forum

Problematic storyboards with widescreen [confirmed] [resolved]

posted
Total Posts
47
show more
Arnold0
I can see the BG of the map in the border, the image in the middle should be full screen
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/29157
STAIRWAY TO THE SKIES diff

happy30
I'm currently experiencing problems with the SB of these of my maps:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/7940 | Demetori - Ghostly Eyes
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/9641 | Demetori - Jehovah's YaHVeH
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/11336 | lily-an - White Lotus...
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/11341 | Tatsh Assault X - The Dirty of Loudness
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/13223 | Demetori - Emotional Skyscraper ~ World's End
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/17275 | DystopiaGround - Silence, In the Rubble
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/24611 | DystopiaGround - AugoEidEs
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/32522 | Kayano Ai - secret base ~Kimi ga Kureta Mono~ (10 years after Ver.)
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/42234 | Demetori - Desire Drive ~ Desire Dream

edit: http://osu.ppy.sh/s/11616 | Rie Kugimiya & Eri Kitamura - Holy Night
Snepif
My SB is broken too. Checked on 3 PCs, all the same problem. Looks like you enlarged the BG image, but you didn't enlarge the SB stuff, so they appear smaller.
This is my map: http://osu.ppy.sh/s/69001

The normal BG without any SB effects going on:

When the SB effect happens (its supposed to be a purple version of the BG image with the same size, just like a purple flash), but it's smaller now, yesterday it was okay since the BG was not wide like now... :

imo you should just leave the bg images like they were before, or enlarge the sb as well or something... also happened with lots of other ranked maps that i tried... example:

Notice how the red effect, which is the same image as the BG but a bit redish, is supposed to have the same size as the bg image, but now it's smaller.

So, the issue is simple, peppy: The new bgs are wider than before, the SB's aren't.
deadbeat
Snepif
Also the wide BG thing is badly cropped:


The original image says DragonForce on top and Heart of the Storm in the bottom :/ :

AdRon Zh3Ro

AdRon Zh3Ro wrote:

This is also happening with all storyboards and alike because of one simple thingy: the bg is now displaying in 16:9 but all the resources are still in 4:3, which obviously makes it look weird.
Quoted from the 3-2-1-ready thread because it's the same.
Snepif
^ exactly that
XinCrin
yeah ,totally sure
69653863

Yes.
deadbeat
inverness: what map is that?
Cuvelia
all the taiko backgrounds died :(
 
Why not just back former specifications that nothing issue?
peppy
To those saying that "backgrounds are too wide", this is not the case. When a storyboard is present, the background is not scaled to widescreen. The only issue is when a storyboard is not detected (ie. when there are only a few storyboarded elements), and this will improve as I work on detection.

In other words, the issue with scaling being wrong is only happening on maps that has "flash" layers.
The other issue is clipping no longer being present, causing areas which were previously hidden off-screen to now be visible. Depending on how the storyboard was made, this may result in unintended behaviour.

I am working on both of these cases and not looking for solutions, but examples.
69653863
Storyboards that applied on the actual backgrounds also have this issue.



Because now the backgrounds are treated differently.

@deadbeat: http://osu.ppy.sh/b/119626
ReVeNg3r
I set osu on 1440x900 FullScreen

I think the black borders should be totally removed.

also There,on the right side, i experience it on every beatmap with video.

then when i entered edit this appeared
peppy
All issues should be fixed in the next build. Marking resolved for now.
h3k1ru

peppy wrote:

All issues should be fixed in the next build. Marking resolved for now.
its not.. the borders sometimes looks weird, especially on moving sprites

SPOILER
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/196280


^ look at borders

SPOILER
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/196280


^ borders and that sprite..

SPOILER
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/140890


^ not fixed yet
Topic Starter
TakuMii
The new update seems to have fixed the problem. Although it's still problematic with this song:

YayMii wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/17670
Snepif
The problem still exists.

Before "solving" the problem:


Now:


The problem still exists, the image should turn red with the same size, the bg size and SB elements size still don't match :/
h3k1ru
the BG layer should be hidden during SB, but its not
TheVileOne
I have observed some weird issues with moving sprites. There are probably other issues still left.
Kuro

Cuvelia wrote:

all the taiko backgrounds died :(
 
Why not just back former specifications that nothing issue?
It looks like we'll need a new taiko BG template to fit in widescreen
Snepif
Oh wait, in the editor my SBs look buggy but while playing they look great. Thanks peppy :D although looking at them in the editor is weird ><
peppy
Do not make a new taiko bg template. Instead wait until i hard-code "taiko bg" into osu!, then fix all the created ones (by removing them).
TheVileOne
Hopefully by hard code you mean, make it a skin object and thus skinnable. because there's no sense forcing all songs of a particular gamemode to use the same background, at least in my opinion. you should at least give members of the taiko community a way to stylize their maps as creatively as other gamemodes. (Same for osu, mania, when someone wants to make a mania background. Let us create one that scales properly.
peppy
I mean coding the text into the game, and allowing an offset of the standard background. Wrong thread, though.
ztrot

ztrot wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/45752

images are being drawn that were normally hidden and that sun still moves to a odd spot even the the code is as detailed
Sprite,Background,Centre,"Smile\happy sun.png",320,240
L,22783,122
R,0,0,445,-0.4,0.4
R,0,445,889,0.4,-0.4
L,141894,113
R,0,0,445,-0.4,0.4
R,0,445,889,0.4,-0.4
M,0,22783,,424,135
F,0,22783,,1
S,0,22783,,0.2479999
MX,0,22783,27050,724,424
MY,1,22783,27050,300,135
MX,0,129449,131227,424,-60
MY,2,129449,131227,135,300
M,0,131227,,-60,300
F,0,131227,,0
M,0,141894,,424,135
F,0,141894,,1
MX,0,141894,143672,724,424
MY,1,141894,143672,300,135
F,0,241338,241783,1,0
this is still borked but not sure if you have put out the "next bulid"
the bg is hidden but objects are still not clipping out as they should.
peppy
Likely due to rotations. This may be fixed in the future, but should affect a minimal number of maps for now. Re-resolving.
h3k1ru

peppy wrote:

but should affect a minimal number of maps for now.
like every map with moving sprites is still buggy in widescreen

none of this: p/1999556 got fixed

just random map i took a look:

SPOILER
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/197225


i request un-resolve it once again..
Derekku
Map: Crazy Loop - Joanna Shut Up!
Song Select: http://puu.sh/1EZVO
Map Loading: http://puu.sh/1EZW2
4:3 Resolution: http://puu.sh/1EZWs
Widescreen: http://puu.sh/1EZX7 (letterboxing at bottom during break)

I thought that the problem was just with widescreen (due to the map having a couple of SB elements), but it seems that the background gets fit to height in 4:3 as well. This is a special case (since the background should've been landscape instead of portrait), but it fit to width in old versions and it doesn't make sense to have it look nice for song select/loading and then switch to something else! :p
osu41698
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/68001 Vip- Tenchou , 96Neko - Matryoshka
Sure
Map : http://osu.ppy.sh/s/35036

There are two problems in this map.

1. The images in chapter 2 won't be loaded at first attempt.

2. The screenshot explains itself. (Chapter 3)
MillhioreF
2. looks like an error with the storyboard itself, not osu!. 1. seems like a separate issue, with storyboard not loading instead of not aligning right.
Sure

MillhioreF wrote:

2. looks like an error with the storyboard itself, not osu!.
No, the map has a lots of wide scrolling images but that is the only one not cutted.
statementreply


1. Images are not always accurately cropped (sometimes a few pixels off). Moving background looks "shaking" at the border. This happens in 4:3 resolutions too.

2. Some images are not properly cropped. Rotated images are not cropped.

peppy wrote:

Likely due to rotations. This may be fixed in the future, but should affect a minimal number of maps for now. Re-resolving.
h3k1ru
u need to make new thread and put this video in. i think noone will look over it in "resolved" thread. this bug with flashing borders confirmed by many ppl already, and lasts from the first day update with widescreen bg support.
peppy
I read resolved threads. I am still aware of these issues.
Doodley
Not sure if we're still posting examples but two of my maps, http://osu.ppy.sh/s/41162 and http://osu.ppy.sh/s/52439 are busted.


EDIT: Ranking screens for custom skins are busted as well, but this is a problem on my part I'd say. Gotta update.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply