SPOILER

1. Spacing is very inconsistent. Just because this is a high-tier difficulty, spacing must not be ignored.
2. Try to avoid overlaps that don't look appealing. 00:32:076 (2,4) - 00:39:712 (2,4) - 00:40:803 (6,9) - these were just some examples.

Quiz-chan wrote:

Hey, from my Q~

[General]
Flawless.

[Easy]
wow, this diff is very linear...
But otherwise, it's fine ATM. Just one little thing:
01:24:076 (2) - Spacing issue.

But that's pretty much it.

[Normal]
This diff is quite hard for a Normal. Maybe you should make some parts a little easier, and besides, don't forget about design:
00:10:621 (1,2,3) - For example, this. The flow doesn't really promise much. Maybe re-arrange this?
And also, try to avoid as many overlaps as possible in easier difficulties.

00:22:985 (5) - New combo here.
00:34:621 (1,2,3) - Don't make (1) so narrow and compact. Rather expand it (placement-based). Also, re-shape the sliders so they make a great blanket pattern:

SPOILER

00:40:440 (4) - Definitely new combo.
00:41:530 (5,6,1) - Spacing inconsistency between (6) and (1).
00:43:349 (1,2,3) - (box)

SPOILER

1. 00:43:349 (1) - last node one grid up
2. 00:44:803 (3) - adjust last two nodes to make better blanket

00:53:349 (5,6) - Don't make the reverse arrow reach (6).
01:03:712 (1,2,3,4) - This is all narrow and overlapping. Re-arrange this, please.

[Hard]
AR -1

00:23:712 (3,4,5) - Spacing inconsistency.
00:44:803 (4) - Delete second node, it is just unnecessary.
00:47:712 (8,1) - Spacing issue.
01:20:985 (1) - Spinner ends offbeat. Please change that.

[Ixxm's]
Just some general tips:

1. Spacing is very inconsistent. Just because this is a high-tier difficulty, spacing must not be ignored.
2. Try to avoid overlaps that don't look appealing. 00:32:076 (2,4) - 00:39:712 (2,4) - 00:40:803 (6,9) - these were just some examples.

00:27:348 (8,9) - Whistle overusage here?
00:51:530 (1) - Remove NC here.

Stopped here. It's basically the two general aspects repeating over and over again. You should consider remapping this. If not, please re-arrange concerned patterns.

[Insane]
HPDR -1
AR -1
OD -1

00:05:894 (4,5,6) - Remove (5).
It doesn't follow any sound that is in the background or whatever. It is just redundant.
00:25:167 (7,1) - Serious spacing issue.
01:25:440 (1) - Silence this spinner.

Nice diff. I like it.

Good luck.

vahn10 wrote:

starred

xChippy wrote:

Quiz-chan wrote:

Hey, from my Q~

[General]
Flawless.

[Easy]
wow, this diff is very linear...
But otherwise, it's fine ATM. Just one little thing:
01:24:076 (2) - Spacing issue.

But that's pretty much it.

[Normal]
This diff is quite hard for a Normal. Maybe you should make some parts a little easier, and besides, don't forget about design:
00:10:621 (1,2,3) - For example, this. The flow doesn't really promise much. Maybe re-arrange this?
And also, try to avoid as many overlaps as possible in easier difficulties.

00:22:985 (5) - New combo here.
00:34:621 (1,2,3) - Don't make (1) so narrow and compact. Rather expand it (placement-based). Also, re-shape the sliders so they make a great blanket pattern:

SPOILER

00:40:440 (4) - Definitely new combo.
00:41:530 (5,6,1) - Spacing inconsistency between (6) and (1).
00:43:349 (1,2,3) - (box)

SPOILER

1. 00:43:349 (1) - last node one grid up
2. 00:44:803 (3) - adjust last two nodes to make better blanket

00:53:349 (5,6) - Don't make the reverse arrow reach (6).
01:03:712 (1,2,3,4) - This is all narrow and overlapping. Re-arrange this, please.

[Hard]
AR -1

00:23:712 (3,4,5) - Spacing inconsistency.
00:44:803 (4) - Delete second node, it is just unnecessary.
00:47:712 (8,1) - Spacing issue.
01:20:985 (1) - Spinner ends offbeat. Please change that.

[Ixxm's]
Just some general tips:

1. Spacing is very inconsistent. Just because this is a high-tier difficulty, spacing must not be ignored.
2. Try to avoid overlaps that don't look appealing. 00:32:076 (2,4) - 00:39:712 (2,4) - 00:40:803 (6,9) - these were just some examples.

00:27:348 (8,9) - Whistle overusage here?
00:51:530 (1) - Remove NC here.

Stopped here. It's basically the two general aspects repeating over and over again. You should consider remapping this. If not, please re-arrange concerned patterns.

[Insane]
HPDR -1
AR -1
OD -1

00:05:894 (4,5,6) - Remove (5).
It doesn't follow any sound that is in the background or whatever. It is just redundant.
00:25:167 (7,1) - Serious spacing issue.
01:25:440 (1) - Silence this spinner.

Nice diff. I like it.

Good luck.

Fixed all :3
Thanks for your mod !

Tsusuko wrote:

Star~

1. off Letterbox during breaks
2. your current offset is too early, set it as 456

1. 00:08:238 (1) - too soon after spinner, i'd not use the spinner for this Easy diff
2. 00:21:510 (3) - awkward, remove the arrow and make it as 2/1 slider
3. 00:24:420 (3) - ^ but this slider is ok with an arrow
4. 00:41:874 (3) - make it 2/1 slider
5. 00:43:329 - add a circle
6. 00:54:056 (1) - it should be end at 00:56:056 - , but that would make another problem. so i recommend to remove this spinner and add some notes instead
7. 01:05:874 (1) - no, it doesn't fit with the music at all
8. 01:23:147 (1) - too soon after spinner
9. 01:25:147 - maybe add 1/2 slider here, move the spinner to 01:25:510 -

1. 00:19:874 - ~ 00:30:238 - follow vocals, it's too boring
2. 00:41:510 (2) - stack on 00:39:692 (3) -
3. 00:43:329 - ~ 00:55:692 - remap this part, you could really make it better and better
4. 00:54:238 (1) - it should be end at 00:56:056 -

• sorry, remap these diffs if you really want to rank this map

Star Stream wrote:

From my queue

[General] Fixed

1. off Letterbox during breaks
2. your current offset is too early, set it as 456

[Easy] Fixed

1. 00:08:238 (1) - too soon after spinner, i'd not use the spinner for this Easy diff
2. 00:21:510 (3) - awkward, remove the arrow and make it as 2/1 slider
3. 00:24:420 (3) - ^ but this slider is ok with an arrow
4. 00:41:874 (3) - make it 2/1 slider
5. 00:43:329 - add a circle
6. 00:54:056 (1) - it should be end at 00:56:056 - , but that would make another problem. so i recommend to remove this spinner and add some notes instead
7. 01:05:874 (1) - no, it doesn't fit with the music at all
8. 01:23:147 (1) - too soon after spinner
9. 01:25:147 - maybe add 1/2 slider here, move the spinner to 01:25:510 -

I see only 1/2 sliders with an arrow, that was too boring. try to catch more dynamic beats

[Normal] Fixed

1. 00:19:874 - ~ 00:30:238 - follow vocals, it's too boring
2. 00:41:510 (2) - stack on 00:39:692 (3) -
3. 00:43:329 - ~ 00:55:692 - remap this part, you could really make it better and better
4. 00:54:238 (1) - it should be end at 00:56:056 -

[Hard,Insane,Ixxm's] Remapped parts of these difficults

• sorry, remap these diffs if you really want to rank this map

Good luck then

Verlaren wrote:

Hi~ From Aincrad's Modding queue~

Red: must be fixed
Blue: high recommended
black: suggestion

General:
add to title (Short ver.) Uuhm is it necessary? Because it already got TV size in the title


Easy:
AR -1, because 4 too fast for easy diff, fix it please.
00:03:365(1) - mahe this slider same as previous slider.
00:41:910(3) - add clap on slider's end
00:45:183(2) - ^
00:52:819 - add clap
01:04:819(4) - NC. Fix it! otherwise it will be difficult for beginners to restore the level of HP after blunders.
01:19:728(3) - add clap on sliders's end


Normal:
00:05:910(4) - make same as 00:04:637 (more symmetrical)
00:54:092(6) - maybe add finish. IMO
00:56:092 - add finish. you must add this finish
01:03:728(1) - spacing...use distance snap tool please!!

and good job - nice diff


Hard:
00:06:274(8) - move to x:359 y:348. That is more fun
00:44:546(4) - unsnapped slider! move to one tick back!!
00:46:274(8) - NC
00:48:819 - add note
00:57:365 - maybe add note?
01:03:910 - ^
01:17:365(2) - add one reverse
01:22:637 - add note.
01:23:001(1) - remove NC


Ixxm's:
AR -1 IMO
00:02:456(3) - make slider more symmetrical
00:36:637(2) - move to x:168 y:180 IMO it's better
00:41:728(7) - NC
00:56:183(6) - hidden reverse arrow. Fix it please!
01:07:637(5) - unsnapped pattern
01:25:274(5) - remove this note.
...and remove all bookmarks in this diff.


Insane:
AR -1 IMO it's better
CS -1 !
00:41:183(3) - make a symmetrical slider, same as 00:40:456(1)
01:17:365(2,3,4,5,6) - make a polygon circles. That is more fun and looks better.


Nice map and good luck

P.S. if something is not clear - ask me in game.

MineC24 wrote:

Modding queue~

Easy

00:13:546 (1,2,3) - how about this? -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/735532
(00:13:546 (1) - x:144 y:120 and 00:15:728 (3) - stack by 00:13:546 (1))
00:31:001 (3) - move -> x:272 y: 180
00:47:365 (5) - stack by 00:45:910 (3)
(and 00:45:910 (3) - stack grid)
01:00:092 (2) and 01:01:546 (1) - avoid these
01:07:728 (4) - avoid 01:07:001 (3)'s reverse?
01:09:183 (2,4) - avoid these

Normal

imo, AR - 1

00:03:365 (1) - Distance (keeping x1.0 spacing plz)
00:05:910 (4) - ^
00:35:728 (2,3) - Blanket these

Hard

00:04:092 (4) - how about this? -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/735547 (Blanket )
00:06:274 (8) - imo, NC here
00:11:728 (4) - this jump -> looks bad...
01:03:910 (1,2) - unstack by 01:04:456 (3) and change by slider
01:12:092 (2) - unstack by 01:11:728 (1) (because this stack -> little unfollow music..)

