02:10:074 (1,2,3) - ^[/color] Moved
02:37:083 (1,2,1) - Is this necessary?moved

1. O god... not this song! xD
2. Where's my banana pizza? \:

1. 01:19:033 (1) - Off screen.
2. 01:25:049 (6) - Make this go 1/6 later, on the red tick.
3. 02:21:037 (4) - Off screen.
4. 02:31:018 (3,4) - Spacing.
5. 02:38:037 (2) - Off screen.
6. 02:40:001 (1) - ^

1. 01:10:057 (1) - Off screen.
2. 01:25:044 (4) - Make this go 1/6 later, on the red tick.

1. 00:40:044 (2) - Off screen.
2. 01:25:049 (3) - Off screen.
3. 01:25:049 (3) - And here it's already good, on the red tick. Lol.

1. Source and tags must be set on all difficulties.
2. Combo colours aren't the same between difficulties. [Angry Banana] has a 5th combo colour.

1. There are some skinning elements with white-ish edges, and they look ugly. I don't have good image-editing skills so I can't help you with that.

Gladi wrote:

- General / All diff's.

1. O god... not this song! xD
2. Where's my banana pizza? \:

SPOILER

I might sb it in, but i hafta fix other skin stuff first.

- Angry Banana.

1. 01:19:033 (1) - Off screen. Moved
2. 01:25:049 (6) - Make this go 1/6 later, on the red tick. Moved
3. 02:21:037 (4) - Off screen. Moved
4. 02:31:018 (3,4) - Spacing. Moved
5. 02:38:037 (2) - Off screen. Moved
6. 02:40:001 (1) - ^ Moved

- Crackers.

1. 01:10:057 (1) - Off screen. But it isn't
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 01:25:044 (4) - Make this go 1/6 later, on the red tick. kk

- Nuts.

1. 00:40:044 (2) - Off screen. Now I'm just confused
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 01:25:049 (3) - Off screen. ^
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 01:25:049 (3) - And here it's already good, on the red tick. Lol.

Starred~

Gens wrote:

[General]

1. Source and tags must be set on all difficulties.
2. Combo colours aren't the same between difficulties. [Angry Banana] has a 5th combo colour.

[Skin]

1. There are some skinning elements with white-ish edges, and they look ugly. I don't have good image-editing skills so I can't help you with that.

:( I'll fix it as I have time.


[Crackers]

01:25:071 (4) - Move 1/6 later? It just doesn't sound right here. Also, remember to respace it after that. From Gladi's mod
01:26:066 (2) - Shorten by 1/6? Basically, the same as above. Kk
01:27:088 (2) - This slider sounds weird, but eh... don't know what to do with it. I wouldn't map to a person talking anyway.

[Angry Banana]

00:06:088 (7) - IMO sounds better if you shorten it by 1/6. Shortened
00:09:057 (7) - Same. Shortened

~ ~ ~

Well, I guess I can't help with anything else. Timing still sounds iffy in some places, but meh... don't know what to do with those notes. I guess this still needs a long way before it gets ranked. =/
This song is driving me bananas, by the way. Dunno if this is a good thing lol

BananasGoMoo wrote:

nice song choice lol
[Crackers]
fine.

[Nuts]
i would lower the drain a little, just a bit too high imo. Lowered a tick

[Angry Banana]
fine as well.

[Overall]
Just wanted to say really good skin. Looks like you put lots of effort into it.

hope this gets ranked soon.

Bitzeralisis wrote:

I like the Bananaphone skin

ouranhshc wrote:

Crackers
01:01:561(2) - this slider is ugly IMO Reshaped.
01:07:674(3,1,2,3) - line up with the end of (2) Done


Angry Bananas
00:30:061(1) - line up with (7,8) Done
01:07:674(4,5) - center between (2,3) Done
02:18:756(5) - line up with (3) Done

Agent Spin Here wrote:

Damn awesome Thank you!

Crackers
00:33:688 (4) - Remove whistle from sliderpath, it sounds weird Done
01:24:997 (2,3,4) - Confusing spacing T_T Done
Get rid of all the inherited sections after the end of the map. Done

Nuts
00:22:809 (3) - Remove whistle from slider path Done
01:17:674 (3) - ^ Done
Wtf is it with that countdown in the break dude? o.o It was a small play on Strager's request a long while ago viewtopic.php?f=4&t=17878&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&hilit=break but I'll remove it.
02:40:010 (1) - End on the white tick please Done

Angry Banana
Hey, could you make backgrounds like this for the other difficulties? Done
I lol'd hard at banana hell. Nice work dude. Haha thanks!

Contact me when you've fixed it and I'll see if we can arrange a pubble

Armin wrote:

Why I have to mod this >_>

[Crackers]

Overall: I can't see any error of spacing/timing/snapping and stacking, just some imperfections for the hitsounds: I think that the clap rythm is too low and repetitive. Also, delete the short breaks if you want.
Download the file .osu at the end of the post (It has just some hitsounds added)

[Nuts]

Overall: No major problems found. Just the hitsounds, the same things in the previous difficulty <_<'

00:08:586 (2) 1/6 back
00:30:281 (Break) Short break: consider to remove it
01:10:570 (1) This slider is a bit offscreen, consider to move it in another place

[Angry Banana]

Overall: Decrease the overall difficulty please and add more hitsounds.

01:33:246 (2) Divide the slider in other sliders (it has 5 repeats D:)
01:56:827 (2) 1/6 later
01:57:432 (2) 1/6 later
02:02:918 (3) 1/6 later
02:03:465 (1) 1/6 later
02:29:274 (3) 1/6 before
02:40:010 (1) 1/8 before (and then make it longer of another 1/8)

That's all,
starred!

Lissette wrote:

I'm popping the Pubble 'cuz i found some spacing, file size and snapping problems

Tags should be the same of all diff They are.
File size should not be larger than 10 MB with no video There was only a 90 kb difference D: Compressed MP3
The SB objects should not be larger than 640 x 480 Fixed

Crackers
01:17:341 (2) - i suggest to move one beat later and remove one repeat Changed

Nuts
00:07:323 (2) - move 1/6 later moved
01:17:341 (2) - i suggest to remove, and place a note here 01:17:508 changed
01:57:212 (3) - make it end at 01:57:432 and repeat changed
01:57:926 (4) - 1/6 earlier changed

Angry Banana
01:07:920 (5) - wrong spaced moved as to:

ouranhshc wrote:

Angry Bananas
02:18:756(5) - line up with (3)

*Sigh* OK
01:50:736 (5) - maybe remove? I kinda like it that way?
01:57:926 (4) - move 1/6 earlier Moved
01:59:465 (1,2,3) - put it like ^ Moved
02:07:258 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^ Moved
02:10:256 (9) - ^ Moved

Star

EDIT: 02:07:258 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - wrong spacing It's correct?
forgot to put the problem with that

Lybydose wrote:

Ok first of all, this timing seems odd. It is. All of these suggestions sound better (to me) when listening to them, but are snapped in such odd ways that it seems wrong. Before making any of these changes, listen to it yourself at a slower speed to see if it sounds better to you as well.

Crackers

00:30:226 (1) - I think this spinner sounds better if you end it on the next white tick instead Moved (I believe this was cut back a few pages ago since the space between spinner and notes is kinda short.)
00:40:446 (2) - End point of this sounds odd. I THINK it sounds better if you move the endpoint back to the white tick. Also part of the problem is that your really loud finish sound doesn't really fit here, and makes it sound off no matter what you do. Hitsound changed and slider moved back a bit. Hope this helps.
01:17:619 (3) - move this slider so that it's the same (on the timeline) as the one in this same position on Nuts Okay, moved

Nuts

00:46:545 (4) - The repeat on this slider sounds off, and should be 1/6 forward from where it is. However, if you extend the slider like that, the endpoint will sound wrong. You could remap it by making the slider end where the repeat is now instead of using the repeat. Changed as suggested - but slider is extended a bit
01:28:326 (3) - I think this sounds better if you end on 01:28:659 KK
01:29:935 (1,2,3) - move 1/6 forward Moved
01:57:226 (3) - Switch to 1/8 snap. Move this so that it begins at 1:57:266 and repeats at 01:57:473Moved
01:57:926 (4) - Move from wherever it was before to 1:57:926 Moved
02:20:609 (2) - I don't know where it was before, but use 1/6 snap at move to 2:20:609 Ok
02:28:565 (4) - extend by 1/6 Ok
02:29:219 (6,7) - move both forward 1/6 6 wasn't moved, but extended. 7 moved.
02:29:273 (6) - extend by 1/6 after moving it ^
02:32:326 (10) - move to 02:32:380 (1/6 forward) KK
02:38:102 (1,2) - forward 1/6 2 Moved
02:40:010 (1) - extend 1/6 Kk
03:00:604 (4) - forward 1/6 Adjusted repeat in 1/8 instead.

Angry

There are a lot of places where seem to be mapping notes at the same timeline spots as in Nuts, but you have different timing here. For example, 02:19:901 (1) is different from Nuts, where it's mapped at 02:19:955 (1). It sounds better in Nuts. Go through the entire map and compare what you've mapped here to what you've mapped in Nuts (after taking the suggestions above), and move stuff here to match up with Nuts accordingly. While you're at it, make sure everything matches up in Crackers as well. Should be fixed

Mafiamaster wrote:

Both Crackers/Nuts~
01:10:570 (1) - Extend to 01:10:843 using 1/6 divisor.
01:11:117 (2) - Extend to 01:11:335 ^

Angry Banana~
01:10:789 (1) - Move forward a 1/6 tick (01:10:843)

Lissette wrote:

Re-Pubble

DeathxShinigami wrote:

[Crackers]
00:57:111 (3) - New combo? I don't think it fits D:
01:26:162 (1) - Doesn't sound well to me Shifted

[Nuts]
Lol at misleading diff name. I thought this was going to be like Nexy's Nuts or something similar
02:06:714 (1) - Move below the (1) slider Kk

[Angry Banana]
I think slider tick rate of 1 is more suitable for this diff. Kk
O_O A bit crazy for me but I believe everything is looking good for this diff.

[Overall]
Just minor suggestions is all.

AgnesChan wrote:

Yo! I came to mod. Whee.

[Crackers]

No errors.

[Nuts]

No errors.

[Angry Banana]

01:58:043 (4,5) - Fix spacing? Fixed
02:01:553 (2,3) - ^ Isn't it fine?

Pretty awesome map. I really do hope it get ranked soon. Star'd!

Starrodkirby86 wrote:

Ring-ring-ring~

[Crackers]:
01:26:204 (1,2) - Shorten (1) by 1/6 by the end, and extend (2) by 1/6 from its starting point? I could care less about (1), I'm focused on (2). Fixed

[Nuts]:
00:25:446 (3) - Shorten this slider so it ends on the red tick before it? (25:940) Fixed

[Angry Banana]:
01:35:290 (4) - Note seems a bit late. Fixed

Angry Banana has a different Background Color than the other two difficulties. Mind making it a little difficulty consistent? It's noticeable in the Song Select Screen. Fixed

You may want to do a quick check in case if there's something shifty with the rhythm as like I aforementioned. Of course, if you're not already driven bananas by this song. XD Ok!

Starrodkirby86 wrote:

Ring ring ring ring ring ring ring

B-bubble phone ~

whymeman wrote:

Did something happen with the SB?

white.png isn't being used here.... http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/4936

Not going to pop the bubble [yet], but would like to know if this is really being used, or just taking up space.

Takuma wrote:

...Second, I think you should remove the fade out at the end - it's really unnecessary, especially since there's nothing really fading out in the song.

whymeman wrote:

Hmmmm, alright then. Ranked.

Derekku Chan wrote:

Why is hit100k the same as hit300k?

Derekku Chan wrote:

Thanks; also, the thumbnail is broken :X