forum

Yiruma & Skullee - River Flows In You (A Love Note)

posted
Total Posts
109
show more
Topic Starter
h3k1ru
after some talk with other BATs i decided to keep 140 bpm

the main reason is the fact of using 3.2 sv and 1\16 is just wrong and bug editor:


there no strict rule about doubled / halved bpm, but 70 bpm in this map ruin the mapping (editor) experience

thx for check those
those
If you want to play the "rule" card, there is a rule saying timing must be correct. Have these other BATs talk to me. Until then, I hope this doesn't get ranked.

Edit: I was told a wrong bpm wasn't a basis to pop a bubble, so I'm giving it back for now.
mm201
Quick incomplete mod, don't kudosu.

140BPM is fine
There are (effectively) silent hitsounds. Please never use a volume less than around 20%.
Please set tick 2 on all difficulties.
Cryo difficulty has really silly spacing. The overlapping 1/2s don't make any sense.
The sliders beginning on 1/8 ticks are very odd and don't make sense. You shouldn't sync an improvised "lyric", but instead base your mapping off the music's structure. It confuses the player when you follow stylizations in the music.
Quilt
go go :D
cRyo[iceeicee]

mm201 wrote:

Cryo difficulty has really silly spacing.
where
The overlapping 1/2s don't make any sense.
where
The sliders beginning on 1/8 ticks are very odd and don't make sense.
where
mm201

cRyo[iceeicee] wrote:

mm201 wrote:

Cryo difficulty has really silly spacing.
where
The overlapping 1/2s don't make any sense.
where
The sliders beginning on 1/8 ticks are very odd and don't make sense.
where
First two:

I think the other half spacings are probably fine.

Third: Your diff doesn't have as many of them as Aleks and h3k1ru's difficulties, but stacks like 00:16:933 (1) - could use an extra rebound.
cRyo[iceeicee]
00:41:147 (3,4,5,6) -
00:42:862 (3,4,5,6) -
00:44:576 (3,4,5,6) -
00:45:433 (7,8,9,10,1) -
00:47:147 (3,4,5,6) -
00:48:862 (3,4,5,6) -
00:50:576 (3,4,5,6) -
I dont see any problems with this antijumps, they fits well
Thanks for mod o.o
mm201
They all make sense but the last one. h3k1ru: I'll rebubble once you self-pop but I don't feel okay ranking this with the sudden nonsense spacing change at 0:52 in Cryo's diff.

Also IRC mod. I had to merge two different logs since I forgot to savelog >_<
SPOILER
09:21 <h3k1ru> hi mm, thx to looking at my map, will u continue with ur mod or
i can apply fixes now?
09:21 <h3k1ru> im agreed with tick rate 2, and 1/8 parts
09:23 <h3k1ru> but about cryo's sliders and spacing.. its too vague for me,
everything looks fine until u give an explanation what parts are
weird in ur opinion
09:29 <mm201> the half spacing parts don't feel right to me
09:30 <mm201> 00:51:005 (5,6,1,2) - these especially
09:30 <mm201> you break into double spacing with no change in the music
09:31 <h3k1ru> welp.. not me XD
09:31 <h3k1ru> but i will tell to cryo take a look at it
09:31 <mm201> the earlier ones are probably okay but stuff like this doesn't
make sense
13-06-23 08:31:26 h3k1ru: thanks
13-06-23 08:31:31 h3k1ru: I'll clarify this part
09:32 <h3k1ru> and about the sound
09:32 <h3k1ru> with less than 20% volume
09:32 <h3k1ru> i know its bug sometimes with low general volume
09:32 <h3k1ru> but the song sooo quiet
09:33 <mm201> also the spinners at the beginning feel forced to me
09:33 <mm201> that part of the music is quiet and doesn't suit a spinner
09:33 <mm201> it's a pause, not a buildup of energy
09:35 <h3k1ru> there was a solution with break, but i decided to stay with
spinners
09:35 <h3k1ru> if u look at this spinners in autoplay
09:35 <mm201> I think a break makes more sense
09:35 <h3k1ru> there score sound fits well
13-06-23 08:36:42 h3k1ru: 01:29:576 (1,2,3,4) - can you fix spacing here?
09:36 <h3k1ru> what diff
09:37 <mm201> highest one
13-06-23 08:37:15 h3k1ru: should be more like 01:32:576 (3,4) -
09:38 <h3k1ru> i think i can adjust it from 0.8x to 1.0x
09:38 <mm201> thanks
13-06-23 08:44:08 h3k1ru: 02:03:432 (3,4,5) - Aleks difficulty - has odd spacing
13-06-23 08:44:52 h3k1ru: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/827978 1.58 and 1.2, it stands out as wrong
09:45 <h3k1ru> okay i will take a look
13-06-23 08:45:53 h3k1ru: and you got my message about the sliders ending on 1/8s?
09:46 <h3k1ru> not the message but the post on forum
13-06-23 08:46:19 h3k1ru: yeah that's what I mean
09:46 <h3k1ru> yeah i will change it
13-06-23 08:46:39 h3k1ru: thanks
09:46 <h3k1ru> tbh i think the both solutions are good
09:47 <h3k1ru> but ur solution is more "playable"
09:47 <h3k1ru> i was thought about it before, its hard to choose
09:49 <h3k1ru> 02:03:861 (4) -
09:49 <h3k1ru> about this note on Aleks diff
09:49 <h3k1ru> the main point is he used it to stack with 02:02:575 (1) -
09:49 <h3k1ru> because 02:02:575 (1) - have 1.6x 1.6x
13-06-23 08:50:01 h3k1ru: be more clever~
13-06-23 08:50:14 h3k1ru: move (5) down, flip (6)
09:50 <h3k1ru> if move (4) to proper spacing
09:50 <h3k1ru> it will looks.. ugly?
09:50 <h3k1ru> :>
13-06-23 08:51:05 h3k1ru: like dis https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/827984
09:51 <h3k1ru> i got it
13-06-23 09:05:08 h3k1ru: I'll be back online in about an hour, call me for a rebubble
10:05 <h3k1ru> alright, thanks
Topic Starter
h3k1ru
updated, please check!

unfortunately cRyo refuse to make changes to that pattern
mancuso_JM_

mm201 wrote:

They all make sense but the last one. h3k1ru: I'll rebubble once you self-pop but I don't feel okay ranking this with the sudden nonsense spacing change at 0:52 in Cryo's diff.
I agree with mm in this case, hmm.. you should also have consistent with the next pre-chorus, I think an antijump between 00:51:433 (1,2,3,4,5) - works better and it is more consistent with the next pre-chorus since you used anti-jumps as well, just take that it mind please and give it a try.
I'd really like to see this changed, I think the other spacing changes are consistent and makes sense but this one it doesn't to me.
Btw, I'll probably check this map after to get the bubble.
mm201
The colours all look very different to me. I don't see why to be worried about them.

Aleks 00:33:272 (2) - I don't mind this but you may want to change it too for consistency's sake.
Aleks 02:04:290 (5) - I discovered that the spot with wonky spacing I got you to change was a paste from 01:05:147 (3) - which uses basically the same fix I recommended. I guess it was caught in an earlier mod? I think both instances ought to look identical (with a 180 flip).
Topic Starter
h3k1ru

mm201 wrote:

Aleks 00:33:272 (2) - I don't mind this but you may want to change it too for consistency's sake. wow i just missed that, was the way too sleepy, nice find mm ><b
Aleks 02:04:290 (5) - I discovered that the spot with wonky spacing I got you to change was a paste from 01:05:147 (3) - which uses basically the same fix I recommended. I guess it was caught in an earlier mod? I think both instances ought to look identical (with a 180 flip). yup, u r right, its the same now
i will throw this update 00:33:272 (2) with the next BAT mod, thx for recheck mm!

mancusojuanmattos wrote:

Btw, I'll probably check this map after to get the bubble.
thx mancuso!
Zero__wind
aha
I love this song
go and rank it~
dkun
I love this song! And an amaaaazing set to go along with it. :)

(I saw mm's mod but I didn't really find it really necessary. Map is good to go as-is imo!)
Satellite
Congratz~~ :D
Quilt
omedeto-
Laurier
omedeto
Lanturn
soooooooo amazing!!!! great job mapper and the guest diffs ;)
Heanday

Lanturn wrote:

soooooooo amazing!!!! great job mapper and the guest diffs ;)
pkhg
Yay~ Colorful post xD
I love piano songs <3 and this is really amazing.
Too beautiful storyboard, when i played it i was about to cry, I'm too sentimental.
Not everyday you see awesome mapsets like this, with awesome mapping and awesome SB.
I'll love this map forever <3

Also, congratzz :D
Zero__wind
yeah !
congratz
ryuu
поздравляю, хеки и алекс :3/
and congratulations icee-nyan and saten-san >w<
69653863
Oh, nice.
dkun
mapper requested an unrank

sorry for the lack of communication.
this should be really short and quick process!
ryuu
;_;
Nyquill
agh both my shoulders hurt now wtf
Gillwindy
why this become unranked?!
I down this map when noon and this map are ranked...
but when I play again in afternoon it become unranked......
what happened?
Dark_Ai

dkun wrote:

mapper requested an unrank

sorry for the lack of communication.
this should be really short and quick process!
this :P
Gillwindy

Dark_Ai wrote:

dkun wrote:

mapper requested an unrank

sorry for the lack of communication.
this should be really short and quick process!
this :P
Really thanks~
I have never meet this situation before. this really made me confused
Topic Starter
h3k1ru
there was some changes pending from the previous mods

im really sorry for it

the map will back to ranked soon, and its will be even better than before
-kevincela-
As there were just a few fixes, I guess this is once again ready to go!

Reranked!
Lanturn
That.. rerank >_<;
Topic Starter
h3k1ru
thx a lot dkun, Nyquill, -kevincela-

and thanks everyone for support~
wendao
congrats on rerank \:D/
ryuu
yay!

ryuu wrote:

поздравляю, хеки и алекс :3/
and congratulations icee-nyan and saten-san >w<
cRyo[iceeicee]
hryuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu >333333333<
Dark_Ai
congrats on re-ranked :3


EDIT:
OMG nice SB ;A; and this song makes me cry as well ;A; >.<
Gillwindy

h3k1ru wrote:

there was some changes pending from the previous mods

im really sorry for it

the map will back to ranked soon, and its will be even better than before

:3 I really love this map.
thx a lot to all of you
-Seren-
congrats!!! love this song so much
Konei
congratz~
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply