forum

Allow individual mod use in Multiplayer [added]

posted
Total Posts
158
This is a feature request. Feature requests can be voted up by supporters.
Current Priority: +910
show more
Uncle Buly

Kuro wrote:

Uncle Buly wrote:

i cri cuz no dt allowed but still awesome suggestion, support
If DT was allowed then players would finish before others and would have to wait.. But they wouldn't wait too long because DT on this game isn't true DT. It's only 1.5x so they would only wait 1/4th of the entire song when they finish, correct me if i'm wrong. ^_^
It'd be the choice of the DT user to wait though, and it'd give them time to browse forums or something :p but I doubt this will happen and HR is also nice

peppy wrote:

If I was to implement this, it would exclude DT and HT completely from the per-user selection, because I believe multiplayer should always be played in realtime. The host would still have control over the game speed.
Italo
Wow, this can be soo funny, looks amazing!
ieb
Support. One of my friend is very strong among us so others always end up with a "Failed"... That would be helpful ^_^
H_Hitachiin
Then everybody would be playing with different mods.
Different Mods = Totally Different Scores.
Kuro

H_Hitachiin wrote:

Then everybody would be playing with different mods.
Different Mods = Totally Different Scores.
Would that even make a difference? I mean, if you play with mods and someone really wants to beat you, they'll use the same mods.
Or if they just don't want to fail, they'll use easy/No Fail/Half Time and take a lower score because if you fail you won't even have a score.

"Low score" beats "No score" :P
Irisu_old
You have my full support on this. The idea seems like it could work out ^^
she_old
I'm pretty happy to see that this has received so many stars! I really hope this will be implemented!
Iku Acme
Would love to see this implemented in the near future.
Olivares
Nice!, support .
KaosFR
That would be great
she_old
Was wondering: this would also apply to osu!mania right?
for like the 4k mod
theowest
all game modes, obviously
TOKI
nice feature
i usually play with my friends. but we can only play 4*or4.5* beatmap or some new players fail, while it's boring for me
-libili
where the feature could be added is on the corner over the chat down right into

Play Mode:
  • 1. osu!standard (all mods can only be chosen by host)
    2. osu!free2play
    3. Taiko
    4. CatchTheBeat
    5. osu!mania
Drafura

-libili wrote:

osu!free2play
ogod no !

I still support this request.
Kuro

-libili wrote:

2. osu!free2play
Wth is that!? :o
jemhuntr
osu!std with per user individual mod...? Wat. xD
she_old

JeMhUnTeR wrote:

osu!std with per user individual mod...? Wat. xD
*In multiplayer.
That's the whole point of this thread

-libili wrote:

where the feature could be added is on the corner over the chat down right into

Play Mode:
  • 1. osu!standard (all mods can only be chosen by host)
    2. osu!free2play
Why complicate things when there's already something easier and more usable mentioned in the OP?
jemhuntr
i mean the osu!free2play. Is it supposed to be the toggle whether you use this feature or what??

loseri wrote:

Why complicate things when there's already something easier and more usable mentioned in the OP?
she_old

JeMhUnTeR wrote:

i mean the osu!free2play. Is it supposed to be the toggle whether you use this feature or what??

loseri wrote:

Why complicate things when there's already something easier and more usable mentioned in the OP?
Oh, misunderstood.
Aquamarine

Iku Acme wrote:

Would love to see this implemented in the near future.
+1
she_old
I'm so shameless (bump)
Vmx
This is the only thing that I really really really really want in osu!
Macacito
waat
Starz0r
I need this so I can beat all my friends in osu!standard :D

+ Support
Nostalgia
Genius and sounds like a good idea. But gives a higher advantage on only a specified person. Just seems too OP in my perspective.

If it's too easy, just play a harder diff or make your own server to make things fair. /:
she_old

Nostalgia wrote:

Genius and sounds like a good idea. But gives a higher advantage on only a specified person. Just seems too OP in my perspective.

If it's too easy, just play a harder diff or make your own server to make things fair. /:
If it gave them an advantage they'd already be at a high enough skill level to win.
And what if you wanna play with less good friends and keep them company, it's not to beat up every single person you see, and even if they aim for that they would win anyway regardless of the mods chosen if they're really already better.
And what if there's nobody that wants to play with you and nobody joins your room?

You sound as if you didn't even read the thread.
Nostalgia

loseri wrote:

Nostalgia wrote:

Genius and sounds like a good idea. But gives a higher advantage on only a specified person. Just seems too OP in my perspective.

