Fix the spacing. Fix the inconsistent combos. BPM is around 115. Offset is around 1196.
forum
Futurama - Opening song
posted
Total Posts
52
DeletedUser_39338
huh. whats wrong with spacing?
combos maybe, but spacing Oo.
will try bpm and offset. wasnt easy to find that in this song.
edit: ur timing is good. im using it.
edit²: easy fixed and updated. can someone or better JarJarJacob check it and say me if its ok/better now pls?
Download: kirikuro - DJ Sharpnel - Siin [Insane] (2011-07-17) CatchTheBeat.osr
combos maybe, but spacing Oo.
will try bpm and offset. wasnt easy to find that in this song.
edit: ur timing is good. im using it.
edit²: easy fixed and updated. can someone or better JarJarJacob check it and say me if its ok/better now pls?
Download: kirikuro - DJ Sharpnel - Siin [Insane] (2011-07-17) CatchTheBeat.osr
Easy:
00:11:630 - the 8 and 9 should be farther apart from the 7, based off of your previous patterns
00:17:369 - 6 should be farther away from the 4
Normal:
00:03:282 - 5 should be farther away from the 4 (6 and 5 are fine, though)
00:09:543 - I think a new combo should start on the 7. Same with the 10 that comes later on.
Hard:
00:05:338 - the blue 1 and 2 should be part of this combo, and the blue three after that should start a new one, having the next two notes. (carried on throughout the intro and such; that is the phrasing, right?)
00:22:051 - The rolling is off.
00:17:099 - this phrase sounds messy. (namely the 2)
00:20:736 - the 3 and 5 sound slightly off.
00:22:593 - to me, the combo should be ascending instead of descending. But either way, the 3 and 4 aren't close enough and it sounds awkward. Perhaps just make it a long slider?
End - 4 sounds off and the final spacing is kinda weird.
For all of 'em, I don't like the ship crashing being part of the map itself, but that's just me.
Hope this helped in some fashion. I do like this show's intro very much and hope to see it polished for osu! some time soon.
00:11:630 - the 8 and 9 should be farther apart from the 7, based off of your previous patterns
00:17:369 - 6 should be farther away from the 4
Normal:
00:03:282 - 5 should be farther away from the 4 (6 and 5 are fine, though)
00:09:543 - I think a new combo should start on the 7. Same with the 10 that comes later on.
Hard:
00:05:338 - the blue 1 and 2 should be part of this combo, and the blue three after that should start a new one, having the next two notes. (carried on throughout the intro and such; that is the phrasing, right?)
00:22:051 - The rolling is off.
00:17:099 - this phrase sounds messy. (namely the 2)
00:20:736 - the 3 and 5 sound slightly off.
00:22:593 - to me, the combo should be ascending instead of descending. But either way, the 3 and 4 aren't close enough and it sounds awkward. Perhaps just make it a long slider?
End - 4 sounds off and the final spacing is kinda weird.
For all of 'em, I don't like the ship crashing being part of the map itself, but that's just me.
Hope this helped in some fashion. I do like this show's intro very much and hope to see it polished for osu! some time soon.
DeletedUser_39338
thanks zeek!
k, im going to change the bpm n offset now as from jarjarcob and then add your fixes.
btw. i thought the ship crashing would be a good place for a spinner.(the sound before the crashing) and then the "dededemmmdemmmdemmdemmdemmdemm" sounds like music imo :x. and the song would be even shorter than its now already.^^
if some more will review, say if you prefer including the crashing sounds or leaving them out. if some more say it doesnt fit ill take it out.
k, im going to change the bpm n offset now as from jarjarcob and then add your fixes.
btw. i thought the ship crashing would be a good place for a spinner.(the sound before the crashing) and then the "dededemmmdemmmdemmdemmdemmdemm" sounds like music imo :x. and the song would be even shorter than its now already.^^
if some more will review, say if you prefer including the crashing sounds or leaving them out. if some more say it doesnt fit ill take it out.
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
DeletedUser_39338
DeletedUser_39338
. Perhaps edit out the ship from
DeletedUser_39338
Offset is late.
Easy:
00:05:36 (6) - New combo.
00:06:67 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:10:05 (7) - New combo.
00:18:67 (7) - New combo.
00:20:76 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:24:67 (1) - One less repeat.
Normal:
00:09:51 (9) - New combo.
00:17:86 (7) - New combo.
00:22:10 (1) - Move to white tick.
00:24:64 (1) - One less repeat.
Easy:
00:05:36 (6) - New combo.
00:06:67 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:10:05 (7) - New combo.
00:18:67 (7) - New combo.
00:20:76 (1) - Remove new combo.
00:24:67 (1) - One less repeat.
Normal:
00:09:51 (9) - New combo.
00:17:86 (7) - New combo.
00:22:10 (1) - Move to white tick.
00:24:64 (1) - One less repeat.
DeletedUser_39338
done, even if i find your combo changes way weird.
lemme explain:
in easy for example:
(new timings)
you said new one at (7) 00:10:03
same as later at (7) 00:18:652
but therefore every 4th beats should be a new one. but before, there are 8 beats. did you forget to make 2x4 out of them or shall it be?
btw. i had the same combo system at beginning, when you said "fix the inconsistent combos". -.-
00:20:739 should also be anew one imo.
lemme explain:
in easy for example:
(new timings)
you said new one at (7) 00:10:03
same as later at (7) 00:18:652
but therefore every 4th beats should be a new one. but before, there are 8 beats. did you forget to make 2x4 out of them or shall it be?
btw. i had the same combo system at beginning, when you said "fix the inconsistent combos". -.-
00:20:739 should also be anew one imo.
Combos should be based on a factor of time, the way the music is playing and difficulty of a section. What I was trying to say before was that it wasn't steadily following all 3 guidelines.foLn wrote:
done, even if i find your combo changes way weird.
DeletedUser_39338
well, k.
should i change them as i said? before the new combo with 4 beats starts there is a 8 beat combo which, can definitely made to two 4 if you ask me.
ill let hard as it is.
btw. anyone else has the problem, that the comboburst shows up just sometime after it should show up? i have that somehow. but i dont think its the map/the picture. some bug in osu i guess.
should i change them as i said? before the new combo with 4 beats starts there is a 8 beat combo which, can definitely made to two 4 if you ask me.
ill let hard as it is.
btw. anyone else has the problem, that the comboburst shows up just sometime after it should show up? i have that somehow. but i dont think its the map/the picture. some bug in osu i guess.
DeletedUser_39338
DeletedUser_39338
DeletedUser_39338
I could not find a flaw with your new insane mode.
Your hard mode is a bit too easy, though. You could add a little more flourish and get away with it.
By the way, if you want a video for it, I could get you it.
Your hard mode is a bit too easy, though. You could add a little more flourish and get away with it.
By the way, if you want a video for it, I could get you it.
DeletedUser_39338
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
DeletedUser_39338
Nevermind about the video. Sorry. I can't find the good quality one on YouTube.
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
DeletedUser_39338
thank you metroid, i did all, but
"No need for complete finish spam."
makes the song more interesting if you ask me.
normal:
00:20:73 (1,2,3,4) - It needs to overlap more.
huh, i dont think so. then the overlapping would be too much. look at the other 1/2 overlaps. this fits imo.
hard
00:24:39 (1) - Add a beat or something here.
why Oo i like the reverse slider fitting better to this.
is it true maps need to include spinners to get ranked Oo
"No need for complete finish spam."
makes the song more interesting if you ask me.
normal:
00:20:73 (1,2,3,4) - It needs to overlap more.
huh, i dont think so. then the overlapping would be too much. look at the other 1/2 overlaps. this fits imo.
hard
00:24:39 (1) - Add a beat or something here.
why Oo i like the reverse slider fitting better to this.
is it true maps need to include spinners to get ranked Oo
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
DeletedUser_39338
For all of them
-I think a lead-in time of 0.5s would be good, considering how fast it starts.
-Colors for beats:
[H/S/L] 133, 240, 90 [RGB] 0,128,192;
[H/S/L] 40, 240, 106 [RGB] 225,225,0;
[H/S/L] 0, 231, 91 [RGB] 200,4,4;
Easy
For the sake of it all, reduce the number of finishes. It gets very annoying after awhile. Perhaps have only the high notes get the finish moves, while the rest get the standard hit (ex: 00:10:826; the (1) slider is finish while the (2) & (3) are normal). Otherwise, it's good.
Normal:
Good.
Hard:
00:07:434 - New combo; at the (8), too.
00:15:260 - new combo; also at (12)
Insane:
00:00:000 - (7) new combo
00:15:260 - (6) new combo; [random suggestion] merge the next combo (@ 16:043) with this one, and then make the (5), (6) and (7) new combos as well.
-I think a lead-in time of 0.5s would be good, considering how fast it starts.
-Colors for beats:
[H/S/L] 133, 240, 90 [RGB] 0,128,192;
[H/S/L] 40, 240, 106 [RGB] 225,225,0;
[H/S/L] 0, 231, 91 [RGB] 200,4,4;
Easy
For the sake of it all, reduce the number of finishes. It gets very annoying after awhile. Perhaps have only the high notes get the finish moves, while the rest get the standard hit (ex: 00:10:826; the (1) slider is finish while the (2) & (3) are normal). Otherwise, it's good.
Normal:
Good.
Hard:
00:07:434 - New combo; at the (8), too.
00:15:260 - new combo; also at (12)
Insane:
00:00:000 - (7) new combo
00:15:260 - (6) new combo; [random suggestion] merge the next combo (@ 16:043) with this one, and then make the (5), (6) and (7) new combos as well.
DeletedUser_39338
done all but the first color change. i made the green a bit darker instead. cause your blue is a bit bad to see in front of the background.
The finishes sound so annoying now, cause i changed the hitsounds from soft to normal. The finish sound did fit better in soft. But I feel like I should use normal. Anyway, I edited them out at easy.
thanks zeek.
I wont let this die btw.^^ I'm just to lazy to ask any BAT's yet lol.
The finishes sound so annoying now, cause i changed the hitsounds from soft to normal. The finish sound did fit better in soft. But I feel like I should use normal. Anyway, I edited them out at easy.
thanks zeek.
I wont let this die btw.^^ I'm just to lazy to ask any BAT's yet lol.
Song Setup->Audio->Music Track->Lead-in.foLn wrote:
btw. how can I make the map start earlier??
DeletedUser_39338
[Overall]
They all look good, but there are too many finishes and whistles IMO. Star for you!
[Easy]
Looks good enough but one thing that kinda bothers me:
00:24:65 (1) - Maybe start a red tick earlier and add a repeat. That just sounds better to me.
[Normal]
00:11:60 (6) - Check your distance snap here. Looks ugly the way it is anyway.
00:13:69 (4) - Please make this a circle, the slider ending just doesn't sound good IMO.
00:24:65 (1) - Same as easy's slider.
[Hard]
00:16:04 (2) - Move this so it doesn't overlap with the slider, it looks nicer that way, then make sure to move other notes in the combo to keep the distance consistent
00:16:82 (5,6) - ^ Except you're working with two notes.
00:24:39 (x) - Add note? Sounds better to me
[Insane]
00:11:60 (1) - I don't like this spinner, why do you need it anyway? The other maps don't have it.
00:18:91 (9,10,11) - Not sure if the huge spacing was your intention, but it's very hard to pull off.
00:24:91 (1) - This doesn't need to be a new combo.
00:25:69 (1) - This doesn't either.
They all look good, but there are too many finishes and whistles IMO. Star for you!
[Easy]
Looks good enough but one thing that kinda bothers me:
00:24:65 (1) - Maybe start a red tick earlier and add a repeat. That just sounds better to me.
[Normal]
00:11:60 (6) - Check your distance snap here. Looks ugly the way it is anyway.
00:13:69 (4) - Please make this a circle, the slider ending just doesn't sound good IMO.
00:24:65 (1) - Same as easy's slider.
[Hard]
00:16:04 (2) - Move this so it doesn't overlap with the slider, it looks nicer that way, then make sure to move other notes in the combo to keep the distance consistent
00:16:82 (5,6) - ^ Except you're working with two notes.
00:24:39 (x) - Add note? Sounds better to me
[Insane]
00:11:60 (1) - I don't like this spinner, why do you need it anyway? The other maps don't have it.
00:18:91 (9,10,11) - Not sure if the huge spacing was your intention, but it's very hard to pull off.
00:24:91 (1) - This doesn't need to be a new combo.
00:25:69 (1) - This doesn't either.
DeletedUser_39338
[All]
00:05:347 - move this inherited section back a bit, just as a precaution
[Easy]
a lot of the combo numbering changes don't make sense, but there's nothing blatantly wrong
[Normal]
00:08:73 (1,2,3) - don't really care for this pattern, but that's about it
[Hard]
the tick rate at 3 sounds horrible.
[Insane]
00:18:91 (9) - new combo please
00:05:347 - move this inherited section back a bit, just as a precaution
[Easy]
a lot of the combo numbering changes don't make sense, but there's nothing blatantly wrong
[Normal]
00:08:73 (1,2,3) - don't really care for this pattern, but that's about it
[Hard]
the tick rate at 3 sounds horrible.
[Insane]
00:18:91 (9) - new combo please
DeletedUser_39338
Hm, just something minor that came to mind as I played it, but don't you think you should either increase the volume of the song or decrease the volume of the hitsounds? It seemed as though I could barley hear the song due to the hitsounds.
DeletedUser_39338
bumping..
No excuse not to have a lossless (or 128kbps at least) mp3 for a theme this popular.
Find one. It'll take you three minutes.
Find one. It'll take you three minutes.
DeletedUser_39338
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
DeletedUser_39338
I can't see anything wrong with this, I hope it gets ranked.
STAR!
STAR!
I enjoy short theme song type beatmaps like this and I couldn't find anything wrong. *starred*
Very good. I like the well placed star fountain.
Only two pieces of advice for Insane: One is that after the sound fountain there's a bit too much finish hitsound spamming. The other is that I'd replace the back and forth slider with a spinner like on Easy and Normal.
But it's definitely not bad as it is. Star.
Only two pieces of advice for Insane: One is that after the sound fountain there's a bit too much finish hitsound spamming. The other is that I'd replace the back and forth slider with a spinner like on Easy and Normal.
But it's definitely not bad as it is. Star.
DeletedUser_39338
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.