Ixxm's

Diff name change -> Ixxm's Insane

00:17:910 (11) - move -> x:184 y:268
00:19:910 - add note here (stack by 00:20:092 (1))
00:26:456 (2,3) - this jump -> looks bad... change this plz
00:37:365 (1,2) - Blanket plz
00:44:274 (2,4) - stack plz
00:49:910 (1) - 1/1 beat slider plz
00:53:546 (1) - stack by 00:52:819 (4)
00:59:001 (1,2) - Distance
01:06:819 (1,2,3,4,5) - note shape change -> Star
01:13:728 (2) - Distance (Close plz)
01:25:183 (4,5) - stack plz

Insane

imo, OD - 1

00:03:365 (1,2,3,4) - how about this? -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/735572
00:34:637 (1) - stack by 00:34:092 (4)
00:53:546 (8) - avoid 00:52:637 (7) plz (So Hidden...)
00:58:092 (7,8) - So confuse these... change by -> http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/735576
01:07:365 (3,4) - connection these
01:09:728 (7,8) - same as 00:58:092 (7,8)

GL

Yuki-kun wrote:

Hi~
From my queue.~

General

Nothing here except one: hitsound volume is a bit low. Try to raise it up.
Fixed
My Mod

[Insane]
Overall, this diff is good, but about hitsound, you almost used only clap, that's too boring. The part you used clap doesn't have whistle and same as whistle part - no clap. Try to use more. I'm pretty sure it will be better than.
OD - 1, your circle size 5 with OD 8 is hell. CS is 4 o_O
00:33:874 (3) - Stack with 00:33:147 (1) -
00:39:510 (2,3,4,5) - This seem so random. Make it better.
00:52:601 (7) - Make some jump instead of so many slider repeat. Also, you can add more note and start spinner at 00:54:056 - instead of 00:53:692 (1) -
00:57:874 (6) - NC.
00:58:601 (1) - Remove NC.
00:59:329 (3) - NC here.
01:09:510 (6) - NC.
01:10:237 (1) - Remove NC.
01:10:965 (4) - NC.
Fixed all
[Ixxm's]
00:25:874 (3) - Unsnapped slider (end).
Meh....Hitsound in this diff seem so random,especially last part. And also, if you want a fast slider, try to use high slider velocity. You changed slider speed too much and that's really annoying
Flow is good but i really don't like the way you use stack in this map.
Unecessary timing point:
00:07:420
00:16:783
00:48:420
01:03:513
01:13:692
01:19:692
01:25:510
01:28:420
Fixed

00:06:965 (4) - One grid to the left.
00:46:238 (1,2,3) - I don't see any reason in music to make 00:46:601 (3) - jump from 00:46:420 (2) -
01:08:056 (1) - Finish at start and clap at the end.
01:08:783 (3) - remove clap at the end
01:09:147 (4) - Clap here.
01:11:329 (4) - Clap at start.
01:18:420 (6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4) - No hitsound?
01:22:601 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - Random hitsound
Few things here we're already fixed
[Hard]
BPM is 165, and i don't think slider velocity 1.00 is good for a hard diff. Yes it is 165 o_O
Also, this diff try to avoid overuse Shift key. I mean, it's a bit straight and diagonal. Make it more free.

00:15:692 (5) - Overlap. I dont see overlapping O_o

[Normal]
Hitsound problem like the other diff.
00:07:692 (1,2,3,4) - Too hard for a normal diff.

[Easy]
Same problem with hitsound, pattern seem fine.
Good luck

Good luck~ <3

DakeDekaane wrote:

Hi there o/
Summoned because M4M :3

[General]
00:31:718 - Add an uninherited timing point (red line) here with the same BPM, just to adjust the metronome, It may happen that some green lines may unsnap by -1ms, check at least that the ones needed for kiai time are properly snapped after this. Resnap all your objects after this.

[Easy]
00:21:536 (3) - Making this a bit more curved would look nicer, remember fix the spacing after you do this, in case you do.
00:41:910 (3) - You can make this a curved slider, greatly improving the flow and make it nice to play for beginners.

SPOILER

00:44:092 (1) - Soften a bit the curve for these type of sliders, maybe like this.

SPOILER

00:46:274 (4,5) - Something similar as above.
01:00:456 (3,1,2,3,1) - All these repeat sliders may be a bit boring even in an Easy, try to make this part with more variety, maybe like this, of course if you decide to change, you can make your own pattern.
http://puu.sh/2NwUt.png
01:05:910 (2) - There's a strong beat in 01:06:456, you can do this and this will sound better in my opinion.


[Normal]
It seems this is a collab, put who made which parts in Creator's Words :p well we didnt kinda did it in parts :3
Why this diff has different claps than the other diffs? o3o
01:09:183 (2) - Maybe make this curve leads more to the next circle?
01:12:456 (3) - Make this curve a bit softer, in a way it looks similar to the previous slider, adding a nice look.

[Hard]
This diff uses the same Slider Velocity than Normal, I'd recommend incresing it a bit.
00:06:274 (1) - Maybe remove the NC here?
00:15:910 (8) - Remove clap in the end.
00:08:274 (3) - Stack this with 00:08:092 (2), it plays better in my opinion.
01:22:637 (1) - Unstack this, it's a bit confusing as it's after a spinner, or you could add a circle in 01:22:819, fitting very nice.

[Ixxm's Insane]
00:06:456 (4) - Remove the whistle in this slider and put it in each of its beats, select the circle in the slider until it becomes red and you put the whistle.
00:13:910 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - For this part you could use this hitsound pattern, put claps on every white tick, delete those claps in red ticks, it hears very spammy. Also, put a finish in the start of 00:16:456 (1).
00:19:092 (3,4) - Move both to the previous blue tick, after you do, fix the placement.
00:23:001 (2) - Remove the whistle in the body and put only in the sides.
00:24:456 (6) - ^
00:25:910 (1,3,5,6) - ^
00:28:456 (1,8) - ^
00:29:819 (7) - Delete this circle, the triple here is not expected.
00:31:728 (1) - Put a finish in te start
00:35:910 (5) - Put a whistle in the reverse, to keep consistency with your previous whistle in 00:34:637 (1)
00:31:728 - 00:47:728 - For all this part you could use a whistle every 3rd beat, like the one you used in 00:34:637 (1).
01:13:728 (2) - Make this a single circle, remember what I said about unexpected triples, this is one of them
01:14:546 (5) - Delete this too, same reason as above.
01:14:546 (5) - Make a circle instead.
01:16:000 (5) - Delete this.

[Insane]
00:19:910 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - To be honest, I find this quite boring as it's the same circular motion for all this part, please rearrange this part in a diferent way
00:52:183 (2,4,6) - This is a bit overmapped, please delete them.
01:04:910 (2,4) - As I said above, delete this.
01:07:365 (3,4) - I think these sliders could be better as 1/2 sliders.
01:10:910 (8) - Delete this.
01:13:819 (2) - ^
01:22:546 (4) - ^
01:24:728 - Add a circle here
01:24:910 (2,6) - And delete this two, by doing this and the one above, this would be a nice final for the map.

That'd be all from my part, good luck /o/

zorefire wrote:

[Easy]

Ok 00:49:182 add finish.

what's with those inherited timing point mumbo jumbo going on there. If your not doing anything special with it I suggest u remove them will decrease file size by like 0.56% percent xD. Well it's slowly decreasing the sound :3

P.S - I know it's a little tiny modd but I have nothing to really fix win people give me maps near perfect like that sorry.

Hehe its not near perfect though :3 but thanks anyway

AnimeStyle wrote:

From my modding queue


[General]

The map is a little bit to "straight" :< imp

Unsnapped Circles and Sliders at Normal Diff:
00:58:273 (2)
00:58:637 (3)
01:07:364 (3)
01:07:728 (4)

01:25:546 - In alomost every diff, this slider ends at an other time , pls let all end at 01:27:909
[Hard]

00:16:546 - Low the volume of this timing point to 5%
01:00:445 - Rotate this 23°, Clockwise, Selection centre
01:08:808 - Unsnapped
01:24:081 - ^
01:24:263 - ^

[Ixxm's Insane]

00:19:183 - Maybe delete this Slider, fits not imp

[Insane]

00:19:365 - Volume = 5%
01:01:536 - Rotate this 11° , Clockwise, Selection Centre

Defnitly the best diff ;P

Hitsounds are very well placed at this map :3
( Sry I'm bad at modding Insanes :/ ) , I'm better at modding Easy and Normal XD

0,0,"Yukitoki.jpg",1,1

0,0,"Yukitoki.jpg",0,0

XeVary wrote:

hi
Little suggestion
on insane
00:42:928 (9) - Try to put one here?

00:45:473 (7) - 00:50:382 (6) - 01:01:473 (6) - Here too
01:23:201 (1) - More that of the DS(Distance Snap) might be good
01:23:746 (4) - Let's reverse　:D

01:25:019 (3) - DS
on Ixxm's Insane
01:06:837 (1,2,1,2,1) -New Combo

I like this song　:D
do your best!

ritsu-tanaika wrote:

Hihi~

GENERAL: Good patterns and spacing. but some hitsounds need to be improved on, especially in hard

EASY

00:05:540 (3) - Change the audio here, lower it to 10% to finish it better before the slider. Fixed

00:47:382 (4,5) - Should be changed to one long slider. Its easy difficulty, so the long sliders would be more appropriate. Fixed

01:00:473 (3,1) - ^ I like it better this way :3

NORMAL

00:16:268 (7) - Please add finish sound

00:45:565 (5) - The circle note doesnt sound so approriate. consider changing it to a slider, then making 00:45:928 (6) - not bounce back



01:06:474 (4) - Without hitsounds, the circle isnt exactly appropriate for this part of the song. can be improved by adding Finish+Whistle hitsound

01:13:928 (1) - Distance spacing, should be X:324 y:100
Fixed all
HARD

00:06:269 (7) - This section should be changed to a spinner, to make the playing more smooth for players

00:22:655 (3) - A circle should be added after 00:21:564 (2) - to make the rhythm sound better

00:42:655 (5,6) - Finish/Clap hitsounds for emphasis on stacked circles

01:04:291 (3) - Try to make this slider more curvy, like this



01:20:473 (6) - Finish hitsound after the slider . Sounds weird to me :/
Fixed the rest.

Sorry but Im not good at mapping Insane difficulties so I only did 3. but i hope I helped~

Awaken wrote:

Here's my mod.

I am just a newbie in modding
Maybe my mod can't help you
I can only mod harder difficulty than "hard" sorry!

[Hard]
00:19:904 (1,2) - I always don't like this kind of flow http://puu.sh/2S17o.jpg fix
01:05:746 (1) - this spinner may be better to use slider to replace ^

[Ixxm's Insane]
01:13:564 (1,2,3) - jump or may read wrong Fix
01:15:019 (1,2,3) - ^ ^
00:18:450 (1,2,3,4) - I think you should add a note on 0:19:086Fix
01:06:473 (7,8,1,2,1,2) - the jump may be able to be more interesting http://puu.sh/2S0ZG.jpg no fix


[Insane]
00:03:360 (1,2,3,4,5) - how about changing this? http://puu.sh/2S00s.jpg fix
00:05:905 (4,5,6) - i think it's a little crowded. you can try jumping http://puu.sh/2S09p.jpg ^
00:52:109 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - I think this jump is more beautiful http://puu.sh/2S0ny.jpg Changed it but into something else
01:04:837 (1,2,3) - jump or may read wrong fix
01:23:201 (1,2,3,4) - try jumping http://puu.sh/2S0x7.jpg ^

TheVileOne wrote:

Mod

Easy
It's a very clean map. Only minor things to say.

00:10:631 (3) - Wrap more evenly around 4? That gap just looks ugly to me. Just in case you don't know the terminology, wrapping an object around another object is referred to as blanketing. I will refer to it as such.
00:34:655 (1,2) - Blanket around this should be more even. I fixed this by having the second point (of slider 2) at x 33 y 134, the last point is at x 58 y 193. I turned grid snap off to fix. Make sure to fix the spacing with 3 afterwards.
00:47:382 (4,5) - Blanket here?
00:52:110 (3) - Any particular reason why you didn't add a finish here? I think I know this answer. you're only using them every so many measures. This sound stood out from the other sounds in terms of tone though. Maybe consider having a finish here because of that.
01:00:473 (3) - I suggest having this look similar to 1.

01:05:928 (2) - Starts a bit too close to the body of 1 for my tastes. It would help if 01:05:201 (1) - and 01:07:382 (3) - were in the exact same position. 01:05:201 (1) - is at x 266 y 242 and 01:07:382 (3) - is at x 267 y 244. The easiest way to fix this is to move 1. This will make the gap a little better.

Normal

00:07:722 (1,2,3,4) - Straight sliders just don't give this part justice. I think you could create a more interesting pattern utilizing two repeat sliders or at the very least adding more curves.
00:20:110 (2,3,4) - I think this looks better as a blanket. What do you think?
00:27:383 (2,3,4,5) - These curves look sloppy to me. I think reducing the arc makes a nicer pattern in general. Here's an example. You don't really have to change it if you don't want to. The arc just seems out of place to me.
00:51:383 (4,5) - Too linear. Something like this makes more sense IMO.
00:59:383 (1) - Move lower and more under previous slider for a better alignment. I'm pretty sure you could fix the alignment without screwing with your patterns.
00:59:383 (1,2) - Too close/ spacing breaks pattern consistency.
01:10:292 (4,1,2,3,4,1) - Normally I would prefer patterns like these to be more consistent (similar slider shapes, spacings etc) But I rather like how 01:13:201 (4,1,2,3) - is executed. It makes up for the lack of consistency.
01:22:655 (1,2) - I think this could be a better pattern. I suggest placing the sliders in a more interesting way.

Hard
[Note] Chrome ate my first attempt at a mod for Hard. I apologize if this mod feels rushed. ask me if you have any questions.

Some parts of this difficulty felt randomly placed. It would be nice if this difficulty had elements that all fit together coherently and were based upon a common structure. There were parts that were just mapped very differently than other parts, sometimes unnecessarily so.

Kiai lacked finishes. the easier difficulties had more finishes than this difficulty has.

00:01:178 (3,4,5,6) - I think it would be better if you made the blanket perfect with 3,4 and then made a triangle pattern with the stack. http://puu.sh/2Sh3M.jpg
00:03:723 (3,4) - I think a perfect blanket here would look better. http://puu.sh/2Sh8N.jpg
00:05:904 - I suggest adding a note here. The gap between the next note throws me off the rhythm, which in turn makes the spinner uncomfortable to spin.
00:07:723 (1,2,3,4,5) - Are you happy with this pattern? It's probably not the best pattern, but it's not bad either. I could try to find a better one in a recheck if you want.
00:14:814 (4,5,6) - Stack leaning is messing with the spacing. You might want to manually space to fix it.
00:19:904 (1,2) - I don't like this blanket. It's imperfect and I think that the beat spread out is much more desirable to look at. consider forming it similarly to the next segment.
00:32:837 (3,4) - Weird pattern. How about something like this? http://puu.sh/2SizE.jpg
00:36:109 (3,4) - I did not expect this pattern to be angled. Could you try to make it so 3 doesn't angle upward as much?
00:42:655 (5,6,1) - Spacing is different and it shouldn't be. It's fine that you're using a higher distance snap, but make sure that the distance snap is the same spacing across the transition. (It isn't).
00:44:110 (3,4,5,6) - Randomly shaped pattern doesn't really fit considering that there are so many consistent patterns in this area.
00:47:438 - I'm not sure about this finish.
00:53:382 (2,3,4) - Is this spacing change intentional?
01:03:746 (2) - Looks bad curved in that direction. I recommend curving in the other direction and making a blanket with 01:02:837 (4) - Example http://puu.sh/2ShUR.jpg
01:05:746 (1) - The flatness of this doesn't complement the rest of the pattern IMO. Try adding more of a curve to wrap around the previous part.
01:22:655 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Just looks random to me. I think it could be a lot better.

Ixxm's Insane
I will need to be a better mood to more accurately mod this. There's a lot of senseless speed changes and some parts were so slow it was affecting my ability to play. The slowest parts of the Insane should not be the hardest parts.

00:02:450 (3) - Use a better curve. Use the new slider algorithm. It should look similar to 00:04:995 (3) -
00:20:110 (2) - Move last point to x 112 y 199. I think it looks better entering the note curve that way IMO.
00:29:564 (5) - The misalignment here is bad. You should fix this.
00:39:746 (2,3,4) - This would look so much better if the pattern after 2 was placed where 2 is pointing. http://puu.sh/2Sjnf.jpg
00:41:928 (2) - Looks to curve unnecessarily inward. If anything it should curve like this http://puu.sh/2SjrW.jpg
00:43:382 - This slowdown had terrible flow.
00:45:746 (4) - Use a better curve here?
00:52:110 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - A spam of annoying hitsounds >.< also the jumps are faster than the slider speed of the slider right before them. I find that very awkward.
00:54:110 (4) - I consider this abusing slider velocities. Slowing down like this doesn't make any sense here.
01:17:201 (4,1,2,3,4,5) - Annoying.
01:18:473 (6,7,8,9,1,2) - Speed changes are unreadable and do not make any sense.
01:19:382 (9) - I feel this should be a single note.

Insane
There's probably a lot more things to be naziid about in this. I covered a large portion of the issues though.

00:04:632 (2) - I suggest a curve similar to 00:04:086 (5) - .
00:14:086 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - It's weird that the slider shapes keep changing. I recommend making it more consistent, especially here 00:14:631 (4,5,6) - 00:15:177 (6,7,8) - could use a pattern change. It's not that interesting.
00:28:837 (1) - I feel this doesn't look great in relation to slider 7. I suggest blanketing around the edge of 7 for a better pattern. http://puu.sh/2SkvK.jpg
00:29:564 (3,1) - Doesn't look that good either. Not sure how to fix though.
00:34:655 (1,2,3) - Spacing looks like an error to me. (Make sure this whole combo has consistent spacing)
00:49:928 (4,5,6,7,8) - This pattern just screws me up. Sliders are so slow. >.< it just kills the flow. i'm pretty sure it's because of that triple. I highly recommend removing the middle note, and spacing out. It plays a lot better.
00:58:655 (5,6) - Too close.
01:00:110 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Structure is shaky here. I feel that the notes don't form a cohesive pattern, despite first appearing like they were going to. also 4 and 5,6,7 look randomly placed.
01:11:746 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Structure is a bit off here too, but not as much.


Conclusion

I don't want to star this with the GD is such a poor shape. I would be willing to recheck, but perhaps after a mod or two. I'd appreciate it if you would :3

_nara_ wrote:

hi, m4m from your queue.

[Easy]
00:07:722 insert break between this 00:16:450 bcs its easy diff, and youre gonna kill their hands o.O
-1 ar and hd?

[Normal]
00:06:268 spinner?
00:07:722 break between this? 00:16:450

[Hard]
well, this is a hard diff, so no break time isn't big case.
and so for other diff.

sorry for the short mod ^^ bcs your map was good.

Arrival wrote:

Okay let's go :

[Insane]
00:00:450 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - On all this pattern you use like 1/3 of all the playground, try to develop this part a bit better. I think this pattern is okay though
00:19:904 (1) - Here from a looooooooong part you use the SAME rythm again and again, it's just really boring after repeating 4 times the 1/1 Slider, circle, 1/1 slider. Please diversify this. Following the vocal..
00:34:655 (1) - Stack it with 00:34:109 (4) - fix
01:06:655 - Place a circle, here you are on a Downbeat (The big white tick) it's important to map this. It's important but it follows nothing

[Ixxm's Insane]
00:36:837 (3,1,2) - This doesn't look symmetric
00:39:019 (6) - Make a better blanket here
00:41:201 (6) - ^
00:51:564 (1) - Why is there a NC ? Timing or SV don't change.
00:52:110 (1) - What about this ? http://puu.sh/2TYkd.jpg + http://puu.sh/2TYld.jpg
01:00:473 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - Spacing inconsistence, you stay on the same rythm, and make jumps which don't have sense.
01:16:655 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - I advice the same kind of pattern as 00:52:110 (1) -

[Hard]
00:52:110 (1) - Lack of inspiration ? following vocal
Nice diff here, i just think you should use more the playground.

[Normal]
00:37:200 (4) - I suggest you to use something else than a Slider-reverse. Consider this. I like it this way :3
00:39:018 (2) - Stack it perfectly... use grid level 4 fix
01:02:292 (1) - 01:03:747 (1) - I find these two sliders too curvy, personal feeling. fixing
01:03:746 (1,2,3,4,1,2,1,2) - Like in the previous difficulty : You stay more than 5 seconds on the same 1/4 part of the playground..... fixing

[Easy]
01:09:564 (3,4,1) - Like this ? : http://puu.sh/2TYHU.jpg fix
Nice diff, except 01:07:382 (3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - where you map on the same 1/2 of the playground for like 10 seconds fixing

That's all :3 Good luck for your map !

Thunderstorm wrote:

Hey! You're welcomed by Thunderstorm's modding system v 220708000...2!

Some suggestions

[Overall]

Your custom claps sounds really off starting w/ [Hard]. Consider to recheck.
All incoming spinner suggestions is made for follow vocal part properly.

[Easy]
Don't know 'bout 00:00:450 (1) - and incoming kick-sliders. It can be tiring and confusing to play for newbs.
For example, you can 00:00:450 (1,2) remove repeats here, making it 00:00:450 - 00:01:177 length, remove 00:02:631 (3) - putting 1 note here instead.
And other like this. So your patterns will go just for vocal part.
Also, you can try to deal w/ same 1/1 kick-sliders some things, that will give an easy opportunity to being easy
If you want to keep it all, I'd still suggest to don't spam these sliders at least
I'll try to shorten my amount of these sliders :3
[Normal]
00:05:359 - I'd remove repeat of previous slider, remove incoming slider and make here a spinner to 00:07:359 Fixed
00:54:110 (7) - I'd delete it and start spinner from here, following vocal part I'd rather catch that loud bgm

[Hard]
00:16:450 (9) - I'd better start spinner here instead op putting a circle ^
00:54:473 (4) - cirlce instead of slider, start spinner at 00:54:655 Changed it but into something else
01:20:473 (6) - ^ -==- 01:20:837 I like it this way better :3

[Ixxm's Insane]
AR -1
00:03:359 (1) - any reason to make this jump THAT huge?
00:30:473 - Empty unmapped spaces w/ 7 HDR? Consider to put here something
01:20:291 (7) replace w/ circle, spinner 01:20:473 here
00:06:268 (1) - better start spinner here

[Insane]
00:53:928 - start spinner here Fixed


Other seems acceptable fine

azu-nyan14 wrote:

I love this song!

[General]

I think the timing is wrong, try this timing I found with the help of pimpG (thx again ^^):

SPOILER

440,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
10237,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
10600,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
13864,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
14984,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
20075,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
42612,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
43358,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
55017,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
56073,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
56449,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
61879,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
62267,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
65156,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
67621,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
68086,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
78420,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0
79722,363.636363636364,4,2,1,100,1,0

Fixed
I have a 2 better bg for you, use one of them if you want! ^^

SPOILER

I like the one I have more :3
In Insane GD have one inconsistency in combo colours, in all diffs except Insane GD Combo4 colour is 255,5,5 and in Insane GD Combo4 colour is 240,5,5.
Fixed
[Easy]

00:02:631 (3): Add whistle in start? Fix
00:05:540 (3): ^ in the end? ^
00:20:838 (2): Whistle in start and remove clap in the end? ^
00:21:565 (3): Maybe replace whistle for finish? ^
00:23:747 (2): Same as 00:20:838 ^
00:24:473 (3): Same as 00:21:565 ^
00:29:565 (2): Remove clap in the reverse? Also you can improve the flow here, like this: ^

SPOILER

http://puu.sh/2TDHm.jpg

00:43:019: Add a note? Feels empty without a one here imo. ^
01:01:564 (1,2,3): Maybe try this for better flow: fixed but into something else

SPOILER

01:12:110 (2,3,4): ^

SPOILER

01:16:473 (2,3,4,1,2,3): I think you sholud try this for better flow and rhythm: fixed

SPOILER

168,348,75382,2,0,L|261:348,2,80,2|8|2,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
110,290,76474,2,0,P|100:252|110:193,2,80,8|2|8,0:0|0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
188,268,77564,2,0,P|244:260|332:276,1,120
424,292,78655,6,0,L|464:208,1,80
488,144,79383,1,0,0:0:0:0:
440,80,79746,2,0,P|379:69|308:80,1,120

[Normal]

00:08:268 (2,3): This rhythm can confuse newbies when playing, turn (2) into a 2/2 slider. Well it has to be a little more challenging though :/
00:16:268 (7): Delete this note to make the diff more easier to beginners. ^
00:47:382 (1): I think the rhythm can be improved here, i would have make like this: sounds odd to me though :/

SPOILER

01:23:746 (3): Why not make this curved? fixed

[Hard]

00:05:504 (7,8): You can improve this rhythm moving (7) to to 00:05:722, after this add a 1/2 slider in 00:05:504 and keep the note in 00:06:268. sounds odd to me :/ (maybe i did it wrong)
00:09:359 (6,7,8): Make this to improve the flow: fixed

SPOILER

00:15:360 (6,7,8,9): ^ fixed

SPOILER

00:31:382: Add a note here? Looks empty imo and if you fix this, stack with 1 will be great fixed
00:42:655 (5): Unstack this note. ^
00:47:382 (2,3): Improve the rhythm moving (3) to 00:47:564 and add a note on 00:48:473.sounds odd to me :/ (maybe i did it wrong)
00:53:382 (2,3,4): ^ (2) to 00:50:200, after this make a 2/2 slider in 00:53:746. fixed

SPOILER

00:57:200 (2,3,4): ^ (2) to 00:57:019, after this make a 1/1 slider in 00:57:200 and a 2/2 slider in 00:57:746, and after make a 1/2 slider in 00:58:291.fixed

SPOILER

00:59:928: Add a note here? fixed

If you fix the suggestion above

Move (2 - 01:00:473) to 01:00:655, after add a note in 01:00:473. Make the same in 01:09:200 and 01:12:110.

[Insane]

00:10:268 (4): Consider unstack this note? fixed
00:12:813 (5): Turn this to a 1/4 slider with 3 repeats? Sounds bettter imo. ^

SPOILER

00:14:995 (5,6,7,8): Improve the flow here making this: fixed

SPOILER

301,209,14995,1,0,0:0:0:0:
220,152,15177,2,0,P|202:122|195:88,1,70
292,88,15540,2,0,P|317:63|332:32,2,70
316,184,16086,2,0,P|331:215|364:236,1,70

00:32:837 (3,4,5,6,1): Make this pattern more clean: didnt fix cuz the next jump would look odd

SPOILER

Well is a good map, but need more improvements imo. GL

Jemmmmy wrote:

easy
fine

NORMAL

normal
00:37:165 (4,1) - change rhythm CB and place to Fixed
00:50:813 (3,4) - change rhythm and place to didnt fix cuz it sounded off w/o the white tick
01:06:610 - add a circle didnt fix don't see a reason to put one here :3

hard
00:08:440 (4) - move middle anchor point to 440,316 and end anchor point to 380,332 didnt fixed cuz it's to sharp
00:08:803 (5) - move to324,348 fixed
00:31:711 (1) - move middle anchor point to 128,60 end's to 188,56 and distance snap 1,2,3 fixed
00:33:165 (4) - move to 260,248 ,middle achor point move to 308,280,end's to 372,276 fixed

Ixxm's Insane
00:18:620 (2,3,4,5) - change rhythm to . let 3,4,5,6 closer to 2 is better
00:39:711 (2) - move middle anchor point to 188,172 ,end's to 200,216(all this for beautiful)
00:51:539 (7) - move middle anchor point to 76,108 and end's to 104,180

insane
00:25:165 (7) - better same as 00:24:438 (5) - it's already the same but Control G-ed
01:07:337 (3,4) - move to 180,184 fixed
01:18:086 (6) - move to 168,280 fixed

Sun Rainbow wrote:

Mod Request from Clannad Modding Queue~

[Easy]
00:16:438 (1) - Delete Finish Fixed put whistle instead
00:20:074 (1) - ^ ^
00:22:985 (1) - ^ ^
00:25:893 (1) - ^ ^
00:30:985 (3) - ^ ^
00:28:802 (1) - ^ ^
00:45:539 (2) - Add Clap on Slider Start fixed
01:10:995 (1,3) - Don't overlap fixed
01:18:390 (1,3) - Add Clap on Slider Start fixed

[Normal]
00:12:054 (2) - Delete Clap
00:13:894 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - Why Don't add clap?
00:20:075 (2) - Delete Finish
00:34:257 (4) - X:252 Y:156
00:37:165 (4) - Add Clap
00:52:085 (5) - Clap on Slider End
01:07:711 (3,2) - Stack
01:09:903 (3,2) - Slider Arrow Stack 01:09:903 (3) -
all fix
[Hard]
00:00:439 (1) - Delete Finish and add whistle
And volume--->50%
00:20:074 (2,1,1,6) - Delete Finish
00:42:075 (4) - red line--->normal hitsound
01:06:792 (2,3,4) - Normal Hitsound
01:13:541 (4) - Clap
01:16:449 (4,2) - Don't Overlap
all fix

[Insane]
So Lazy zzz....
Sorry
for
My
English is Bad
And I can't
Mod
YouR
Insame QAQ

OEvil wrote:

[Hey, From Quene ]

[All Difficulties]

Tags
- Consider adding "Ixxm" to all of your tags

Timing Sections
Inconsistency in uninherited (red) timing sections, All The Timing Sections Must Be the Same At All Difficulties:
Huh it's same at all difficulties o-o?
- [Easy]
Red timing sections at:
- 00:00:440, BPM of 165.000
- 00:10:237, BPM of 165.000
- 00:10:600, BPM of 165.000
- 00:13:894, BPM of 165.000
- 00:14:984, BPM of 165.000
- 00:20:075, BPM of 165.000
- 00:42:612, BPM of 165.000
- 00:43:358, BPM of 165.000
- 00:55:017, BPM of 165.000
- 00:56:073, BPM of 165.000
- 00:56:449, BPM of 165.000
- 01:01:879, BPM of 165.000
- 01:02:267, BPM of 165.000
- 01:05:156, BPM of 165.000
- 01:07:621, BPM of 165.000
- 01:08:086, BPM of 165.000
- 01:18:420, BPM of 165.000
- 01:19:722, BPM of 165.000

- [Hard]
Red timing sections at:
- 00:00:450, BPM of 165.000
- 00:20:110, BPM of 165.000

- [Insane]
Red timing sections at:
- 00:00:450, BPM of 165.000
- 00:20:110, BPM of 165.000

- [Ixxm's Insane]
Red timing sections at:
- 00:00:440, BPM of 165.000
- 00:10:237, BPM of 165.000
- 00:10:600, BPM of 165.000
- 00:13:894, BPM of 165.000
- 00:14:984, BPM of 165.000
- 00:20:075, BPM of 165.000
- 00:42:612, BPM of 165.000
- 00:43:358, BPM of 165.000
- 00:55:017, BPM of 165.000
- 00:56:073, BPM of 165.000
- 00:56:449, BPM of 165.000
- 01:01:879, BPM of 165.000
- 01:02:267, BPM of 165.000
- 01:05:156, BPM of 165.000
- 01:07:621, BPM of 165.000
- 01:08:086, BPM of 165.000
- 01:18:420, BPM of 165.000
- 01:19:722, BPM of 165.000

- [Normal]
Red timing sections at:
- 00:00:440, BPM of 165.000
- 00:10:600, BPM of 165.000
- 00:20:110, BPM of 165.000
- 00:43:358, BPM of 165.000
- 00:55:017, BPM of 165.000
- 00:56:073, BPM of 165.000
- 00:56:449, BPM of 165.000
- 01:02:267, BPM of 165.000
- 01:08:086, BPM of 165.000
- 01:18:420, BPM of 165.000
- 01:19:722, BPM of 165.000

[Easy]

Spinner New Combo
- 00:57:176 (2) - Consider adding a NC here, since this note follows a spinner.

fixed
[Hard]

Good Diff

[Insane]

Nice Diff

Spinner New Combo
00:19:904 (2) - Consider adding a NC here, since this note follows a spinner.

fixed
[Ixxm's Insane]

Nice Diff

Spinner New Combo
00:48:995 (2) - Consider adding a NC here, since this note follows a spinner.

it isn't following a spinner o-o
[Normal]

Nice Diff
- 00:05:894 (4) - Remove this circle. removed
- 00:05:530 - Add a spinner from here until 00:07:349, with a finish.

I'd rather follow the piano

AsprikaQ wrote:

Hi, all suggestion (for M4M from your queue)

[General]

Why you no use Yui BG Some notes are being placed in some weird position. Hard to say.

[Insane]

00:16:438 (1) - Add note and start spin at 00:16:620 (1) - started it at the blue tick
00:16:620 (1) - Personally, I would say remove this and add notes and sliders is better choice I rather keep this spinner here :/
00:41:893 (5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - Good hitsounds used!
00:42:256 (6) - Add clap Sounds a bit messy to me though ><
00:42:793 (9) - ^ ^
00:42:975 (11) - ^ for both head and tail ^
00:44:085 (2) - Clap to head
00:47:721 (5) - Change Finish to Clap at tail
00:49:176 (3) - Finish at head
00:52:084 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Add some hitsounds maybe nice
01:19:722 (1) - Remove spinner and add some notes and sliders as you want please Keeping the spinner here :/
01:25:449 (1) - Change Finish to Whistle is better and also make it start at same time (01:25:540) like other diffs please
fixed the rest
[Hard]

00:05:894 (7,8) - I don't think stacking these is a good idea
00:23:711 (3) - Change to Finish at tail
00:46:267 (1) - Finish at head
01:05:701 (1) - Whistle at reverse
01:19:722 (4) - Finish
01:25:540 (1) - Change Finish to Whistle is better
fixed all
[Normal]

00:09:894 (5) - Remove Clap
00:10:237 (6) - Why it suddenly become so loud..
00:10:600 (1) to 00:12:054 (2) - - ^
00:16:438 (1) - Not recommended spinner right after in Normal & Easy diff. I rather keep itlike this :3
00:38:983 (3) - Don't stack with same pattern please
00:44:630 (4) - Remove overall Whistle
00:49:904 (1) - Clap at head
00:53:358 (6) - Remove and place note at each white line sounds better Following the vocal here though :0
01:23:176 (2) - Finish at head
01:23:722 (3) - ^
01:25:540 (1) - Change Finish to Whistle is better
fixed the rest
[Easy]

Everything perfect! but only

01:25:540 (1) - Change Finish to Whistle is better
fixed
That's all GL HF GG WP from Germany

1. From what i understand the Normal diff is a collab right? if yes add Collab to tags,and maybenotice us witha SB the parts o3o

1. 01:01:539 (1) - Unsnapped slider end
2. 00:54:085 (1) - spinner end is not right snapped
   
   Unsnapped inherited sections at:
3. 00:10:440 - snap to 00:10:418
4. 00:18:963 - snap to 00:18:984
5. 00:31:746 - snap to 00:31:711
6. 01:07:883 - snap to 01:07:893

1. 00:21:529 (3,1) - look good the spacing here,is like a jump òwò
2. 00:27:347 (2,1) - this 2 objects are a bit near to each other
3. 01:10:995 (1) - the next slider is a bit far

1. 01:03:721 (4) - about this circle,also you can do a btter blanket with the next slider,and personally i don't like really much the overlap with 01:05:156 (1) -
2. 01:13:176 (3) - can be stacked with 01:10:631 (4) -
3. 01:19:329 (2,3) - you can do a better blanket here
4. 01:25:176 (3) - do it like this : / for improving the flow and the ugly slider
   
   SPOILER

   

1. 00:13:540 (1) - Unsnapped circle.
2. 01:01:175 (3) - Unsnapped slider end

1. 00:22:984 (1) - the next and the prev objectmake with this circle a double jump,you should fix the spacing here
2. 00:30:984 (7,1) - again :V try to don't use jumps in normal easy diffs
3. 00:37:529 (1,2) - same again about the wrong spacing

1. 00:05:530 - start spinner here
2. 00:07:712 (1,2,3,4) - this patten looks a bit hard for a normal imo why don't you try to make it a bit simpler?
3. 00:31:711 (1,2,3) - i think this pattern will flow better if you make it symmetrical
4. 00:44:630 (4) - remove whistle from slider body
5. 00:50:448 (2,3) - try a simpler rhythm like this:
   
6. 01:18:420 (1,2) - place itlike this for improving a bit the flow
   
   SPOILER

   
7. 01:24:449 (4) - the clap on slider end sounds weird

1. 00:23:505 (2) - Unsnapped circle.
2. 00:26:415 (2) - Unsnapped circle.

1. 00:55:177 (4) - Unsnapped slider (start).
2. 00:55:177 (4) - Unsnapped slider (end).
3. 00:55:540 (5) - Unsnapped slider (start).
4. 00:55:540 (5) - Unsnapped slider (repeat).
5. 00:55:540 (5) - Unsnapped slider (end).
6. 01:04:994 (1) - Unsnapped slider (end).
7. 01:07:316 (2) - Unsnapped circle.
8. 01:19:692 (5) - Unsnapped slider (end).
9. 00:48:995 - add NC here, since this note follows a spinner.

1. 00:10:258 (4) - Unsnapped circle.
2. 01:01:539 (7) - Unsnapped slider (end).
   
   Unsnapped inherited sections at:
3. 01:22:291 - snap to 01:22:267
4. 01:25:928 - snap to 01:25:903
5. 01:26:655 - snap to 01:26:631
6. 01:27:382 - snap to 01:27:358
7. 01:27:746 - snap to 01:27:722

Lally wrote:

hi o3o reqfrom my queue

[General]

1. From what i understand the Normal diff is a collab right? if yes add Collab to tags,and maybenotice us witha SB the parts o3o

Well we didn't really did it in parts ><
[Easy]
Snapping

1. 01:01:539 (1) - Unsnapped slider end
2. 00:54:085 (1) - spinner end is not right snapped
   
   Unsnapped inherited sections at:
3. 00:10:440 - snap to 00:10:418
4. 00:18:963 - snap to 00:18:984
5. 00:31:746 - snap to 00:31:711
6. 01:07:883 - snap to 01:07:893

Spacing:

1. 00:21:529 (3,1) - look good the spacing here,is like a jump òwò
2. 00:27:347 (2,1) - this 2 objects are a bit near to each other
3. 01:10:995 (1) - the next slider is a bit far

Placement:

1. 01:03:721 (4) - about this circle,also you can do a btter blanket with the next slider,and personally i don't like really much the overlap with 01:05:156 (1) -
2. 01:13:176 (3) - can be stacked with 01:10:631 (4) - alot of people complain about stacking in easy :/ so I rather keep it like this :3
3. 01:19:329 (2,3) - you can do a better blanket here
4. 01:25:176 (3) - do it like this : / for improving the flow and the ugly slider
   
   SPOILER

   

fixed the rest :3
[Normal]
Snapping:

1. 00:13:540 (1) - Unsnapped circle.
2. 01:01:175 (3) - Unsnapped slider end

Spacing:

1. 00:22:984 (1) - the next and the prev objectmake with this circle a double jump,you should fix the spacing here
2. 00:30:984 (7,1) - again :V try to don't use jumps in normal easy diffs
3. 00:37:529 (1,2) - same again about the wrong spacing

Placement:

1. 00:05:530 - start spinner here
2. 00:07:712 (1,2,3,4) - this patten looks a bit hard for a normal imo why don't you try to make it a bit simpler? No idea how to make simpler ><
3. 00:31:711 (1,2,3) - i think this pattern will flow better if you make it symmetrical
4. 00:44:630 (4) - remove whistle from slider body
5. 00:50:448 (2,3) - try a simpler rhythm like this:
   
6. 01:18:420 (1,2) - place itlike this for improving a bit the flow
   
   SPOILER

   
7. 01:24:449 (4) - the clap on slider end sounds weird

fixed the rest
[Hard]

1. 00:23:505 (2) - Unsnapped circle.
2. 00:26:415 (2) - Unsnapped circle.

fixed

[Insane]

1. 00:10:258 (4) - Unsnapped circle.
2. 01:01:539 (7) - Unsnapped slider (end).
   
   Unsnapped inherited sections at:
3. 01:22:291 - snap to 01:22:267
4. 01:25:928 - snap to 01:25:903
5. 01:26:655 - snap to 01:26:631
6. 01:27:382 - snap to 01:27:358
7. 01:27:746 - snap to 01:27:722

fixed all :3

Hope it can help good luck o3o

ZLOdeuka- wrote:

hello, my dear. mod at your request.

[General]

propose a new time for KiAi:
Hmm will consider ^^
00:56:449 (1) - start
01:06:428 (5) - finish
01:08:086 (1) - start
01:18:420 (1) - finish


[Easy]

00:05:530 (3) - whistle
00:10:600 (4) - new combo
00:13:894 (1) - whistle
00:14:984 (2) - ^
00:15:711 (3) - ^
00:16:073 (3) - remove whistle
00:41:893 (3) 00:42:612 (4,5,6) - whistle
00:46:267 (3,4,5) - http://puu.sh/33BCA.jpg I think this will sound better Sounds odd te me though :/, so no fix ><
fixed the rest =w=
[Hormal]

00:46:812 (x) - add note
00:50:994 (3) - remove note
00:51:176 (x) - add note
01:24:449 (4) - new combo fixed
further no change ><
[Hard]

00:16:438 (1) - remove new combo and align under 00:16:256
00:21:347 (1) - remove new combo
00:27:347 (1) - ^
00:28:802 (4) - new combo
00:58:994 (7,8) - this is bad... propose to do so. it slider 00:58:903 (7) - move here 00:59:358 (7) - and remove return.
00:58:994 (x) - add note . 00:59:358 (8) - new combo. 01:00:085 (1) - delete new combo
01:05:156 (6) - new combo and 01:05:701 (1) - delete new combo
01:06:792 (2) - new combo
01:10:631 (5) - move here 01:10:995 (5) - and delete return. 01:10:631 (5) - add note (01:10:995 (6) - new combo.01:11:721 (1) - delete new combo )
fixed all :3

eveless wrote:

• [General]

1. I’m worried about the timing, maybe try to ask Charles445 or lks to give you a correct one.

Ill ask one of them ^^

• [Insane]

1. 00:00:439 (1) – Maybe it’s just me but the volume is really too loud…
2. 00:02:985 (4) – It sounds good if you can add whistile in the beginning~
3. 00:16:438 (9) – missing a gong here, add finish please~
4. 00:29:347 (2) – nazi spacing stuff
5. 00:31:529 (1) – well how about try this to emphasize the 00:31:711‘s downbeat?
   SPOILER

   
6. 00:43:358 (1) – looks ugly if you do it like this, I think all the slow down stuff are start at this note so make a normal spacing here will be better. (that means you should use 1.86x cause the speed was changed.)
7. 00:48:994 (1,2,3) – Flows better if you can try sth like this~
   SPOILER

   
8. 00:49:903 (4,5,6) – everything is straight make me confusing, I’d like to make a change at ordinate like this.
   
   SPOILER

   
9. 01:00:085 (1) – Does this new combo really necessary? It doesn’t make any sense at all imo.

• [Hard]

1. 00:15:711 (7) – nazi spacing.
2. 00:22:984 (1) – how about remove these finish stuff, they’re very annoying in such a quiet part.
3. 01:17:358 (3) – missing a finish in the end.

• [Normal]

1. 00:07:712 (1) – use finish instead of clap will be better, hear it at 25% rate if you can.
2. 00:45:540 (5) – Flows better if you can move it a bit down.
3. 00:56:449 (1) – I think there should be finish but not whistle cuz the hitsound is gong.

• [Easy]

1. 01:17:540 (4) – missing a finish in the end

Xinely wrote:

ohai~
from m4m in my queue

[General]
why add "collab" in tags? i don't see any diff with collaboration

[Easy]
00:43:358 (6,1) - swap NC?
00:47:358 (4) - NC for consistency
01:03:721 (5) - NC
01:19:722 (3) - whistle in end?
all fix
[Normal]
00:01:712 (3) - x:248 y:64. don't stack it.. hard to read for newbie
00:04:621 (3) - x:140 y:92. same as above
00:05:530 (1) - end in 00:07:712 - please. and remove 00:07:712 (1) - . give little break after spin I'll consider if more people suggest this :3
00:10:237 (6) - spacing issue (1,06x)
00:19:893 (1) - remove? give break after spin.. and not stack.. better if remove imo I'll consider if more people suggest this :3
00:28:802 (4) - NC for consistency
00:43:721 (2) - spacing issue (0,94x)
00:46:267 (6) - NC for consistency
00:52:085 (5) - NC
01:03:721 (1) - why NC?
fixed the rest
[Hard]
00:06:258 (8) - NC
00:16:438 (9) - ^
00:24:984 (4) - spacing issue
00:30:256 (3) - use normal spacing better
00:31:347 (5) - ^
00:59:903 (2) - spacing issue
01:05:701 (2) - ^
01:08:631 - add note?
01:11:540 - ^
fixed all
can't mod insane.. but insane nice imo Thanks~! :3

Good luck

1. 00:05:894 (4,5) - place (4) at normal distance, and (5) jump, i think is better flow~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791140
2. 00:15:529 (7) - suggest jump the slider here~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791141
3. 00:22:984 (1,3) - make 1 and 3 symmetrical ww http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791143
4. 00:44:449 (3) - being too close to (2) makes it weird; try this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791147
5. 00:47:721 (5) - same as above; http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791150
6. 00:49:176 (3) - move left about 2 grids, stream not even wwwww

1. 00:05:894 (4,5) - x:268 y:100 i think good flow www
2. 00:13:894 (1,2,3) - looks too close ww http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791152
3. 00:17:710 (9) - move this to x:208 y:220, note (10) to x:188 y:240
4. 00:19:075 (3) - remove this note.. o.o
5. 00:42:438 (3,4) - this is too close.. move it up at least 5grids
6. 01:07:155 (1) - remove new combo o.o since it's a star formation, you should only add combo at 01:07:711 (2) -
7. 01:20:267 (9) - x:308 y:232

1. 00:04:076 (4) - move the sliderpoint in the middle 1 grid outside to make slider blanket ww
2. 01:15:359 (2) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791157
3. 01:24:813 (8) - flip bottom, i think it's good flow~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791158

1. 00:15:711 (6,7) - this is too straight; suggest http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791159
2. 00:36:075 (3) - x:344 y:124 blanketing is off :3

1. 00:08:258 (1) - you could as well make a blanket~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791163

bokito wrote:

Hi~from your modding queue
Maybe I can not help you with my Mod
[Insane]
00:47:358 (4) - remove finish I feel so strange fixed
00:59:357 (1) - add finish is star In here have strong voice don't think it's neccessary, I'd rather keep the whistle
01:10:268 (5) - add finish in star ^

[Hard]
fine

[Normal]
00:01:530 (2,3) - x192 y72 I'd rather avoid stacking here

[Easy]
01:10:995 (1) - star add finish fixed
01:17:540 (4,1) - It have little overlapping Can't avoid this overlap, or else it would break the spacing
Good luck

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

for m4m~


Insane

1. 00:05:894 (4,5) - place (4) at normal distance, and (5) jump, i think is better flow~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791140
2. 00:15:529 (7) - suggest jump the slider here~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791141
3. 00:22:984 (1,3) - make 1 and 3 symmetrical ww http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791143
4. 00:44:449 (3) - being too close to (2) makes it weird; try this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791147
5. 00:47:721 (5) - same as above; http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791150
6. 00:49:176 (3) - move left about 2 grids, stream not even wwwww

Ixxm's Insane

1. 00:05:894 (4,5) - x:268 y:100 i think good flow www
2. 00:13:894 (1,2,3) - looks too close ww http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791152
3. 00:17:710 (9) - move this to x:208 y:220, note (10) to x:188 y:240
4. 00:19:075 (3) - remove this note.. o.o
5. 00:42:438 (3,4) - this is too close.. move it up at least 5grids
6. 01:07:155 (1) - remove new combo o.o since it's a star formation, you should only add combo at 01:07:711 (2) -
7. 01:20:267 (9) - x:308 y:232

Hard

1. 00:04:076 (4) - move the sliderpoint in the middle 1 grid outside to make slider blanket ww
2. 01:15:359 (2) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791157
3. 01:24:813 (8) - flip bottom, i think it's good flow~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791158

Normal

1. 00:15:711 (6,7) - this is too straight; suggest http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791159
2. 00:36:075 (3) - x:344 y:124 blanketing is off :3

Easy

1. 00:08:258 (1) - you could as well make a blanket~ http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/791163

:3

1. 00:20:074 (1,2,3) - Something like that to make flow less..linear? http://puu.sh/387Gm.jpg
2. 00:51:358 (2,3) - ^ http://puu.sh/387Lx.jpg
3. 01:17:540 (4,1) - Check spacing between them, they touch themselves, remove distance snap and increase the distance :3

1. 00:07:712 (1,2,3,4) - Not intuitive at all. Try a rhythm like http://puu.sh/3889H.jpg maybe?
2. 00:28:074 (3) - Why don't you make a 1/2 slider instead of beat?
3. 00:29:529 (2) - ^
4. 00:45:540 (5) - Why linear slider ;_; make it curvy like 00:44:630 (4) - but upside down
5. 00:49:903 (1,2,3,4) - I have an idea for a better rhythm: http://puu.sh/3885O.jpg less complicated :3
6. 01:02:266 (1,2) - I wish they could have the same shape
7. 01:03:721 (3,4) - ^
8. 01:06:792 (1) - Move second slider point to x:240 y.:88, much better
9. 01:22:631 (1,2,3,1,2) - Bad to see and play, my suggestion: http://puu.sh/3880e.jpg

1. 00:28:802 (1) - This slider can have a better shape
2. 01:16:631 (1) - Rotate 45° clockwise?
3. 01:17:358 (3) - Why linear slider here ;_;

1. 00:25:165 (8) - CTRL+J
2. 00:33:711 (2,1,2,3) - Do a better blanket? http://puu.sh/388jX.jpg
3. 00:54:995 (1,2,3,4) - I dislike this vertical pattern, but that's okay, meh
4. 00:57:358 (4) - CTRL+G it :3
5. 01:06:792 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - Delete all this NCs aaah, they are so useless
6. 01:18:420 (1) - Stack on 01:18:086 (5) - (if yes, fix next spacing)

1. 00:28:802 (1,2,3) - Do a better blanket
   I suggest using less linear sliders next time, they could ruin flow.

Leader wrote:

Hi, from my Modding Queue

[Easy]

1. 00:20:074 (1,2,3) - Something like that to make flow less..linear? http://puu.sh/387Gm.jpg
2. 00:51:358 (2,3) - ^ http://puu.sh/387Lx.jpg
3. 01:17:540 (4,1) - Check spacing between them, they touch themselves, remove distance snap and increase the distance :3

All fix
[Normal]

1. 00:07:712 (1,2,3,4) - Not intuitive at all. Try a rhythm like http://puu.sh/3889H.jpg maybe?
2. 00:28:074 (3) - Why don't you make a 1/2 slider instead of beat? I'll consider ><
3. 00:29:529 (2) - ^ ^
4. 00:45:540 (5) - Why linear slider ;_; make it curvy like 00:44:630 (4) - but upside down
5. 00:49:903 (1,2,3,4) - I have an idea for a better rhythm: http://puu.sh/3885O.jpg less complicated :3
6. 01:02:266 (1,2) - I wish they could have the same shape
7. 01:03:721 (3,4) - ^
8. 01:06:792 (1) - Move second slider point to x:240 y.:88, much better
9. 01:22:631 (1,2,3,1,2) - Bad to see and play, my suggestion: http://puu.sh/3880e.jpg

fixed the rest
[Hard]

1. 00:28:802 (1) - This slider can have a better shape
2. 01:16:631 (1) - Rotate 45° clockwise?
3. 01:17:358 (3) - Why linear slider here ;_;

fixed all
[Insane]

1. 00:28:802 (1,2,3) - Do a better blanket
   I suggest using less linear sliders next time, they could ruin flow.

fixed all
Good luck~

Kuria wrote:

nice mapset, hope this can rank soon

[TimingPoints]
445,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
4821,362.537764350453,4,2,1,50,1,0
6271,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
7725,361.44578313253,4,2,1,50,1,0
12063,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
20087,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
24463,358.208955223881,4,2,1,50,1,0
25895,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
30271,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
34634,362.537764350453,4,2,1,50,1,0
43334,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
52089,359.281437125748,4,2,1,50,1,0
53526,365.853658536585,4,2,1,50,1,0
54989,387.096774193548,4,2,1,50,1,0
55376,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
55739,333.333333333333,4,2,1,50,1,0
56072,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
56435,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
59352,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
62261,362.537764350453,4,2,1,50,1,0
65161,361.44578313253,4,2,1,50,1,0
66606,364.188163884674,4,2,1,50,1,0
76803,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
81166,359.281437125748,4,2,1,50,1,0
82603,365.853658536585,4,2,1,50,1,0

Charles445 wrote:

Gave timing a shot

[TimingPoints]
445,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
4821,362.537764350453,4,2,1,50,1,0
6271,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
7725,361.44578313253,4,2,1,50,1,0
12063,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
20087,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
24463,358.208955223881,4,2,1,50,1,0
25895,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
30271,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
34634,362.537764350453,4,2,1,50,1,0
43334,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
52089,359.281437125748,4,2,1,50,1,0
53526,365.853658536585,4,2,1,50,1,0
54989,387.096774193548,4,2,1,50,1,0
55376,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
55739,333.333333333333,4,2,1,50,1,0
56072,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
56435,364.741641337386,4,2,1,50,1,0
59352,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
62261,362.537764350453,4,2,1,50,1,0
65161,361.44578313253,4,2,1,50,1,0
66606,364.188163884674,4,2,1,50,1,0
76803,363.636363636364,4,2,1,50,1,0
81166,359.281437125748,4,2,1,50,1,0
82603,365.853658536585,4,2,1,50,1,0

You'll need to redo the hitsounds on the sections.

-Umi- wrote:

not yet ranked >3< ?! I thought it will be ranked before my map, but no D: (mouahah) Hey BAT come on ! Yeah come on =w=

1. Add more tags, so we will be able to find your map faster. You can add My Youth Romantic Comedy Is Wrong As I Expected. (english title) and you can also add a Machigatte Iru (part of alternative title) and maybe Brains Base (name og the studio)
2. Start your kiai #1 (Normal diff) on 00:56:435 instead of 00:56:072 to keep your kiais consistent!
3. Your colours are too bright, consider fading them a bit. Current ones may hurt players' eyes!
   
   colours

   
   

   Combo1 : 141,220,124
   Combo2 : 226,172,227
   Combo3 : 150,233,237
   Combo4 : 237,158,158
   Combo5 : 211,105,252
   Combo6 : 228,225,120

4. Your source is incorrect. Just one dot ._. you forget to add it.

   Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatteiru.

1. 00:24:463 (3) - try to end this slider a bit earlier and add one more 1/1 slider on 00:25:179 - to follow vocals. example
2. 00:25:895 (1,2) - nazi - (2)'s tail is too close to (1), so players mght mistakenly click it.
   
   click me!

   Red is wrong flow. Confusing for beginners, you know.
   Blue is correct one. Doesn't looks good, imo.
   
3. 00:53:526 (4) - consider adding a new combo here. It'd ft with music and BPM/rhythm changes. What's more it looks really cool here!
4. 00:56:072 - consider finishing spinner here or earlier. So, you'll be able to place a circle or 1/1 slider at 00:56:435 - to follow vocals. Having spinner end at this point sounds awkward because it doesn't fits with background music. example
5. 01:06:970 - don't leave unused green lines. They are useless, so, what's the point of keeping them.

1. 00:02:633 - even if you follow vocals, please don't ignore sound here. Consider adding 1/1 slider here, it'll fit with vocals, too! example
2. 00:04:821 - bpm changes here, please, don't ignore it! Consider using 1/2 slider with a circle instead? example
3. 00:09:170 (2,3) - nazi - try to make a blankt slider here? Current flow looks a little bit messy, imo. Something like this looks better, don't you think so?
4. 00:12:063 (2) - nazi - move its tail a bit away, so that reverse arrow will be easier readable. take a look at this example and consider it!
5. 00:25:000 (5,6,7) - this combo feels too long and kinda off vocals and your pattern. So, consider swapping new Combo between 00:25:895 (7) and 00:26:624 (1) - Looks like it is needed.
6. 00:53:526 (3) - nazi - I'd move (3) a bit away from (1). Looks like players may mistakenly click t after hitting (1). You don't have to do it, but that'd be a good idea.
7. 00:53:526 - kiai is the most memorable part of the song, that'd be a good idea to use more 1/2 notes here. Consider making it a bit harder?

1. How about using AR8? I feel like it'll fit with this diff musch better, your playfield is flooded with circles. If you do it, use HP/OD 7 for this diff to keep diff settings more balanced.
2. 00:10:074 - remove unused green line. It doesn't make any sense to keep it here, anyway.
3. 00:12:062 (5,6,7) - consider replacing them with reversed 1/3 slider, you have two [Insane] diffs, so making [Hard] a bit easier is a good idea. That's the only 1/4 pattern in the whole diff, anyway.
4. 01:16:984 (3,4,5) - nazi - this stacked triplets looks pretty weird. I'd unstack them all to keep pattern visually consistent.
   
   Pretty neat.

1. 00:17:169 - consider reducing volume of hitsounds a bit, sounds too loud, imo.
2. 00:18:628 (2) - why whistle+clap sound here? It's really sounds off music, consider removing it. If fact, I'd relace that slider with stream.
3. 00:48:987 (1) - too soon after spinner. Players have no time to focus on circle. Consider replacing it with a circle at 00:49:169 - instead.
4. 00:53:346 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - because of patterns like this one I strongly recommend you to use AR9 here. Otherwise all these patterns looks messy and hardly readable, imo.
5. 01:18:439 (1) - patterns like this one aren't really readable.(inconsistent spacing, and things..) How about working on spacing a bit more? I feel like you can really improve it!
   
   Rhythm is fine, but diff itself is quite messy.

1. I'd recommend AR9 here, but it's up to you. Personally, i think that AR9 will make this iff much more readable for players.
2. 00:12:792 (5) - ths is the hardest diff, so replacing that long slider with stream would e a good idea, let's make this diff a bit more challenging!
3. 00:30:271 (1) - what's the point of jump here? it doesn't really fits with music/vocal/anything, so I'd recommend you to remove it.
4. 00:56:435 (1) - try to finish that slider at 00:56:617 - and place a circle at 00:56:799 - to follow vocals and music better. I thnk that ignnoring vocals at 00:56:617 - is a bad idea.
5. 01:11:704 (1,3) - swap new combo. It'll fit with vocals and make your combos a bit more consistent.
   
   Same as other [Insane] diff, it's a bit messy. I guess you can clean it up a bit, avoid some extra overlaps and similar things. you can do it,, just try!

-Bakari- wrote:

hi

[General]

1. Add more tags, so we will be able to find your map faster. You can add My Youth Romantic Comedy Is Wrong As I Expected. (english title) and you can also add a Machigatte Iru (part of alternative title) and maybe Brains Base (name og the studio)
2. Start your kiai #1 (Normal diff) on 00:56:435 instead of 00:56:072 to keep your kiais consistent!
3. Your colours are too bright, consider fading them a bit. Current ones may hurt players' eyes!
   
   colours

   
   

   Combo1 : 141,220,124
   Combo2 : 226,172,227
   Combo3 : 150,233,237
   Combo4 : 237,158,158
   Combo5 : 211,105,252
   Combo6 : 228,225,120

4. Your source is incorrect. Just one dot ._. you forget to add it.

   Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Come wa Machigatteiru.

fixed all
[Easy]

1. 00:24:463 (3) - try to end this slider a bit earlier and add one more 1/1 slider on 00:25:179 - to follow vocals. example
2. 00:25:895 (1,2) - nazi - (2)'s tail is too close to (1), so players mght mistakenly click it.
   
   click me!

   Red is wrong flow. Confusing for beginners, you know.
   Blue is correct one. Doesn't looks good, imo.
   
3. 00:53:526 (4) - consider adding a new combo here. It'd ft with music and BPM/rhythm changes. What's more it looks really cool here!
4. 00:56:072 - consider finishing spinner here or earlier. So, you'll be able to place a circle or 1/1 slider at 00:56:435 - to follow vocals. Having spinner end at this point sounds awkward because it doesn't fits with background music. example If i do that the slider would appear to fast in for newbs =w=
5. 01:06:970 - don't leave unused green lines. They are useless, so, what's the point of keeping them.

fixed the rest
[Normal]

1. 00:02:633 - even if you follow vocals, please don't ignore sound here. Consider adding 1/1 slider here, it'll fit with vocals, too! example I'll consider
2. 00:04:821 - bpm changes here, please, don't ignore it! Consider using 1/2 slider with a circle instead? example
3. 00:09:170 (2,3) - nazi - try to make a blankt slider here? Current flow looks a little bit messy, imo. Something like this looks better, don't you think so?
4. 00:12:063 (2) - nazi - move its tail a bit away, so that reverse arrow will be easier readable. take a look at this example and consider it!
5. 00:25:000 (5,6,7) - this combo feels too long and kinda off vocals and your pattern. So, consider swapping new Combo between 00:25:895 (7) and 00:26:624 (1) - Looks like it is needed.
6. 00:53:526 (3) - nazi - I'd move (3) a bit away from (1). Looks like players may mistakenly click t after hitting (1). You don't have to do it, but that'd be a good idea.
7. 00:53:526 - kiai is the most memorable part of the song, that'd be a good idea to use more 1/2 notes here. Consider making it a bit harder?

fixed the rest and for the kia I'll try to fit some notes in
[Hard]

1. How about using AR8? I feel like it'll fit with this diff musch better, your playfield is flooded with circles. If you do it, use HP/OD 7 for this diff to keep diff settings more balanced.
2. 00:10:074 - remove unused green line. It doesn't make any sense to keep it here, anyway.
3. 00:12:062 (5,6,7) - consider replacing them with reversed 1/3 slider, you have two [Insane] diffs, so making [Hard] a bit easier is a good idea. That's the only 1/4 pattern in the whole diff, anyway.
4. 01:16:984 (3,4,5) - nazi - this stacked triplets looks pretty weird. I'd unstack them all to keep pattern visually consistent.
   fixed all except the setting changes
   Pretty neat.

[Ixxm's Insane]
I don't really like how you play with velocity multipliers, but that's ok, I guess.

1. 00:17:169 - consider reducing volume of hitsounds a bit, sounds too loud, imo.
2. 00:18:628 (2) - why whistle+clap sound here? It's really sounds off music, consider removing it. If fact, I'd relace that slider with stream.
3. 00:48:987 (1) - too soon after spinner. Players have no time to focus on circle. Consider replacing it with a circle at 00:49:169 - instead. I'll consider
4. 00:53:346 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - because of patterns like this one I strongly recommend you to use AR9 here. Otherwise all these patterns looks messy and hardly readable, imo.
5. 01:18:439 (1) - patterns like this one aren't really readable.(inconsistent spacing, and things..) How about working on spacing a bit more? I feel like you can really improve it!
   
   Rhythm is fine, but diff itself is quite messy.

fixed the rest
[Insane]

1. I'd recommend AR9 here, but it's up to you. Personally, i think that AR9 will make this iff much more readable for players.
2. 00:12:792 (5) - ths is the hardest diff, so replacing that long slider with stream would e a good idea, let's make this diff a bit more challenging!
3. 00:30:271 (1) - what's the point of jump here? it doesn't really fits with music/vocal/anything, so I'd recommend you to remove it.
4. 00:56:435 (1) - try to finish that slider at 00:56:617 - and place a circle at 00:56:799 - to follow vocals and music better. I thnk that ignnoring vocals at 00:56:617 - is a bad idea.
5. 01:11:704 (1,3) - swap new combo. It'll fit with vocals and make your combos a bit more consistent.
   
   Same as other [Insane] diff, it's a bit messy. I guess you can clean it up a bit, avoid some extra overlaps and similar things. you can do it,, just try!

