I'm like a boomerang. Try to reply to mods it's easier to keep track of changes and your opinion.
[Easy]
00:55:693 (1) - I think it'd be better to replace this with notes and a slider because this is pretty short. Maybe add a return to 00:54:408 (4) - and add another slider or notes at 00:56:550 - and 00:56:979 -
[Normal]
00:41:336 (3,4,5) - Probably better to keep this 1/1. Or at the very least add a note at 00:42:408 -
00:44:550 (2) - Ugly compared to 00:45:408 (3) - just copy and paste and reverse selection?
01:01:265 (2) - Make this slider go down vertically, it works better with the pattern at 01:02:550 (3,4) -
01:15:622 (4) - Make this one go down vertically too? Ugly overlap with 01:17:122 (1,2) - in game.
01:32:550 (3) - Awkward angle after 01:31:265 (2) - make it go down?
01:34:265 (5) - ^ Same thing with 01:32:979 (4) -
02:05:550 (1,2) - Align this.
[Hard]
00:38:765 (4,5,6,7) - Same as ^ and move down 1 square, mass pattern misalignment; really noticeable in game o_o
00:40:908 (4) - ^
00:44:979 (5) - This could still be neater, look at Gabe's suggestion from before.
00:49:050 (5,6,1) - Align this and make a nice triangle, looks odd, ugly and messy.
01:06:193 (2,3,4,5) - Align. Also maybe make a more interesting pattern than just a straight line?
01:06:836 (5,6,1) - Spacing? 01:06:836 (5,6) - too close? or 01:07:050 (6,1) - too far? Just use distance snap here?
01:07:265 (1) - Ugly, make this one symmetrical.
01:10:479 (2,3,1) - Align this with 01:10:265 (1) - diagonally.
01:11:122 (3) - Copy and rotate 01:12:836 (7) - for this? Right now this slider is ugly and can be improved simply by doing this.
01:17:550 (1) - Longer sliders sound and play better on longer vocals, so it's better to start this at 01:17:336 -
01:18:408 (3) - ^ better to start at 01:18:193 - also the same as Gabe said, you can improve this simply by copying his slider.
01:20:550 (8) - ^ start at 01:20:336 -
01:25:265 (4) - ^ at 01:25:050 -
01:26:122 (5) - ^ at 01:25:908 -
01:32:765 (2) - Ugly and kinda ruins flow, make it go in the same direction as 01:33:193 (3) - you'll have to respace a bit to do it.
01:33:408 (4) - Sounds better on the longer vocal, start at 01:33:622 -
02:07:050 (1) - Think a long slider would work really well here ending at 02:07:693 -
02:12:836 (1) - Really ugly, why not just copy 02:11:122 (3) - and flip it horizontally?
02:17:550 (3) - ^ Even uglier
02:20:979 (3) - ^
Okay I feel I'm repeating myself just a little so I'll summarize my thoughtts to improve this (I suppose you could apply this to Normal/Easy too):
-- Improve presentation by aligning notes, making patterns neater and nicer sliders. (I pointed out the worst offenders but really you could go through the whole map and do this.)
-- Improve rhythm; longer sliders should be at a matching part in the song etc.
-- New combos; don't place them randomly have a pattern that follows the song.
If you get into the habit of making of doing these things it'll help your future maps too ^_^
[Sakuya's Insane]
00:41:550 (1,2,3) - Use a 1/2 slider here? It's a better rhythm imo and then just continue the stream.
00:56:872 (8) - Delete this note? Sounds better without it.
01:25:586 (3) - Delete this? No drum sound here so it sounds odd. Obviously respace 01:25:693 (4) - if you do this.
01:21:300 (2,3) - Maybe space these out so it's something like 01:13:050 (7,8,9) - think it has better flow.
02:06:836 - Note? Drum here and I think it'll play better ^_^
02:10:908 (2,3) - Stack this on 02:11:122 (4) - ? it looks neater. If not align it like 02:10:050 (5,6,7) -
02:17:550 (1,2,3,4) - Start 02:17:550 (1) - in the same position as the start of 02:16:265 (2) - and then respace the stream a bit? It looks much neater when playing.
02:27:622 (1) - Add a return to follow the drum.
Okay that's my opinion. You can always get a second opinion if you disagree with me that's cool too ~
[Easy]
00:55:693 (1) - I think it'd be better to replace this with notes and a slider because this is pretty short. Maybe add a return to 00:54:408 (4) - and add another slider or notes at 00:56:550 - and 00:56:979 -
[Normal]
00:41:336 (3,4,5) - Probably better to keep this 1/1. Or at the very least add a note at 00:42:408 -
00:44:550 (2) - Ugly compared to 00:45:408 (3) - just copy and paste and reverse selection?
01:01:265 (2) - Make this slider go down vertically, it works better with the pattern at 01:02:550 (3,4) -
01:15:622 (4) - Make this one go down vertically too? Ugly overlap with 01:17:122 (1,2) - in game.
01:32:550 (3) - Awkward angle after 01:31:265 (2) - make it go down?
01:34:265 (5) - ^ Same thing with 01:32:979 (4) -
02:05:550 (1,2) - Align this.
[Hard]
- The new combo issue from before is still here, you ignored all of Gabe's combo mod...? ._. Insane is still a good reference for this.
00:38:765 (4,5,6,7) - Same as ^ and move down 1 square, mass pattern misalignment; really noticeable in game o_o
00:40:908 (4) - ^
00:44:979 (5) - This could still be neater, look at Gabe's suggestion from before.
00:49:050 (5,6,1) - Align this and make a nice triangle, looks odd, ugly and messy.
01:06:193 (2,3,4,5) - Align. Also maybe make a more interesting pattern than just a straight line?
01:06:836 (5,6,1) - Spacing? 01:06:836 (5,6) - too close? or 01:07:050 (6,1) - too far? Just use distance snap here?
01:07:265 (1) - Ugly, make this one symmetrical.
01:10:479 (2,3,1) - Align this with 01:10:265 (1) - diagonally.
01:11:122 (3) - Copy and rotate 01:12:836 (7) - for this? Right now this slider is ugly and can be improved simply by doing this.
01:17:550 (1) - Longer sliders sound and play better on longer vocals, so it's better to start this at 01:17:336 -
01:18:408 (3) - ^ better to start at 01:18:193 - also the same as Gabe said, you can improve this simply by copying his slider.
01:20:550 (8) - ^ start at 01:20:336 -
01:25:265 (4) - ^ at 01:25:050 -
01:26:122 (5) - ^ at 01:25:908 -
01:32:765 (2) - Ugly and kinda ruins flow, make it go in the same direction as 01:33:193 (3) - you'll have to respace a bit to do it.
01:33:408 (4) - Sounds better on the longer vocal, start at 01:33:622 -
02:07:050 (1) - Think a long slider would work really well here ending at 02:07:693 -
02:12:836 (1) - Really ugly, why not just copy 02:11:122 (3) - and flip it horizontally?
02:17:550 (3) - ^ Even uglier
02:20:979 (3) - ^
Okay I feel I'm repeating myself just a little so I'll summarize my thoughtts to improve this (I suppose you could apply this to Normal/Easy too):
-- Improve presentation by aligning notes, making patterns neater and nicer sliders. (I pointed out the worst offenders but really you could go through the whole map and do this.)
-- Improve rhythm; longer sliders should be at a matching part in the song etc.
-- New combos; don't place them randomly have a pattern that follows the song.
If you get into the habit of making of doing these things it'll help your future maps too ^_^
[Sakuya's Insane]
00:41:550 (1,2,3) - Use a 1/2 slider here? It's a better rhythm imo and then just continue the stream.
00:56:872 (8) - Delete this note? Sounds better without it.
01:25:586 (3) - Delete this? No drum sound here so it sounds odd. Obviously respace 01:25:693 (4) - if you do this.
01:21:300 (2,3) - Maybe space these out so it's something like 01:13:050 (7,8,9) - think it has better flow.
02:06:836 - Note? Drum here and I think it'll play better ^_^
02:10:908 (2,3) - Stack this on 02:11:122 (4) - ? it looks neater. If not align it like 02:10:050 (5,6,7) -
02:17:550 (1,2,3,4) - Start 02:17:550 (1) - in the same position as the start of 02:16:265 (2) - and then respace the stream a bit? It looks much neater when playing.
02:27:622 (1) - Add a return to follow the drum.
Okay that's my opinion. You can always get a second opinion if you disagree with me that's cool too ~