If it's too easy, just play a harder diff or make your own server to make things fair. /:
If it gave them an advantage they'd already be at a high enough skill level to win.
And what if you wanna play with less good friends and keep them company, it's not to beat up every single person you see, and even if they aim for that they would win anyway regardless of the mods chosen if they're really already better.
And what if there's nobody that wants to play with you and nobody joins your room?

You sound as if you didn't even read the thread.
Apologies, my internet is too slow and cuts off from loading everything. But yes that makes a lot of sense.
Drafura
Can I add another point in favor of "This feature could balance more the multiplayer rooms" ?

I heard in standard mode some people read better AR9 or 10 with HD and others not.

In CtB this case is actually ruining A LOT of multiplayer room :
Host goes for HR or DT and half room wants HD half doesn't want it (well actually more people wants HD at a point I can ask : "why DT/HR HD actually gives more points than HR/DT ?" but this isn't the topic). The point is that some players would be better with HD and others not and this actually change the winner when playing the same map with HR or DT (and even on some none AR9/8 maps). If each player could adapt the mod they use to play with, it would be REALLY MORE balanced cause each players are going to play the map with the mod they're used to (I mean can you say you beat a player if he isn't playing at his maximum ?).
she_old

Drafura wrote:

Can I add another point in favor of "This feature could balance more the multiplayer rooms" ?

I heard in standard mode some people read better AR9 or 10 with HD and others not.

In CtB this case is actually ruining A LOT of multiplayer room :
Host goes for HR or DT and half room wants HD half doesn't want it (well actually more people wants HD at a point I can ask : "why DT/HR HD actually gives more points than HR/DT ?" but this isn't the topic). The point is that some players would be better with HD and others not and this actually change the winner when playing the same map with HR or DT (and even on some none AR9/8 maps). If each player could adapt the mod they use to play with, it would be REALLY MORE balanced cause each players are going to play the map with the mod they're used to (I mean can you say you beat a player if he isn't playing at his maximum ?).
I tried reading your post several times and I still don't understand what you're trying to say, maybe I'm just tired.

So the host goes for DT or HR as Global Mod.
Half the room wants HD.
Other half doesn't.
Both sides choose or don't choose HD in their Player Individual Mods panel.
???
Profit.

Isn't that the point of this request, or is this what you meant by adding an extra point? (derp then)
And if you meant the opposite, the host could just disallow HD from the Allowed Mods.
The host basically sets all the rules, and the players should just go with it.
Drafura
Lemme tldr by quoting your words.

loseri wrote:

So the host goes for DT or HR as Global Mod.
Half the room wants HD.
Other half doesn't.
This is the actual problem wich ruins a lot of good rooms.

loseri wrote:

Both sides choose or don't choose HD in their Player Individual Mods panel.
This is the way to solve the problem.

loseri wrote:

Isn't that the point of this request, or is this what you meant by adding an extra point? (derp then)
And if you meant the opposite, the host could just disallow HD from the Allowed Mods.
The host basically sets all the rules, and the players should just go with it.
What I said just show how this feature can make the room more balanced. Some people posting here seems to say that this feature could unbalance multiplayer rooms, I think it's wrong because of that example. This is just an argument in favor of "why this feature is required", i'm not trying to modify the request. I hope it's more comprehensive.
Makyu
What happen if there is TAG coop and someone select HR mod?
she_old

Makyu wrote:

What happen if there is TAG coop and someone select HR mod?
I highly doubt this would apply to TAG mode, unless a team selects HR and the other team doesn't, it sounds reasonable then.
TheVileOne
As long as they don't get a higher multiplier, then they can use all the mods (except the easier ones) they want.
nutnnut
Support, sometimes playing with lower level friends can be boring
Topic Starter
haha5957
You need extra skills to get multiplier so I don't think there's need to remove multiplier.

Imagine a #1500 vs #5000, their skill might have difference but maybe not much. adding Hidden to #1500 will make the game much fair because there's higher probability of missing(and increased difficulty)in that case. if #1500 sill manages to FC hidden then he deserves his victory.
she_old

haha5957 wrote:

You need extra skills to get multiplier so I don't think there's need to remove multiplier.
I agree!
Lunaties
support la ..!!
Dustice
makes sense to me :3
S o r c e r y
support!!!! really fun
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply