Lybydose or those. If one is a scum, the other is not. Not sure about the 3rd one yet.Tsukasa wrote:
@fart: Who are your suspects then?
Lemme guess... Me?
Lybydose or those. If one is a scum, the other is not. Not sure about the 3rd one yet.Tsukasa wrote:
@fart: Who are your suspects then?
Lemme guess... Me?
...Soooo... who's 2nd? Looks like a slip...fartownik wrote:
Lybydose or those. If one is a scum, the other is not. Not sure about the 3rd one yet.
Ah, yeah. Not sure about the 2nd and 3rd one yet. But it depends on the results of the lynch today.JInxyjem wrote:
...Soooo... who's 2nd? Looks like a slip...fartownik wrote:
Lybydose or those. If one is a scum, the other is not. Not sure about the 3rd one yet.
f uTsukasa wrote:
It's ok hika.
It's ok to sheep us like this. :3
K Hika is so town
Wow I didn't notice that bull asked for copping BRBP.NoHitter wrote:
Raging Bull: Why did you vote for brbp when you said that cop should scan him in an earlier post?
explain why -- how do these two connect together? the OMGUS is soooooooo strongfartownik wrote:
Lybydose or those. If one is a scum, the other is not. Not sure about the 3rd one yet.Tsukasa wrote:
@fart: Who are your suspects then?
Lemme guess... Me?
Oh... and this...fartownik wrote:
I'm not following to those, he's obviously following me with a vote on Lybydose not to get lynched this day, as he already gets most of the votes. Seems like a normal act of defense. Well, the most reasonable thing from me is this.
Unvote
Vote: those
Lol wot, those was my suspicion as well as Lybydose. People started to say I'm a scum buddy with him, simple change to prove them wrong.Tsukasa wrote:
Oh... and this...fartownik wrote:
I'm not following to those, he's obviously following me with a vote on Lybydose not to get lynched this day, as he already gets most of the votes. Seems like a normal act of defense. Well, the most reasonable thing from me is this.
Unvote
Vote: those
After reading this more, I kinda want to sheep lyby now.
THAT VOTE ON THOSE
But I'll stick to those for now and wait for a response from him
So you voted him because you wanted to lynch a vanilla townie? That's how this post is reading to me. There's no reason to vote for someone you simply want a cop scan on.Raging Bull wrote:
I voted for BRBP because of what you said about lynching vanilla townie > power role, but lynching mafia instead of town is still better. He could have claimed a power role, but somehow went for mafia. If he truly was pro-town then he would have helped us and not confuse us even more by claiming mafia.
From my perspective (judging how I know you, how you would react in my opinion) that action would be the right move if YOU were scum.Lybydose wrote:
because I can't edit:
The 'OMGUS' is strong with those. fartownik on the other hand has shown the chainsaw defense twice, although the first could be dismissed as RVS. You (fartownik) also say that moving votes in a certain way is the 'right' move to make for scum, but the same can be said about the way you moved your vote to the wagon on "those".
Lybydose wrote:
So you voted him because you wanted to lynch a vanilla townie? That's how this post is reading to me. There's no reason to vote for someone you simply want a cop scan on.Raging Bull wrote:
I voted for BRBP because of what you said about lynching vanilla townie > power role, but lynching mafia instead of town is still better. He could have claimed a power role, but somehow went for mafia. If he truly was pro-town then he would have helped us and not confuse us even more by claiming mafia.
Though I do see the logic behind voting people who are playing anti-town, regardless of what faction they actually are.
@fartownik: I'm not even sure what you're trying to say. Are you thinking that I'm scum, or those is? Or both of us?
From my perspective, your action would also be the 'right' move if YOU were scum. It goes both ways here. Except I'm not sure how me voting those at the start of the day is the right move if I'm scum. Explain please.fartownik wrote:
From my perspective (judging how I know you, how you would react in my opinion) that action would be the right move if YOU were scum.Lybydose wrote:
because I can't edit:
The 'OMGUS' is strong with those. fartownik on the other hand has shown the chainsaw defense twice, although the first could be dismissed as RVS. You (fartownik) also say that moving votes in a certain way is the 'right' move to make for scum, but the same can be said about the way you moved your vote to the wagon on "those".
Or you could check the stickied iso threaddkun wrote:
n. please bold if you request something from me.
Also sorry for the delay, but I'll be coming out with a player ISO later tonight.
Tsukasa wrote:
Well throwing WIFOM may or may not be a good idea.
icwudtTsukasa wrote:
may or may not be
I thought about that but thought the doctor could protect him without revealing their identity. And i did not vote for BRBP without thinking about it first.Nyquill wrote:
kanye prodding me EXACTLY 24 hours after I last posted... what a man.
Raging Bull: The problem is that asking for a cop scan in the first place was a huge nono, and is something scum would want to do, as forcing the cop onto who scum would know is innocent means one night where cop is wasted. In addition, cop will still have to reveal his identity to confirm BRBP, since we cannot be sure the cop actually exists.
It also doesn't help that you jumped on the BRBP wagon after one has been started.
But the doctor can't protect the same target every night, if there exists one.Raging Bull wrote:
I thought about that but thought the doctor could protect him without revealing their identity. And i did not vote for BRBP without thinking about it first.
1) Did you realize that NL was quite anti-town when you first did that?those wrote:
What exactly do you want explained, Tsukasa?
As anti-town it may be, NL votes are simply an \obligatory\ first vote kind of thing, and never stays that way for day 1. My NL vote will always be unvoted by night.Tsukasa wrote:
1) Did you realize that NL was quite anti-town when you first did that?
Cuz he voted me.Tsukasa wrote:
2) Why lyby?
A vote with next to zero basis, probably a defensive vote.Tsukasa wrote:
3) What do you think of fart for voting you?
Probably the same as what would you think if you were L-2.Tsukasa wrote:
4) Thoughts on being at L-2?
not necessarily, there was a huge bandwagon in that NL vote, it potentially could have passed and messed up the game. imo just don't start it D1 because it's always badthose wrote:
As anti-town it may be, NL votes are simply an \obligatory\ first vote kind of thing, and never stays that way for day 1. My NL vote will always be unvoted by night.Tsukasa wrote:
1) Did you realize that NL was quite anti-town when you first did that?
ok see how you're contradicting yourself hereCuz he voted me.Tsukasa wrote:
2) Why lyby?A vote with next to zero basis, probably a defensive vote.Tsukasa wrote:
3) What do you think of fart for voting you?
OMGUS is zero basisKanye West wrote:
so basically you said that your vote for lyby had zero basis
yeah i corrected myselfTsukasa wrote:
Well to be fair...
those never voted fart. So it's not much of an OMGUS.
though fart's vote is quite scummy and I want to push him for it.
But I'd like those on the hot seat first.
EVERYONE ELSE: Pushing those on L-1? Good or Bad?
Kanye West wrote:
I didn't vote for BRBP because I thought he was a bad player and not mafia. What kind of actual mafia would give themselves up D1?
CARNIVAL OF LUNACYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYKanye West wrote:
What kind of actual mafia would give themselves up D1?
"Follow the cop" strategy basically cop claim, doc not. The doc will protect the cop every night. Worse scenario, doc being killed after the day this strategy implemented. If there is 2 cop or nurse, 1 cop claim, the others cop, doc, and nurse are not claim. Simple strategy, but effective. I don't like the worse scenario, but I like the strategy because this put mafias to WIFOM.Lybydose wrote:
@nohitter: we *could* do follow the cop, but since the doctor can't protect the same target every night, it wouldn't last very long
Fartownik and Meatstick maybe only sheeping. Hika and (fuck, my slot) Seph were sheeping without read. Seph was joking, you can see he said "LyLyLy". It still stupid...Kanye West wrote:
So D1, fartownik, Meatstick, Hika and Seph jumped the nolynch bandwagon with little/no explanation. Seph seems especially scummy because he voted nylo even after it was explained that it was a stupid idea to begin with. My vote's still on those for today though.
What do you mean by this, may I ask?Lincolm wrote:
Probably Fartownik - Those are not mafia-mafia. Hika - Those also.
He means we are certainly not mafia together, and you and Hika are certainly not mafia together as well.those wrote:
What do you mean by this, may I ask?Lincolm wrote:
Probably Fartownik - Those are not mafia-mafia. Hika - Those also.
@Mod: Requesting extension for the replacement. Pretty please with cherry on top? :3dkun wrote:
Just a friendly warning -- day ends in about 18 hours.
Why this looks for me like a try to secure yourself in case those is not scum and I'm the one left, so people vote on me in the next day? I was the only one to say you might be suspicious, I have no clue why you would really say this knowing I'm a newbie in this game.Tsukasa wrote:
Guys. It's either those or fart
And those is the most likely
Well, this is correct. Want me to post the reason? Because I like to tell it in certain situation.fartownik wrote:
He means we are certainly not mafia together, and you and Hika are certainly not mafia together as well.
I voted those in the bandwagon.Lincolm wrote:
Well, I believe when someone do something huge scummy or anti-town as town, mafias like to watch the mislynch. I like Kanye West have same logic with me, but another question, Kanye West, Lybydose, and Those, why you did not defend BRBP if you thought he was town?