fixed all, and I'll try to clean the overlaps a little
~~~~~~~~~~~
Good luck!

jonathanlfj wrote:

here is the promised mod
yanaginagi yes

Black is suggestion
Blue is highly recommended
Red is unrankable

[General]
The combo colours in Normal diff are different from other diffs, please fix it
the tiny font on the top right side of the bg is really bothering me, here is one without them:

SPOILER

[Easy]
00:37:534 (1) - shift this so it perfectly overlaps the position of 00:34:634 (1)
00:41:884 (3,4) - the clap patterns change here; take clap off the end of 00:41:884 (3) and place on 00:42:609 (4)
00:52:089 (3) - add finish to slider start, and NC should be here instead of 00:53:526 (1)
01:13:161 (3) - stack on where 01:10:612 (4) was

[Normal]
00:13:886 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - they rhythm here makes more sense if you place it like this:

SPOILER

00:41:522 (2,3) - same as Easy
00:53:526 (3) - clap on slider start
01:05:161 (5) - NC
01:16:621 (4) - ^

[Hard]
00:06:361 (1) - add finish like Normal?
00:07:725 (1) - NC
00:16:531 (1) - i think a clap on this fits better than a finish (or no sound at all)
00:49:899 (3) - spacing change here intentional?
00:53:526 (3) - clap
01:15:346 (2) - put a blanket around 01:15:892 (3)
01:20:075 (5,6,7) - this plays better imo:

SPOILER

[Ixxm's Insane]
00:03:362 (1) - whistle on slider head
00:17:169 (3) - the volume here is a bit low imo, its hard to properly determine if ur hitting on time if you dont hear audio feedback; try 35% volume
00:28:083 (2) - snap end to 00:28:630 (for some reason AIMod didnt catch this)
00:48:987 (1) - NC
00:50:537 (4) - move to 00:50:446
00:53:166 (6) - NC here instead of 00:53:346 (1) to mark start of new square
00:56:435 (1) - the distance on this with 00:56:072 (7) makes it tempting to hit it too early, i would say stack this on 00:56:072 (7) instead which is more readable imo
01:16:803 (2) - stack properly on where 01:16:439 (5) was
01:25:163 - add a note here

[Insane]
00:16:439 (10) - NC
00:16:531 (1) - use clap
00:30:998 (3) - clap on slider end
00:56:435 (1) - NC
01:01:897 (7) - adjust spacing on this note so it flows better with the whole combo (1.4x i believe)

Great song and mapset, would love to see this ranked
Good luck~

Flower wrote:

Hi~

[Insane]
00:02:998 (4,1,2,3,4,5) - look quite random. make into a perfect hexagon or at least blanket 00:02:998 (4,1) - fixed
00:12:427 (3) - try this: fixed

SPOILER

00:26:989 - add whistle? I'm following the piano here >< so didn't fix
00:42:881 - 00:42:972 - 00:43:153 - try adding claps on the three points. those indicate the beginning of a new part. I'll consider
from 00:43:334 - to 00:53:891 - lack of soft whistles. Added some
00:58:441 (4) - maybe add whistle or clap sounds weird to me >< since I got a consistent whistle pattern
01:01:352 (3,4,5,6,7,1) - maybe arrange like this, which sounds more dynamic: I'll consider

SPOILER

01:01:352 (3) - add whistle
01:01:533 (5) - remove whistle
01:01:715 (6) - add whistle
01:02:079 (1) - add whistle

01:02:079 (1,2) - switch NC fixed
01:13:161 (4,1) - same as 01:01:352 (3,4,5,6,7,1) - same as above

[Icemixxa]
00:01:174 - whistle
00:01:721 - ^
00:01:903 - remove whistle
00:04:092 - whistle
00:04:639 - ^
00:04:821 - remove whistle
I know you will say there is piano tick on 00:01:903 - and 00:04:821 - , but obviously current arrangement sound quite weird.
00:08:267 - add finish
00:11:158 - ^
00:55:557 (4) - I think converting this into 2 notes plays better, since the map is not as hard as JOINT STRUGGLE.
01:06:788 (1,2,3,4,5) - re-adjust the placement to let them form a perfect pentagon. ctrl+shift+d helps. Up to icemixxa
01:25:072 (4) - delete this. plays bad.
fixed the rest
[Hard]
00:44:975 (5,6) - move downwards, because 5 is overlapped by 4 while playing.
00:56:435 (1,2) - blanket better
00:57:711 (4) - ^
01:00:079 (3,4) - move downwards, reason same as above
01:05:161 (1) - move to x:271,y:116, and do some rotation to blanket 01:05:703 (2) -
01:07:698 (3,1) - move downwards
01:16:621 (1,2) - switch NC
fixed all
[Normal]
Fine. Glad to hear :3 ~

[Easy]
turn grid snap off and check all of the notes. there are slight spacing inconsistency, like 00:09:893 (2,3,1) - , though hardly noticeable in game play.
00:03:362 (1,2) - blanket better
00:47:346 (1,2) - ^
fixed all
Good luck~

Hollow Wings wrote:

hi, I'm a newbie modder here giving some noob suggestion, most of them are given as a player :3

Insane

00:05:908 (5,6,7) - make same ds like 1.7x? keeping the 5 at 1.4 ><
00:24:463 (5,7) - r these sliders too close? have an other shape? (just suggestion Don't think they are that close tho :3 so I'll keep it like this for now
00:32:452 (4) - move to 298,223? fixed
00:52:089 (1,2,3,4) - looks better than 00:52:987 (1,2,3,4) - ...? same DS but changed the angle a bit

Ixxm's Insane

00:18:628 (2,3,4,5) - wowww, this stream is easily cause combo breaking, maybe that's just for pro players playing this diff huh? :3
00:38:803 (4) - didn't fit 00:38:984 (5) - 's bent perfect, maybe change a little? (just suggestion The blankets are fine imo o_O
00:37:534 (1,2) - ^ ^
00:41:159 (6,1) - ^ and more... ^
01:09:155 (5) - arrange ds? fixed the whole combo

ds changing appeared frequently, still good for playing. idk... that's the distance to pro mapper like u and noob mapper like me? O_Q We're not pro mapper :3

Hard

00:11:158 (3,4) - fix this... u know what i mean... :3 fixed
00:58:623 (6) - move to 352,121? fixed
01:20:803 (7) - is this note's position too high? its fine imo

Normal

00:01:539 (2) - maybe u can put this note on the curve of 00:00:445 (1,3) - ? like position:105,122 fixed
00:40:434 (1) - fit the bent to 00:39:709 (4) - to make a better shape? (just suggestion keeping the blanket ><
01:05:161 (1,2) - ^

^

Easy

fine Good to hear :3

nice song, nice pattern except the one I called pro-only stream before, that really shocks me even i'm a player in #1000... D:
good luck

kajiyatta wrote:

M4M
[General]
BG is large size... try to use it http://puu.sh/3dZcg.jpg BG is the same size, you have given me O_O
[Easy]
Placement
00:41:159(2) move some grids left, it will be nice flow
Rhythm
01:16:803(4) maybe it would be better imo

SPOILER

Keeping mine for now ><
Hit Sonud
00:05:546(4) add whistle at head to follo your pattern
01:23:151(1) add S:C:1 clap at end
fixed the rest
[Normal]
Placement
00:07:725(1) too far from center of a spinner
0101:897(4,3) stack better
Rhythm
00:01:539(2,3) this ryhthm seems unexpected for newbie sinece it is quite part, so use 1/2 slider insted 2 combos. it is more common I'll keep it like I have for now ><

SPOILER

00:46:981(2,1) to foolow the drum sound, you can use 1/2 slider with reverse. e.g) ^

SPOILER

Hit Sonud
01:06:788(1) add claps on all points since it is emphasized.
01:18:439(1)^
fixed the rest
[Hard]
Placement
00:08:267(3) if stacked, on (2) better not (4)'s head.
00:40:434(1) not good flow I suppose, change the direction like this?

SPOILER

00:41:159(3) make a down-curve?
Rhythm
00:05:002(6,7) like this? I don't like the blank I'll consider

SPOILER

Hit Sonud
00:30:271(3) delete finish and add whistle since here is a piano sound
00:46:251(1)^
00:54:440(5)^
01:20:257(6) add finish at head
01:22:603(1)^
fixed the rest
[Ixxm's Insane]
AR8 better since there is a few jumping.
Placement
00:37:534(1) spacing, it is narrow and unexpected for AR9.
Rhythm
00:08:809(1) start at 00:08:899 and add a note.
Hit Sonud
00:47:528(6) delete finish since there isn't cymbal sound
00:48:987(1) add finish at end
01:02:161(2) ^ don't here cymbal here o-o
fixed the restl
[Insane]
Placement
00:31:543(1) I don't agree with this jump, if you aim to jump maybe (1) to (2) better, not (3) to (1). e.g)

SPOILER

Rhythm
00:53:891(1) this is a Insane diff, so this spinner seems so long. you should start it at 00:54:623It's not that long imo >< I'll consider
Hit Sonud
00:45:887(1) delete finish at reverse
fixed the rest
overall, it needs more works. but not bad, don't give up. good luck with star.

1. The background is in the folder twice (the pictures differ slightly). Gotta fix that.

1. Overall this isn't very interesting. It's a 1/1 Easy, which has no innate rhythm that comes from the song, and the comboing is inconsistent.
2. 00:06:271 (1) - Pretty damn short spinner for an Easy. Also the next object follows with a confusing rhythm. It'd be better to remove this spinner and make the next slider start on 00:07:725 - otherwise the rhythm is too complex for an Easy.
3. 00:13:521 (4,1) - I'm not quite sure why the new combo isn't on (4). It'd be more consistent with what you had before and make more sense musically...
4. 00:24:463 (3,4) - Turn this into a single 1/1 slider to make the map more consistent (the rhythm in the song is the same as 00:21:545 (3) - which is a 1/1 slider).
5. 00:44:063 (2,3,4,1,2) - This comboing's weird. To stay consistent both musically and with the rest of the map I suggest to move the new combo onto (4).
6. 00:48:440 (2) - Also, this slider ruins our comboing. To be consistent with 00:43:334 (1,2) - the new combo should be on 00:49:169 - but the slider ends here, which makes it impossible to place a new combo at this point, so you have to plae it somewhere else and it ruins it. Same problem on 01:13:525 (4) - the new combo should be on the big white tick.

1. Similar problems as Easy... It becomes kinda 1/1 after a while.
2. 01:20:075 (1,1) - Not quite sure about this. The spinner's pretty long but the object after it is too soon. You could easily shorten the spinner.

1. AR7 is uncalled for, this Hard would be better with AR6. AR7 makes it faster than it actually is and it feels weird.
2. I fail to see the logic behind the stacks. They just... stop the movement at random moments ? Try to use less of them D:
3. 00:06:361 (1) - Super short spinner. I'm not sure it's a good idea for a Hard.
4. 00:12:063 (5) - Only 1/4 in the entire diff and it doesn't even fit the song.
5. 00:53:526 (3) - Are you sure this should have a clap ? It sounds very weird.
6. 01:03:348 (5,1) - To stay consistent with 01:01:897 (1,2) - the new combo should be on (5). For the same reason, 01:04:798 (4,5,1) - the new combo here should be on (4).
7. 01:01:897 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2) - This was pretty good. You have a definite rhythm and keep at it for the whole pattern, instead of changing it midway for absolutely no reason. The pattern itself flows and plays well. Also, this has structure, which is something I haven't seen in any map for a long while. Just fix the comboing to make the structure more apparent.
8. 01:13:525 (6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - Same remarks as above for the comboing, also fix 01:16:621 (1,2,3,4,5) - because it breaks the structure of this part.

1. Is this really AR9 ? It feels so out of place that I was unable to play it until I changed it to 8.
2. 00:31:543 (1,2) - New combo should be on (2). You're not even consistent with your other diffs, and the comboing as it is now doesn't make musical sense. Also, you're obviously changing your rhythms and patterns on (2)...
3. 00:45:340 (6,7,8) - This triple - and this jump - don't fit. There's a slow part here why accelerate both the rhythm and the movement ?
4. 00:50:446 (6,7) - Same here, except this just looks like a spacing mistake, not a purposefully placed jump.
5. 00:52:089 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - You accelerate the pace with the first combo, which is good and makes sense, but then you instantly slow it down quite drastically with 00:53:526 (4,5) - ...
6. 01:18:076 (6,1) - That was very confusing because the spacing is the exact same as 01:17:893 (5,6) - but the time distance is different. If I understand what you're going for, it'd be better to stack 01:18:075 (6,1) - .

1. Notes 1/2 after a spinner is a... gimmick. It doesn't play well and is confusing/frustrating.
2. 00:18:628 (2,3,4,5) - Gimmicky and confusing spacing. There's no need for a jump here, especially not a 1/4 jump.
3. 00:25:000 (7,8) - That felt weird and inconsistent. You haven't used any jump so far in this slower part, and you have one now. I'm guessing you just reversed 00:25:179 (8) - for some reason.
4. 00:55:822 (7) - Why a slider here ? I thought 00:55:822 (7,8) - was a 1/4 jump because of that...

Shiro wrote:

As per your request.

Please reply to this mod saying what you didn't fix (and what you did) and why.
Also, if you have any questions, feel free to ask me in-game.

General

1. The background is in the folder twice (the pictures differ slightly). Gotta fix that.

Easy

1. Overall this isn't very interesting. It's a 1/1 Easy, which has no innate rhythm that comes from the song, and the comboing is inconsistent.
2. 00:06:271 (1) - Pretty damn short spinner for an Easy. Also the next object follows with a confusing rhythm. It'd be better to remove this spinner and make the next slider start on 00:07:725 - otherwise the rhythm is too complex for an Easy.
3. 00:13:521 (4,1) - I'm not quite sure why the new combo isn't on (4). It'd be more consistent with what you had before and make more sense musically...
4. 00:24:463 (3,4) - Turn this into a single 1/1 slider to make the map more consistent (the rhythm in the song is the same as 00:21:545 (3) - which is a 1/1 slider).
5. 00:44:063 (2,3,4,1,2) - This comboing's weird. To stay consistent both musically and with the rest of the map I suggest to move the new combo onto (4).
6. 00:48:440 (2) - Also, this slider ruins our comboing. To be consistent with 00:43:334 (1,2) - the new combo should be on 00:49:169 - but the slider ends here, which makes it impossible to place a new combo at this point, so you have to plae it somewhere else and it ruins it. Same problem on 01:13:525 (4) - the new combo should be on the big white tick.

Normal

1. Similar problems as Easy... It becomes kinda 1/1 after a while.
2. 01:20:075 (1,1) - Not quite sure about this. The spinner's pretty long but the object after it is too soon. You could easily shorten the spinner.

Hard

1. AR7 is uncalled for, this Hard would be better with AR6. AR7 makes it faster than it actually is and it feels weird.
2. I fail to see the logic behind the stacks. They just... stop the movement at random moments ? Try to use less of them D:
3. 00:06:361 (1) - Super short spinner. I'm not sure it's a good idea for a Hard.
4. 00:12:063 (5) - Only 1/4 in the entire diff and it doesn't even fit the song.
5. 00:53:526 (3) - Are you sure this should have a clap ? It sounds very weird.
6. 01:03:348 (5,1) - To stay consistent with 01:01:897 (1,2) - the new combo should be on (5). For the same reason, 01:04:798 (4,5,1) - the new combo here should be on (4).
7. 01:01:897 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2) - This was pretty good. You have a definite rhythm and keep at it for the whole pattern, instead of changing it midway for absolutely no reason. The pattern itself flows and plays well. Also, this has structure, which is something I haven't seen in any map for a long while. Just fix the comboing to make the structure more apparent.
8. 01:13:525 (6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - Same remarks as above for the comboing, also fix 01:16:621 (1,2,3,4,5) - because it breaks the structure of this part.

Insane

1. Is this really AR9 ? It feels so out of place that I was unable to play it until I changed it to 8.
2. 00:31:543 (1,2) - New combo should be on (2). You're not even consistent with your other diffs, and the comboing as it is now doesn't make musical sense. Also, you're obviously changing your rhythms and patterns on (2)...
3. 00:45:340 (6,7,8) - This triple - and this jump - don't fit. There's a slow part here why accelerate both the rhythm and the movement ?
4. 00:50:446 (6,7) - Same here, except this just looks like a spacing mistake, not a purposefully placed jump.
5. 00:52:089 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - You accelerate the pace with the first combo, which is good and makes sense, but then you instantly slow it down quite drastically with 00:53:526 (4,5) - ...
6. 01:18:076 (6,1) - That was very confusing because the spacing is the exact same as 01:17:893 (5,6) - but the time distance is different. If I understand what you're going for, it'd be better to stack 01:18:075 (6,1) - .

Ixxm's Insane

1. Notes 1/2 after a spinner is a... gimmick. It doesn't play well and is confusing/frustrating.
2. 00:18:628 (2,3,4,5) - Gimmicky and confusing spacing. There's no need for a jump here, especially not a 1/4 jump.
3. 00:25:000 (7,8) - That felt weird and inconsistent. You haven't used any jump so far in this slower part, and you have one now. I'm guessing you just reversed 00:25:179 (8) - for some reason.
4. 00:55:822 (7) - Why a slider here ? I thought 00:55:822 (7,8) - was a 1/4 jump because of that...

Smoothie wrote:

Heya~
From my modding queue

[Ixxm's Insane]
00:00:809 (3) - Add a whislte because of the piano sound?
00:02:086 (1) - Add whistle on the start~
00:02:451 (2) - ^
00:03:727 (2) - Add a Whistle
00:04:639 (6) - Remove the whislte on the start and add one on the reverse (if you added the one i've mentioned above) I'll consider those whistles (same as above)
00:05:364 (2) - Whistle on the slider start~ fixed
00:07:725 (1,2) - how about making one reverse slider instead? Fits better imo Since this is insane I think it's okay :O
00:08:809 (4) - Add finish? Don't here symbal o-o
00:19:357 - You should add a note here added
00:58:441 (8) - Place it at x:236 y:288? don't think a jump here is neccessary
00:59:352 (2,3) - Mh... how about this?

SPOILER

fixed
01:18:075 (5) - Add finish? added

[Insane]
00:08:267 (3) - Add a finish on the start?
00:08:628 (4) - Finish on the end.
00:11:158 (3) - Same here, finish on start?
00:11:520 (4) - Finish on end~ sounds a bit messy if I add all these finishes :/ so didn't fix
00:41:884 (5) - NC fixed
00:42:247 (6) - Add clap? sounds weird to me
00:42:972 (11) - Clap on the slider start~ added this one
01:08:062 (1) - Finish on the start added
01:18:076 (6) - Soft finish here added
01:23:151 (1,2,3) - Make a slider with reverse instead? I'll keep it the way it is

[Hard]
00:04:092 (4) - Remove the whistle on the Slider end
00:04:639 (5) - Add a whistle on the start and remove the one on the end (only when you removed the one i've mentioned above) I'll keep the pattern I have for now
00:05:002 (6) - Whistle on the start end reverse. I want to keep it silent since the vocal is soft too ><
00:09:351 (6) - NC fixed
00:07:725 (1,2,3,4) - That somehow plays a bit weird... but it might be just me. fixed
00:07:725 - 00:13:521 - If you added the finishes i mentioned on Insane you may want to apply them here too for consistency
00:21:363 (3) - Move it to 00:21:181 following vocal here
00:22:640 - Add note ^
00:54:440 (5) - Remove the whistle on the end and add a finish instead? Whistle is enough here imo
01:20:803 (7) - Remove whistle and add a finish~ fixed
01:19:712 (4) - NC fixed

[Normal]
00:04:457 (2,3) - Mh... how about this?

SPOILER

slider would become unsnapped
00:07:725 - 00:13:521 - Same as i mentioned on hard~
00:16:257 (7) - Remove this one? nah sounds better this way imo
00:53:526 (3) - Move to x:304 y:244 fixed

[Easy]
00:07:725 - 00:13:521 - Same as i mentioned on hard and normal :3
00:09:351 (2) - Start the slider at 00:09:170 and extend it to 00:09:532 It's fine as it is cuz the instrument
00:30:998 (4) - I assume you added the whistle here because of the piano sound. But consider removing it. Imo it sounds way better without it. I'll consider
01:01:533 (1) - Remove NC fixed
01:19:712 (3) - Remove the clap at the end of the slider and add a finish instead~ fixed
01:23:151 (1) - ^ fixed
01:25:163 (3) - Clap at the start? fixed

That's all
Good luck!