Meatstick is town. I don't think mafia like to hammer in BRBP's wagon, reason like above.Well, this is correct. Want me to post the reason? Because I like to tell it in certain situation.fartownik wrote:
He means we are certainly not mafia together, and you and Hika are certainly not mafia together as well.
Also this is quite good question. It's funny how Kanye and Lybydose didn't comment it at all, avoiding the discussion and not taking the sides.Lincolm wrote:
Well, I believe when someone do something huge scummy or anti-town as town, mafias like to watch the mislynch. I like Kanye West have same logic with me, but another question, Kanye West, Lybydose, and Those, why you did not defend BRBP if you thought he was town?
It's not the town's job to actively defend people that are probably town (except possibly information roles), rather, they should be actively hunting people that are scum. Do you honestly believe that if I showed up and said "I don't think he's town" that everyone would just be all like "oh, well in that case I'll just unvote"? What would that even accomplish? With absolutely nothing to go on day 1, letting a bandwagon like that sit around is going to give more interesting information that just randomly voting, and I didn't think anyone would be stupid enough to end the day so early.Lincolm wrote:
Well, I believe when someone do something huge scummy or anti-town as town, mafias like to watch the mislynch. I like Kanye West have same logic with me, but another question, Kanye West, Lybydose, and Those, why you did not defend BRBP if you thought he was town?
So you suspect Tsukasa to be mafia?fartownik wrote:
Why this looks for me like a try to secure yourself in case those is not scum and I'm the one left, so people vote on me in the next day? I was the only one to say you might be suspicious, I have no clue why you would really say this knowing I'm a newbie in this game.
Sure, this sounds fair. As day is supposed to end now, let's extend it another 24h then.Tsukasa wrote:
@Mod: Requesting extension for the replacement. Pretty please with cherry on top? :3
Pushing your top reads is not something that's rare.fartownik wrote:
Why this looks for me like a try to secure yourself in case those is not scum and I'm the one left, so people vote on me in the next day? I was the only one to say you might be suspicious, I have no clue why you would really say this knowing I'm a newbie in this game.Tsukasa wrote:
Guys. It's either those or fart
And those is the most likely
Yes, a little bit. I suspect a lot of people but Tsukasa just gained some more of my attention.those wrote:
So you suspect Tsukasa to be mafia?fartownik wrote:
Why this looks for me like a try to secure yourself in case those is not scum and I'm the one left, so people vote on me in the next day? I was the only one to say you might be suspicious, I have no clue why you would really say this knowing I'm a newbie in this game.
because he's pushing those+farto the hardest.Tsukasa wrote:
Just curious... Why lyby, kanye?
why? because you're scum and want to kill another innocent townie at night? makes sense to me.Hika wrote:
I was hoping for night. Darn.
Kanye West wrote:
why? because you're scum and want to kill another innocent townie at night? makes sense to me.
The thing is it's not likely at all.Tsukasa wrote:
What's wrong with pushing a likely buddy match-up?
Well, nothing if those flips scum.Tsukasa wrote:
What's wrong with pushing a likely buddy match-up?
Oh, right. But if it's not true then he will die because there's no scenario with a cop and no doctor.Raging Bull wrote:
If what those said is true he can check someone tonight and have a doctor protect him.
Scum also (fake) hunting scum which everyone who scum hunting isn't guaranteed as town . When you said logical read, it can happen someone will stop that and not lynching your read. In other side, you can take a look at the wagon why people still vote him (fuck my slot again). Discussion can be done by anything, not only by vote and wagon. It also town job to not waste lynch.Lybydose wrote:
It's not the town's job to actively defend people that are probably town (except possibly information roles), rather, they should be actively hunting people that are scum. Do you honestly believe that if I showed up and said "I don't think he's town" that everyone would just be all like "oh, well in that case I'll just unvote"? What would that even accomplish? With absolutely nothing to go on day 1, letting a bandwagon like that sit around is going to give more interesting information that just randomly voting, and I didn't think anyone would be stupid enough to end the day so early.
Errrr... Kanye and Lybydose already answered it?fartownik wrote:
Also this is quite good question. It's funny how Kanye and Lybydose didn't comment it at all, avoiding the discussion and not taking the sides.
Also yes please, explain your reason further on my side.
There is another scenario. I will not tell it because let to many WIFOMs to both alignment. By the way, post something else please. Read or whatever.Raging Bull wrote:
Well the thing is that the doctor has to protect him and the doctor cannot protect him every night. So most likely he will die in the third night. So we have to see who is most scummy and get those to scan them.